Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Car crash not my fault

112 replies

Shibby585 · 13/01/2022 12:52

Just wondering people's thoughts on this. Been driving for 15 years, 12 years no claims on my own policy. Was hit by a young driver from behind as I was waiting to pull off at the roundabout, she was really upset and I said its OK. I got her to pull over, told her to put hazards on and checked our cars.

There was more damage to hers than mine, I have some scuffs and some paint mark. I told her again not to worry and asked for insurance details, she said she didn't know them. She was upset so I also spoke to her dad and said there was only a bit of damage and we were both OK. I told them. I had the car in for a service the next day so would get it checked for safety. Dad also apparently did not know insurance details.

Got the girls number went home and messaged all my details, again she apologised and said if there were any repairs she would pay. I said that's fine I probably just need a new car seat it's probably not worth repair.

I asked again for details to cover myself in case of injury or something turned up wrong with the car she again refused. Then her dad got involved and started messaging saying he didn't have to provide details and they would pay for the car seat. I said if I didn't get them I would notify insurance and police. He said he's already made a police report.

I had to take the day off work and had to take it today, so I've been and got checked I have whiplash. In the end I got sick and rang my insurance and have asked them to deal with it all.

I feel really bad as her insurance will go up and the damage wasn't major, but I got sick of asking and I am actually injured and there is damage to my car. Am I the asshole here?

OP posts:
GrannyWeatherwaxsHatpin · 13/01/2022 16:32

You can get whiplash from fairly low speeds. Anyway, I think whiplash is just a term used for neck pain in this situation, as it would be far too early to determine whether there was long term lasting damage.

It's not necessarily the speed, it's the force - I was hit by a large vehicle accelerating from a standstill. And whiplash is most certainly not 'just a term for neck pain". As someone who has suffered the after effects of 'just' whiplash for nearly 10 years now, not only is it my neck, but my shoulders, the muscles in my face (causing migraines), my back and the muscles around my ribcage.

Anyone who thinks whiplash is 'just' anything, or indeed an automatic insurance con, should just be bloody grateful they don't find out what it can really be like.

vixeyann · 13/01/2022 16:07

Your obliged to report any accident or damage to the insurer anyway, regardless of claiming so you are doing the right thing and saving yourself hassle. What if you had a long term condition that took a while to show and you need physio etc.

MrsPinkCock · 13/01/2022 16:05

[quote Shibby585]@NiceTwin this is what I don't understand was a minor bump, although my car is suv so higher than hers, a few scuffs and paint chip. Hers had a dent and crack in the middle so more than mine. Felt OK first day, second day neck hurt and migraine so took the day off work and today my neck kills and I feel so headachy and sick. I didn't think she was going that fast?[/quote]
I worked for six months in personal injury when I was doing my training contract.

We regularly had whiplash claims for cars that collided at or around 10MPH.

Foolsrule · 13/01/2022 16:04

Why is everyone infantilizing the woman who caused the accident? She’s not a girl, she’s a woman. Why is her dad involved? Was he in the car? If not, it’s none of his business. It’s her mess to clear up.

If she’s old enough to drive, she’s old enough to know what she does in the event of an accident, particularly one she’s caused. If she’s old enough to drive, she should know that she should (technically) have a copy of her insurance details with her in the car.

EricScrantona · 13/01/2022 15:30

You don't need to pay a small fee, your insurance are able to see who it is insured with. You've done the right thing. They are either not insured correctly or don't want an increased premium.

Shibby585 · 13/01/2022 15:30

@NiceTwin this is what I don't understand was a minor bump, although my car is suv so higher than hers, a few scuffs and paint chip. Hers had a dent and crack in the middle so more than mine. Felt OK first day, second day neck hurt and migraine so took the day off work and today my neck kills and I feel so headachy and sick. I didn't think she was going that fast?

OP posts:
JudgeJ · 13/01/2022 15:29

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

Except for use of the term "asshole"
But MN is the home of some of the foulest language used with impunity, why not 'asshole' though the English language version of 'arsehole' is better?
mommybear1 · 13/01/2022 15:26

You did the right thing - usually under your t&c's you have to report any incident to your insurers in any event.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 13/01/2022 15:23

Oh, and I suspect the girl wasn't insured or only has third party, hence why she's refusing to give her details (which is a crime and should be reported to the police).

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 13/01/2022 15:23

@NiceTwin

She must have been going at a fair whack to give you whiplash, surprised the damage on your car is so minor.
You don't need to be going that fast to get whiplash - it only really means strained neck/upper back muscles, anyway.
soughsigh · 13/01/2022 15:11

I thought insurance companies didn't pay out for whiplash anymore? Since it's an injury that can't actually be medically verified so people can easily fake the pain.

Let the insurance companies sort it out. I would assume either she isn't insured to drive to vehicle or she doesn't want her premiums to go up by making a claim. If it's the latter, yours shouldn't go up. Sadly if she's uninsured, you will have to swallow that. You won't lose your whole no claims, maybe 3 years (it should state in your policy how many years no claims an accident gets you).

Puccini3506 · 13/01/2022 15:10

I'd advise anyone to buy a front and back dashcam these days. Mine was about £40 and a doddle to install....

Kuachui · 13/01/2022 14:59

sounds like either no insurance (likely) or doesnt want a claim as knows itll be marked as fault

Minfilia · 13/01/2022 14:56

No, you weren’t being an asshole.

Legally, as you were injured, they are required to report their insurance information and as that didn’t happen at the roadside, you should both report the incident to the police.

It’s unfortunate for the girl, but the accident was still her fault!

DerAlteMann · 13/01/2022 14:55

Dealing with this sort of stuff is what your insurance company is charging you for (among other things). Let them deal with it - it's their job.

2DogsOnMySofa · 13/01/2022 14:46

Tell your insurance company and report to the police

Exasperatedhousehunter · 13/01/2022 14:43

She must have been going at a fair whack to give you whiplash, surprised the damage on your car is so minor.

Not necessarily. You can get whiplash from fairly low speeds. Anyway, I think whiplash is just a term used for neck pain in this situation, as it would be far too early to determine whether there was long term lasting damage.

Exasperatedhousehunter · 13/01/2022 14:41

I made a PI claim when someone hit the back of my car last year. I got £1,000 in compensation for a minor shoulder injury but could have gotten more if I'd gone through a full medical. I settled on the basis of no medical report. My solicitor explained to me that once you have an accident that's your fault, the insurance company will automatically put aside money for a potential PI claim so whether you make a claim or not doesn't affect the other driver's premiums (they will go up whatever you do). So I'd recommend that you do make a claim. Accidents mean that your car is often less attractive if you were to sell it and you don't get that loss in value back.

I am pleased that you have now reported it. I strongly suspect that she is uninsured too. Either that or she is on her parents' insurance and they are shitting themselves that their premiums will go through the roof.

Zombiemum1946 · 13/01/2022 14:15

YANBU . The father probably hasn't contacted the police and is worried about insurance costs. She may well be insured on his policy and this will put his premiums up, or, she wasn't insured at all. Their behaviour would suggest there's a problem. Contact the police and make sure its been reported. You've sustained an injury and they've been obstructive.

AryaStarkWolf · 13/01/2022 14:10

@NiceTwin

She must have been going at a fair whack to give you whiplash, surprised the damage on your car is so minor.
mmm coming up to a roundabout too.....
AdobeWanKenobi · 13/01/2022 14:06

[quote dinahsdishes]You can check their insurance for a small fee here

www.askmid.com/askmidenquiry.aspx[/quote]
Fee? 😂
Just tick the own vehicle and check for free. Realistically, whats going to happen if you do?

Cabbagepie · 13/01/2022 14:06

Make sure your car is fully checked out. Someone went into the back of me in a queue of traffic, fairly low speed and looked like only my rear bumper was damaged - their car looked much worse. Got home and opened the hatchback and then it wouldn't close properly. Insurers told me not to drive it and collected it on a recovery vehicle. Turned out the floor was buckled and the car was written off.

NiceTwin · 13/01/2022 14:05

She must have been going at a fair whack to give you whiplash, surprised the damage on your car is so minor.

theworldsgonefeckingmad · 13/01/2022 14:03

I was hit in the back of my car by a new driver a few years ago, I put in a claim for whiplash, car got repaired (it was badly damaged) and even though it wasn't my fault you have to declare any accidents regardless of fault for 5/6 years o think it is and my premiums rose by over £100 a year, if the damage isn't bad to your car and you don't have severe whiplash I would think again about going through insurance and personally I wouldn't claim again

BlueSky8 · 13/01/2022 14:02

You pay for insurance so use it.
She won't she sitting feeling sorry for you.