Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To talk to son’s ‘friend’s’ mum?

187 replies

ScatteredMama82 · 15/01/2022 00:11

My DS is 12. Has been friends with this bit, let’s call him Oliver, since toddler group. I’m friends with his mum, not close friends but we do socialise occasionally. Dos and Oliver both moved to the same school last year. They were friendly to begin with but Oliver is now in the ‘in’ crowd and DS isn’t. Oliver seems to be making a low-level campaign against DS. If DS sits at the same lunch table Oliver gets up and moves and takes his mates with him, on occasion leaving DS sitting on his own. He’s telling people DS is weird, annoying, lazy, crap at sport etc and DS is finding other people he thought we’re friends are now pulling away from him too. Do I speak to Oliver’s mum, or do I speak to school? Or do nothing? Is this normal adjustment of friendship groups? I’m thinking it is verging on bullying but I worry I am overreacting. DS is crying in bed and I’m absolutely raging at Oliver, so I need some perspective please fellow MNers!

OP posts:
sydenhamhiller · 16/01/2022 12:58

@Neolara

I would talk to the school. It's not verging on bullying. It is bullying. Sorry your son is going through this.
This ^^.

It is bullying.

I have three kids, and middle one had this situation, always tricky when their parent is part of wider friendship circle.

I went through school. Always go through school. It happens at school, Oliver’s mum can’t police what happens at school, and in my experience, most parents get very defensive in this situation.

Let school handle it. Contact them by email (I would email form tutor and also head of pastoral affairs, who is usually someone a bit higher up the hierarchy); state how many times it has happened; explain how it makes son feel; say you look forward to their response of how they will implement their anti bullying policy to make sure this will no longer be happening, you are so grateful for their support in this matter… and if you don’t hear anything by end of the week, forward it again, moving up the SLT hierarchy - maybe to an assistant or deputy head this time.

I would leave it up to Oliver’s mum if she contacts you about it.

I have been you with Dc1 and DC2. In dc1ma case, when I turned up at primary next day, Oliver’s dad burst into tears and cried about how mortified he was.

In DC2’s case, her friend’s mum responded with a ‘I’m sorry your DC2 and you felt she had to complain to school about this’ apology. Our friendship has not recovered, and I am civil at group gatherings but make sure I am the other side of the room for most of the evening…

It’s great your son is telling you about this, and he is very lucky to have you fighting his corner with him.

MammaRoly · 16/01/2022 12:55

Just to add from the other perspective..... My DS is a little younger in Year 4 but I was horrified to get called in to school this week about issues with a boy who I would think of as his best friend. He claims DS is boisterous and makes him feel excluded. I felt sick hearing DS' behaviour described as such. But also that the Mum (who I am on good speaking terms with) didn't say anything to me first or as well as the school.

This thread is making me think about why she didn't say anything - was she trying to get her son to stand up for himself or did she think I wouldn't take it seriously? I have had long chats with DS this weekend, with many tears, discussing how his behaviour might be making his friend feel and how he needs to be kind and more mindful of others feelings. Ironically this same friend gave DS his friend code to play Minecraft online together on Friday and I have said no to this until DS has proved he is being kind in the real world. But I don't believe DS is unkind just thoughtless probably and I can imagine him getting carried away in the moment. Or am I deluding myself and I am raising a bully?

thatsnotabadger · 16/01/2022 12:50

That's bullying. Speak to the school.

FireDancer1 · 16/01/2022 12:48

Thinking of you today OP. Please come back and tell us what Oliver's mother is going to do about the situation

Nanny0gg · 16/01/2022 12:46

@MsTSwift

We have to teach them they are going to have to deal with horrible people throughout life it’s upsetting and shit but they need coping mechanisms and they need to be (or at least appear to be) strong and confident.
Easier said than done.
Nanny0gg · 16/01/2022 12:46

I hope it goes well, but imo it should always be done through school. And they need to know about it too

Flipflopblowout · 16/01/2022 12:44

"At 12 your son needs to learn how to deal with this." Yes but he needs help to get out of it first. Somehow I don't see him approaching the Head or any of the school Governors

MsTSwift · 16/01/2022 12:36

We have to teach them they are going to have to deal with horrible people throughout life it’s upsetting and shit but they need coping mechanisms and they need to be (or at least appear to be) strong and confident.

ImALittlePea · 16/01/2022 12:31

Good luck today OP.

I was your son in this situation as a child. Pushed out of my friendship group that transitioned from primary to secondary, strung along, taken advantage of, mocked and bullied. My mum did speak to the school once or twice, but never really achieved anything or did much to support me. Eventually, it made me stronger, but at the time is was devastating. Well done for sticking up for your child.

Glowtastic · 16/01/2022 12:24

DS experienced very similar last year at the start of year 7. I contacted school immediately, and it was sorted, very good supportive form teacher luckily. DS now has his own friendship group away from the 2 horrible boys that tried to exclude him.

I've learnt my lesson from staying quiet and saying nothing, unfortunately thinks persist and don't just fade out. I've done similar at work with some bullying (towards me), all feeding everything back to my manager and compiling evidence from emails screenshots etc.

MsTSwift · 16/01/2022 12:18

Don’t approach other mum.
Go to the school.
Try to teach your son to deal with this and toughen up and not show weakness.

We had similar year 7 when a new friend not only kicked Dd out of their group but bad mouthed her and spread mad rumours to prevent her making other friends/ turn every mine against her. She had to sit alone at lunch etc. we coached Dd to approach vile girl and tell her that it’s fine if she doesn’t want to be friends anymore but if she didn’t stop bad mouthing her she would be reported for exclusionary bullying.

Dd rebuilt from scratch and has now formed the most popular group and vile bully girl is desperate to join it! Success is the best revenge.

GreetingsAndSalutations · 16/01/2022 12:13

Speak to the school. I would have done this before now. In my experience, the sooner this stuff is nipped in the bud the better and it rarely improves if left. A good head of year in a decent school will want this kind of thing dealt with ASAP and have managed these situations more times than they can count.

So sorry your poor boy is going through this- such a hard age as it is and a tough time for all children the past couple of years. Hope he finds his own crowd soon. Boys it seems can be just as bitchy as girls (I went through similar with my daughter previously at the same age).

DinaofCloud9 · 16/01/2022 12:11

Don't let Oliver's mum twist it round to make your son look the one in the wrong.

Also I agree with a previous poster who said don't tell her your DS is crying over it all. It will get back to Oliver and he'll probably use it against DS.

Mrsjayy · 16/01/2022 12:08

Ah it's shit when this happens Oliver is trying to fit in with the crowd and taking it out on your son. I wouldn't go to his mum I'd go to the school then maybe his mum if school take it further.

SGBK4682 · 16/01/2022 12:04

I'd speak to the school as bullying is not acceptable. One of my dds experienced this in y7 from 2 boys she had been at primary school with. Her head of year sorted out out immediately and it stopped. One boy later became a friend of hers.

I'd also counsel your son to keep clear of this boy as much as possible and look out for new friends.

I'd avoid talking to the mother as some people can become very defensive with their own children and won't accept their child is in the wrong. My dd has had two sets of parents blame her for ' bullying' their child. Both are former friends. One was always an oddball and constantly made up stories about herself (so did her father, her father, he's a complete fantasist). The girl has significant problems socially speaking but dd was loyal to her until she got old enough to see through it and dropped the friendship. Another is now mid teens and feels shunned by dd and other friends but they just don't get along anymore - teens change as they age and find they don't fit with others so well anymore. It's perfectly natural.

Not saying you son isn't being bullied, just that other patents will have their own pov or just get upset. Plus you can talk to your son about how teens change as they grow and leave old friendships behind. As they develop their own identity they look for others who suit them better.

Spudina · 16/01/2022 11:53

I agree with the above poster. Don’t give Oliver more ammunition. I think it’s reasonable to say that you understand that Oliver doesn’t want to be friends with your DS anymore, but that doesn’t mean he should be turning the other kids against him. Hopefully she will respond the way you hope, but as said, there is a chance she won’t. It can take a while to find your tribe in Comprehensive school. I hope your DS finds his soon.

Blackberrybunnet · 16/01/2022 11:37

Do NOT tell "Oliver's" mum that your son is so upset he is crying at night! If she mentions this to Oliver, or if he somehow gets to hear about it, your son will never live it down. I really agree with other posters who are suggesting that at age 12, you need to help your son to deal with the situation rather than jumping in to help - there is a strong chance you will only make it worse.

ChiefStockingStuffer · 16/01/2022 11:37

I don't care how 'lovely' you think she is. She will defend her child.

He is out and out bullying your son. Doesn't matter what they fell out over. His behaviour is bullying behaviour. And the school needs to be alerted immediately and formally.

Pleaseuniverseplease · 16/01/2022 11:36

It's pretty obvious Oliver's loving life at senior school. His Mum will be over the moon he's happy and enjoying it therefore will not want to hear how her son is a bully. Not will she want the school to hear of any of this and have to witness hod fall from grace.
I don't think she'll take it well OP and I'd worry they're going to twist all this into being something your ds has done so her ds doesn't get into trouble. They'll definitely be on the defensive and just know you're going to involve the school.

Go to the school before she gets wind of this.

GreenClock · 16/01/2022 11:24

It’s fine to drift away from a primary school friend when you reach secondary school. It’s not fine to engage in social bullying ie making a big deal of moving away from the table and encouraging others to do the same.

Oliver may have forged new friendships but that doesn’t excuse spite and bad manners.

Sallycinnamum · 16/01/2022 11:14

OP a similar issue is happening to my 12 yr old DS.

He went to secondary with his best friend who also happens to be a twin. The three of them have been friends from the first day at primary but my DS is closer friends with one twin.

All was well in year 7 but in the last few months DS' best friend has started being quite mean and is simply not interested in being close mates anymore.

It has been very hard and I have been tempted to talk to the mum who I am friends with but DS has lots of other friends at school and he needs to learn how to navigate issues like this without parental interference.

I also know judging by what I see on DS' WhatsApp groups that I will probably make things worse!

Secondary school friendship groups are absolutely brutal. One minute it's all drama and so and so doesn't like me, the next they're all mates again.

Be realistic when chatting to the mum. I've learnt through bitter experience that kids will choose who they want to be friends despite what we as parents say.

ditalini · 16/01/2022 11:05

This happened to ds at a similar age.

"Oliver" upgraded his friendship group and seemed to think that excluding and bullying ds would seal the deal.

I didn't speak to the parent but we did speak to the school who kept an eye out and encourged ds with other friendships.

A few years on, ds has a strong friendship group. Sad* to say "Oliver's" new friends ditched him and his life is not so happy.

*Fuck it, I'm not sad. °Oliver" was a shit and I'd have been mortified if one of my children had thought it was reasonable behaviour.

ScatteredMama82 · 16/01/2022 10:56

Also, I feel I can approach Oliver’s mum as she has phoned me before when Oliver was upset about something DS had said. This was in Year 6. It was about whether Santa was real or not!

OP posts:
ScatteredMama82 · 16/01/2022 10:54

Thanks folks, it’s useful to have different perspectives. The other mum is lovely and we have known each other for years. I’m not going in to criticise Oliver, I’m looking to hear the other side of the story. I’m totally fine with them not being friends anymore, it happens. It’s the blatant nastiness I’m bothered about. I’m entirely prepared to hear that DS has done or said something that upset Oliver.
We are encouraging him to focus on other friends, it’s a valuable lesson to learn. I hear that some of you say I should let him deal with it on his own, but would you say that if it was physical bullying? If he was being beaten up? My 12 year old son is crying himself to sleep. I’m not going to stand back and do nothing. We really are taking a two pronged approach here, encouraging other friendships and teaching him to choose friends carefully and build his self-esteem. However if Oliver continues to demean him in front of everyone else he’ll have no friends left at school.

OP posts:
LessTime · 16/01/2022 10:37

I once said something to the other Mum in this type of circumstance. I wasn't going to but she had phoned me about something else and had asked about my child. Maybe she knew there was a problem. I phrased everything very gently and gave a very specific example that had happened that day (along with caveats that I hadn't actually witnessed it myself). The result was that the Mum dealt with it, the child apologised and my child was never bothered again. I was glad I mentioned it.