Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should he stay with his elderly mother?

94 replies

badspella · 14/01/2022 09:07

I am caught between two very strong sets of opinions with respect to a situation relating to the care of my elderly mother in law.

MIL is 89 and has the early stages of dementia. She is not poorly enough to need daily care, but my husband (her son) pops in to see her every day, and her husband (husband's stepfather) receives daily care for chronic mobility problems (help getting up and dressed etc). The carers also check on MIL.

My husband's stepfather had a nasty fall yesterday and he has broken his hip. He is now in hospital and will almost certainly need an operation. It is estimated that he will be in hospital for about two weeks, if no complications set in. It is also likely that complications will set in because the poor man has had several episodes of sepsis over the past five years.

MIL would like my husband to stay with her until her husband returns home. She lives in a very rural setting, and, although she is quite healthy, she is 89, walks with a stick and there is a risk of her falling. She is very afraid of being on her own, particularly at night,

My husband and I do not live together and he has no work commitments. My husband is adamant that he cannot stay with his mother. He states that they do not really get on and that his mother constantly follows him and asks him repetitive questions. He stayed with her for a few days when his stepfather was in hospital last year, and it ended with my husband leaving abruptly (to put it mildly) and upsetting his mother. He will, however see her every day.

Yesterday, my MIL called me and pleaded with me to try to persuade my husband to stay with her. She did sound quite upset. I talked to her and told her I would speak to my husband, and that he would see her every day whatever the case. My husband, however, is vehemently opposed to staying with his mother, even for a short time.

I would stay, if it was possible. However, I am the sole carer for our young adult son who is in MH crisis, I do not drive, and I could not work from my MIL's property (no Internet). Furthermore, it is my husband whom she wants to stay. We get on well, and speak every day on the phone, but she wants her son to stay.

On one hand, I feel that as long as my husband sees his mother every day, and her care needs are met, there should be no problem, and this would be better than my husband losing his temper or storming off.

On the other hand, I feel really sorry for his mother, who is very old, very worried about her husband and very scared.

What should I do in this situation? I really feel for my MIL, but I am aware of what happened last year.

OP posts:
EmmaH2022 · 14/01/2022 12:23

@Thevoiceofreason2021

Respite care, overnight companion or alarm. Which would she be more comfortable with? It’s pointless trying to get your husband to do it - you are flogging a dead horse there. You can’t do it, so that leaves you the 3 options. She is vulnerable, call SS but don’t hold your breath or have you tried age concern?
I agree with this.

I feel sorry for her but I also understand why he can't stay with her. It's too much responsibility, even if she didn't annoy him.

I have thought about even living with my mum but tbh if she was 89 and using a stick I'd want a carer there rather than me.

Gonnagetgoing · 14/01/2022 12:20

another possibility - would the carers do overnight stays or could the agency they're employed by send out an overnight carer?

Gonnagetgoing · 14/01/2022 12:19

Could your MIL stay you for a short period of time? As in it would be harder to get short term carers, etc organised ASAP.

Then your DH could sort out proper care, PoA, possible moving etc.

Quartz2208 · 14/01/2022 12:18

@Nanny0gg relevant to us - it is clear he is not wanting to do this so they have to work around it. He could have huge number or none I dont think it matters

It is the danger of just assuming that ones children are going to look after you in your old age. From what the OP says this isnt an out of the blue reaction by the husband/son but a long term pattern of behaviour.

Is the right thing to do what you say - of course but it is something that should have been started ages ago. He is clearly not going to do it now so more should have been done before

Nanny0gg · 14/01/2022 12:12

@Quartz2208

I dont think the husbands commitments are actually relevant.

It looks like this is at the stage where living together on their own in a rural setting with their joint needs simply is no longer sustainable. Him staying over for the next two weeks is a papering over the cracks solution rather than actually solving the cracks themselves - it doesnt look like it is going to just be 2 weeks.

They need I think to start the process of moving somewhere that can offer them more

Which is going to take months (assuming they sell relatively quickly)

What's she to do till then?

He could stay and use the time to organise proper care for her. And maybe get PoA as it looks like that may be needed urgently

countrygirl99 · 14/01/2022 12:07

I agree that additional care would be more appropriate. From what the OP said from and personal experience this could stretch out for months or years. But no alternative arrangements can be made quickly, especially at the moment, so he may need to suck it up for a couple of weeks while they are made. And hope that it is just a couple of weeks and that his parents see sense (unlike many). I have a lot of sympathy with the DH, he can probably see what the future will hold very clearly indeed. Boundaries are as important as empathy.

WaterBottle123 · 14/01/2022 12:06

Why doesn't he live with you and share care of your son??

Thevoiceofreason2021 · 14/01/2022 12:04

Respite care, overnight companion or alarm. Which would she be more comfortable with? It’s pointless trying to get your husband to do it - you are flogging a dead horse there. You can’t do it, so that leaves you the 3 options. She is vulnerable, call SS but don’t hold your breath or have you tried age concern?

LakieLady · 14/01/2022 11:57

My late mother had dementia. There is no way I could have stayed with her for more than a couple of days before she drove me raving bonkers.

She needs respite care while her DH is in hospital.

158W0rkawayArk · 14/01/2022 11:51

From his point of view
Perhaps he is thinking, how long will this go on for, the request to stay overnight?
Days
Weeks
Months
Years

Quartz2208 · 14/01/2022 11:51

I dont think the husbands commitments are actually relevant.

It looks like this is at the stage where living together on their own in a rural setting with their joint needs simply is no longer sustainable. Him staying over for the next two weeks is a papering over the cracks solution rather than actually solving the cracks themselves - it doesnt look like it is going to just be 2 weeks.

They need I think to start the process of moving somewhere that can offer them more

WishIwasElsa · 14/01/2022 11:43

What about getting her a care alarm so in case she does fall she can summon help for herself.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 14/01/2022 11:41

Why on Earth doesn’t he take some part in caring for your son?

He doesn’t work, doesn’t parent and won’t help his mother? What does he do?

TakeMe2Insanity · 14/01/2022 11:41

Could your husband sleep over every night at his mum’s then go to work/wfh at his home? That way he’s there at night, but has a break and can conduct his normal life? Definitely not ideal and desperately sad.

ThreeLittleDots · 14/01/2022 11:34

The problem is that there's no guarantee that the husband will come home. Two weeks is not 'a few days' and if the man doesn't want to stay at his mother's then he is not the best carer anyway. She needs to have her own care assessment done.

girlmom21 · 14/01/2022 11:31

@BigFatLiar

So is the new MumsNet concept that we have children so they can care for us in old age and infirmity?

The lady has a carer already. It sounds as if she needs extra help overnight. It also sounds as if while she wants her son they don't actually get on. If he can't cope with her condition then the last thing needed is to force him into it. If he's forced into it and it all goes wrong then he's the baddy rather than those who put him in that position.

It's a situation thats going to become more and more common as we live longer.

No the carers are her husbands carers and he's not home so the carers won't visit. She just wants her son to stay with her overnight for a short while, until her husband comes home.
BigFatLiar · 14/01/2022 11:28

So is the new MumsNet concept that we have children so they can care for us in old age and infirmity?

The lady has a carer already. It sounds as if she needs extra help overnight. It also sounds as if while she wants her son they don't actually get on. If he can't cope with her condition then the last thing needed is to force him into it. If he's forced into it and it all goes wrong then he's the baddy rather than those who put him in that position.

It's a situation thats going to become more and more common as we live longer.

HacerSonarSusPasos · 14/01/2022 11:01

His Mum is 89. It is very possible that he is retired

@user1471505494, if he's retired, all the more reason for him to step up when his mother needs him. OP works and is the sole carer for their son. So what are the husband's committments?

Caring for an elderly with dementia is no walk in the park, but this is temporary and (unless his mother was abusive/neglectful/narcissistic/etc and ruined his childhood) he owes it yo her to suck it up for a few days.

IncompleteSenten · 14/01/2022 10:48

Doesn't live with you, doesn't work and won't put himself out for his mum. Lovely.
Can I assume he would step up to care for his son if you were able to go stay with his mum for a few days?

Your best bet is to phone social services and see what they can put in place.

ThreeLittleDots · 14/01/2022 10:46

He needs to ring adult social care for an urgent vulnerable person needs assessment.

MrsSkylerWhite · 14/01/2022 10:46

I would agree to stay if I were your husband on condition that his mum agrees to them trying to use the time to put in motion moving to sheltered housing with a warden.
Living rurally at their age with complicated health issues isn’t sustainable and the situation will become progressively more demanding.

Foolsrule · 14/01/2022 10:43

It sounds as though everyone has had their heads in the sand about old age and care needs. This situation is not sustainable. Both MIL and SFIL need to be somewhere where they are looked after properly. They should have made plans to move somewhere more appropriate before crisis point was hit. I see this time and again and then suddenly it’s panic stations as a home that was suitable for a family and drivers becomes a prison for someone elderly and infirm. There needs to be much more focus on people adapting and moving before something like this occurs.

Zilla1 · 14/01/2022 10:27

All good suggestions but none of those will necessarily make some people with dementia safe at night. Have been involved in patients' safeguarding where distant family members insist on trying to keep a family member stay in their home when the patient wants to go into a residential setting and is obviously unsafe at home and a short visit from the family member doesn't touch the sides. Not for the OP here but a couple of times it appeared the family were concerned about losing inheritance and day to day access to spending money.

158W0rkawayArk · 14/01/2022 10:16

If he doesn't wish to stay overnight

Practical things that could be put in place at MIL property

Personal fall alarm worn by MIL
CCTV
Outside lights which activate when there is movement
Night lights Inside the property that plug into the wall or stick to the wall
Ring door bell
A dog ?
A carer

Zilla1 · 14/01/2022 10:15

At 89 with mobility issues and early stage dementia and living in an isolated setting then a daily visit might not touch of sides of safety though you can only control what you do, OP, rather than mediate your MIL's wishes and your DP's boundaries. It might not be so much that MIL wants permanent presence rather that FIL has been keeping her safe. Does your DP expect the world to revolve around him and does he do anything to support you and your DC?