Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ireland . Tonight . A woman beaten to death in broad daylight

266 replies

goodyear2021 · 13/01/2022 21:42

I know this is predominantly
A UK site but I am so full of rage .
Beautiful young girl. 23 year old teacher went for a run at 4pm beaten to death.yesterday afternoon .
What can we do to stop this relaxed attitude to violence against women. We are all hurting here.
AIBU to think that violence against some. Women ever ever be fucking taken seriously .
110 convictions and out on bail murder Ed Ashling on a run way called after another woman who was brutally murdered there.
I'm full
Of sadness and fucking rage . I'm
Done with this shit for our girls.

OP posts:
goodyear2021 · 14/01/2022 13:51

Or imagine his wife has been sleeping blissfully by his side last night.

OP posts:
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 14/01/2022 13:50

@goodyear2021

To think he is at large, roaming around makes me sick to the out of my stomach.
Imagine sitting at work wondering if it was any of the men in your building.

Imagine not know where your husband or son or brother was that afternoon and wondering what if?

goodyear2021 · 14/01/2022 13:47

So now that this guy who has been Released says his life has been ruined according to his solicitor .
Same guy with 110 previous convictions and is out on bail btw....
more fucking nonsense.

OP posts:
Anotherviewtoyou · 14/01/2022 12:36

@CaveMum

As was frequently pointed out on the many threads about Sarah Everard, there is always a string of “minor” offences behind these men.

A vanishingly small number of murders are committed by first time offenders, there will be a history of domestic abuse or sex offences of some description in the perpetrator’s history.

Exactly. I read a really good article by the husband of Jill Meagher who said men can engage in catcalling, aggro with women who don’t give them attention in bars, locker room banter about women while comforting themselves that their behaviour is nothing like Bayley’s who was an evil monster. Whereas in reality all of those things contribute to facilitating people like Bayley. It’s well worth a read. We won’t solve anything by saying these men are evil monsters and not all men are like this. All men need to recognise how they or their friends behave and make that behaviour unacceptable.

www.theguardian.com/world/2014/apr/18/jill-meagher-husband-forget-the-lone-monster-myth-society-has-a-role-in

Dancingonmoonlight · 14/01/2022 12:32

I hope the police didn’t concentrate so much on the original suspect that the killer has moved from the area. :-(

FionaMacCool · 14/01/2022 12:28

RIP Ashling and condolences to her family on the loss of a wonderful human being- its sounds as if she added light to everyone she met.

I read the reports in the Irish Times this morning.
I was braced for the comments underneath that would veer toward "not all men are like that".
That mindset sickens me... I dont let anti-Semitic or anti-BLM or anti-Traveller "jokes" go past. I argue the case for immigrants who may be fleeing their country the way that Irish people did in 1847-48. I wont tolerate little digs at myself or others in my company.
I dont ignore it, let it go past, and then say "well, not all Irish people are like that".
Pathetic.
Men are more interested in where they stand in the hierarchy with other men, than they are in the safety of women and children.

In the company of men, there are too many little sneery remarks from "decent men" that set up a misogynistic culture.
You would have to be extremely naive to think, that this doesn't influence the less "decent" men, who may not have the intelligence or insight to discriminate between fantasy and reality.
Who think that female super-heroes from Marvel is somehow related to how strong women are. Or who imagines that what he sees in porn is even remotely related to how women enjoy sex.

I hear you (men) with your remarks about :
"She was asking for it"
"What was she wearing?"
"What did she do to set him off?"
"the town bicycle"
"there are 2 types of women, those you shag and those you marry"
"girls are bitchy and hold a grudge, but boys will fight it out"
" single mothers bringing up children in broken homes"
"my daughter loves playing with the hoover"
"my blond daughter- the other girls are jealous"
"did she have a boy or a child?" (hahaha)

  • all of the above are real life examples
goodyear2021 · 14/01/2022 12:21

To think he is at large, roaming around makes me sick to the out of my stomach.

OP posts:
irene9 · 14/01/2022 12:13

That guy they were questioning, it turns out he could not have been there at the time. He's been released.
The killer is still at large.

DdraigGoch · 14/01/2022 12:06

@goodyear2021

Yes 110 convictions and On bail
Why does the justice system never come to the point where they go "this person is never going to reform, time to throw away the key"?
MogsBestestFurball · 14/01/2022 12:02

I'm so angry that men keep doing this to women.

I had to rephrase my sentence there as I initially wrote 'that this keeps happening to women' like it's some random occurance and not a predictable behaviour by violent men. Whether or not the man arrested was the perpetrator, you can be certain that whoever did this will have come to the attention of the police before.

What is the solution, what can we campaign for? Would more funding for our overstretched police forces be a start? Minimum percentage of women police officers? National monitoring of stats for male violence against women and targets for forces to reduce this?

bythebanksof · 14/01/2022 11:53

It is really is shocking. Working in legal area for many years, I thought I'd get used to it, but I have not, and that's a good thing. The poor girl, and her family and friends. Heartbroken.

When the murderer is found, he will be found to have a history of violence and sexual inappropriate behaviour, that will be well known to family, and friends, and perhaps work colleagues.

Most of the time these spaces are totally safe, until they are not. The sad thing is wonderful parks (and college campuses) near where I live are often a magnet for antisocial elements, drinking/drugs, stalking, flashers, etc. In my field, I'd be much more aware of this than others.

The "notallmen" thing really pisses me off.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 14/01/2022 11:30

Currently out of jail after serving 10 years for rape. Police can not constantly watch him 24/7 , nor can they lock him up on case he offends again

The legal system needs to recognise that rape convictions should be an indication that the perpetrator is a sexual deviant. Rape should be seen as a violent crime. Therefore a violent criminal who is sexually deviant should not be given the opportunity to "reform "

And thus should not be freed

CaveMum · 14/01/2022 11:12

@Stillfunny the man originally arrested has been released without charge. As unpleasant an individual as he sounds the police are content that he is not the murderer.

In any case with an attack on a woman, sadly the fist place to start is with those men known to her - family, boyfriend/ex-boyfriends, friends and work colleagues.

The fact is that most women will be killed by a man they know - The Femicide Census 10 Year Report found that, of the 1,425 women killed by men in the UK between 2009-2028, 92% were killed by a man they knew.

loveisanopensore · 14/01/2022 10:44

What men can do is challenge their friend's shitty behaviour.
Not let rape jokes go by.
Don't defend them to women being harassed.

Stillfunny · 14/01/2022 10:28

Unfortunately, nothing in my opinion can be protect anyone against this type of offender.
An alcoholic violent man who has no regard for himself or others . He will probably plead insanity and get off relatively lightly.
I live in a town that also has a well known individual like this .Currently out of jail after serving 10 years for rape. Police can not constantly watch him 24/7 , nor can they lock him up on case he offends again.

There will always be evil in the world . So depressing and so true.

My heart goes out to this beautiful young girl's family. It is every parents nightmare that their child will cross paths with an evil person like this. So very sad and tragic.

The outpouring of grief and anger in this case has highlighted how unsafe women in this society feel right now. Sentences for DV and so called " minor " attacks on women are disgusting light .

Idontreplytotrolls · 14/01/2022 10:12

@BackBackBack

My heart goes out to her family and friends. As well as all of those families and friends of women who are murdered and don't make the news.

We're told not to take risks, not to get drunk, to dress appropriately, to be aware. It's still not enough. I wonder what exactly it is we are supposed to do to "protect ourselves" when Sarah Everard was just walking home, Sabina Nessa was just walking to meet a friend, Sukhjeet Uppal was in her own home when she was stabbed to death, and Ashling Murphy just went for a run. At what point will society accept that placing the responsibility and blame on us as women is wrong, and that actually it's the men - and it is almost always men - who are at fault and need to be held responsible?

Instead of women being told not to walk after dark, why not tell men they can't go out? What will it take, because even in broad daylight, in well lit areas, in busy streets and in our own homes we aren't safe?

My god some of these comments on here do you actually think about what your posting rather than just ranting.

Just how exactly telling all men they can't go out is going to stop a murderer or person who does not give two shits about the law or others, going out anyway. Do you think they care or even care what other men think. There killers and evil full stop 🙄.

Bad shit happens daily it's not just picked up by the media. I'm really sorry for the family but the blame game won't stop murders and never has, it just breeds devision. What we need is unity, right now, and all the comments like this don't help.

MorningStarling · 14/01/2022 10:02

@immersivereader

The men need to stand up.

When will they?

Men? You there?

What should they actually do though? Like many things it probably needs spelling out to them. Telling them to "stand up" is an empty gesture, you need to explain to them how their actions (individually) contributed to this murder. A great number of men, probably the majority, will never murder a woman. They genuinely don't understand how they can prevent a murder by someone they don't know, of someone they don't know, at a place they've never been to.
BackBackBack · 14/01/2022 09:36

My heart goes out to her family and friends. As well as all of those families and friends of women who are murdered and don't make the news.

We're told not to take risks, not to get drunk, to dress appropriately, to be aware. It's still not enough. I wonder what exactly it is we are supposed to do to "protect ourselves" when Sarah Everard was just walking home, Sabina Nessa was just walking to meet a friend, Sukhjeet Uppal was in her own home when she was stabbed to death, and Ashling Murphy just went for a run. At what point will society accept that placing the responsibility and blame on us as women is wrong, and that actually it's the men - and it is almost always men - who are at fault and need to be held responsible?

Instead of women being told not to walk after dark, why not tell men they can't go out? What will it take, because even in broad daylight, in well lit areas, in busy streets and in our own homes we aren't safe?

CaveMum · 14/01/2022 09:35

As was frequently pointed out on the many threads about Sarah Everard, there is always a string of “minor” offences behind these men.

A vanishingly small number of murders are committed by first time offenders, there will be a history of domestic abuse or sex offences of some description in the perpetrator’s history.

UserBot2022 · 14/01/2022 09:26

Absolutely @honeyrider the thoughts of a man getting free legal aid to defend himself against a rape or sexual assualt charge for the third or fourth time, that just BEGGARS BELIEF

katepilar · 14/01/2022 09:25

I am also always sad about how our society works and how women are generally worse off. I think it all has evolved because men are stronger and competitive in their nature, in general. We probably have it better than most in the past 2000 years but still not fair at all.

UserBot2022 · 14/01/2022 09:24

sorry quoted wrong post.

UserBot2022 · 14/01/2022 09:24

@CaveMum

Forgot to add the screenshot of the. Irvin News tweet to my last post
''misogyny greenlights killers'' yes, and it greenlights rapists as well.

I think there needs to be a class in school. We have SPHE or whatever it's called, it needs to go deeper in to subject of what behaviour is unacceptable.

On my facebook last night ONE man spoke out about this. ONE. The others are sitting there thinking ''not all men, what about the menz who get killed?''
But good for him.

UserBot2022 · 14/01/2022 09:20

@EishetChayil

For a start, violent porn needs to be made much harder to access.
I agree.

If you speak up about the men who view porn, forward porn you're seen as confusing different issues or blaming poor innocent porn-users of being killers / rapists but it's all contributing to this world we live in where women are just pretending to have lives and careers and responsibilities equal to men's but really, they're just there to be objectified and it's so frustrating to the poor men that they can't just harrass and objectify with as much freedom as they'd enjoy.

Very few men speak out. All the vigils, all the donations to women's aid, all the sponsored walks for women's aid, it's always women. Men just say not all men. that's literally their only contribution, to obfuscate and be defensive.

Cam77 · 14/01/2022 09:16

The men need to stand up.
When will they?
Men? You there?

The majority of people who commit this kind of crime -murdering a stranger in broad daylight -are psychopaths - possibly circa 1% of the population. Encouraging these people to read some woke articles on the Guardian will probably not do any good. They need to be identified early, monitored as necessary, and then locked up for as long as necessary.