Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Quite a lot of better off people would be happy to pay more tax?

368 replies

Echobelly · 15/01/2022 10:48

Provided it was channeled towards things like NHS, social care, education.

It seems weirdly outdated to me that mainstream political parties find raising taxes on the wealthy anathema. We've been living in such a low-tax society for so long, but households like mine (I'd say it's a 6-figure annual income between us) could easily afford to pay more in tax and still enjoy our lives.

But instead parties are obsessed with recouping money by removing benefits for the poorest people, which is stupid as the difficulties resulting from plunging people into greater poverty, as well as being cruel, will ultimately cost more money than it saves.

Take that money off people like me in taxes! We won't become homeless or sick or suffer mental distress for the sake of a bit more tax. Year after year I see budgets that will apparently save people like me £500 a year, as if this is supposed to be an incentive to vote for the Tories but tbh, I won't even notice being better off by £500 a year. Give that saving to someone for whom it'll make an impact!

OP posts:
Brainwave89 · 17/01/2022 16:23

@Floundery

Exactly why the NHS will disappear should they win the next GE

I don't think this threat has the teeth it once has. Too many people get poor or non-existent NHS care. We all know that European systems are better and that the US is not the only alternative. We've all been duped into "saving the NHS" enough times to know it's a busted flush.

I just wish they'd be more honest about it.

Agreed. It is a myth that our public services are great. Healthcare is much better in Europe in my opinion. It is easier to get to see a doctor, treatment is quicker and overall more is spent. The principal being there is no issue spending more if this guarantees care when it is needed- which in the NHS it does not. One poster said earlier would we refuse an ambulance as we have got private healthcare? In my region, ambulances are not coming at all at the moment, and this is only in part down to Covid.
Floundery · 17/01/2022 15:26

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

user1497207191 · 17/01/2022 15:16

@Alexandra2001

As Thatcher said "the problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money"

Exactly why the NHS will disappear should they win the next GE.

However, given the overall tax burden is the highest since WW2 and that the Govt p!$$ed away £43 billion of "other peoples money" on a largely failed test/trackntrace/PPE program, even handing contracts to their personal contacts, i don't think that socialism is the real problem here.

How many billions did Blair give to his financial market friends in all those ruinous PFI contracts for schools, hospitals, etc - the last figure I saw was more than £43 billion.
lampygirl · 17/01/2022 14:29

The system is not set up to support the average person. If my company went bust as someone with a mortgage and no kids I’d be eligible for diddly squat, so I put my money into savings for myself. I’d not be happy at having to pay more tax to go into the general coffers tbh.

Brainwave89 · 17/01/2022 13:48

To be very honest, no I would not be happy to be paying more tax. I already pay most of my salary is taxed at 40 and 45%, a good slug of council tax, VAT and 10% of NI is added to this. As a rule of thumb, when more than 50% of income is disappearing in tax, the rate is too high. I would prefer more use of insurance- I would not ask anyone to fund my care in later life and would bring in insurance to cover this and slimming down the public sector.

Alexandra2001 · 17/01/2022 13:31

As Thatcher said "the problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money"

Exactly why the NHS will disappear should they win the next GE.

However, given the overall tax burden is the highest since WW2 and that the Govt p!$$ed away £43 billion of "other peoples money" on a largely failed test/trackntrace/PPE program, even handing contracts to their personal contacts, i don't think that socialism is the real problem here.

Pazuzu · 17/01/2022 11:10

@RandomLondoner

Tip: being generous with other people's money does not make you nice.

The people like you who are willing to give away money are free to do so, and in all likelihood will be able to spend it better than the government would.

Don't try and rope in people who don't have the same feelings and priorities. For example, it is perfectly reasonable for any person to think they don't have enough money unless they could maintain their lifestyle for the rest of their life, without working, if they lost their job tomorrow. Almost no-one who works for a living is that well off.

Well put.

As Thatcher said "the problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money".

user1497207191 · 17/01/2022 11:01

@Alexandra2001

Well we are lower than 14 other countries inc all comparable economies plus we have lower vat, more tax loop holes, far less bandings and tax property less

You really can't compare UK taxes directly against other countries because rules/tax are very different.

Yes, our "headline" income tax rate may be lower than some, but some other countries allow workers to deduct expenses, such as commuting, private healthcare costs, etc from their wages pre-tax, whereas we don't in the UK.

Yes, our "headline" VAT rate is lower than some, but some other countries have permanently lower rates for certain types of supply, so VAT on some things in those countries is less than in the UK.

As for property tax, you can't just compare council tax etc., as some other countries have other property taxes, such as no exemption for capital gains on the home you live in.

There are few, if any, countries, where you can draw an exact comparison, i.e. exactly the same taxes, but just different rates.

user1497207191 · 17/01/2022 10:48

It's not just staffing though. My OH has cancer and takes a cocktail of tablets. One of them is a chemo tablet which costs over £1k PER TABLET, but he's got loads spare because the monthly prescription is 3 tablets, but his haematologist has told him to only take 2, so he has a spare every month. Same with another tablet where the prescription is 21 per month, but he's told to take 1 every second day, so only uses 10 or 11 per month - they cost £300 per tablet. (costs per NHS website). That's on top of cheaper tablets he doesn't take but which are prescribed automatically such as anti sickness and anti diarrhoea. He's asked many times for the haematologist to stop prescribing the ones he's not taking but apparently "it's too much hassle" to change the prescription. So OH has thousands of pounds of tablets in the cupboard, and that's just growing every month. There's just no accountability in the NHS - they spend money without regard!

SussexSussex · 16/01/2022 23:04

As a senior NHS Doctor. The waste in our system is astounding. In our trust we have Divisional Directors, then under that multiple operation managers, then under that multiple deputy operation mangers. Then we have a layer of office managers/waiting list managers/admin managers the list goes on. This model is repeated for “Medical/Surgical/Emergency/Support Service” etc divisions. At the top end the managers are on equivalent salaries to us Consultants.

I for one have no idea what they do aside from act as an irritant to my Consultant colleagues and m

Alexandra2001 · 16/01/2022 18:22

@Snakeplisskensmum I wouldn't argue with you on waste but it exists in all large organisations, public or private s and of course it has to be addressed.

But the UK has over decades spent less on health, inc prevention, than comparable european nations and that has a cost, as we now see in the NHS, which had 3m waiting for treatment pre CV, now its 6m, set to go to 12m (according to the Govt)
Thats a huge economic loss as well as a human tragedy, thats around 18% of the population!

Alexandra2001 · 16/01/2022 18:12

@Valeriekat

The UK is not a low tax economy. You obviously don't remember the early 70s when the top rate was over 90%... those who could do so left the country. Corporation tax in the UK is considered high compared to eg Ireland
Research worldwide shows its not the case at all.

“It’s very clear that, over all, modest changes in top tax rates do not affect millionaire migration,” he told me this week. “Neither tax increases nor tax cuts on the rich have affected their migration rates.”

The very rich flock to London but don't go off to Moscow, with far far lower rates.

www.nytimes.com/2013/02/16/business/high-taxes-are-not-a-prime-reason-for-relocation-studies-say.html

Snakeplisskensmum · 16/01/2022 17:58

@Alexandra2001 I've seen the mismanagement first hand for many many years and in response to your comment, I would be delighted to pay more tax if I could see the benefit of it, even if I do have private health care. The issue I have is that I have been involved in countless IT projects where many millions, if not billions have been thrown down the toilet because of personal politics, managers not having a clue what they're doing and not taking advice and taking a short term view. The waste is disgusting.

chopc · 16/01/2022 17:19

DS pays more than half his income in tax being a high earner and this is enough to buy a property outright i some areas. He says he doesn't mind if he can be first in the queue for any benefits such as healthcare ......

dafey · 16/01/2022 17:14

Using Ireland is a benchmark is like saying that the UK is a very warm country because it's warmer than in Finland. Ireland has one of the lowest corporate tax rates of any developed country.

Ireland is also a young country, I think the youngest in the EU so they are in a very different economic position.

liliainterfrutices · 16/01/2022 16:07

@forinborin

Well I said I would but that's provided that it was linked to good public services. Paying for Dido Harding to get £37 billion for a failed Test and Trace, not so much. If Labour published a manifesto withhighertax rates, it wouldn’t put me off at all. Then maybe the root of the problem is not the absolute amounts harvested through taxation as such, but rather mismanagement and incompetency? Can't fill up a leaking bucket, even if you open the tap further.
Fair point, yes. I don’t approve of the way in which the Tories use public money. I’d have more confidence in Labour.
Pendolino · 16/01/2022 15:37

I was about to post this. The UK is not a high tax country. More places pay proportionally more than those that pay less.

ReallyaSecretMillionaire · 16/01/2022 15:33

@Valeriekat

The UK is not a low tax economy. You obviously don't remember the early 70s when the top rate was over 90%... those who could do so left the country. Corporation tax in the UK is considered high compared to eg Ireland
Using Ireland is a benchmark is like saying that the UK is a very warm country because it's warmer than in Finland. Ireland has one of the lowest corporate tax rates of any developed country.

The UK has a slightly lower corporate tax rate than most of the rich countries in Europe, and it's also lower than in the US (even post the Trump tax cut).

forinborin · 16/01/2022 14:05

Well I said I would but that's provided that it was linked to good public services. Paying for Dido Harding to get £37 billion for a failed Test and Trace, not so much. If Labour published a manifesto withhighertax rates, it wouldn’t put me off at all.
Then maybe the root of the problem is not the absolute amounts harvested through taxation as such, but rather mismanagement and incompetency? Can't fill up a leaking bucket, even if you open the tap further.

Sussex89 · 16/01/2022 11:40

Fumblingbee. I entirely agree with you. Collectively DP and I pay anything between £80-90k a year in income tax alone. That doesn’t include the NI we pay or the VAT we pay on the spending from our post tax income.

We get absolutely no benefits for our DS as we both earn over £100k. We won’t get free childcare. Both have private health and dental cover. So what exactly are we getting for our money a year?!

Reallyasecretmillionaire - you clearly don’t understand public sector pensions. Our contributions aren’t linked to a pot in our own name. We are on CaREs now and the contributions simply go back into HMRCs massive pot. We contribute 14.5% the employer pays in a notional 20%. So very easily you reach your £40k annual allowance triggering MORE tax.

Whilst I’m not asking for anyone to pity us. I’m merely asking what more can you squeeze from the middle earners? Focus imho needs to be taken to means test more benefits - eg free tv licensing/free travel/green home grants for more wealthy pensioners/households.

worriedatthemoment · 16/01/2022 09:34

So op are you now going to voluntarily pay more tax in now you have seen its possible and the others who said they would or use the excuse oh well its not used properly
The nhs is actually pretty well funded compared to other countries, its often how the money is used
Charities will always exist to the poster who said they shouldn't feel the gap, as some will always spend money on wrong things or make the wrong financial decision etc
But i bet none of the people on here have now gone and signed up to pay more tax

Valeriekat · 16/01/2022 08:48

The UK is not a low tax economy.
You obviously don't remember the early 70s when the top rate was over 90%... those who could do so left the country.
Corporation tax in the UK is considered high compared to eg Ireland

fumblybumblingbee · 16/01/2022 08:38

I don't want to pay more tax because I believe the government is totally inept at distributing them appropriately. I don't think any amount of tax will save the NHS and can never understand why we can't move to one of the better European healthcare models. I feel taxes every which way I go, I couldn't get a school place in a school where my dc would speak the same language as everyone else (English) and my friend who's a teacher said my dc would most likely be isolated because all the dc were from a different background it meant culturally they'd had to change the way they taught as well ie ban Christmas/Easter celebrations/acknowledgement of most things British so I went private because those things are important to me, I could have moved to a much more expensive area but that's another tax already isn't it and tbh I tried and my house didn't sell on time.

I can never get an appointment to see a doctor so I go private, I can't see a dentist for me or my dc again have to pay privately.

Just such a massive pain and I really don't see how much tax I'd have to pay before this is all sorted out. We pay about £70k a year in taxes and have never claimed or been entitled to any benefits. I imagine if you pay less and can see a doctor/dentist get a good school place have dc benefit you're probably imagining yay let's pay more taxes. Not for me!!

Lavendersquare · 16/01/2022 07:41

@FridaRose

Also we are not driven by taxes going on nhs, as we have private healthcare. *
*
Good luck if you have a premature baby need a kidney transplant or heart bypass surgery done in a private hospital, the best your insurance will do is speed up seeing a consultant at the start.

It's unbelievably naive to think that having private health insurance comes any where near what the NHS provides, or negates your responsibility to pay towards it.

Alexandra2001 · 16/01/2022 07:32

[quote Snakeplisskensmum]@THisbackwithavengeance I so agree with you. One of my absolute big bears is people talking about the lack of funding to NHS etc when they've never been given as much cash! The issue is how it's spent!
I've spent 30 years dealing with Govt and the wastage at grass roots level in procurement, admin, people taking the piss is shocking.
The management needs sorting our not the funding! You can't keep throwing cash down a massive black hole and expecting different results. [/quote]
The problem with this argument (usually made by people who don't want to fund public services) is that the NHS scores very highly on efficiency, low on staff numbers and outcomes... on Doctors, the NHS has the 3rd lowest per 10,000 pop. of any european country.... to get more Doctors/Nurses and scanners etc takes money, no matter how you move it around, remember the Tories re organised the NHS under Thatcher and by Cameron - yet did not improve.

The NHS isn't getting all this record funding, it is getting a little extra money that will go someway to correcting 11 years of underfunding since 2010, where it got around 1% extra per year, compared to the 4% it was getting under Labour, where the NHS finally began to catch up with european HC systems and had its highest ever satisfaction ratings.

For those that say "we have private health, we don't use the NHS" the vast majority of Doctors and other private HC staff were trained by the NHS plus keep their skills up via their NHS work, so you are getting a direct benefit plus private often uses NHS facilities.