Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Another private school thread

166 replies

nearly4o · 14/01/2022 12:49

I guess iI am looking for endorsement of our schooling approach as I am from very worki mg class background and private school is a lot of money that could be spent paying off mortgage .

We have two DC. DC1 is nearly 7 and going into yr 3 In September. He is in an infant school now and needs to move anyway for yr 3. He had very bad glue ear which delayed him with speaking and impacted his overall progression in reception. That has been fixed now and he has had speech therapy but he is ~1 ye behind academically more or less. Sometimes we aee the other kid's work through the app and it is light-years ahead of our son. He is getting swallowed up in a class of 30. Has said multiple times when he puts his hand up to ask Qs, no one comes
To see him.

Daughter age 5 in reception. Already reading and writing. No concerns.

There is a prep school close by with class size 15. It is no selective and they have space.

The junior school achieves below average results in reading and maths.

The prep is £10k per year plus uniforms etc

I earn £70k plus shares worth between £15k-£20k per year. Husband is leaving his job in May (he has to) and is yet to secure employment but he will have a £10k a year pension.

Mortgage £1600
Plus usual bills probably £3k per month in bills -

My take home is £4K.

I feel a bit queasy about the risk given husband's job situation. But don't want to fail my child.

He does have tuition currently as well once a week.

Don't want to regret not sending him in 4 years when he is even further behind going into secondary school.

Then obvs the question of do we send our daughter as well?

Thoughts ?

OP posts:
Namenic · 14/01/2022 21:32

I think I would prefer to give more tuition to him in holidays and I would do some English and maths with him on weekends to catch up.

nearly4o · 14/01/2022 21:24

Unless we have a drastic change in fortune then we would plan to send DD as well when she leaves infant school.

OP posts:
Petrarkanian · 14/01/2022 19:59

I was the child who's brother went to private and I went to state. It was unfair then and I still feel its unfair now.
I am of the opinion that its both or none, I would have loved to go to my brothers school but me and my sister were sent to the local comp.

Pottedpalm · 14/01/2022 19:53

@Blinkingbatshit

I’ve had 2 go through state primary and 1 through private primary. I think you’d be better off finding an after school tutor a couple of times a week and a bit more home support (in a fun way - lots of educational computer games out there etc). Private’s really only worth it for the extra curricular stuff which doesn’t seem to be your focus.
I disagree entirely. Being in a class if 16 instead of 30makes a massive difference in so many ways, and the issues will be addressed in school, rather than an exhausting round of after school tuition.
Pottedpalm · 14/01/2022 19:46

Of course you can send one and not the other if the situation warrants it. You can reconsider when your daughter reaches the transfer age and see what your financial situation is. Intervention now could mean he is able to cope in secondary rather than floundering.
You shouldn’t have to pay vast sums above and beyond the fees; that’s a myth. Use secondhand shop or facebook group for uniform, and schools are not running expensive trips these days.

nearly4o · 14/01/2022 19:20

Fairly sure he doesn't have any additional special needs. My mum is a special needs teacher . He has not had any issues sitting through speech therapy, his one hour tuition etc. accept for getting upset with his maths and not wanting to go extra work at home, his is very well behaved and plays beautifully with his sister. He is just behind.

OP posts:
Thirtytimesround · 14/01/2022 18:04

Pa caveat to that: we fpund a fab school. They aren’t all as good and some push children too much. Shop around.

Thirtytimesround · 14/01/2022 18:03

OP we were in a similar situation and moved DD to the prep. I am so happy we did. She loves her life now, she was miserable before. She is learning so much but more importantly she is confident and happy (and super fit from all the sport!). Old school had bullying problems but at the prep any bullies are asked to leave the school pretty much instantly.

The uniform expense was annoying, but not too bad and we took that into account before we joined. There are almost no extra expenses for clubs and trips at our prep, the poster above who said this was a major issue may have been thinking about senior school I don’t know.

Talk to the marketing department. Ours offers bursaries to families who struggle with the cost and it’s possible you might be eligible for something I don’t know.

If I did it all again I’d buy a smaller house and do prep from reception.

Rangoon · 14/01/2022 17:23

This was my son. We did transfer him to another state school where the staff made a real effort to help him with his issues. Our son had the hearing thing and was also ADHD. He was privately assessed and we started on medication for him - only for school and homework - not in the weekends or holidays. Don't be frightened of medication if your child is ADHD as it can be a game changer.

I tutored every week night. I started out trying to introduce some structure into his handwriting - printing really as there was no point focusing on cursive for him. I used special "learn to print" pencils to try to get him to use the correct grip. His spelling was terrible - I used a book by Jeffrey Freed "Right-Brained Children in a Left-Brained World: Unlocking the Potential of Your ADD Child" which taught a way of visualising the word and learning it that way. The 10 word weekly spelling list was brought under control and was no long a 7 days slog. (I'm not related to the author of the book in any way but it was the first really practical advice that worked for me - and I read a lot of books on the subject.)

I basically found out whatever they were covering in the curriculum and revised it with him. You probably need to start with say 20 minutes and a 5 minute break. I tried to make it interesting for him - have stories or amusing mnemonics or pictures. Practical examples worked well. The second school was very co-operative with this and were willing to share the curriculum. I bought a bunch of cram books and taught from those and they did follow the curriculum. There are lots of great educational sites online which have lessons on particular topics - often very engagingly presented.

He lagged in maths badly. I started at the beginning and helped him to memorise the times tables which is very difficult for ADHD children generally. We had stories, mnemonics, special maths video games where you chased a monster round a dungeon opening doors etc with times table answers. Eventually, he had them down. By high school I was basically teaching the school maths curriculum every night plus helping with English texts, history learning. Maths isn't my strongest subject but my husband has a maths degree and revised me to teach it. We were lucky that I had a very broad education and could teach a range of subjects but I had no teaching experience whatsoever.

This took up enormous amounts of energy and time over years. My husband worked overseas a lot but when he was home did a lot of the meals and clean up so I could spend the time. He needed constant revision - encouraged to think of what he'd learned before he went off to sleep. Cue cards were a big thing and getting him to teach it back to me was a good technique. We supplemented with some professional tutoring - tutors vary a lot and you want to get somebody who can engage a young person rather than hand out long vocabulary lists. His high school teachers were actually very helpful again with the curriculum and areas to focus on except for one sour crabby one. We revised past exam papers and did practice answers. I always praised hard work rather than intelligence.

He is at university now. His marks are generally respectable. The subject is not particularly hard - not law or medicine - but there is a career path or he can use it as a springboard for something else in the area. I am not going to lie and say it was easy because it wasn't but it was worth it to give him a future. I am sorry to say that I think once a week tutoring will not be enough to make a major difference because there will not be enough consolidation or revision to make it stick.

Not all private schools are good for somebody who struggles academically. I know another ADHD boy who was sent to a private school and he was just laden with piles of homework. Homework is only valuable if it reinforces some learning - not hours of make work. On the other hand, the private school may be really helpful to your son. Can you go and look at it and talk to the teachers.

If your daughter is doing fine, there is no need to send her. You need to prioritise the child who is falling behind. I certainly didn't tutor my eldest and he is in medical school as a postgraduate.

Boombastic22 · 14/01/2022 17:17

No way would I put myself in such a financial position for private school.

Move house to a better area with a better school?

MrsBaublesDylan · 14/01/2022 17:15

I would spend your money on a really good Educational Psychologist assessment op.

My eldest son had glue ear and three sets of grommets later, he caught up really quickly.

My youngest son is really, really behind and used to get lots of mini seizures - we thought it was holding him back but he grew out of them in yr 2 and now in year 3, he is still working at pre-curriculum levels.

The EP report identified Dyslexia and re commended screening for ASD and ADD.

Find out what he needs in terms of provision first, then decide.

PearPickingPorky · 14/01/2022 16:58

@Shimy

Good question *@PearPickingPorky*. What is working class these days? it used to be anyone who works for a living as opposed to living on inherited wealth, so your doctors, accountants, teachers etc are all working-class which I think was 99.9% of my dc's prep school parent body. One could also define it by blue-collar v white-collar type jobs. I never know which one they're referring to on MN.
I think people just identify (themselves or others) in or out of either category as suits their particular agenda.

Load of nonsense, IMO.

Shimy · 14/01/2022 16:50

Good question @PearPickingPorky. What is working class these days? it used to be anyone who works for a living as opposed to living on inherited wealth, so your doctors, accountants, teachers etc are all working-class which I think was 99.9% of my dc's prep school parent body. One could also define it by blue-collar v white-collar type jobs. I never know which one they're referring to on MN.

PearPickingPorky · 14/01/2022 16:40

neverbeenskiing The OP says she's from a working-class background, but clearly she has done well and is not living a a typical WC life anymore. Her amd her DH have two professional jobs, and therefore her children are unlikely to be considered "working class" (whatever that even means anymore).

LittleGwyneth · 14/01/2022 16:37

Am I right in thinking this means that you would go private for your son but not your daughter? I think that's got a lot of potential to cause damage for their relationship with each other and with you.

PearPickingPorky · 14/01/2022 16:36

I think you should visit the private prep school as you've planned and of you like it and they think they can help your DS, do it.

DH's pension will pay the fees.

Your own salary will pay all your bills, plus food.

Then DH's job which he'll hopefully get soon can be used for all the other non-essentials.

It's only for 4 years. You're not committing to secondary school too. And just see how DD goes at her current school (maybe doing extra tuition or extracurricular activities for DD to let you feel like she's getting the appropriate opportunities too).

neverbeenskiing · 14/01/2022 16:35

The fact that you are working class has no bearing on your situation. Many children from working class backgrounds attend private schools.

I think it should be a consideration actually. I am from a working class background and went to a private school. It was a very difficult experience and not one I would choose for my own children. Maybe things have changed radically since I was at school but there weren't "many" kids there from working class backgrounds at all. I can only recall one other child during my whole time at school. I felt like an outsider. Adults often assume children are oblivious to such things but they aren't.

Shimy · 14/01/2022 16:28

My experience has been that private schools might be quick to flag up a problem with not keeping up they aren’t particularly up to speed with recognising problems with learning which may be an indicator of other problems (such as ADHD) because simply not enough children pass through for them to recognise indicators even if they have the resources in theory to cater for it (a very small private school may not)

That's not been my experience. In fact, it was within the 1st 2weeks of prep school that they recognized ds had all the classic symptoms of ADHD and he eventually went on to be diagnosed with a whole host of other issues. He had been at the local state school up to from reception to yr 2 and nothing had been flagged up. Thank goodness we made the switch.

hibbledibble · 14/01/2022 16:24

Based on your outgoings and income it doesn't sound like you can afford it, so it's not an option unless your husband secures regular employment. I wouldn't look into private school if you aren't sure you can afford it long term: moving school repeatedly would cause unnecessary upheaval.

Innocenta · 14/01/2022 16:17

If the OP is considering a private school then the fact that she is working class has very little relevance, there will be other children from similar backgrounds, and it shouldn't be one of the issues that affect her choice.

@Handholding587 I agree that it should have relatively little impact on her choice, but that point can be made without massaging the facts. Very few children have access to private education.

LethargicActress · 14/01/2022 16:15

If he’s the sort of child that needs extra help, I think it could be incredibly difficult for him to go from a prep school with tiny classes to a comp at secondary.

Unless you’re going to do this for both your children, until they can leave school, I wouldn’t do it. If anything, pay for extra tuition now, and save so that you can afford private secondary comfortably. It will be much more beneficial. There is loads you can do to support a child at primary school yourself, but it becomes much harder at secondary

Isonthecase · 14/01/2022 16:11

We're on similar incomes and manage about that on childcare but I think it'll be tight. Could you use savings to top up for the years you'd have two there?

Wisewordswouldhelp · 14/01/2022 16:11

Although you have said the prep isn't selective, even the non selective preps will do some screening. So if he is a year behind it is possible they might not give your child a place. You usually have to pay for additional SEN support at independent, around £45 per week for 1 hour!

ThanksItHasPockets · 14/01/2022 16:10

It sounds like his current school is not meeting his needs but you can’t assume that SEN support will be better in the prep. In some it is virtually non-existent. Do you know anyone with children at the prep who could give you an honest assessment?

KleineDracheKokosnuss · 14/01/2022 16:02

Yes you can send one private and not the other. Your school choice should be based on where each will flourish.

Given the uncertainty of income, I would only send him to the prep if you are absolutely sure they have the skills, a plan and the ability to help him catch up. Just because it’s private is no guarantee.

If you ultimately choose to send both, remember that it means you yourself will likely be tied to your job and earning at your currently level for nearing a decade. More if you end up wanting private senior school.
You will need to increase your income periodically (assume 5%fee increase a year) and there will be no dropping to fewer hours. Can you accept that?

Swipe left for the next trending thread