Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what the ideal mother in law looks like?

64 replies

motherormonsterinlaw · 15/01/2022 10:11

I've seen all sorts on here about mother in laws, whether to add them on Facebook when relationship is new, how they call to see where their precious son is if the relationship has broken down, how they expect to come visit for a week at a moments notice, favour certain GC, show distain if a GC is a certain sex, turn up unexpectedly on your holiday etc etc etc

I realise this is the extreme of MiL relationships but what does the ideal mother in law look like for you?

OP posts:
Crepusculum · 15/01/2022 15:25

I guess what a friend looks like to me - emotionally mature, caring, understands and respects boundaries (her own and other people's), interested in life and other people and so on...good fun would be nice too but not essential.

Billandben444 · 15/01/2022 15:21

@nokidshere
Well said.
And please don't refer to the mother of your boyfriend (who you've seeing for 2 months and just moved in with you and your 2 kids) as your MIL cos she isn't. She's sitting back waiting to see how long it lasts before she gets emotionally involved and treats you all like family (like she did last time and the time before). She's your boyfriend's mum, that's all.

nokidshere · 15/01/2022 15:08

I can’t understand how so many mil find it so hard to get on with their adult childrens new families. The amount of mil threads on here are unbelievable, as are the posters saying they dread becoming a mil because they’re so hated. But honestly, it’s really not hard to not be a complete knobhead is it? You just follow the general rules of life of being a decent person. Don’t stick your oar in in ANY situation. If your opinion wasn’t asked for then don’t give it. If you’re unsure of the parents wishes then ask (when would you like me to visit when the baby has been born? Would you like me to keep a travel cot/supplies at my house for if you visit? Would you like me to buy x for the baby or is it not needed? I’m happy to give you a break from the baby so let me know if you’d ever like me to babysit for a few hours/overnight etc). It’s not hard to use common sense.

I can't understand how so many DIL find the relationship so hard to get on with their in laws. It's not hard to be a complete knobhead is it? Just follow the rules of being a generally nice person. Maybe don't brush off every bit of their experiences as interfering, maybe accept gifts sometimes wether it's needed or not, maybe ask for some help instead of expecting them to be mind readers, maybe once in a while listen to their opinions - nod and smile you don't have to agree. And accept that getting older brings its own anxieties and be there for them in the way you expect them to be there for you.

I'm not a MIL. I loved my MIL, we didn't always agree and we annoyed each other at times but she loved her son, me and our children. We got on well for 40yrs because neither of us was a knobhead.

Peasweet · 15/01/2022 14:07

Every one of these posts from people whose mother in law is from marrying a son.. I am a mother in law to two sons in law who think I'm great! Grin

BitterTits · 15/01/2022 14:07

Mine is nice, I have only good things to say about my relationship with her. I wish she would grab life by the horns a little bit, having lost my own DM far too young, but that's not a complaint. She helps with childcare without intruding. She knows we both work hard and doesn't judge our priorities in not being able to maintain a pristine home. She has cleaned out oven a couple of times which some would consider to be overstepping the mark but absolutely does not offend me at all. I'm very happy that she's my MIL.

JanuaryBluehoo · 15/01/2022 14:06

Winnie I agree but unfortunately there are also personalality disorders at play as well.
People who are nasty or can't see their dc as separate people or people who can't see beyond shallows things like looks/dress /clothes etc.

HeadToToesNo · 15/01/2022 14:04

To me, the ideal mother in law looks very very small because she is very very far away.

JanuaryBluehoo · 15/01/2022 14:01

Why op?. What's your Mil like, or are you a Mil?..

pinkiepiee · 15/01/2022 13:57

My MIL is dead but DH says my DM is the ideal MIL. She is caring towards him, remembers his birthday and buys thoughtful gifts. She will ring a lot if he is poorly, just checking in. She's warm towards him and kind and supportive of his interests and career. But she is not overbearing. Would never drop round without an invite, would not be over familiar, would never make a joke at his expense. Essentially very gentle, respectful and caring.

He does not say the same about my DF though

TheSunIsStillShining · 15/01/2022 13:45

I have my ideal MIL. Been married for 25+ years. Have seen her 2x when we took our newborn for her to see and when our son was about 1. She wasn't interested in her own son who moved out at 14 or her grandson. I can live with that. So can my husband as he has my parents treat him as their own son (which can be weird sometimes, but at lest they love him).

ThrobbingToothacheOfTheMind · 15/01/2022 13:29

What’s the ideal mother like?
What’s the ideal DIL like?
What’s the ideal wife like?

If you really want to get into telling women how to behave and be “ideal”?

rushingallday · 15/01/2022 13:25

I think the true colours of a MIL come out when you've split with her son.

Then you'll know a good MIL. 😬

RampantIvy · 15/01/2022 13:23

@Theroughoperator

My late MIL was lovely she was rather homophobic and racist

We have differing views regarding the definition of lovely. Lovely people are not racist or homophobic!

I didn't respect her views on homophobia or racism, but the options would have been to be at loggerheads with her for 40 years, or just not discuss this subjects. I chose option B.

To give a bit of background. She was born in 1929 and grew up in the middle of nowhere in Northumberland, with no electricity or running water. She didn't encounter anyone of a different race to her until there were some Italian POWs at the end of the war, so she would have been about 16. She would have been older than that before she met a black person. I think her racist comments were naive, and based on the original meaning of ignorance - i e lacking knowkedge.

The homophobia was because she was very religious (but not evangelical about it).

JurgensCakeBabyJesus · 15/01/2022 13:21

Friendly, supportive, recognises DH isn't perfect, wonderful with my DC but very respectful of the choices we make (with things like sweets etc). Lives in the country and has lots of animals which is great for DS. Has great taste and buys me presents I would genuinely buy for myself and is very generous with her time but doesn't just show up unannounced. We see her every week and that would be too much for some, but it's no hassle, I now make sure I always have ingredients in for some quick veggie meals so we can extend spontaneous dinner invitations.
She also has an enviable shoe collection and the same size feet as me, but no matter how many times she offers I can't walk in the heels she can!

She and DH has a tumultuous relationship when he was younger and she wasn't the same personality she is now, but she's now more relaxed and DH more understanding of dinner if the trauma she's experienced and tried to shield him from. She's just a good person and you can't ask for more than that.

motherrunner · 15/01/2022 13:06

*love

motherrunner · 15/01/2022 13:04

I move my MIL. She’s the mum I never had.

Although she’s over 30 years older than me, we go out for lunch/coffees/boozy dinners! She never involves herself in any disagreements DH and I may have. She never undermines my parenting but likewise if she is in sole charge of DCs, I wouldn’t dream of telling her how to parent (she raised 3 wonderful children!).

Tbh, I feel very lucky to have the in-laws I do. I love them.

ashorterday · 15/01/2022 13:03

Friendly, supportive, but not overly demanding!

Mine is ok to be fair, if anything she's a little bit distant. I don't think she would ever want to meet up for coffee on our own or anything, even though I've known her over 30 years.

MarmaladeToastAndAMarmaladeCat · 15/01/2022 13:01

I’d really like it if mine was remotely interested in me as a human being for a start. For the first 10 years of my relationship with dh she showed not the tiniest bit of interest in me and then suddenly wanted to be a huge part of our lives once grandchildren came along. She seems to see me as a vessel for grandchildren/ inconvenient barrier to those grandchildren and thinks she entitled to an opinion on literally every aspect of how we are raising them. She is very hard work. My own mum by contrast, while not perfect respects the fact that while we may do some things very differently to her, that’s ok and it’s our decision as parents whereas mil tells us how everything we do is wrong and her (outdated) advice is right. Very tiresome.

SusanSHelit · 15/01/2022 12:55

Not thinking that no one could ever possibly be good enough for her children. I am apparently not good enough for dp despite the fact we have been together 15 years, but then neither have any of the perfectly pleasant men sil has brought home either. Mil has ended more than one sil's relationships bbecause sil's bf/partner has been so wholly unwelcomed and outright ridiculed by mil.

It's quite sad really.

I have a ds and although he is still very young, I hope that I don't behave like my mil when he gets himself a partner. As long as he is happy whoever he goes out with is good enough as far as I am concerned, with obvious exceptions like violent criminals etc.

Other than that I think, offer help if you can provide it. Don't say you can help then don't.

When dc are tiny babies, the advice around newborns will probably have changed, and the parents will probably be following whatever that advice is. Trust their judgement with their dc and don't interfere. You have had your turn it's theirs now.

When buying dc presents, please, please, please consider the size of the house they live in, the available space and the practically of what you are buying.

Yes it would be lovely if dc could have a full size fuseball table, a giant Tracey Island, a play Fort, tent and five foot Teddy bear. But they live in a two bed terraced house with both parents, where exactly are they supposed to put those lovely gifts?

Don't take it upon yourself to do ANY 'first', of any description. Especially with a first born. Especially especially when that first born is very likely to be an only. It is absolutely not your place to take that from the parents. Ask by all means, but expect a no.

Generally just try not to be an interfering know it all tit. Mum (and dad) really do know best. Remember you are neither.

Offtobednow · 15/01/2022 12:12

My lovely MIL always says she’s gained another daughter not lost a son. She’s supportive and fun to chat to. I see her as an extra mum and she’s someone I would be friends with if I hadn’t married her son.

Theroughoperator · 15/01/2022 12:00

My late MIL was lovely
she was rather homophobic and racist

We have differing views regarding the definition of lovely. Lovely people are not racist or homophobic!

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 15/01/2022 11:59

Ideal is supportive but unjudgemental, neutral/ evenhanded yet affectionate to the grandchildren, emotionally and practically available but on both those fronts undemanding, humourous but not at anyone's expense... But mil are just people and no human is actually that perfect unless they're really, really self aware and living in ideal circumstances themselves...

SnowDropMania · 15/01/2022 11:59

I would want them to be pleasant and not too interfering. That's all

Laiste · 15/01/2022 11:54

I have a better relationship with my MIL than my DM. Having said that, although i'm friendly and smiley and chatty i like to keep my own council. A visit once every 2 months or so is enough.

MIL is fine with this - friendly a d chatty too. I know she respects me as a capable mother and a woman who doesn't need anyone interfering. She doesn't pry or try and change anything.

She has a lot of praise for DH and how we're raising the kids. Because of this i drop my gaurd and she knows lots about our lives.

Perfect MIL for me.

Hemingwayzcatz · 15/01/2022 11:51

Not turning up unannounced and letting yourself in is a starting point. Not dishing out your opinions when nobody asked and not thinking you’re always right. Just being supportive but in a distant way so you’re not smothering your D/SIL.