Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is a house where a murderer lived always the murderers house?

63 replies

NCforThis2022 · 13/01/2022 22:57

I'm rewatching Criminal Minds for the fifth or sixth time, and it occurred to me - is a house where a murderer once lived always the murderers house? Does it ever just become the house on the corner?

Obviously places like 25 Cromwell Street are 'famous', but what about the less well known places?

Would you be able to live in a house that a murderer had lived in? And if you could/do, how do you deal with true crime tourism?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
notanothertakeaway · 14/01/2022 22:06

I live near a house where a woman killed her 3 children. It's still there. I know which street, but couldn't tell you exactly which house

If I owned a house like that, I'd probably rent it out, rather than sell. I imagine people might be willing to rent it, knowing they can move on quickly if they don't feel comfortable

IWantChocolates · 14/01/2022 20:57

My DH was closely related to a murder victim in Brighton some years ago. It happened in a flat - no way to demolish that! I sometimes wonder who's living there now and if they know. I guess it wasn't a notorious murder, so perhaps it's faded into history.

RedToothBrush · 14/01/2022 20:37

Its not quite the same as being the home of a murderer but very similar:

Theres a whole thing in Japan about properties with a history.

A “jiko bukken” is a property where the former occupant died of unnatural causes, such as suicide, murder, fire or neglect. They can be rented or purchased at very low prices, provided you are okay with the ‘history’ of the home or apartment.

There is legal requirement to 'declare' if a property has such a history. And that lead to a whole specialist market in these properties because it can drop so much off the value.

Its fascinating that people do attach value to history and a negative value to history.

I do think its good there is a tenancy to knock places down with a particular notoriety.

Nat6999 · 14/01/2022 16:40

A flat in the block I live in had a murder in 2017, a woman was strangled & stabbed by her partner, neighbours heard & dialled 999, the first time they called they didn't see her behind the shower curtain in the bath but found her when he tried to commit suicide. He was detained in a secure mental health unit until the state is sure he is no longer a danger. I think about it every time I go past.

CounsellorTroi · 14/01/2022 16:38

There must be loads of houses previously occupied by victims of Harold Shipman.

Hemingwayzcatz · 14/01/2022 16:37

Made sense to demolish Huntley’s home. It was the caretakers house in the school grounds, not exactly something children want to be reminded of on their way to school! Also pretty certain no future caretaker would want to live there…

x2boys · 14/01/2022 16:30

People do have a ghoulish interest in murders ,I can understand why houses such as Fred West, and Ian huntly were demolished .

ShirleyPhallus · 14/01/2022 16:26

I’ve just googled murders in my area and a few have come up in houses I walk past / have admired. I’d have never known, very odd

Kanaloa · 14/01/2022 16:25

@Alayalaya

I would be somewhat concerned that the criminal might return to their former home if they were released. There’s a house in my village which has been for sale for years, nobody will buy it because it’s owned by a rapist, his ex-wife is selling it while he’s in jail. People are concerned that when he’s released he might come back home and attack the new occupant. The price is stupidly low but still nobody will risk it.
Yeah I would be slightly scared of this too as well as what I said about the murder tourists. If the murderer was dead though/likely to die in prison then it wouldn’t bother me.
Alayalaya · 14/01/2022 16:16

I would be somewhat concerned that the criminal might return to their former home if they were released. There’s a house in my village which has been for sale for years, nobody will buy it because it’s owned by a rapist, his ex-wife is selling it while he’s in jail. People are concerned that when he’s released he might come back home and attack the new occupant. The price is stupidly low but still nobody will risk it.

BlackAmericanoNoSugar · 14/01/2022 16:09

I do think there is a big difference between a house where a murderer lived and a house where murder was committed. There was a murderer living near me, on one of my dog walking routes. He murdered someone elsewhere, his family were living in the house with him and had no idea so it was just a normal family home. It was a very gruesome case and was in the media a lot and photos of the house were in the media, but I couldn't pick the house out now. I wouldn't even think of him anymore as I walk down that street.

Whereas a house in which murders were committed would stay longer in my mind, and I would think of the trauma of the poor victims and would wonder how the neighbours didn't notice anything. Although, having said that, there was a very gruesome murder in the house behind my MIL's, the boundary wall is at the bottom of both gardens, and I stopped being constantly aware of it being there after the first 24 hours.

SirGawain · 14/01/2022 15:59

There was a murder in a house near us about forty years ago. The house (one of a terrace of modern houses). The house is still their but I’ve no idea if anyone presently living in the same street is aware of the houses past.

Frankola · 14/01/2022 15:55

This woman lives in Jon Benet Ramseys house
www.westword.com/news/meet-the-woman-living-in-boulders-notorious-jonbenet-ramsey-house-11199075

LuluBlakey1 · 14/01/2022 15:46

There was a house round the corner from us in Gateshead where, a few years before I was born, a man shot his two children and his wife in their beds then took himself off to a quarry and shot himself. It was often up for sale when I was growing up and my mam always told me the story. It was a religious thing - they were some odd religion and he felt driven to do it apparently (there was a note). We used torun past ig on our way to school because we were so scared of it- it was often unlived in and dark.
Eventually it seems to have been forgotten about- the house is still there, looked after and lived in.

Toomanypeople · 14/01/2022 15:44

There are 3 houses I know of in my town where people were murdered in them. I personally couldn't live in them

Gingerninja4 · 14/01/2022 15:39

House on our road had 3 people killed including a 17 year old 2 injured (drug shooting )but to be honest not known as that any more

It was Catalyst for clearing the area out and is area now that people want to move to and houses go for fair amount

Pedalpushers · 14/01/2022 15:37

I had to Google 25 Cromwell Street, and I know who Fred and Rose West were so maybe the actual address isn't that notorious? Maybe just me...

I'm not overly spooked by these things but no way would I live in Dennis Nilsen's house. He buried his victims under the floors and left them there for months! There are probably still bone fragments in his back garden. Grim.

TheSixthSickSheik · 14/01/2022 15:34

@Teaandakitkat

Unpleasant info warning

My bil is a police forensics expert and he loves sharing gruesome facts about how far microscopic body fragments and blood spatter can travel and how hard it is to completely remove them, which is why police can revisit the homes of murderers years later and still find some forensic evidence. That would put me off.

Fair enough, but wouldn’t this to some extent apply to any house you buy that’s been lived in by people?
ImJustNotMeAnymore · 14/01/2022 15:16

There have been several murders in houses near mine, including the one right opposite. To us who remember it is, and always will be, the murder house.

Gymrats · 14/01/2022 15:13

The house where the children died in the fire (murder) by Something Philpot was it?? That was demolished.

Kitkat151 · 14/01/2022 14:58

Yes IMO....I live in a small market town ....been here years.... I can tell you every house where sOne one has been murdered ( 4 ) ......so can my now adult children and every one of my friends and family

Teaandakitkat · 14/01/2022 14:58

Unpleasant info warning

My bil is a police forensics expert and he loves sharing gruesome facts about how far microscopic body fragments and blood spatter can travel and how hard it is to completely remove them, which is why police can revisit the homes of murderers years later and still find some forensic evidence. That would put me off.

ShirleyPhallus · 14/01/2022 14:46

I think it’s a really interesting thing, because a lot of houses are over 100 years old and we likely don’t know the history of what’s happened in them beyond about 40/50/60 years

NCforThis2022 · 14/01/2022 14:44

@absolutenightmare, I'm sorry for your loss.

I think the idea of crime tourists would put me off more than anything tbh. It would seem intrusive to have random strangers staring at the house.

OP posts:
WhatIsThisPlease · 14/01/2022 09:13

I live not too far away from the Yorkshire Ripper's house. Everyone still refers to it as that. I had to drive past it yesterday and while discussing directions with DP said "so I go past the Ripper's house..."

Think it will always be known as that round here.