Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Quite a lot of better off people would be happy to pay more tax?

368 replies

Echobelly · 15/01/2022 10:48

Provided it was channeled towards things like NHS, social care, education.

It seems weirdly outdated to me that mainstream political parties find raising taxes on the wealthy anathema. We've been living in such a low-tax society for so long, but households like mine (I'd say it's a 6-figure annual income between us) could easily afford to pay more in tax and still enjoy our lives.

But instead parties are obsessed with recouping money by removing benefits for the poorest people, which is stupid as the difficulties resulting from plunging people into greater poverty, as well as being cruel, will ultimately cost more money than it saves.

Take that money off people like me in taxes! We won't become homeless or sick or suffer mental distress for the sake of a bit more tax. Year after year I see budgets that will apparently save people like me £500 a year, as if this is supposed to be an incentive to vote for the Tories but tbh, I won't even notice being better off by £500 a year. Give that saving to someone for whom it'll make an impact!

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 15/01/2022 14:39

more income tax and perhaps more high earners would be looking at selling up their London terraces to invest in a nice beach house on the Caymans... Or those in finance would be snapping up those post-Brexit relocation offers

Then who is left to pay the tax bill?

Can you point to any properly conducted study which shows this actually happens en masse? We all know of various high profile cases when people have done it, but when you look at studies out of Canada and New Jersey, it shows that tax migration because of wealth taxes actually doesn’t happen. When you think about it, it doesn’t make sense that people en masse are willing to uproot their entire family and their lives just to avoid paying a few k more in that which they can easily afford to pay. If you are, one of the charity bosses I mentioned earlier earning £300,000 a year and your job is based in London, and your spouse has a job in London and your kids go to private schools in London, where exactly are you going to move to?

Abetes · 15/01/2022 14:38

I don't want to pay more tax because I don't trust government to spend it properly or wisely. Contracts to their already rich mates, the huge enormous inefficiencies within the NHS and the general waste and corruption of government doesn't inspire me to want them to have any more of my money. I give regularly to charities which I consider to make a huge difference to my local area and look upon that as my own directed tax to services which need the money and spend it wisely.

saleorbouy · 15/01/2022 14:36

Increasing taxation is not necessarily the answer.
Reducing waste within the system should be a priority.
The NHS will consistently require increasing amounts of funding that taxation cannot meet. Increases in National Insurance have happened twice by both Labour and Conservative governments apparently "ring fenced" the money, this still can't provide service let alone decent wages for many NHS workers.
I think I would prefer a more straightforward taxation system of 33% on salaries, Capital gains and IHT, that could easily be implemented and less easily avoided.
There might be more money in people's pockets and then this would return to the economy through VAT from spending on goods, services etc and income tax of the supporting workers.

MarshaBradyo · 15/01/2022 14:35

Calls..

Foxyloxy1plus1 · 15/01/2022 14:35

People like value for money. We don’t have value for money, as far as taxation is concerned. Vast sums are wasted, as has been evidenced by PPs. Projects cancelled, computer systems that are inefficient and ineffective, people milking the systems where they work and some who don’t work milking the benefits system too.

Money is wasted in every area of central and local government and most of us will never know the half of it. There are plenty of people with stressful jobs, who work long hours, but earn a very average wage too.

If major organisations like the NHS, police, public service organisations worked cohesively and efficiently, the savings could be substantial. The money that is wasted, is wasted on layers of unnecessary management and wasted resources. It’s not the workers at grass roots level, but they’re the ones trying to prop it all up.

MarshaBradyo · 15/01/2022 14:35

@Pendolino

It’s all academic anyway. The pandemic has been so expensive, big tax rises will be on the way regardless of what we think. Someone has to foot the bill for those dodgy PPE contracts.
And lockdowns and furlough

The falls for more and more to be spent was maddening

Government need to fund… when really it’s us who will pay. And our dc

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 15/01/2022 14:35

[quote User310]@daimbarsatemydogsbone

When you take into consideration council tax, road tax VAT.. you will be very close![/quote]
If you include those it's probably well over 50% - but I assume the poster was talking about income tax and NI.

SarahBellam · 15/01/2022 14:34

Donating money to charity doesn’t solve the major systemic problems though. All it does it plug some gaps and tinker about round the edges. Systemic change requires political leadership and at national level at least we have a government currently that exists in an ethical and credibility vacuum

Staffy1 · 15/01/2022 14:34

Depends what you define as better off. The people at the lower end of the defined group who might already be struggling wouldn’t be happy.

Pendolino · 15/01/2022 14:34

It’s all academic anyway. The pandemic has been so expensive, big tax rises will be on the way regardless of what we think. Someone has to foot the bill for those dodgy PPE contracts.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 15/01/2022 14:33

@dafey

Why not tax mega corporations such as amazon, google and facebook appropriately. Amazon in particular is killing off the high-street because it can undercut partly to paying very low taxes by being based offshore etc.

You can't target someone like Amazon unless it's a global initiative. Customers though could use their spending power & not shop there but the cheap prices suit them.

Yes you can - Amazon pays a lot more tax in the USA because the US makes them. We could do the same.
User310 · 15/01/2022 14:33

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

When you take into consideration council tax, road tax VAT.. you will be very close!

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 15/01/2022 14:32

[quote TwiggletLover]@daimbarsatemydogsbone
I wouldn't describe those as benefits. Everyone in the country has access to those services whether they pay taxes or not. What I am referring to is things like child benefit, the tax free child care scheme, sharing your personal allowance as a married couple. None of these things are available to us as higher rate tax payers [/quote]
No they aren't - I have no need of them and I prefer they go to people who need them. I do receive a return for the taxes I pay in services, that's how it works. If you are only interested in what you get back there's no point in taxes at all.

dafey · 15/01/2022 14:32

Why not tax mega corporations such as amazon, google and facebook appropriately. Amazon in particular is killing off the high-street because it can undercut partly to paying very low taxes by being based offshore etc.

You can't target someone like Amazon unless it's a global initiative. Customers though could use their spending power & not shop there but the cheap prices suit them.

sqirrelfriends · 15/01/2022 14:31

No, we pay so much tax already.

If all additional date taxpayers lived in a cheap part of the world then sure, but most of us live in expensive places and don't feel particularly well off.

dafey · 15/01/2022 14:31

I think people would be more open to higher taxes if they felt the burden was equally spread.

BorsetshireBanality · 15/01/2022 14:30

Why not tax mega corporations such as amazon, google and facebook appropriately. Amazon in particular is killing off the high-street because it can undercut partly to paying very low taxes by being based offshore etc.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 15/01/2022 14:29

@HermioneWeasley

Nope, if the government can’t survive on half of everything I earn, they’ll have to cut their cloth. I’m happy to come and help them cut budgets - no money to stonewall, reduce budgets for any police force recording non Crime hate incidents off the top of my head,
You aren't paying half of everything you earn.
Amaya89 · 15/01/2022 14:28

I'm not a high rate tax payer and lately really struggle month to month with bill increases, but the idea of taxing higher earners more really bothers me. An increase on tax for unearned income seems a much better solution than pulling yet more money from people that have worked to earn what they have.

dafey · 15/01/2022 14:28

I moved house and paid around 65k in stamp duty (for a nice but fairly normal family home in the south east).

This is a huge problem, the fairly normal home cost 1m plus.

dafey · 15/01/2022 14:26

@RedToothBrush has a point though, there is too much burden on the young when you take into account housing costs.

Cam2020 · 15/01/2022 14:25

Public services need to address their problems before I'd ever back that. It's like putting more water into a leaky bucket.

I'm not an additional tax payer though, I'm one of the poor sods stuck on the 40% tax bracket, living in the SE.

eurochick · 15/01/2022 14:24

One year I earned around 200k. A substantial amount, obviously.

I paid around 90k in income tax. I moved house and paid around 65k in stamp duty (for a nice but fairly normal family home in the south east). Out of the remaining 45k I paid council tax, employer tax for our nanny, VAT, etc. I feel like the govt got a decent share!

Blinky21 · 15/01/2022 14:22

I'm happy to pay more for a fair society to help those less privileged than me, but then I'm not a Tory

arethereanyleftatall · 15/01/2022 14:21

@IllManneredBitch
Ah, I should have said - it was a very well known comedian off the tv who did this experiment. It was for the bbc, clearly presented as not a scam.