Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ireland . Tonight . A woman beaten to death in broad daylight

266 replies

goodyear2021 · 13/01/2022 21:42

I know this is predominantly
A UK site but I am so full of rage .
Beautiful young girl. 23 year old teacher went for a run at 4pm beaten to death.yesterday afternoon .
What can we do to stop this relaxed attitude to violence against women. We are all hurting here.
AIBU to think that violence against some. Women ever ever be fucking taken seriously .
110 convictions and out on bail murder Ed Ashling on a run way called after another woman who was brutally murdered there.
I'm full
Of sadness and fucking rage . I'm
Done with this shit for our girls.

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 16/01/2022 02:44

I also think it would be a good idea to publish details of the sentencing of the murderers of women, where applicable.

I think this would be something to behold.

mathanxiety · 16/01/2022 02:38

I think it would be a good idea to post the names of the murderers too, if known.

That way, society would be able to envision perhaps 244 murderers and they wouldn't be just some hazy notion, some bogeyman you hope you won't have anything to do with.

It is a very good thing to commemorate the dead, especially when in doing so you reveal the scale of the problem.

But when you focus only on the victims you are only looking at the symptoms of the problem, not the cause. When you don't look at the cause you are never going to find the cure.

CaveMum · 15/01/2022 19:29

Women’s Aid Ireland have today been tweeting the names of the 244 women murdered in Ireland since they began their work in 1996. It’s a sobering read.

twitter.com/womens_aid/status/1482317138522218499?s=21

PleasantBirthday · 15/01/2022 16:44

Some complete loser emailed Katie Hannon to tell her that if her show solicited any bad statements about men, there were 200 like minded slow burners listening in who'd make her answerable.

Maybe not all men, but that 200 for sure.

FormerlyAHoarder · 15/01/2022 16:38

Wow, that is horrible. We arent even allowed to acknowledge that it's men who kill women.

I read one comment from a man with hurt feelings "do we know for sure it even was a man?".

Wow. His ability to live in delusion is enviable. When has a woman ever killed another woman in daylight and then run off. What are the stats on that. But this man b3lieves we dont know yet that it was a man. 😲🤔

Laiste · 15/01/2022 16:37

@PleasantBirthday

I'm done with a minutes silence. Women need to be doing a minutes scream in all the places they congregate to remember.
This is a fucking amazing idea!

You know what though - so many women wouldn't take part though, for fear of causing 'disturbance'.

We're dying week in week out at the hands of men, but the conditioning to not be difficult or not be seen to be angry is STILL so strong.

Can anyone imagine the fucking uproar if it was that many men dying at the hands of women?

PleasantBirthday · 15/01/2022 16:31

God, they're pathetic.

Anotherviewtoyou · 15/01/2022 16:26

This is crazy

m.independent.ie/irish-news/crime/rtes-katie-hannon-sent-chilling-threat-not-to-solicit-negative-comments-about-men-during-discussion-of-ashling-murphy-murder-41243241.html

We just got an email before we came on air addressed to me that says: ‘I’m just letting you know that your show will be recorded and should you interview or solicit negative comments about men, you will have to personally answer for it,” she read from the message.

“It goes on to tell me there’s some online meeting and that ‘we have close to 200 listening in’ and it’s warning us not to solicit negative comments about men,”

PleasantBirthday · 15/01/2022 16:09

Men are pathetic whingebags is the takeaway again. They can wibble about how it's not all of them but christ, it's some number. Frankly, they are self centered babies unless proven otherwise, as far as I'm concerned.

MargieMo · 15/01/2022 16:07

Many of the comments from the Irish Times editorial today beggar belief. I hope to God my son does not turn out like any of them.

www.irishtimes.com/opinion/editorial/the-irish-times-view-on-violence-against-women-the-right-to-live-without-fear-1.4776648

Anotherviewtoyou · 15/01/2022 15:37

@PleasantBirthday @FionaMacCool it gets worse! There was a thread on here about a woman calling her DH out on making rape jokes and nearly all posters said she was overreacting/ being too sensitive / needed to lighten up / brought it on herself by making an unrelated joke before he made the rape joke!

So depressing. The thread ended up getting deleted.

UserBot314159 · 15/01/2022 10:54

The repeated endless free legal aid gets me too. I am just thinking about how when I fled an abusive relationship with two toddlers and one bag, my x tried to have me ordered back to the uk. I couldn't get free legal aid because I had ''removed the children from their habitual domicile''. Yes I had done that. He attacked me for one last time as I escaped. Then he calmed down. He always used to feel better after he'd been abusive. For a while. Then he used the law to abuse me. He tried to have me ordered back to the UK. He failed luckily and I didn't realise how lucky I was until much later. So I cannot help feeling aghast that these repeat offenders get free legal aid ad infinitum. A woman trying to keep her children in safety doesn't get free legal aid. The whole system is stacked against women but men who are in charge believe that the opposite is true.

LadyEloise1 · 15/01/2022 10:49

@honeyrider I'm with you on the limitless free legal aid. It's a joke. We, the hard working taxpayers are funding criminals who put two fingers up to the system.
The whole justice system is a joke in Ireland.
They moan in the UK about lenient sentences but they ain't seen nothing like Irish lenient sentences.
What is wrong with our judges ?
I know legal appointments in the past were political but not sure now.
It appears the criminals have more human rights than the victims and their families.

FionaMacCool · 15/01/2022 10:08

@PleasantBirthday

*The comments Under breakingnews.ieandjournal.iemake me want to scream.*

There are so many unselfconsciously horrific men around.

Same on the Irish Times..... the "misandry" word in every second comment. As if there is any comparison in the relative levels of threat to men from women, vs the threat to women - and men- , from MEN.

I am not saying that all men are responsible for the murder of women, but they ARE responsible for being part of the solution to male-on-female violence.

PleasantBirthday · 15/01/2022 06:54

The comments
Under breakingnews.ieandjournal.iemake me want to scream.

There are so many unselfconsciously horrific men around.

CheeseMmmm · 15/01/2022 06:33

The amount of instinctive urge to protect males full stop is v damaging.

The popularity of things like.
Find excuse.

He was under strain.
Apparently she was having affair.
She undermined him constantly. Just snapped. Sad for the children killed as well.
What did she expect talking to him, going outside with him, going to party with him?!

Expect she regretted.
Girls make up stuff like this all the time.
Not right a moment of madness mean loss of job/reputation/taken away from family!
Never done anything like this before too harsh.

I mean on and on.

CheeseMmmm · 15/01/2022 06:28

With anything to do with MVAWG it always comes back to that. And it's embedded so so deeply across society.

What did she do wrong?

And the hideous also widely embedded hand in hand fundamental.

Need to be very very careful indeed that this is all it seems. It's imperative to protect men around this sort of thing. Even a name mentioned in pub can bring s good man down permanently.

BackBackBack · 15/01/2022 06:14

@CheeseMmmm

No I think it would be counterproductive.

What needs to happen is for the existing laws to be enforced.

For the police to stop ignoring 'low level crime' like flashing. To give those things the priority they deserve.

Flashing been known for DECADES to be high risk escalation. A sex offenders starter crime as it were. That stopping them before escalate prevents terrible crimes down the line.

Couzens would not have been in police and would have been known as escalating risk if they did that. Even in prison etc.

Plus the fact that indecent exposure is not TRIVIAL FFS. men who do this tend to do it a lot. Loads of victims. Schoolgirls v popular with flashers. And just because non contact does not mean v little impact victim. It happens to so many of us often more than once.

FFS it's all OBVIOUS step to take.

Agree.

The emphasis on women having to protect themselves has got to change - because it doesn't address the root cause which is male violence and misogyny - and because it doesn't work, as evidenced by the fact that a woman can be murdered anywhere and at any time regardless of how "careful" she is.

CheeseMmmm · 15/01/2022 04:48

And sort out police culture.
Watsapp groups.
Photos of murder victims circulated.
Huge numbers of reports from public sex crimes/dodgy behaviour police officers.
Piled up back room not looked at.

Come on cops! These are no brainers.

Never happens that says it all.

CheeseMmmm · 15/01/2022 04:46

No I think it would be counterproductive.

What needs to happen is for the existing laws to be enforced.

For the police to stop ignoring 'low level crime' like flashing. To give those things the priority they deserve.

Flashing been known for DECADES to be high risk escalation. A sex offenders starter crime as it were. That stopping them before escalate prevents terrible crimes down the line.

Couzens would not have been in police and would have been known as escalating risk if they did that. Even in prison etc.

Plus the fact that indecent exposure is not TRIVIAL FFS. men who do this tend to do it a lot. Loads of victims. Schoolgirls v popular with flashers. And just because non contact does not mean v little impact victim. It happens to so many of us often more than once.

FFS it's all OBVIOUS step to take.

RantyAunty · 15/01/2022 04:05

Is anyone following the case to make misogyny a hate crime?

I tried to read through the Law Commison report but only have gotten through about 150 pages of it.

Does anyone feel it would help if misogyny was a hate crime legally?

mathanxiety · 15/01/2022 03:44

Death penalty means they won't do it again.

The death penalty sometimes makes juries hesitate to convict. It's hard enough to get juries to convict now, even if a rape case comes to trial. Society frets about the impact on the poor men of accusations of criminal conduct involving women, how their lives are ruined by bitter or vindictive women...

mathanxiety · 15/01/2022 03:39

Sad but completely true ^^

CheeseMmmm · 15/01/2022 02:36

The majority reaction in society, as shown on this thread. Illustrates really clearly the fundamental reasons that men committing sex offences (from flashing, frotting etc all the way up to rape murder) against women/girls aren't tackled in any meaningful way.

This sort of thing-

Women girls all learn self defence. Good idea it is exercise, increases confidence and self image generally, group things like that good for MH, etc

If it means some women/girls get away then that's brilliant. And then... He goes off finds another to attack.

Great for anyone who gets away 100%. Realistically, no impact on overall prevalence. So that's changed nothing.

Realistically, likelihood of getting away from man who out to commit extreme crime targeted while out and about.

It's sadly vv low. It's a lovely idea but in practice it's unusual that a girl/woman who is unaware has been targeted by man intent on crime of this level will be able to fight him off. Yes can happen that's brilliant. To think it will really increase our safety from this risk is a lovely fantasy.

And say it did? That if women/girls learned krav maga or whatever they could fight back enough to get away?

Then dodgy men learn it too. Then what?

Or even if they didn't. They'd just target more vulnerable women/girls and/or use more dangerous means of overpowering them.

Younger girls, smaller women. Women with obvious mobility problems. A stick. An arm in plaster. Etc.

Or simply. First thing done sweep legs from under with baseball bat. Hit them round head with it. Throttle from behind. Throw chemical in eyes so can't see. I mean. It makes things worse.

Example DNA testing comes in. Some use bleach on/inside victim of rape to try and destroy evidence since then.

So no overall impact, society feels great women/girls can better protect themselves on an individual basis. Feel like something done.
Possible increase in selection of more vulnerable victims, unintended impact crimes even nastier.