Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to allow my DDs to spend their money on overpriced items?

30 replies

RiverLola · 14/01/2022 08:39

DM and I went to an event with DD1 (10) and DD2 (7). We bought treats for them and a small gift shop item. DDs both spotted some branded items from the event and wanted them. For what they were they were hugely expensive (as you expect from an event's own gift shop) but they were adamant.

So I told them if they wanted them they would have to spend their own money. DD1 spent 1/3 of her saved money (the value of which is the amount she was gifted from a relative for her birthday) and DD2 spent half of her money (all saved pocket money)

DM says I was unreasonable as it was overpriced, i could have found them similar items online for cheaper and i shouldn't have let them 'waste their money'

I feel it was their money so who am i to stop them spending it? I explained to them that they were expensive for what they were, that cheaper versions could be found etc but they still wanted to spend their own money.

WIBU to let them spend over the odds? Should I have said no, even though it was their money?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MadeOfStarStuff · 14/01/2022 10:10

Everyone does stupid stuff with money at some point. It’s much better to do it as a child on overpriced tat and learn the lesson than to do it as an adult with real consequences. This is exactly why children should be allowed to have pocket money and spend it as they like, because it’s the best way to learn how to manage money.

Proudboomer · 14/01/2022 10:06

@Pinkflask

It was super painful to watch DS spend over £20 on a tin of Pokemon cards but it was his own money, he'd spent a while weighing up the options and came to the conclusion himself that it wasn't worth it afterwards! It was money given to him by relatives who would be happy to see him spend it frivolously TBH so I didn't feel bad about it. It is exactly how you learn the value of money.
My oldest son has been an avid collector of Pokémon cards for 20 years. As a child he would spend all his pocket money on them and folders to keep them in. Now 20 years later some of those cards are worth serious money and he is still adding to the collection. They are kept in mint condition in their own wallets and will go up in value even more.
RiverLola · 14/01/2022 10:01

thesunwillout DC get £3-4 a week at present. we live rurally so there is no 'popping to the shop for sweets' etc so money tends to be saved and then they go to the toy shop, or sometimes they will ask to look for a particular toy/item online. they don't have much opportunity to 'fritter' due to where we live. both DDs are more inclined towards bigger purchases rather than many small ones.

OP posts:
Hemingwayzcatz · 14/01/2022 09:56

That’s why you give children pocket money in the first place, so they can save and buy things they want with it. Kids always want overpriced shit, it’s part of the parcel. They usually realise it is shit after no time at all and hopefully won’t repeat the mistake in future. They don’t learn this if it’s you buying the items for them but hopefully will when it’s their own money.

thesunwillout · 14/01/2022 09:55

I need to know what the items are to judge, but I wouldn't have allowed my daughter at that age to buy something that was over priced, at that sort of price.

I would and have asked why they wanted it. Again impossible to judge not knowing what the things were.

If it was a specificly named item for an important event or branded for a particular cause or interest maybe.

Depends on how much money your child regularly gets to spend on themselves too.

As a comparison iyswim.

Pinkflask · 14/01/2022 09:54

@Mumdiva99 - my DS is the Y6 who would be ripping off the younger ones except they're thankfully not allowed to swap at school! He does swap but only with his best friend and has had all the warnings about people scamming you/not taking advantage (for all the good this does). Anyway we've had no tears or drama about them so they must be working out any disagreements themselves - another life lesson!

PinkSyCo · 14/01/2022 09:44

Going against the grain but if you could have got the items a lot cheaper online I think you missed a good opportunity to teach your DC about shopping around and that waiting brings rewards rather than giving in to instant gratification all the time.

Mumdiva99 · 14/01/2022 09:43

@pinkflask and just wait till you hear they were given away to little Bobby in the class because he didn't have any cards to swap.
Or when the special shiny card - the one per tin - is swapped for 2 regular cards with a y6 kids who knows what he's doing with swapping with younger kids. Or when one child only has fakes and swaps for the real cards....... (to be fair we were the people that flooded the fake market at our school....we bought a load of fakes back from Hong Kong and shared them with friends kids so they could swap happily.....although when they swapped with another child with real card the mum was vvvv unhappy....)

Pinkflask · 14/01/2022 09:32

It was super painful to watch DS spend over £20 on a tin of Pokemon cards but it was his own money, he'd spent a while weighing up the options and came to the conclusion himself that it wasn't worth it afterwards! It was money given to him by relatives who would be happy to see him spend it frivolously TBH so I didn't feel bad about it. It is exactly how you learn the value of money.

St0rmTr00per · 14/01/2022 09:28

My DC were given a choice as its their money. I would quickly google the price and explain that they could buy the item now for £30 or It could be here the next day from argos / amazon etc for half the price. Both now do this every time without fail and have done since being around 7 (my earliest memory of being in lego land and choosing to wait to go to argos instead). Maybe have a chat with them about inflated prices and shops making excessive money off them etc. Some things you obviously cant avoid but branded goods you generally can.

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 14/01/2022 09:18

Justin Bieber (? Studio Tour) Sweatshirt ( nothing special red/white/blue) it was £70 at a JB concert and DD despertately wanted it .

TBF , she still has it four years later .........

PegasusReturns · 14/01/2022 09:13

Bejewelled water bottles are exactly the thing you want your DC to buy so they learn very early on that not all that glitters is gold.

Three weeks later, a drop on the floor and a cycle through the dishwasher and they’re left with a very unsatisfactory return in their investment.

Hopefully that gives them pause for thought in the future

RiverLola · 14/01/2022 09:13

RJ yes these were event specific items. i could have found them very similar cheaper ones but probably not these exact items. that was part of why i let them after explaining it all to them - they will associate the items with the event.

OP posts:
RJnomore1 · 14/01/2022 09:12

I think sometimes an item from an event, overpriced though it is, is more than the item it’s the memory of that particular day and the whole event. Like buying a band T shirt at a gig.

I have however if we are just out shopping checked prices online and shown my kids, say we are in Tokyo toys and the same item is on amazon for a lot less but you need to wait a few days - to let them see sometimes waiting pays off. Sometimes they’ve just bought the thing anyway but at least they realised the options.

RiverLola · 14/01/2022 09:07

they spent between £40 and £50 each.

oh i wont give in, i never do!

OP posts:
BrioNotBiro · 14/01/2022 09:06

Better they waste £20 now, than £20,000 when they're older. It's a valuable life lesson to realise money is finite and if you blow it on crap now, you don't have it later for something worthwhile.

Just don't give in when they're pleading for something that they could have bought with their savings Grin

RiverLola · 14/01/2022 08:51

mumdiva no bejwelled water bottles! i would have put my foot down on that, they are not practical at all!!!

OP posts:
IncyWincyGrownUp · 14/01/2022 08:51

Their savings*

IncyWincyGrownUp · 14/01/2022 08:51

How can they learn the value of theirs acinus if they’re not allowed to poss them up the wall when they’re small?

The only rule I have is that the middle child is not allowed to spend more than £20 a month on cards (Pokémon, yugioh etc) as he used to be a sod for obsessing over ridiculously expensive cards on eBay. A hard and fast rule helped, but he does have ASD, so 🤷🏻‍♀️

Haveyoubrushedyourteethtoday · 14/01/2022 08:49

Depends in the items but I may not have.

Understanding the value of money is all well and good but there is a limit to the cost of a lesson learned I’d allow my children to cop.

Bagelsandbrie · 14/01/2022 08:48

Yanbu.

RiverLola · 14/01/2022 08:48

i do occassionally put my foot down with crazy items (the time DS1 wanted to borrow £100 from me to then spend £200 on a old figurine thing that cost £8 when new for example....) but the items in question were good quality items, just overpriced.

It is hard to watch them spend it on stuff i see as a waste but then, they don't understand why i pay for hardback copies of books when i have the cheaper paperbacks already!!

OP posts:
Mumdiva99 · 14/01/2022 08:47

I think you did the right thing... .as long as it wasn't ridiculous.....if it was a tshirt for £30 then they will learn. My kids often decide they don't really want something if I tell them they are paying. (I do sometimes absorb the cost as they don't get loads of pocket money....but that's my - 'do they really want this test').

Although if you took them to Frozen the musical and they have spent £100 on a bejazzled plastic water bottle then you are being vvvvunreasonable....that stuff was very over priced tatt!!!

mdh2020 · 14/01/2022 08:45

They have to learn. When they want something they can’t afford then they will remember what they did with their money and it will be a lesson. My GD went to a concert at Wembley and spent a small fortune of her own money on a t-shirt but she loves the performer and has worn the t-shirt constantly. It gave her great pleasure.

PinkWaferBiscuit · 14/01/2022 08:45

That's literally the whole point in them having their own money. They use their money and after realising that the tat is overpriced and often only gives a short amount of enjoyment they start to make wiser choices in how they spend it.

I'd much rather they started learning this lesson at 7 and 10 than when they get their first job or university grant.

Swipe left for the next trending thread