Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Quite a lot of better off people would be happy to pay more tax?

368 replies

Echobelly · 15/01/2022 10:48

Provided it was channeled towards things like NHS, social care, education.

It seems weirdly outdated to me that mainstream political parties find raising taxes on the wealthy anathema. We've been living in such a low-tax society for so long, but households like mine (I'd say it's a 6-figure annual income between us) could easily afford to pay more in tax and still enjoy our lives.

But instead parties are obsessed with recouping money by removing benefits for the poorest people, which is stupid as the difficulties resulting from plunging people into greater poverty, as well as being cruel, will ultimately cost more money than it saves.

Take that money off people like me in taxes! We won't become homeless or sick or suffer mental distress for the sake of a bit more tax. Year after year I see budgets that will apparently save people like me £500 a year, as if this is supposed to be an incentive to vote for the Tories but tbh, I won't even notice being better off by £500 a year. Give that saving to someone for whom it'll make an impact!

OP posts:
Snakeplisskensmum · 16/01/2022 07:08

@THisbackwithavengeance I so agree with you. One of my absolute big bears is people talking about the lack of funding to NHS etc when they've never been given as much cash! The issue is how it's spent!
I've spent 30 years dealing with Govt and the wastage at grass roots level in procurement, admin, people taking the piss is shocking.
The management needs sorting our not the funding! You can't keep throwing cash down a massive black hole and expecting different results.

ReallyaSecretMillionaire · 16/01/2022 04:25

@Sussex89 What I’m saying is that the effective tax rate for income earnt between £100-£125k is 63.5%. DP and I contribute 14.5% into our pensions. So for every £1 we earn between £100-125k we will pay 74% in PAYE+NI+pension contributions. So from the remaining 24p in the £1 how much more do you think we should pay?!

Is the 14.5% into your pension really a tax, meaning that you will never, ever get anything extra back for that 14.5%? Or is it really deferred savings, meaning that it gets added to a pension pot with your name on it or at least adds to your DB benefit eligibility if you have a defined benefit pension, meaning that you will get it back in the future, plus accumulated investment earnings, less income tax that will be paid on it in the future because pension contributions are made out of pretax income?

Also, while it may be true that each individual £1 from £100k to £125k is taxed at a marginal rate of 63.5%, would you not agree that any £1 above £125k is taxed at a meaningfully lower rate, somewhere in the neighbourhood of 47-49%? and furthermore that anyone with income falling right between £100k and £125k likely has access to certain deductions (such as additional pension contributions or even charitable contributions) to bring their taxable income right down to or at least towards £100k?

While I have been arguing that increasing taxes on unearned income and gains would be the fairest way to increase tax revenue to HMRC, I also think that focussing on the anomalous 63.5% effective tax band in UK is not a good argument against income tax increases for high earners. One could, for example, eliminate the phaseout of the personal allowance, but also raise the additional rate from 45% to 50% and start the threshhold for that rate at £100k instead of £125k. A person on £100k-125k would see a tax cut, a person on £125k-150k would see a smaller tax cut, a person at £150k would pay exactly what they pay now, and only a person earning more than £150k would see a tax increase.

The highest marginal tax rate would be 50% for income tax or 53.5% including NI, and it would apply from £100k on up. As a bonus, the tax calculation would become simpler.

Sort0f · 16/01/2022 00:50

DH earns about £250k. Works about 70-80 hours a week. Top rate taxpayer and he always votes for parties who would increase taxation.

He works ina very specialised area of accountancy. He is also very clear on how much could be down to reduce corruption, tax evasion and tax avoidance with relatively little effort in relation to how much money could be brought in.

Sort0f · 16/01/2022 00:47

Totally agree. You can’t build a decent society with such low taxation.

purplehairlady · 16/01/2022 00:19

[quote Echobelly]@lfailed - i think the top 10% of people, which includes us, generally pay a fairly small % of our earnings into tax nonetheless.[/quote]
What percentage tax do you pay?

If a higher salaried rate taxpayer it would be close to 50%.

How much more do you want people to pay??

Sussex89 · 16/01/2022 00:15

DP and I are senior NHS doctors. We have trained for 6 years at Med School and have been working nearly 15 years in the NHS. We are both in acute specialties. So make life/limb decisions on a daily basis. Are responsible for a team of “juniors” (who by the way are highly trained in their own right). Are the ones before coroners if something goes wrong under our names care - even if we didn’t have anything physically to do with it. Deal with piles of paperwork/complaints/needless DoD directives. Is that enough to justify our pay? And reluctance to pay anymore into the system?

Bitbloweyoutthere · 16/01/2022 00:07

Just out of interest, how much harder does the person on 125 work than the person on 40? I earn around the lower figure and regularly work around 50- 60 hours a week in a stressful job, with responsibility. If I were to be paid 125 for doing that, I'd happily pay more tax.

Sussex89 · 16/01/2022 00:01

Correction 78% effective rate

Sussex89 · 16/01/2022 00:00

jcyclops. I know the overall effective tax rate will always be lower than the top rate of tax an individual pays on their last £1 earnt.

What I’m saying is that the effective tax rate for income earnt between £100-£125k is 63.5%. DP and I contribute 14.5% into our pensions. So for every £1 we earn between £100-125k we will pay 74% in PAYE+NI+pension contributions. So from the remaining 24p in the £1 how much more do you think we should pay?!

It only gets marginally better at over £125k when the effective PAYE+NI+pensions rate is 61%

jcyclops · 15/01/2022 23:50

@Sussex89

Absolutely NO way would we agree to pay more tax. DP and I have paid well over £250k (quarter of a million!!!) in tax over the last 3 years. We get no benefits for our DS. Nothing from the state. We are absolute NET contributors already.

Remember between £100-£125k people are taxed at an effective 60% PAYE tax rate. In addition to the new rate of NI - we’re already paying 63.5% in tax and NI. In addition to pension contributions we’re keeping less than 30p in the £1!!

When does the magic middle class money tree end?!

£125k salary in 21/22 pays £42,428 income tax and £6,379 in National Insurance, and takes home £76,193. Taxation is 39.0%.

For comparison:
62.5k salary pays £12,428 income tax and £5,129 in National Insurance and takes home £44,943 - taxation is 28.1%
40k salary pays £5,484 income tax and £3,652 in National Insurance, and takes home £30,864 - taxation is 22.8%.
25k salary pays £2,484 income tax and £1,852 in National Insurance and takes home £20,664 - taxation is 17.3%

From the tax calculator www.moneysavingexpert.com/tax-calculator/ excludes pension and student loans. Scotland will be different.

Sussex89 · 15/01/2022 23:14

Absolutely NO way would we agree to pay more tax. DP and I have paid well over £250k (quarter of a million!!!) in tax over the last 3 years. We get no benefits for our DS. Nothing from the state. We are absolute NET contributors already.

Remember between £100-£125k people are taxed at an effective 60% PAYE tax rate. In addition to the new rate of NI - we’re already paying 63.5% in tax and NI. In addition to pension contributions we’re keeping less than 30p in the £1!!

When does the magic middle class money tree end?!

Fr0thandBubble · 15/01/2022 22:37

@blueshoes

what about the poorly children whose parents do not earn 150k plus they have to rely on the NHS or most likely go without.... because people dont pay enough tax....

What about people who choose lower paid jobs for a low stress life who don't pay the tax they would had they chosen to take a higher paying job?

People at the top 45% rates pay more than enough even at a progressive rate. Many of these people are based in London which has some of the highest cost of housing. It is not much change after tax and mortgages are taken into account. Someone has got to take on these high stress jobs otherwise they would kick back like others do and move out of London in a lower cost housing part of the country with a public sector job and utilise more public services.

Hear hear.
blueshoes · 15/01/2022 22:36

what about the poorly children whose parents do not earn 150k plus they have to rely on the NHS or most likely go without.... because people dont pay enough tax....

What about people who choose lower paid jobs for a low stress life who don't pay the tax they would had they chosen to take a higher paying job?

People at the top 45% rates pay more than enough even at a progressive rate. Many of these people are based in London which has some of the highest cost of housing. It is not much change after tax and mortgages are taken into account. Someone has got to take on these high stress jobs otherwise they would kick back like others do and move out of London in a lower cost housing part of the country with a public sector job and utilise more public services.

Alexandra2001 · 15/01/2022 22:20

If your paying 45% income tax, you are only paying it on earnings above 150k, 40% on 113k and 20% on 37k.

what about the poorly children whose parents do not earn 150k plus they have to rely on the NHS or most likely go without.... because people dont pay enough tax....

Fr0thandBubble · 15/01/2022 22:11

No, sorry, I pay enough tax.

I work all the hours God sends in a highly skilled job that not many people could do. I had to train for 3 years after uni to in order to qualify into my profession. I hardly get to see my children, and am very stressed most of the time doing I job I really dislike (for those wondering why I do it, I have a child with special needs that I need to provide for). Well over half of my income goes in tax (when you factor in a 45% tax rate, no Personal Allowance, VAT, council tax and SDLT). I'm well off but I don't have enough money left after bills are paid in order to pay for all the therapy my DS could really do with.

Why do people feel entitled to more of my hard-earned money? If you want to give more of your money away, go ahead - but don't try to say I should be giving more of mine.

Alexandra2001 · 15/01/2022 22:09

[quote 1dayatatime]@Alexandra2001

"We have some of the lowest taxes for the wealthy in Europe"

++++

You may feel this way except the hard evidence shows it's not true.
[/quote]
Well we are lower than 14 other countries inc all comparable economies plus we have lower vat, more tax loop holes, far less bandings and tax property less - oh and VAT free private schools...

Alexandra2001 · 15/01/2022 22:06

@user1497207191

Talking about “rich” people, Labour had to do sweetheart deals with some non resident Olympic athletes as they threatened not to come to the London Olympics if they had to pay UK tax under normal rules.
The London Olympics were under the Tories, who had been in for 2 years.
PetsL · 15/01/2022 22:02

Yabu. Just donate your excess cash to cancer charities, homeless charities or hmrc themselves via the government link.

Yabvu to expect others to pay more too, the highest income tax rate is 50%, that is plenty.

liliainterfrutices · 15/01/2022 22:00

@forinborin

For anyone who declares that you are happy to pay more tax, there's already a way for you to do it. The published tax rate are minimum tax rates, you can overpay voluntarily, just let the HMRC know that you would like to do so. Problem solved!
Well I said I would but that's provided that it was linked to good public services. Paying for Dido Harding to get £37 billion for a failed Test and Trace, not so much. If Labour published a manifesto withhighertax rates, it wouldn’t put me off at all.
DdraigGoch · 15/01/2022 21:59

OP if you are so eager to contribute more, there's nothing stopping you from sending an email to the Treasury, asking them for the account details.

forinborin · 15/01/2022 21:54

For anyone who declares that you are happy to pay more tax, there's already a way for you to do it. The published tax rate are minimum tax rates, you can overpay voluntarily, just let the HMRC know that you would like to do so.
Problem solved!

blueshoes · 15/01/2022 21:50

You pay 20% tax on a significant proportion of you income. As I said, the 50% is a marginal rate.

Do explain.

I hardly pay 20% on my income. That is a miniscule amount of my income compared to the amounts dh and I pay on the rest of our income. I really do not know what you are talking about. I know what my tax return says. I know what my bank account says.

If I pay 20% on a significant portion of my income as you say I would consider myself to be living in a tax haven.

AhNowTed · 15/01/2022 20:58

Once upon a time I would have said this. Not any more. I've paid enough, and am sick to death of watching the very rich pay nothing, and the levels of corruption in government.

user1497207191 · 15/01/2022 20:38

Talking about “rich” people, Labour had to do sweetheart deals with some non resident Olympic athletes as they threatened not to come to the London Olympics if they had to pay UK tax under normal rules.

WinnersDinner · 15/01/2022 20:36

@RandomMess

We both earn a bit above UK average salary. I would happy to pay a bit more things need to change so the lower paid are taxed less.

A big increase in the tax free allowance offset by an increase of the basic and higher tax rate would achieve this.

Do you consider just above the U.K. average to be 'better off'?