Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Another private school thread

166 replies

nearly4o · 14/01/2022 12:49

I guess iI am looking for endorsement of our schooling approach as I am from very worki mg class background and private school is a lot of money that could be spent paying off mortgage .

We have two DC. DC1 is nearly 7 and going into yr 3 In September. He is in an infant school now and needs to move anyway for yr 3. He had very bad glue ear which delayed him with speaking and impacted his overall progression in reception. That has been fixed now and he has had speech therapy but he is ~1 ye behind academically more or less. Sometimes we aee the other kid's work through the app and it is light-years ahead of our son. He is getting swallowed up in a class of 30. Has said multiple times when he puts his hand up to ask Qs, no one comes
To see him.

Daughter age 5 in reception. Already reading and writing. No concerns.

There is a prep school close by with class size 15. It is no selective and they have space.

The junior school achieves below average results in reading and maths.

The prep is £10k per year plus uniforms etc

I earn £70k plus shares worth between £15k-£20k per year. Husband is leaving his job in May (he has to) and is yet to secure employment but he will have a £10k a year pension.

Mortgage £1600
Plus usual bills probably £3k per month in bills -

My take home is £4K.

I feel a bit queasy about the risk given husband's job situation. But don't want to fail my child.

He does have tuition currently as well once a week.

Don't want to regret not sending him in 4 years when he is even further behind going into secondary school.

Then obvs the question of do we send our daughter as well?

Thoughts ?

OP posts:
Socialcarenope · 14/01/2022 15:54

Ours are at private for primary school and we've not found it costs much more than the advertised fees at all. They do 3 trips a year which are paid for as part of the fees (total fees are schools fees+food+trips paid monthly over 10 months). Uniform is only slightly more expensive than a state school. Sports clubs are optional and 2 of them are free, the others are £3.20 a session but my kids aren't sporty.

We have similar income and expenditure to you and we afford it.

YouokHun · 14/01/2022 15:37

And while I’ve been typing away at my incredibly slow rate @ana1s has said it all much more eloquently. Good advice.

chesirecat99 · 14/01/2022 15:33

I think you need to take a step back and consider other options.

As PPs have said, smaller class size may not be better if SEN support is worse at the private school. Also, have you considered that there is a possibility his peers at the private school might be slightly ahead of his current peers, making the gap even wider? The school may not be selective but some schools in the private sector move through the curriculum faster than the state sector. A different one to one tutor who can offer more hours might be able to help him progress faster than a change in school.

Have you considered that he might have other SpLDs and that this might not be just because of the issues caused by the glue ear? A child who is struggling to write but is very bright in other ways could be indicative of SpLDs.

It is very hard to assess at such a young age but, even so, perhaps the first step should be a full assessment with an educational psychologist to see if there are other issues. They will be able to advise on the best support and, possibly, the best local schools that can provide that support.

YouokHun · 14/01/2022 15:32

@itwasntaparty

I wouldn't send him. If he needs additional support he's likely better off in state with good provision. A couple of friends have found out the hard way when they have had to pay on top of fees for additional support.

I'd get a tutor.

I agree with @itwasntaparty about additional support. My experience has been that private schools might be quick to flag up a problem with not keeping up they aren’t particularly up to speed with recognising problems with learning which may be an indicator of other problems (such as ADHD) because simply not enough children pass through for them to recognise indicators even if they have the resources in theory to cater for it (a very small private school may not). My direct experience of this is limited to 3 prep schools and 3 senior private schools but I do know parents who have found the same issue in other private schools. The state sector seems more accountable in this regard and better at the assessment of what is holding a child back or causing them problems academically or socially. Some private schools are very well meaning but don’t have people who are up to speed on these things. That’s not to say there aren’t excellent practitioners in private schools, its just that private doesn’t equal better.

The other issue with a very small school is that although the small class sizes are great, in terms of gaining confidence it can be socially tricky as there are not a lot of friends to choose from so if the year contains ten children and half of them are girls then that can be tricky if a child struggles with friendships. It can also be hard to be leaving at 11 to go back into state school if your friends are staying put to 13, and adjusting to a presumably much larger school with no hand-holding isn’t easy if school is already a struggle.

That said the change could help re-set him and it sounds like change would be good and I can see why the small learning groups and closer monitoring is attractive. I guess there may be some flexibility about which year group he goes into as well. A friend of mine put her struggling August born DS into a private school, joining the year below and it was a huge help. And of course they are able to provide more individual attention which might be enough.

Financially, it’s worth keeping in mind that the extras can tot up as others have said, though a lot of private schools are mindful of this with a good secondhand uniform shop and no flashy trips etc, but a big extra cost would be extra learning support which is likely to go on top of fees, especially in a small school. Another friend of mine tutors lots of children at state school for a certain hourly fee, which is much lower than the private school parents are paying her to provide the same support for their DC as a learning support teacher on a part-time basis at a small local prep school. I would also keep in mind the fee rises each year which are usually inflation busting!

From my experience I’d say be very sure to check that should your DS need very specific help at some point, that a small prep school has the ability to do more than keep its class sizes small; what is its provision? What sort of issues have they and do they work with, how many other children have formal learning support and what will it cost?

Sorry, but of a waffly response!

nearly4o · 14/01/2022 15:31

@ana1s
Good advice thank you .

We have a tour booked with the Head Teacher so will ask all those Qs. They also do a taster day for my son to see how he likes it. Once he sees the football pitch and learns that Tbey have a proper school team, he will probably be very happy!

OP posts:
ana1s · 14/01/2022 15:09

Hi OP. Based on what you have outlined here, I would move him. But first please check -

What exactly is the SEN provision in the prep? Please be aware that in some preps it is shocking. If he needs additional 1:1 who will do this and when exactly? Have the school seen his current profile? What did they have to say about this? How precisely will they commit to helping him?

Honestly, be very specific with these questions. Get the school to commit to a programme before you move him. Don’t blithely assume prep school / smaller classes = better. It can be and often is, but it’s by no means a given.

Is there a full-time ed. support / SEN team in the school? Will you have to pay extra for additional sessions (this is highly likely). Don’t get fobbed off with vague platitudes from the school here. You will be a paying customer - they need to be specific with their plan.

I totally agree that a tutor can’t do much and may actually be counterproductive. This is because they often explain things in a slightly different way which can overload a child who is already confused as it is. Also, how much can really be achieved in a discrete hour (or even several)?

Look now at the leaver’s destinations for this prep. This is key. Is the school preparing children for competitive exams for local independent secondaries? Do you want / need this additional pressure if your plan is for him to go to a non-selective state secondary? 11 plus can be stressful! Will he be the only child not continuing in the private school route (trust me, once on the wagon it can be hard to pull them off).

Overall though, if you are satisfied that this school can offer the support he needs, I would move him. The next few years will be critical to his educational confidence and how he perceives himself. Good luck!

Winter2020 · 14/01/2022 14:52

If you are confident you can afford it I would go for it for your son and think about your daughter after. She might be happy and thriving in her school and not want to move.

Handholding587 · 14/01/2022 14:42

@Handholding587 Only 7% of children go to private school.

93% go to state schools. That is the overwhelming majority. By definition, nearly all working class kids are in state schools

I'm sure they are. But that is not to say that private schools don't have many children from working class backgrounds.
If the OP is considering a private school then the fact that she is working class has very little relevance, there will be other children from similar backgrounds, and it shouldn't be one of the issues that affect her choice.

campion · 14/01/2022 14:40

Do what is most effective for your DS now. Your DD is fine and doesn't need uprooting; you don't have to do the same for each of them right now. Fairness is about more than what you spend on them.
It sounds like DS would benefit from the move and you can certainly afford it on your income surely.

Your background is irrelevant and most private schools are full of people trying to do their best, not a separate breed.

nearly4o · 14/01/2022 14:39

Ideal scenario is that husband earns £50k abs also has his pension which will cover fees for DS.

He has interviews lined up.

I do have the money from my shares as well. I get multiple vests each each which are min 15k

OP posts:
Winter2020 · 14/01/2022 14:32

I understand you love your new home and your lifestyle sounds lovely (genuinely - not being sarcastic) but it does mean that 3k of your 4k income is used up. You will need the remaining 1k for food/ fuel/clothes/ holidays/birthday/xmas/ extra curricular activities.

I'm assuming the flat rental only covers it's own mortgage and expenses (perhaps sometimes you have to dig into your own money for larger expenses and tax).

So it seems clear to me OP that while you can afford to support your family and lifestyle (which you are quite understandably not willing to change) the only way you can afford private school is if your husbands new job covers the cost. I think you will have to wait and see what work he gets before you commit.

I understand your husband has a 10k pension bit you are used to him earning 50k so I would wait and see what work he gets unless you used to have significant left over money or have savings.

Blinkingbatshit · 14/01/2022 14:25

I’ve had 2 go through state primary and 1 through private primary. I think you’d be better off finding an after school tutor a couple of times a week and a bit more home support (in a fun way - lots of educational computer games out there etc). Private’s really only worth it for the extra curricular stuff which doesn’t seem to be your focus.

Innocenta · 14/01/2022 14:25

@Handholding587

:59Innocenta

@Handholding587
only 7% of children go to private schools, and most of them are not working class, so - no, this really isn't true

I taught for many years in a private junior school, and when I said that many pupils were from working class backgrounds, I am speaking from experience.
I suppose it depends on your definition of 'working class.'
In my last class, two parents were taxi drivers, some were nurses, one an electrician and one had a garage. There were children from wealthy backgrounds but it was fairly evenly split.

@Handholding587 Only 7% of children go to private school.

93% go to state schools. That is the overwhelming majority. By definition, nearly all working class kids are in state schools.

RedskyThisNight · 14/01/2022 14:23

@Mummyoflittledragon Any more state school stereotypes you want to throw in there?

Is this a good time for me to mention all the stories of sexual assault reported at private schools?

or is it actually a case that every school is different and OP should evaluate the schools available to her and make the best decision for her child?

Handholding587 · 14/01/2022 14:22

:59Innocenta

@Handholding587
only 7% of children go to private schools, and most of them are not working class, so - no, this really isn't true

I taught for many years in a private junior school, and when I said that many pupils were from working class backgrounds, I am speaking from experience.
I suppose it depends on your definition of 'working class.'
In my last class, two parents were taxi drivers, some were nurses, one an electrician and one had a garage. There were children from wealthy backgrounds but it was fairly evenly split.

nearly4o · 14/01/2022 14:20

@Winter2020
We have just moved into this house 9 months ago. It is a 5 bed detached in the south east. But I am not moving. I was depressed in our last house for many reasons and this house brings me a lot of joy. Plus stamp duty and this village (despite the mediocre junior school) is very popular as it is 10 mins to fast train to London. And on door step of countryside.

The 3k includes the mortgage.
£1600
ct 220
Car tax/ insurance/ tyres/ house insurance other car related things and the ground rent for a flat we rent out £350
Life insurance £40
Sky internet £40
Phones: £80
Gym: 180 (whole family - love it. Took it out when I got promoted )
Gas:electricity - £150 but I think going up
Netflix etc £20

So maybe not quite 3k anymore - we paid off some loans earlier this year so no car debt or any debt other than mortgage.

We do own a flat in a desirable area that we rent out. Don't make anything day to day but it is a retirement plan. There is a lot of equity in it. So worse case we could remortgage but I know husband wouldn't be keen to do that- literally would only do it if we were on fire

OP posts:
RedskyThisNight · 14/01/2022 14:20

90 in a year is not huge for a state junior school by the way! I'd say that was a bit bigger than average. My DC went to a 120 in a year junior school and it never felt too big - and they had more opportunities than they would at a smaller school (including the ability to do small group provision for those that needed particular focus). The private school you are considering is particularly small, and that's not necessarily a bonus at junior level where the DC develop strong ideas about interests and friendships and want to find someone like minded.

What's the intake of the juniors? Remember that below average results does not mean "bad school" is the intake reflects that.

Mummyoflittledragon · 14/01/2022 14:19

As the prep is non selective, what is their provision like for additional needs / SEN? Have you approached them and what is their suggestion?

I think it is entirely possible to send one child to state and one privately. If your dd does fine academically, you could choose private tuition to fill the gaps from the junior school. I know a couple of families who do this, who have multiple children. They send their kids to the school best suited to them. One diverted to a nurturing private due to mental health issues, one sent to one state secondary, the other two sent to another state secondary.

I would be concerned with banking on sending your ds to state secondary. This is generally the sort of approach parents take if they are in an 11+ area and send their children to the selective school if they pass and continue with private schooling if not. Selective state secondaries are renowned for good discipline as the kids want to learn.

I don’t know what your local state secondary is like. But large schools especially have to be very strict. My dd recently changed from one such outstanding ofsted rated school to a relatively small private school because she wasn’t able to be herself and was stuck in a rut, not leading to capacity. Her school was tough, private is so lovely in comparison and your ds could potentially go from being very protected and nurtured in a private school to being treated as barely human.

It seems year 7s from my discussions with parents with children in a few schools are protected from the older kids to ease transition. However by Yr8 if not before they are fully integrated in the wider population with incidents like a kid bringing a lighter to school and using it near others endangering setting them on fire / trying to burn wood, physical fights, threats of violence, vindictive bullying, bringing knives when in a fight, the last not used on school premises but just around the corner after school. All these things were perpetrated by children in the same year group as dd in her former school within the last year (Jan yr8 to Jan yr9). One offs maybe, rather they were things reported by my dd. She also reported that in yr8 there were supply teachers brought in, who were so scared of the kids that they were shaking. Yr8 is age 11-12.

Ok these are far and few between. But they do happen and you should be aware that your ds may really struggle if returned to state. So if you do send him to state school, choose to live well within catchment of a smaller secondary. Until it was too late, we thought dd would probably get into one of the smaller states but it didn’t work out that way. And when it didn’t we didn’t realise it would be so wrong for her. Just because traditionally kids from your area get into the nice out of catchment state doesn’t mean yours will. Policies change, houses are built, parents within catchment and with a choice of 2 schools pick the one you could have sent your kid to a couple of years ago etc.

So think hard about what you’re doing. And look at your red lines. If you embark on this route, what are you prepared to give up to perpetuate it? And what happens if your dd also wants to go privately in secondary?

jeaux90 · 14/01/2022 14:17

My DD also drowned in state primary. She has ADHD and ASD and fell behind but is flourishing in her small all girls private school. Class sizes are 12 and it's exactly what she needed.

I'm a single mum by the way, I have a good career and earn good money but mortgage etc of course so it was a bit of a stretch but worth every penny.

RedskyThisNight · 14/01/2022 14:16

Do his teachers say he is behind? What are they doing to address this? He has 2 more terms at his current school regardless of what you decide and remember that very many children of his age group have missed a lot of schooling due to Covid.

I actually think that writing is not too bad (it's better than my DC's was at the start of Year 2) and "writing" is about putting words together and making sentences, not really handwriting anyway.

That's partly why I asked what his teacher says. If you're reliant on "on show" work, the school may well be picking the best children to showcase.

Winter2020 · 14/01/2022 14:10

Hi OP,
I think your son probably would benefit from the move and I'm on the fence about whether you do the same for your daughter - whatever you prefer.

I wanted to suggest that you review your home and bills to make the finances work.

Do you live in a hugely expensive area? Are you paying £1600 for a 3 bed flat/semi or a four bed detached? Would you be able to downsize to free up up to 1k each month? (Depends where you live and your equity).

When you say 3k of bills do you mean including the mortgage or on top of the mortgage?

What are these bills that add up to £1600/3k?

Council tax (£200?), gas & electric (£200 with bills going up), water £100 if you live in the south west maybe, another £100 for car insurance (for 2) , £100 car maintenance (for 2) £100 sundries - tv licence/ life insurance...that's £800 a month.

Are you paying £5/6/7 hundred each month for cars on HP? Expensive phones on contract £80 odd, £100 on sky. I think if you review your bills you must be able to save a packet - especially if the 3k is on top of the mortgage.

Good luck

nearly4o · 14/01/2022 14:09

Gold

OP posts:
nearly4o · 14/01/2022 14:09

Good star to anyone who can read this.....

Another private school thread
OP posts:
nearly4o · 14/01/2022 14:07

Not really any other state schools he could go to.

The state junior has 90 per year group across 3 classes . It is huge. And whilst yes he does like his infant school and his friends - they all live in the same village so he will see them all The time at beavers, football, play dates etc.

The private school is 1.5 miles away in next village but really close.

I think biggest takeaway is to see what they will do for him to catch him up

OP posts:
waterrat · 14/01/2022 14:04

I totally understand the fear of a child being swalled up in large classes. But school is not just for formal learning. Is he happy there ? Could you spend the money on tuition and other fun things that are good for him like holidays. Remember a lot of school learning is stuff like recycling songs and being a good friend etc !

I would be very concerned about money spent on a private school that gers below average results even with half the class size !

Have you looked at any other schools ?

Swipe left for the next trending thread