Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DB wants half his ex's house

255 replies

username103842 · 14/01/2022 16:38

DB was with his partner for the last 6 years. She has been very successful career wise and earns a high salary and had her own house before they met. Despite working himself (he earns about half what his ex does) he just moved in and did not pay a single bill in the whole 6 years. He did buy some furniture occasionally but other than that she paid for everything.

She split up with him a few month ago and he is now back at our parents house. He could rent his own place but it has dawned after all his bills he wouldn't have much left. He actually would have more than many I think he is so use to have his whole wage he has got a shock.

Anyway with encouragement of my parents he has decided he is going to see a solicitor to get half of her house Confused. I don't have a clue of the legalities and doubt he will get anywhere. I try not to get involved in it all but I'm getting daily phones calls from him and my parents about it. Which is driving me mad so I have stopped answering most of them.

I know this isn't actually any of my business so please don't start with them comments. I feel like I am forced to be involved when I actually want to say it's wrong. I suppose the only reason I am asking AIBU to think that way is when you thinking of other situations like when a cohabiting couple have children and the mother doesn't work/contribute financial to the house. I certainly wouldn't feel the same in that circumstance.

OP posts:
GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 16/01/2022 18:49

He is taking the absolute piss and you should tell him so.

GreetingsAndSalutations · 16/01/2022 18:48

@username103842

I didn't expect so many replies!!

To try and answer some of the general questions...
It all started from a ridiculous conversation he had with a friend. The friends tells him a story about 'a friend of a friend getting half the house...' it's either probably nonsense or half a story. So now he is convinced he is entitled. He has no savings whatsoever and also thinks due to said friend he will be able to claim legal aid.
The constant phone calls are to ask me to look it up on line or find a solicitor or how to claim legal aid. I recently told them I'm too busy. Their tone changed and I haven't heard from them since.
A PP wrote about my parents enabling behaviour that is definitely true. My DB plays the victim constantly. He was completely the victim in this break up ( I don't actually even know why they split). He and my parents somehow blames his ex for him suffering financially now Confused. They can't seem to see the fact he has 6 years with no bills and could have saved a fortune!

Legal aid?! For this “case”? Hahahaha. Good luck with that like.

I’d be so embarrassed to be related to him.

Graphista · 16/01/2022 16:38

Been dipping in and out of this thread

He and your parents are bonkers entitled idiots! How are you normal?! Grin

He's not entitled to a damn thing! As many pps have said.

He certainly isn't entitled to legal aid to pursue it!

Legal aid in such matters is I believe now reserved for those divorcing abusive spouses.

Hell get absolutely nowhere! Though in your shoes I'd let him crack on and waste his time and money! Some dodgy lawyer will likely lead him on and make a fortune out of him, decent sensible ones won't deal with him at all.

My ex during our divorce went through several lawyers simply because he refused to listen to what he was and wasn't entitled to (both financially and in terms of a number of contact hearings relating to dd - which was ironic considering he was shit at contact and as a parent generally!)

I changed to a better lawyer after my 1st was very slow, I'd stupidly let this ride until it resulted in a major cock up for me on financial side (she didn't submit a form in time) and my 2nd lawyer upon seeing who he had for the 1st hearing I had with her (his 6th or 7th lawyer!) Asked me if he'd been through a few! I was like "How'd you know that?" And she was like basically "cos she's rubbish and you only hire her if nobody else will take you!"

It was honestly comedic at points (though didn't feel it at the time)

Brother sounds like he needs a wake up call - and to grow the fuck up!

But then I have a sister who is v similar and I don't see her changing either. Mid 40's now!

username103842 · 16/01/2022 16:27

I didn't expect so many replies!!

To try and answer some of the general questions...
It all started from a ridiculous conversation he had with a friend. The friends tells him a story about 'a friend of a friend getting half the house...' it's either probably nonsense or half a story. So now he is convinced he is entitled. He has no savings whatsoever and also thinks due to said friend he will be able to claim legal aid.
The constant phone calls are to ask me to look it up on line or find a solicitor or how to claim legal aid. I recently told them I'm too busy. Their tone changed and I haven't heard from them since.
A PP wrote about my parents enabling behaviour that is definitely true. My DB plays the victim constantly. He was completely the victim in this break up ( I don't actually even know why they split). He and my parents somehow blames his ex for him suffering financially now Confused. They can't seem to see the fact he has 6 years with no bills and could have saved a fortune!

OP posts:
Pammy55 · 16/01/2022 12:59

I was that woman ! He won’t get a penny .

Fluffmum · 16/01/2022 11:59

He may get a one of payment for whatever he put into the house like furniture or any work he can prove he paid for.

mynamesnotMa · 16/01/2022 11:17

This isn't down to you to solve.
Let him see a solicitor and present his evidence. It's highly unlikely he'll find anyone that won't tell him the truth

VelvetChairGirl · 16/01/2022 09:30

I have only read the first page so far...

I think you need to have a good talk with your parents they may think this is how to get rid of him, or that he will learn his lesson and grow up when he gets humiliated.

but it could and very likely will backfire on them and he could become an even more entrenched freeloader, if he is supported in carrying on with his claims of injustice he just might blow it all and end up in debt and then they will never get rid off him and he will continue, theres nothing like having a bunch of enablers surrounding you to help you ruin your life and stick your head firmly in the sand about it.

userxx · 16/01/2022 09:30

He's a cheeky fucker.

007Stocko · 16/01/2022 09:20

I agree my only possible theory is that my parents are worried he will never move out from their house now. So are encouraging it in order for him to get some money to move out with!

And it will take him even longer to move out if he is throwing all his savings at a solicitor in a futile attempt to get anything from his ex.

Newmumatlast · 16/01/2022 08:46

@LaurieFairyCake

Yeah, I'd warn her Blush
Me too actually
BashStreetKid · 16/01/2022 08:45

Why are they constantly phoning you about it? What are you supposed to do with the information?

Insanelysilver · 16/01/2022 08:38

Do you think your DB might have given your DP’s the idea that he did contribute a lot more financially than he actually did? That might be another reason ( apart from them being worried they will be stuck with him living with them permanently)

Owl55 · 16/01/2022 01:01

He’s being totally unrealistic and no solicitor will support this surely.

Jitters22 · 16/01/2022 00:46

OP, honestly, he will be laughed out of court.

If there is a solicitor willing to take this case on then they are a complete charlatan who will take your brother's money for a no hope case.

  1. It was her house before he met her and he never contributed a single penny towards its purchase

2.They weren't married, so he has absolutely no 'legal' claim to the property.

I could add, 4, 5 and 6 but there's no point.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 15/01/2022 23:21

I'm kicking myself now, thinking of all the hotels and B&Bs I've stayed in throughout my life. Stupid me thought that the money I paid was just for use of the facilities for the agreed time - now I realise that I should have been entitled to permanent half-ownership of each of those rooms. Or does it only count if you don't initially pay them anything at all....?

Cocomarine · 15/01/2022 23:06

@Owl55

Did he pay food, gas, pill tax etc instead of rent?
@Owl55 literally in the OP, in the first paragraph.
cannockcandy · 15/01/2022 22:25

I'm gonna be keeping every single part of my body crossed that he gets laughed out the lawyers office.
He contributes nothing, pays no bills, doesn't marry this woman but somehow thinks he is owed half her house?
Sorry but no!
He doesn't deserve anything!
So no, YNBU

nalabae · 15/01/2022 22:00

Very wrong but some people turn a blind eye to morals when it comes to money.
I was scammed by some girl I knew husband she couldn’t care less.

iloverock · 15/01/2022 21:11

@Tigger1895

In order to have any claim he’ll need to supply proof of investment in the property. Bank statements showing he paid towards the mortgage and bills will be the least he will be requested to provide. He has no claim and will end up with a hefty bill if he tries to take it to court.
This isn't true. Paying any of the mortgage does not give him any kind of interest in the property.
Seahorsemama · 15/01/2022 20:07

Does he work at 10 Downing Street by any chance - is living (and partying) on a completely different planet if he thinks he is entitled to anything - he is dam lucky to have got away without forking out for 6 years

Owl55 · 15/01/2022 19:55

Did he pay food, gas, pill tax etc instead of rent?

caringcarer · 15/01/2022 19:39

She owes him nothing.

Bookloverjay · 15/01/2022 19:33

Can't believe your parents are supporting him doing this.

Absolutely crazy.

Jitters22 · 15/01/2022 19:30

He's not got a hope in hell of getting a penny.

I lived with my ex for 10 years and had two kids by him but the key thing is I sold my house and moved in with him.

I got absolutely fuck all. The only way I could have had a claim would have been if I could prove that the value of the house had increased substantially during the tIme I'd lived there, and that I had contributed to that increase. I had, but proving it would have been a long and lengthy court battle and the only people guaranteed to make money out of it would have been the solicitors.

The key thing here is 'married'. Living together, common law etc is all bollocks.