Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend at DD's birthday party

64 replies

steph8877 · 13/01/2022 12:54

I recently held a birthday party for DD (age 9) at home with a few of her friends from school. Unwrapped presents, had games, food, music etc and all seemed to go well.
One of her friends who attended bought her a present which I saw her unwrap at the time. Fast forward to bed time after the party I was tidying up and helping DD take presents to her room. Present from said friend was missing. Checked in case it had been accidently thrown in water waste bin but wasn't there.
A few days later, my DD was at said friend's house and noticed it there (same item, complete with packaging intact). Didn't say/do anything as was too shocked and upset.
Looks like friend gave the present to DD but then took it back straight away before leaving party. WWYD?

OP posts:
Colderthanever · 13/01/2022 16:40

Hmmm, what’s the odds of your daughter seeing it but not the mother? Doesn’t seem it was hidden, and most parents at least cursory look in their child’s room.

RainbowBridge21 · 13/01/2022 16:34

Maybe say that your dd took it to friend's house and left it there, could she have a look for it? Then you're not accusing anyone but you're tackling it.

topayornottopay · 13/01/2022 16:33

@verytiredofbeingshoutedat

Aunt it would be better to word it like this 'Thankyou for the pressie of xyz with her initials XX for DDs birthday. We wonder if friend may have accidentally taken it home with her as it disappeared after birthday party and DD saw same item with her initials XX on them at your house yesterday and was really confused. Could you please check for us? Thankyou"
I'd agree with this. Also you don't know that the parents are unaware the gift is back in their house. I expect they have seen it there. They would have questioned their dc on it surely. And I expect were given an answer such as I have it because friend didn't like it/want it so said I could bring it home. If that is the case they are probably thinking what a rude and ungrateful child your dd is!!
Santaisstilleatingmincepies · 13/01/2022 16:28

2 choices.. Text the dm or never invite the girl to your home again.
She is a thief...
Obviously mention to her dm thanks for the gift of x but your dd noticed her dd had taken it back.

BoredZelda · 13/01/2022 15:54

Very strange that nobody saw her take it away, doesn’t sound like a tiny pocket sized gift, especially as you are so observant you could tell from a pile of gifts it was missing. I couldn’t tell you what my daughter got at her last party. Also strange your daughter never mentioned it to the girl, that would be an obvious conversation to have.

I’d replace it and move on. Not worth the drama. Certainly not worth banning the other child, just be more observant when they leave in case they have stuck the TV down their jacket on their way out.

Sally872 · 13/01/2022 15:21

It's shit but I wouldn't bother speaking to the mum unless a close friend who I cared about.

I would use it as a learning experience, tell dd that's not tue behaviour of a good friend. Perhaps she is having a hard time but if she often treats you like that distance yourself. And I would replace the gift so dd hasn't lost anything.

wolfstarling · 13/01/2022 15:11

I wouldn't mention it tbh.

Anoisagusaris · 13/01/2022 15:11

Not the point of the thread but no one opens presents at parties here. It’s not a nice thing to do, embarrassing for a child who didn’t bring a present.

Branleuse · 13/01/2022 15:10

@Valeriekat

She stole it! I don't understand how people can think it is acceptable to not say anything to her parents. She knows that your daughter knows. You have to say something to her Mum.
Because if you get involved in every kids squabble, where does it end? Who has time for that?
CallmeIT · 13/01/2022 15:08

I’m with ittakes2 on this as well. My own DD had a friend who in this situation would have lied to their parent and said that the birthday girl was rude about the present and returned it. (And their mother would believe anything, no matter how improbable).

It might nit be the same here but I’d not risk a poorer outcome for your daughter. I assume it wasn’t a high value gift. Your DD can make her mind up about this friend as time passes.

BettyOBarley · 13/01/2022 15:07

Totally agree. At the end of the day it’s a gift they gave rather than the child stealing something of yours or a gift another child gave your DD. Just tell your DD that that’s very strange behaviour to take back a gift but I don’t really think it’s worth saying anything.

This.
It is very weird behaviour but as it was a gift and not something she'd stolen from your daughter, personally I'd let it go and not invite that child again.

verytiredofbeingshoutedat · 13/01/2022 15:01

Aunt it would be better to word it like this
'Thankyou for the pressie of xyz with her initials XX for DDs birthday. We wonder if friend may have accidentally taken it home with her as it disappeared after birthday party and DD saw same item with her initials XX on them at your house yesterday and was really confused. Could you please check for us? Thankyou"

ittakes2 · 13/01/2022 15:01

"I don't understand how people can think it is acceptable to not say anything to her parents."
...because all we care about is the effects of a possible fallout on her innocent daughter. Not a present that will not change her daughter's life. As previous poster said - if OP was close enough to the other mum she would have mentioned it to the other mum already and not have posted on mumsnet.
The other girl is a thief - but something to leave the other mum to deal with. A thief will not take kindly to be called out and will likely then target this innocent girl in school.

verytiredofbeingshoutedat · 13/01/2022 15:00

No one said OP should accuse the friends DD of theft! . It's not unreasonable to state then facts though as suggested earlier

Just message the parents and say 'Thankyou for the pressie of xyz with her initials XX for DDs birthday. (..We think friend may have accidentally taken it home with her as ..) it disappeared after birthday party and DD saw same item with her initials XX on them at your house yesterday and was really confused. Could you please check for us? Thankyou"

Valeriekat · 13/01/2022 14:49

She stole it!
I don't understand how people can think it is acceptable to not say anything to her parents. She knows that your daughter knows.
You have to say something to her Mum.

purplecorkheart · 13/01/2022 14:49

I am not sure that I would mention seeing it at the friends house.
I would just stay that the gift went missing after it was opened and that your daughter really loved it and you would like to get a replacement as she is so upset. The fact that the other girl did not have it hidden when your daughter visited would make me thing there is a chance they bought two (or it was buy one, get one free) regardless of the initials.

piney07 · 13/01/2022 14:44

@ittakes2

This has red flags all over it for me that unfort if you do something about it your daughter is going to end up worse for wear through no fault of her own. It is my experience that the mother/daughter will feel embarassed if you contact them - as others have said a 9 year old knows what they are doing - and will likely speak ill of your daughter to act as if she was somehow at fault ie lying about seeing it at her friend's house. So I would encourage my daughter to spend more time with children with a better moral compass and buy her the gift myself if she is upset about not having it. Unless you are standing in the other mum's house - pointing to the gift questioning it - the other family will somehow discredit you/your daughter.
Totally agree. At the end of the day it’s a gift they gave rather than the child stealing something of yours or a gift another child gave your DD. Just tell your DD that that’s very strange behaviour to take back a gift but I don’t really think it’s worth saying anything.

If you were close enough to the mother where mentioning it wouldn’t be awkward then you would have just called her up rather than asking MN.

ittakes2 · 13/01/2022 14:37

This has red flags all over it for me that unfort if you do something about it your daughter is going to end up worse for wear through no fault of her own. It is my experience that the mother/daughter will feel embarassed if you contact them - as others have said a 9 year old knows what they are doing - and will likely speak ill of your daughter to act as if she was somehow at fault ie lying about seeing it at her friend's house. So I would encourage my daughter to spend more time with children with a better moral compass and buy her the gift myself if she is upset about not having it. Unless you are standing in the other mum's house - pointing to the gift questioning it - the other family will somehow discredit you/your daughter.

CrackerGal · 13/01/2022 14:18

@Ileflottante

Yeah I'd absolutely get that if they were age 4 or 5, but at 9 they ought to have some impulse control unless there's an issue there with that (they possibly might have taken things they wanted before then). But a 9 year old would know they couldn't bring the gift they brought back for themselves. I'd text the mum, say your daughter was upset as her gift disappeared & she spotted it at her friends. Then let her deal with it

Oh they’d absolutely know they couldn’t take it back. But that doesn’t always stop them doing it. I can fully believe it if a nine year old, if they were miffed as it was something they’d like for themselves. Kids can be sneaky.

Yes you're right I hadn't thought of it that way. OP how do the girls get on? Could it be possible this friend was being unkind to your daughter or was jealous & wanted to hurt her? How do they get on usually?
teatime9999 · 13/01/2022 14:17

Do nothing about the incident, as it was just a silly gift and NBD. However, just in case she has sticky fingers, maybe never have her in your house again. Your daughter will understand why.

BliainNua · 13/01/2022 14:10

It's a tough one, I think I'd ask if she's seen it as you can't find it. Either way I wouldn't have that child back in my house.

Ileflottante · 13/01/2022 14:08

Yeah I'd absolutely get that if they were age 4 or 5, but at 9 they ought to have some impulse control unless there's an issue there with that (they possibly might have taken things they wanted before then).
But a 9 year old would know they couldn't bring the gift they brought back for themselves.
I'd text the mum, say your daughter was upset as her gift disappeared & she spotted it at her friends.
Then let her deal with it

Oh they’d absolutely know they couldn’t take it back. But that doesn’t always stop them doing it. I can fully believe it if a nine year old, if they were miffed as it was something they’d like for themselves. Kids can be sneaky.

MiddleClassProblem · 13/01/2022 14:06

I don’t know if I could say anything. It’s a present rather than something you’re owed and I’m a massive chicken.

Your DD must have really loved it though to be very upset so maybe say to the parents that your daughter loves it but you can’t find it and where could get a replacement? It’s unlikely that the other child could hide it from their parents forever, and it’s initialled. They will find out the truth and either return it if feel embarrassed and hide the truth.

I’d be careful accusing anyone, especially if it ends up as a he said/she said. Kids do socially unacceptable things of varying degrees for all sorts of reasons.

Beamur · 13/01/2022 14:04

I would leave out the bit about DD having seen it at the friends house. Just say thank you but that now you can't find it and wondered if it had been taken back by mistake. Leave the child some room to own up.
'm guessing it's a nice desirable item and maybe her impluse control didn't quite kick in enough...

Hemingwayzcatz · 13/01/2022 14:03

If you know the Mum I’d text her and explain what happened, I’m sure she’s completely unaware and will make her DD return it.