Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should we stay with my wife's parents?

86 replies

beatsandbikes76 · 14/01/2022 11:52

Hi, i'm new here, and really looking for some advice.

We are planning a family trip to the US, and my wife who is American wants us to stay with her parents for about a week, the only problem is they live right on a major freeway. The only thing separating the freeway from the house is a breeze block wall which is less than 10m from one of the busiest freeways in the area.

I am VERY concerned about pollution levels from this major freeway and the harm it may cause my children who are 10yrs and 6yrs.

We have stayed at the house previously on more than one occasion, when my first born was a baby for about 2 weeks at a time, admittedly i was not as aware of the freeway, or the potential harm from pollution. However, since that time, there has been more awareness of the dangers of pollution in the news, and my first born was diagnosed with ADHD last year, and although its difficult to say if there is a correlation, it has made me think more about the potential harm of traffic pollution and particulate matter on babies and children.

My wife really wants to stay with her parents from an emotional and also cost saving perspective, however am I being unreasonable to suggest we do not stay at the house this time round?

thanks

OP posts:
Quartz2208 · 14/01/2022 13:18

I dont think it is accusatory @beatsandbikes76 you have had a diagnosis for your child which has shocked you and rocked the core of your world. And in keeping with your personality you desperately want to find a reason for it.

What myself and other posters are saying is that in saying no to staying you are putting the pollution aspect ahead of routine and emotional stability and your wife and children need and want to see their grandparents. And in that balance it isnt worth the risk.

There are many resources out there (and a very good SEN board here) that will help you manage the initial diagnosis process and how best to handle it going forward.

Going back and trying to figure out WHY is going to help with moving forward with HOW you can do the best for your child.

Thingsdogetbetter · 14/01/2022 13:18

You do know adhd isn't the same as ASD? And one single biased source is not strong evidence. You're adding 2 and 2 and coming up with 2347. It's a huge leap to pollution outside inlaw's gave my child adhd.

You're grappling for answers and something to blame. To put order back into your life. But what are you going to do about the research that says gut bacteria causes autism? Or those that blame the older father's sperm? These are clickbait articles unless you do proper, indepth reading across dozens or hundreds of often conflicting research.

RoseMartha · 14/01/2022 13:16

Yabvu

beatsandbikes76 · 14/01/2022 13:16

Thank you

OP posts:
beatsandbikes76 · 14/01/2022 13:15

LOL

OP posts:
beatsandbikes76 · 14/01/2022 13:12

@Burgerqueenbee

id also be interested in what peoples views are on pollution and the planet in general, i wouldn't be surprised if many on here were climate change denialists

That's unduly harsh, there will likely be a proportionate amount of climate change deniers as there are in the general population.

I'm a vegan environmental scientist who drives an electric car when a train or walking is not appropriate, I like my in laws, and have never had a parking dispute or told someone to LTB - we are not all one stereotype just because we are on mumsnet.

good for you, i'm a first time poster here, and although i appreciate all the responses, i do find some/most replies are quite accusatory, being told to get a grip, get therapy, etc for showing that i care for the health of my children, is not what i expected.
OP posts:
Quartz2208 · 14/01/2022 13:11

yes, im very practical - cause and effect person.

Yes you can really tell. Even with the would the responses be different if I were a woman - No because as far as you can say this is just a specific house issue and are we climate deniers - no I dont think anyone here has or will say that climate change and pollution is a real issue. But you are using these again to try and make sense of what people are saying. And again lashing out a little bit

None of it though is going to change the fact that your child has ADHD and you are trying desperately to make sense of it.

But routine is incredibly important for them and if in the past they have stayed there and are used to it have you even remotely thought of the impact that would have.

That you are flying across and that even if you visit you will be by the road.

All of this adds up to. Your child has ADHD please try and come to terms with this in a way that isnt going to cause them or your wife emotional harm. Staying for 1 week at your inlaws in the grand scheme of things isnt actually going to change much from a pollution perspective but from an emotional one will an awful lot.

Last year sounds like it was a recent diagnosis please try to access some support in this

KO81 · 14/01/2022 13:09

I’ve never seen a unanimous 💯 YABU result before.

Mistyplanet · 14/01/2022 13:05

I see where you're coming from but on balance it"s going to be better for your childrens health to have less stress and have their mum happy and see their grandparents than two parents who are fighting. Im sure your wife will really resent you for preventing this time with her family and it will damage your relationship. She'll be really hurt by it. Kids all over the world live with air pollution- i dont think one week will be harmful. The hurt you'll cause by rejecting your wife and inlaws will be alot more damaging to your kids in the long run than air pollution for a week. If you really want maybe buy an air purifier for where they sleep but be careful not to offend your in laws.

AlexaShutUp · 14/01/2022 13:02

Certainly not a climate change denier here. I think there are major problems with pollution and I would be very concerned about living next to a major road. But staying there for a week every now and then? You're massively overthinking it.

There is probably a miniscule risk, but nothing that you need to be concerned about. Frankly, there is a risk in getting on a plane and flying across the world. There is a risk in going out of your front door every day. And there is a risk that, in worrying excessively about this very minor concern, you will cause a lot of emotional hurt to your wife and her parents that may impact on your family relationships. And that, in turn, will impact on the emotional wellbeing of your children.

Risks are everywhere. The risk of one thing needs to be balanced against the risks associated with mitigating against it. It is probably very hard for your wife to bring up her children so far from her home country and her parents. Your excessive anxiety about staying with her parents for just one week probably seems quite cruel and unfeeling.

Do you have an anxiety problem? I do think you need to consider what else is going on here because your response is not proportionate to the risk that you have identified.

Fraine · 14/01/2022 13:01

I thought you were going to say it’s noisy 😂

1 week is fine. We breathe much worse air as we’re under the Heathrow flight path

saraclara · 14/01/2022 13:00

i do wonder if these responses would be different if i were a mother asking these questions about her in-laws, it is Mumsnet after all

I can guarantee that they wouldn't be. There have been many many OPs from mothers with unreasonable anxieties involving inlaws where the responses have been exactly the same as here.

I agree that OPs about relationships with inlaws can sometimes be hypocritical. But this is not a relationship OP. This is an anxiety one and you're being unreasonable.

saraclara · 14/01/2022 12:57

There will be families living on the same street as your inlaws. Children/teens who've grown up there. Do you think they all have ADHD?

You're being absolutely paranoid here. I'm sorry that you are struggling with your DC's diagnosis, but please use your logical thinking here. One week staying with your inlaws is not going to damage your children.

Pumperthepumper · 14/01/2022 12:56

Why would the responses be different if you were a woman?

Burgerqueenbee · 14/01/2022 12:53

id also be interested in what peoples views are on pollution and the planet in general, i wouldn't be surprised if many on here were climate change denialists

That's unduly harsh, there will likely be a proportionate amount of climate change deniers as there are in the general population.

I'm a vegan environmental scientist who drives an electric car when a train or walking is not appropriate, I like my in laws, and have never had a parking dispute or told someone to LTB - we are not all one stereotype just because we are on mumsnet.

LakeShoreD · 14/01/2022 12:50

In a typical American home you have central air for heating and cooling, the system also filters the air and people don’t tend to open the windows very often. I bet the pollution levels in the house aren’t even remotely high. There also isn’t any decent research linking ADHD to pollution. And it’s only a week!! Stay with your in laws.

Ponoka7 · 14/01/2022 12:37

@beatsandbikes76, that research was done on less than 300 children, eight years ago. The main funding came via litigation against housing planners. If they'd cross referenced it with rural Nigeria they would see that their findings were rubbish. There isn't a correlation between ADHD and high traffic. You need to learn to recognise what makes credible research and ask yourself why it hasn't been picked up and continued.

beatsandbikes76 · 14/01/2022 12:35

@Quartz2208

OP are you the sort who always desperately needs to find a reason that something happens because it sounds as if rather than just accepting it is what it is. You need answers and are trying to find them.

I would say that yes you just need to stay there - simply due to the emotional side of it all.

yes, im very practical - cause and effect person.

i don't think i'm being that unreasonable given that pollution is such a popular topic these days, i do wonder if these responses would be different if i were a mother asking these questions about her in-laws, it is Mumsnet after all, and id also be interested in what peoples views are on pollution and the planet in general, i wouldn't be surprised if many on here were climate change denialists.

OP posts:
beatsandbikes76 · 14/01/2022 12:29

@SlyAvocado

Maybe see if you can pick up some therapy while you’re Stateside.
hahaha
OP posts:
Quartz2208 · 14/01/2022 12:29

OP are you the sort who always desperately needs to find a reason that something happens because it sounds as if rather than just accepting it is what it is. You need answers and are trying to find them.

I would say that yes you just need to stay there - simply due to the emotional side of it all.

beatsandbikes76 · 14/01/2022 12:22

Love the direct responses here, thank you everyone who is replying, it does help me put things in perspective.

I am just being an overly cautious Dad, if the freeway was not so close, i wouldn't really be that worried but for the record, my first born lived at the house for 2 - 6 weeks at a time, over a period of 3 years and after her ADHD diagnosis, i found strong evidence that links even short term exposure to high concentrated levels of traffic pollution to development disorders.

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4019010/

when you think about the particles that can be inhaled just overnight when you are sleeping in the space of 24/48 hours and what that could do to a babies or young childs developing brain, it is very scary.

sincerely, thanks again everyone x

OP posts:
Chloemol · 14/01/2022 12:22

You really do need to get a grip and stop being so precious

It’s a week, you wife hasn’t seen the family in however long, just stay there

RenGreen · 14/01/2022 12:18

One week stay with them. How do some people in new Delhi live to a ripe old age with all that pollution for a decades? A week will be fine.

HikingforScenery · 14/01/2022 12:17

One week?! Please stay with them.

SlyAvocado · 14/01/2022 12:14

Maybe see if you can pick up some therapy while you’re Stateside.

Swipe left for the next trending thread