Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what a 'good' pension is?

92 replies

2birdsonawire · 13/01/2022 12:28

What is considered 'good' as a pension contribution from you and your employer percentage wise?

I know this will be pro rata on a salary basis, just want to see if what I get is good or if I should look at other saving schemes.

Thanks Grin

OP posts:
11inch · 13/01/2022 16:40

I was always under the impression with civil service pensions (not so much Local Authority) that there was no pot as such that pensioners were paid out of general taxation. The employer and employee contributions are also going straight into taxation. That might have changed now.

Pensionable age of Alpha - the 2.32% of salary a year one described above - is state pension age. The old scheme was 60. Can be taken earlier with reductions.

RandomLondoner · 13/01/2022 16:36

That's a DC pension, and for may years DW contributed closer to 50%.

MasterBeth · 13/01/2022 16:36

@Biker47

I get it matched upto 10% which for majority of people now is probably standard practice.
Ha ha!
RandomLondoner · 13/01/2022 16:35

DW employer contributes a 6%, plus another 6% if you match it, which you obviously should. So at a minimum, she has sacrificed 6% of her salary and gets 18% total pension contributions.

Mushrooms0up · 13/01/2022 16:35

Ok now it’s defined benefit it’s completely different, the amount contributed is irrelevant.

You won’t get a pot but a right to an annual payment each year which is based on your salary and how long you’ve worked there. If you contribute more you will in effect be increasing the annual amount you’re entitled to.

FindingMeno · 13/01/2022 16:32

27% Shock

BillMasen · 13/01/2022 16:29

[quote BELLAARA]@BillMasen TY for response.

It is a defined benefit scheme, but career average rather than final salary. And the pot in built up with a % (2.32) of annual pensionable earnings.

But myself and my employer do contribute 5-odd and 27-odd %, each month.

I am booked to see a financial adviser as I can't quite get my head around it.[/quote]
Don’t think of it as the pot building up, but your right to an annual pension building up. Your annual pension goes up by 2% of your salary each year but you get that every single year for the rest of your life.

BELLAARA · 13/01/2022 16:20

@BillMasen TY for response.

It is a defined benefit scheme, but career average rather than final salary. And the pot in built up with a % (2.32) of annual pensionable earnings.

But myself and my employer do contribute 5-odd and 27-odd %, each month.

I am booked to see a financial adviser as I can't quite get my head around it.

BillMasen · 13/01/2022 16:19

I think what you’re referring to is that for every year you work here you “earn” an annual pension equivalent to 2% of your salary

Let’s say as an example you earn 50k
You work there 1 year, you retire with a pension of 1k per year
2 years and your pension is 2k per year
30 years and it’s 30k per year

That 1k is an annual pension for the rest of your life so let’s say you live 25th ads after tutoring. That 1k is worth 25k to you and costs the employer 25k to provide for you, hence te big employer cost

If you’ve been there 30 years your pension is “worth” £750k ish, so very valuable and very expensivr

PattyPan · 13/01/2022 16:17

I think anything above about 4% from your employer is good so 27% is fantastic! The half your age rule of thumb is quite good as well. I recently read that it’s good to get have 2x your salary in your pot by your mid-30s but that seems very high. It is better to contribute more earlier though so you can maximise the benefit of compounding.

BillMasen · 13/01/2022 16:06

@BELLAARA

My public sector scheme, while generous, may have myself paying in 5.45% and my employer somewhere between 27.1%, but that doesn't mean all those contributions go into my pension pot.

The pot is filled by 2.3% of annual pensionable earnings (on a career average basis). I can only assume the other 30.23% contributed goes on scheme administration and ensuring funds for all members?

If you have a defined contribution scheme then it will all be going into your pot

If you have a defined benefits scheme you have a guaranteed pension based on years of service and final salary (usually) and the employer has to contribute whatever it costs them to provide this

There’s no scenario where they pay 27% but your pot only sees 2%.

BELLAARA · 13/01/2022 16:00

My public sector scheme, while generous, may have myself paying in 5.45% and my employer somewhere between 27.1%, but that doesn't mean all those contributions go into my pension pot.

The pot is filled by 2.3% of annual pensionable earnings (on a career average basis). I can only assume the other 30.23% contributed goes on scheme administration and ensuring funds for all members?

PiffleWiffleWoozle · 13/01/2022 15:14

To work out if you want extra savings you need to work backwards from retirement.

How much would be a ‘good’ amount for you to live on annually in retirement?

Is your current pension and contribution going to get you there?

If not what is the gap?

SpiderinaWingMirror · 13/01/2022 15:14

Ofgs. You don't have an issue.

Dogsandbabies · 13/01/2022 15:11

Civil service pension contributions and private are not comparable. I'm the CS the employer contributes more but the pot does not get invested so there is no growth.

NotVictorianHonestly · 13/01/2022 15:10

If you're public sector is that a defined benefit pension scheme? If so you're comparing apples with pears by going off the contribution rates people are posting above which are largely for defined contribution scheme

AwayW0rldExit4 · 13/01/2022 15:10

I contribute myself, ontop of the 3%

AwayW0rldExit4 · 13/01/2022 15:08

The maximum my employer contributes is 3%

I have received better contributions from previous employers

Also includes death in service

nonevernotever · 13/01/2022 15:08

A public sector pensioner with a 30k pension probably isn’t unusual under a final salary scheme. For someone else with a contribution scheme to get that they’d need a pot of a million pounds! Totally unachievable for most people.

The vast majority of public sector pensions are no where near that! The following figures are from a UK parliament research briefing in 2021 and are for the average pension in 2019-20 for the four largest PAYG public service pension : schemes. Armed forces £9779; civil service £8104; NHS £9709 teachers £12337

Lipsandlashes · 13/01/2022 15:05

Mine is public sector. I pay 6.8 percent and my employer pays 16.2 - I consider that extremely good

ThreeLittleDots · 13/01/2022 15:05

Oh, so this was a boast Sad

Totalwasteofpaper · 13/01/2022 15:04

@Jizzle

OP, i say this in the nicest way possible, what you have is very, very unusual.

Perhaps not in the public sector, but for the majority of private sector workers (outside of perhaps finance and a few others) you will be lucky if the emplyer pays much above the 3% minimum. Mine pays 4% which i top up with 12% from myself.

The general 'rule' for pensions is you should try and put in half of your age when you start contributing, so if you start your pension at 30 you should aim to put in 15% total.

I am aiming to be able to draw down about 3/4% once i retire, that way the principal should never run out. I think i would want about £30,000 per year in retirement, meaning i need a pension pot of about £900-£1mill

this in spades.

you have a good pension so you can relax...

BillMasen · 13/01/2022 15:02

@BarbaraofSeville

A public sector pensioner with a 30k pension probably isn’t unusual under a final salary scheme. For someone else with a contribution scheme to get that they’d need a pot of a million pounds! Totally unachievable for most people

But only a minority of public sector pensioners would have a 30k pension. You'd have to be on a salary of 50/60k to end up with a pension that size and have had 40+ years of service. Most don't earn anywhere near that amount or have that length of service so actual pensions are usually much smaller.

Someone in the private sector on 50 will have nowhere near a million pound pot on retirement. Lucky to have half that
BarbaraofSeville · 13/01/2022 15:00

A public sector pensioner with a 30k pension probably isn’t unusual under a final salary scheme. For someone else with a contribution scheme to get that they’d need a pot of a million pounds! Totally unachievable for most people

But only a minority of public sector pensioners would have a 30k pension. You'd have to be on a salary of 50/60k to end up with a pension that size and have had 40+ years of service. Most don't earn anywhere near that amount or have that length of service so actual pensions are usually much smaller.

MorningStarling · 13/01/2022 14:57

It's things like public sector workers wondering if a 27% employer contribution is good or not that makes workers in the private sector not be too pissed off when there's a public sector pay freeze.

Jesus, 27%? Sure you're not missing a decimal point?