Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Quite a lot of better off people would be happy to pay more tax?

368 replies

Echobelly · 15/01/2022 10:48

Provided it was channeled towards things like NHS, social care, education.

It seems weirdly outdated to me that mainstream political parties find raising taxes on the wealthy anathema. We've been living in such a low-tax society for so long, but households like mine (I'd say it's a 6-figure annual income between us) could easily afford to pay more in tax and still enjoy our lives.

But instead parties are obsessed with recouping money by removing benefits for the poorest people, which is stupid as the difficulties resulting from plunging people into greater poverty, as well as being cruel, will ultimately cost more money than it saves.

Take that money off people like me in taxes! We won't become homeless or sick or suffer mental distress for the sake of a bit more tax. Year after year I see budgets that will apparently save people like me £500 a year, as if this is supposed to be an incentive to vote for the Tories but tbh, I won't even notice being better off by £500 a year. Give that saving to someone for whom it'll make an impact!

OP posts:
caringcarer · 15/01/2022 15:55

OP if you would be delighted to pay more tax nothing to stop you contacting tax office and telling them how much extra YOU want to pay. Others on higher incomes may not wish to use their disposable income in yet more tax. Each to their own. I don't think you can speak for anyone other than yourself. So crack on with your additional tax payments.

whowhatwhen · 15/01/2022 15:55

Only if it was spent and controlled properly, which it won't be, so no.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 15/01/2022 15:51

@blueshoes

Absolutely not. Higher earners already pay close to 50% on tax.

Whenever you see posts on mn asking whether to take the stressful high paying job with a longer commute or a lower paying local one, the majority say go for the latter, life is for living, life is too short, your fault for living in London.

So NO. I am not further subsidising people to have a nice stressless public services-rich life.

Absolutely not. Higher earners already pay close to 50% on tax. Why do people keep spouting this bollocks? Unless you're that PP who weirdly insists on in including employers NI this is simply untrue, except as a marginal rate.
Chewbecca · 15/01/2022 15:49

I agree OP

% wise, we pay less tax now than my entire working life. It’s no wonder we complain we get worse services.

However, I do think we need more confidence that those services are well run and spending our taxes wisely and efficiently- we don’t currently have this.

The posters suggesting voluntary additional contributions are just deflecting, it would need to be across the board, guaranteed higher funding to result in better services, the odd donation here and there doesn’t do the job. And it shouldn’t be the role of charities to pick up the slack.

user1497207191 · 15/01/2022 15:47

@Biker47

You could probably double or treble the NHS's budget at midnight tonight, and in 10 years times it'll still be the cesspit it is and somehow in the middle of the "worst crisis it's ever faced".
Labour trebled it, and yes, a few years later it was in trouble again.
blueshoes · 15/01/2022 15:45

Absolutely not. Higher earners already pay close to 50% on tax.

Whenever you see posts on mn asking whether to take the stressful high paying job with a longer commute or a lower paying local one, the majority say go for the latter, life is for living, life is too short, your fault for living in London.

So NO. I am not further subsidising people to have a nice stressless public services-rich life.

ChateauMargaux · 15/01/2022 15:45

Interesting point on the first page by @Ifailed.. claiming that X% of the total income tax is paid by Y% of the higher earnings.. this ignores several other wealth and income parameters that should be included for context like... half of all private wealth is held by 10% of British households and 50% of England is owned by 1% of the population. Much of the UK's income and wealth is held in offshore companies that pay no UK taxes. It's not as simple as saying 10% of the population pays 60% of the income tax (I believe the actual figure is closer to 1/3...).. and income tax is not the only tax, VAT, NI are also burdens that are born unequally.

HardbackWriter · 15/01/2022 15:40

@Biker47

You could probably double or treble the NHS's budget at midnight tonight, and in 10 years times it'll still be the cesspit it is and somehow in the middle of the "worst crisis it's ever faced".
I think this is true but not because the money is wasted but because the NHS wasn't created for a world where people live so long, and with chronic health problems for so long, and no one has really figured it out how it can work in that world, and no one wants to talk about it. So it keeps running in the same way but it just doesn't work anymore.
Biker47 · 15/01/2022 15:36

You could probably double or treble the NHS's budget at midnight tonight, and in 10 years times it'll still be the cesspit it is and somehow in the middle of the "worst crisis it's ever faced".

rifling · 15/01/2022 15:31

I agree up to a point - the point being that I don't trust the government to actually spend the money wisely! After all, they have literally wasted millions, if not billions, on Brexit with no tangible benefits whatsoever. I would like to live in a country where education, health and the environment (including subsidised transport such as trains and buses) receive a lot more funding than they do. This government cares little about anything other than lining their own pockets though.

hertsnessex · 15/01/2022 15:30

not a chance. The robbing bastards take enough.

dafey · 15/01/2022 15:27

Personal finance boards are full of people putting money into pensions or working fewer hours or refusing promotions to avoid their taxable income going over £50k meaning they lose some/all of child benefit.

Really? do you mean if they earn 51k? You are not going to turn down a 60k job for child benefit.

user1497207191 · 15/01/2022 15:22

@Dontgetyerknicksinatwist

If you keep upping the tax that higher earners pay then surely it will get to the point where they think “what’s the point” and choose a lower paid less stressful job. Or move to a country with a lower tax bracket. I know I would.
That's exactly what has been happening for years. Doctors and dentists started to reduce their working hours when they were hit by the 62% marginal tax rate on their earnings between £100k and £125k.

Personal finance boards are full of people putting money into pensions or working fewer hours or refusing promotions to avoid their taxable income going over £50k meaning they lose some/all of child benefit.

Lower paid people taking 2 part time jobs instead of a full time job to avoid paying national insurance.

The entire tax system is full of thresholds etc which drive behaviour detrimental to tax revenue, usually brought in, ironically, to raise tax revenue.

Dontgetyerknicksinatwist · 15/01/2022 15:16

If you keep upping the tax that higher earners pay then surely it will get to the point where they think “what’s the point” and choose a lower paid less stressful job. Or move to a country with a lower tax bracket. I know I would.

edwinbear · 15/01/2022 15:07

I pay a marginal rate of 60% on part of my earnings, I feel I pay quite enough tax.

thecatsthecats · 15/01/2022 15:05

Reading this thread, I actually prefer the idea of contributing to charity more directly.

I don't think or believe that governments - especially THIS government deserve more of our money, and therefore control. The NHS is hugely wasteful in resourcing.

I'd rather donate money to say, charities supporting green and healthy living to prevent illness than more to the ministry of sickness.

dafey · 15/01/2022 14:59

@ReallyaSecretMillionaire good post

generaljake · 15/01/2022 14:53

@fridarose plenty of people at all incomes are in stressful jobs. Many without the safety net of financial security. I think you need a better argument than that. Although I am interested. Do you really think that there’s some sort of hierarchy where better paid people work harder or something?

ReallyaSecretMillionaire · 15/01/2022 14:51

@Echobelly, YANBU, and I would further add that one group of people , to which I belong, that really can afford to pay more tax, is people with a good standard of living whose main source of money to fund living expenses is savings and wealth, rather than work. in the UK, income in the form of dividends, interest and capital appreciation are all taxed at much lower rates than income from work.

  1. there is less or no national insurance to pay on any of the above
  2. dividends benefit from a separate, lower tax rate
  3. capital gains benefit from a separate, even lower tax rate
  4. people with extra money can do things to get extra tax deductions or exclusions that are unavailable to people without extra money. This includes EIS investments, pension contributions, charitable contributions and VCTs among others. Selling a primary residence is also tax-free, which makes sense in many ways (the opposite could leave the average homeowner trapped and unable to move at all), but this does also give yet another way for a wealthy person to enjoy tax-free capital gains.
  5. perhaps most importantly: the owner of investment assets can choose the timing of realisation of gains, and therefore has ways to further manage down the tax by holding most assets and their inbuilt gains over time. They can even borrow to a certain extent against the assets in order to access cash for upfront spending, without realising the gain and selling the asset.

What would really be needed to claim a fairer share of tax from the wealthy would be a change in the way investment income and gains are taxed. This is challenging because very wealthy people are often more mobile and sometimes willing to move in order to reduce tax bills. But "challenging" does not mean "should not be done". I am not a tax policy maker, but there must be set of policies that would make it harder for this type of legal tax avoidance (aka "tax planning") to result in very, very low tax rates for the wealthiest, without causing all of them to leave.

Unfortunately I have not seen any politicians offering sensible proposals to do this: it's either the Tories for whom any tax increase on the wealthy is anathema, or it's Labour for whom any value accretion through asset ownership is borderline morally reprehensible and should be punished through some sort of confiscatory taxation. In my own view, investing in productive assets can be socially very useful, but part of the social utility also should come in the form of a fair (which means higher than now) means-based contribution to the collective institutions and infrastructure that enable the wealth increase to occur in the first place.

BoredZelda · 15/01/2022 14:47

An example of this is the five week wait for universal credit. Yes I could give money to my local food bank so my neighbours don’t starve, but I’d rather pay tax for DWP to pay staff so that they can process the claims within a week. More efficient and dignified for all.

I agree, although I’d be looking for the increase in staff to reduce the 3 month wait for people to get disability benefits.

BoredZelda · 15/01/2022 14:45

Depends what you define as better off. The people at the lower end of the defined group who might already be struggling wouldn’t be happy.

I’m not so sure about that. I’m in the higher tax bracket but only just. Scotland has increased our taxes by 1% and it costs me 300 a year more than if I lived in England. That’s roughly a pound a day. Can’t say I’ve noticed.

AliveAndSleeping · 15/01/2022 14:41

@MichelleScarn

Are you donating some of this money you don't need all ready? Say to cancer charities who provide free transport to chemo patients, to homelessness charities who run shelters, to family centres who provide free afterschool clubs and meals to children in need etc? Your money would be better off their rather than being lost in taxes and not really going anywhere.
No, it wouldn't. What a single person can donate on charity is a drop in the ocean compared to taxation. That's why the super rich avoiding tax but donating to their pet charity To make themselves look good is a fallacy.

Taxation pays for the things that we all (or many of us) require but can't afford to finance on our own no matter how well off we are.

Yes, I'd be happy to pay more tax even for stuff that might not (directly) affect me. I believe a society that looks after everyone is a better society even for those that think they don't need so much looking after.

I think though it's the super wealthy and large corporate donors that the Tories are trying to protect from tax and not middle class or upper middle class tax payers.

Pendolino · 15/01/2022 14:41

@SarahBellam

Donating money to charity doesn’t solve the major systemic problems though. All it does it plug some gaps and tinker about round the edges. Systemic change requires political leadership and at national level at least we have a government currently that exists in an ethical and credibility vacuum
An example of this is the five week wait for universal credit. Yes I could give money to my local food bank so my neighbours don’t starve, but I’d rather pay tax for DWP to pay staff so that they can process the claims within a week. More efficient and dignified for all.
dafey · 15/01/2022 14:40

@daimbarsatemydogsbone but they don't pay what they should in the US though!

bordermidgebite · 15/01/2022 14:39

No large organisation are really efficient in every aspect - it's a myth that it would be easy for the NHS to be really more efficient

The nhs gets us a lot for how much it costs - it's pretty hard to find and health service that is as effective for less cash ( although some of the more recent schemes to improve efficiency are wasteful)

Private organisations can spend 10 to 20% of thier budget in marketing and advertising ffs

Swipe left for the next trending thread