Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the driving test system is becoming ridiculous and is harming the economy.

86 replies

HunterGatherer · 15/01/2022 15:43

Yes, I know there's a pandemic on but DS has had his driving test cancelled 3 times now Angry. He has been waiting for over a year (after failing his first test for going too slowly around a roundabout, his instructor who was in the car with him was aghast).
DS is a nurse and currently commutes to work via 2 trains. He frequently has to turn down bank shifts in (in desperately understaffed units) because he can't get there. Quite a few of his friends are in similar situations.
I'm sure other industries are suffering as well. FGS Boris, get your finger out and sort this problem out.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Qwertykeys · 16/01/2022 10:33

I have to agree it’s not an ideal situation with driving tests at the moment. How pro active is your son in looking for tests , i advocate the cancellation apps , DS passed on his fourth attempt on Friday. Three of his tests brought forward by cancellation apps . When he booked his fourth nothing was available at his chosen centre, he booked at a different one then within days the app had found him one at his chosen centre. Unfortunately it is a case in being really proactive in booking tests rather than waiting for more examiners to pop up from thin air.

Alexandra2001 · 16/01/2022 08:16

[quote twelly]@Alexandra2001
I disagree in that I think it should have been something the govt prioritised. There can b e more than one priority, the low level of driving has and will lead to young people finding it difficult to work in many areas and increase isolation. It might not be a problem in London where there is an excellent transport system but that is not the case everywhere.[/quote]
Well we live in the rural s/w, for my DD, she had to stop doing lessons, then her 2nd placement came up and it was the bus followed by a decent walk, she quite enjoyed it.
Many young people do not have the money for tests nor can afford the insurance costs, they have to manage the best they can.

I'm not saying it isn't important but there is only so much DV can do, huge back logs, lack of examiners (many have left the job) its a very F2F job, lessons and exam, so hardly surprising this has occurred.

We need to be moving away from the car and the pollution it causes.

Alysskea · 15/01/2022 23:23

What we need is a country with public transport that's fit for purpose so people can get to work without using a car

hibbledibble · 15/01/2022 23:21

[quote cherryonthecakes]It seems that emergency driving tests are available if you're NHS and need to drive as part of your job

www.gov.uk/apply-emergency-driving-test[/quote]
I checked this, and the criteria are such that very few would be eligible. Most NHS workers don't drive as part of their job, and respond to 'threats to life'. Many do work at rural sites, far from home, which rotate over a large geographical distance though.

Nomorecoco · 15/01/2022 22:58

I agree Its a shambles, dp was supposed to take his first test march 2020 and is now having a 3 month wait to get his theory test redone. He has 2 buses to take to work, taking nearly 2 hours each way each day when most of them are cancelled.

GreenClock · 15/01/2022 22:40

I’d recommend the Testi app.

twelly · 15/01/2022 22:28

@Alexandra2001
I disagree in that I think it should have been something the govt prioritised. There can b e more than one priority, the low level of driving has and will lead to young people finding it difficult to work in many areas and increase isolation. It might not be a problem in London where there is an excellent transport system but that is not the case everywhere.

LoveFall · 15/01/2022 22:17

The problem is the same where I live in Canada. Grandson has been waiting almost two years to get through his driving test.

We gifted him very expensive lessons (well over $1000) just before the pandemic. He did the classroom work and then in car lessons were cancelled. Almost a year later he got lessons in the car but DH had to drive him quite far away as somehow they couldn't pick up.

Then, months later he had a road test. He failed by a ridiculous one error that was essentially a trick by the examiner to bring the examinee by a very obscured sign about bikes sharing the road thus requiring dropping speed.

Speeding is an automatic fail. I get that, but since we have found out many people are failed at the same spot. Seems unfair to me.

Now there are no open slots unless you sit on the website literally for days. Not much good anyway as grandson is away at uni now.

I feel your pain.

Alexandra2001 · 15/01/2022 22:00

@Kite22

It's all very well saying "have a plan" but they can't just magic up driving examiners and test centres from nowhere.

No, but it must be possible to train some. As has been said, this is an issue known about for about 20months. I'm not sure training driving test examiners is quite as intensive and long as training surgeons, for example. I feel there has been time without any magic needing to be involved.

During the last 20months, do you really think it has been a priority?

Catch a bus/train/walk/ride a bike? which is what my DD did to get to her 11 week NHS placement 45 miles away during Uni.

Its a real 1st world problem and i don't blame the govt for not prioritising this, bare in mind also that many examiners retired and were not replaced.

oviraptor21 · 15/01/2022 21:55

@LemonCake79

I completely agree *@HunterGatherer*, the Driving Standards Agency should have waiting time targets to meet like everyone else.

It was terrible when I passed 23 years ago but now it's just appalling. No one wants standards compromises but there needs to be more tests available.

Really feel for your DS.

I don't recall any issues at all either when I passed 25 years ago or when my DC took their tests between 2 and 5 years ago. All booked and sat their tests with no delays or cancellations
Kite22 · 15/01/2022 21:51

It would be nice if they were allowed to retake the theory test without charge, all those youngsters that took it in good faith and haven't had the chance to take their practical test before it runs out.

twelly · 15/01/2022 21:44

Its a mess - and it has just to worse, theory test have run out, cancelled tests and a lack of foresight. Another example of the government not really caring about the younger generation .

Shade17 · 15/01/2022 21:39

Indeed @iklboo. Really basic stuff. I could’ve answered those as a 10 year old! Anyone who struggles with those questions need not be on the road!

iklboo · 15/01/2022 20:50

Dealing with total stranger sat there taking notes and judging me based on their asking me questions about the mechanics of the car which are totally irrelevant in the moment is not necessary for save driving -

Show Me questions, during the drive:

When it's safe to do so:

Can you show me how you put the windscreen wipers on?
Can you show me how you activate the screen wash?
Can you show me how you put your dipped headlights on?
Can you show me how the side windows open

Totally relevant for a safe drive in the moment. They're not asking you to explain the workings of a combustion engine.

Tell Me questions, while the vehicle is parked up:

  1. Tell me how you’d switch on the rear fog light(s) and explain when you’d use it/them. You don’t need to exit the vehicle.

Operate switch (turn on dipped headlights and ignition if necessary). Check warning light is on. Explain use.
11. Tell me how you switch your headlight from dipped to main beam and explain how you’d know the main beam is on.

Operate switch (with ignition or engine on if necessary), check with main beam warning light.
12. Open the bonnet and tell me how you’d check that the engine has sufficient oil.

Identify dipstick/oil level indicator, describe check of oil level against the minimum and maximum markers.

woodhill · 15/01/2022 19:53

@fairylightsandwaxmelts

^ this. I can't believe people are so accepting of a public service performing so poorly over such a long period.

Nobody is just saying "accept it" - but realistically, what are the alternatives?

As has been said, you can't have multiple people at one test centre all at once - they can only have a certain number of learners taking their test at each time slot for safety/space/parking reasons. When I learnt to drive, they staggered starting times by ten minutes so there wasn't a queue of learners in the car park, or all queuing up to do the same manoeuvres at the same time etc.

So what next? Build more test centres? Where? What routes are you going to use for the tests to allow learners to show enough knowledge to pass? They'll need to cover A roads, roundabouts, junctions etc. And lastly, are there going to be enough instructors and examiners in those areas to make it worth the investment?

They shut some down a while back in our area
woodhill · 15/01/2022 19:51

@JuergenSchwarzwald

Thanks

Yes rotten with the pandemic

Nutrigrainygoodness · 15/01/2022 19:45

It's going to sound silly but has he looked every day.

When I booked my test there was no availability, but I checked back every morning for a week and I managed to get a slot 3 months away- I didn't look for cancellations but my instructor had other pupils who we managing to get cancellations within a week or 2 of them failing their test, and others who were able to bring their test date forward by a few weeks.

Blanketpolicy · 15/01/2022 19:17

Dealing with total stranger sat there taking notes and judging me based on their asking me questions about the mechanics of the car which are totally irrelevant in the moment is not necessary for save driving - if I had a passenger being so intentionally distracting I'd tell them to be quiet or get out; similarly if I took a turn which was safe but not correct for my route I would just detour back nobody would be coming along to say I wasn't a safe driver.

The show me/tell me questions are ridiculously basic.

You do not fail the independent driving part if you take a wrong turn as long as you do it safely. If you take a wrong turn the examiner will give you directions to get you back on track.

HelloFrostyMorning · 15/01/2022 19:15

@iklboo

A voluntary driving test was introduced in England in 1935. The test cost 37½ pence and the pass rate was 63%. The first person to pass was called Mr Been.

Mr Been Smile Love that! Grin

To think that the driving test system is becoming ridiculous and is harming the economy.
fairylightsandwaxmelts · 15/01/2022 19:15

Why would an examiner need to fund their own vehicle and fuel? Are you getting confused with instructors, learners are tested in their instructors car or their own car. Examiners are also not self employed, they are civil servants (but not the kind that get cheese and wine while working).

Oops, my bad :)

iklboo · 15/01/2022 19:13

Half the problem is that people are desperately booking tests even though the new driver isn't ready for it.

Not only that - some people are booking tests without an instructor or car to take it in. DH had had loads of calls asking if he's 'free for a test next Tuesday at 11am, my usual instructor can't do it. Oh, and it's in Norwich' (we're in Manchester.

BigYellowHat · 15/01/2022 19:10

Has he tried booking in an area nearby that’s not so busy for tests? My DS was having the exact same problem when we lived in a big city. Waited 5 months for a test which he failed. Then the next test wasn’t for 4 months. He then rang up to see if there were spots in the small town about 25 miles from us and he was in about a month later and passed. Might be worth a try. If your DS can’t do that, he should ring up/look online daily for cancellations at his preferred test centre.

nosyupnorth · 15/01/2022 19:08

@Shade17

Learners shouldn't have to take a test under stress, and no one should ever drive stressed, ever.

But driving IS stressful and you will find yourself in stressful situations. If you can’t handle that then you’ve got no business being behind the wheel.

I might have to drive while under stress but there's no situation in real life where I'd have to drive in the artificially stressful and deliberately offputting circumstances of an exam.

Dealing with total stranger sat there taking notes and judging me based on their asking me questions about the mechanics of the car which are totally irrelevant in the moment is not necessary for save driving - if I had a passenger being so intentionally distracting I'd tell them to be quiet or get out; similarly if I took a turn which was safe but not correct for my route I would just detour back nobody would be coming along to say I wasn't a safe driver.

The driving test process in this country is unnecessarily convoluted and full of artifical pressures, both in the test itself and the system around it: for example there is no need for a theory test to expire after just two years - very few other qualifications require such reknewal so soon after gaining them - it is nothing more than a money making scam so that any driver who does not pass quickly will have to pay for another because the wait is so long they don't have time to retest.

iklboo · 15/01/2022 19:08

At the risk of de railing this thread.....until 2007!!!!!! you could just drive without passing your test. Had to display l plates and no motorway driving, but essentially you could legally drive unaccompanied.

Never in the UK.

A voluntary driving test was introduced in England in 1935. The test cost 37½ pence and the pass rate was 63%. The first person to pass was called Mr Been. There weren’t any test centres and examiners would meet candidates at a pre-arranged spot, like a park or railway station. The compulsory driving test was introduced on 1st June 1935, for all drivers who started driving on or after 1st of April 1934.

HelloFrostyMorning · 15/01/2022 19:06

Still, a shame the DVLA can't get their act together in other aspects though... JMHO.