Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what a 'good' pension is?

92 replies

2birdsonawire · 13/01/2022 12:28

What is considered 'good' as a pension contribution from you and your employer percentage wise?

I know this will be pro rata on a salary basis, just want to see if what I get is good or if I should look at other saving schemes.

Thanks Grin

OP posts:
PattyPan · 13/01/2022 18:03

Not all public sector pensions are as amazing as that. Mine they contribute 8% which is good tbf but they don’t do any matching for under 40s which is so stupid. I’m currently contributing 6% on top.

FrownedUpon · 13/01/2022 17:59

@DrMadelineMaxwell

It makes me very grateful for my teacher pension. I put in 9.8% and my employer puts in 23.68%. I also choose to put away 5% in an AVC to make up for the years I was part time. DHs work pension is him paying 10% and his employer 5%. Luckiou he started a (small) private pension early in his career too.
Your employers contribution is actually irrelevant though & has no impact on the amount you’ll receive in retirement.
fufulina · 13/01/2022 17:58

10% from your employer is not the norm at all. The public sector unbelievably amazing pension skews what people think is normal.

Mia85 · 13/01/2022 17:58

Titchy has explained it well plus there are death in service/ill health benefits that you hopefully won't need but could be incredibly valuable if you do.

Essentially it is one of the best schemes you could be in. It would cost you hundreds of thousands to replicate the advantages in titchy's example yourself.

You would essentially be taking a huge paycut if you didn't join.

Unescorted · 13/01/2022 17:58

Extra holiday, longer maternity do not increase the amount in a pension pot. They are benefits but don't increase the amount payable.

FrownedUpon · 13/01/2022 17:56

Contribution rate is irrelevant for a defined benefit pension like yours. You’re not building up a pot. You’re building up a guaranteed yearly payment for life & it’s based on your salary and number of years worked.

You can basically just ignore the 27% as it means nothing in regard to the amount you’ll receive at retirement.

11inch · 13/01/2022 17:48

@titchy plus CPI adjustment each year. Compound interest element.

titchy · 13/01/2022 17:46

Basically the alpha is the defined benefit civil service scheme. Your pension will NOT be based on contributions, it will be based on your average salary throughout your career whilst at civil service and the number of full time equivalent years you work. Every year of work gets you 2.3% of your salary guaranteed when you retire.

So if you work for 20 years averaging £25,000 a year, your pension will be 2.3% x 25,000 x 20 = £11,500 a year.

dafey · 13/01/2022 17:45

You also have to take into account that public sector wages are lower than comparable jobs in the private sector. So although the % may seem generous the amount is not so different.

i'm not sure that's true. I'm in the public sector. Plus the maternity, holiday & sick pay is far better.

11inch · 13/01/2022 17:41

@2birdsonawire
See if you can sign up for a Pension Power seminar. They are helpful at de-mystimifying the terms.

Unescorted · 13/01/2022 17:41

There are so many public sector pensions so it is unfair to say that pay freezes across the board are reasonable.

You also have to take into account that public sector wages are lower than comparable jobs in the private sector. So although the % may seem generous the amount is not so different.

ProudDada · 13/01/2022 17:37

My friends employer triples your contributions up to 6%. So you pay 6% they pay 18%.

dafey · 13/01/2022 17:35

But only a minority of public sector pensioners would have a 30k pension. You'd have to be on a salary of 50/60k to end up with a pension that size and have had 40+ years of service. Most don't earn anywhere near that amount or have that length of service so actual pensions are usually much smaller.

I'm not sure that's right. The people I work with who earn 60k have much better pensions than 30k a year.

DrMadelineMaxwell · 13/01/2022 17:31

It makes me very grateful for my teacher pension. I put in 9.8% and my employer puts in 23.68%. I also choose to put away 5% in an AVC to make up for the years I was part time.
DHs work pension is him paying 10% and his employer 5%. Luckiou he started a (small) private pension early in his career too.

dafey · 13/01/2022 17:31

It depends what age you are someone who is a public sector worker in their 60s will have a very different view of what is good compared to a 20 yr old!

BELLAARA · 13/01/2022 17:26

Grateful to all the helpful comments on here, especially @BillMasen.
OP don't apologise, if you can't get your head around it by doing your own reading, then this is a forum to ask for the thoughts of others. Just accept that you will get degrees of what you're after.

2birdsonawire · 13/01/2022 17:26

@titchy thank you, I'm going to have a look in to it, I just took everything at face value so glad I asked.

@Mia85 the scheme is called Alpha but there's also partnership but I didn't go with that one.

OP posts:
WildRunner · 13/01/2022 17:19

If you're just trying to choose between whether a pension or an ISA is better, bear in mind the following two things:

  1. You get tax relief on your contributions to a pension, not on an ISA
  2. Your employer won't pay 27% of your salary into an ISA
Mia85 · 13/01/2022 17:09

What's the scheme OP? We can point you to things to help you to understand it but you should talk to your pensions administrator at work if you aren't sure.

titchy · 13/01/2022 17:08

@2birdsonawire

Sorry to offend anyone, I wasn't here to gloat or anything. I was trying to weigh up wether I should be putting more in to my pension or to set up an ISA to save for when I am at retirement age.

I'm in my very early 20's, never had a pension, never been taught about pensions, I don't even really know what a pension is cause I have never been taught. The only thing I have heard about pensions is that you can have a final salary pension but that's a very uncommon thing nowadays.

Sorry to offend I really didn't mean to

Learn about the one you have. The contributions you/your employer make are irrelevant to what you'll get.
2birdsonawire · 13/01/2022 17:01

Sorry to offend anyone, I wasn't here to gloat or anything. I was trying to weigh up wether I should be putting more in to my pension or to set up an ISA to save for when I am at retirement age.

I'm in my very early 20's, never had a pension, never been taught about pensions, I don't even really know what a pension is cause I have never been taught. The only thing I have heard about pensions is that you can have a final salary pension but that's a very uncommon thing nowadays.

Sorry to offend I really didn't mean to

OP posts:
2birdsonawire · 13/01/2022 16:55

@ThreeLittleDots

Oh, so this was a boast Sad
Not at all to boast, I'm sorry I'm new to the public sector and was never taught about pensions before, I got a document from my employer to choose one of 2 pensions and to be honest none of it makes sense. And never having a pension before I thought that was the going rate. I don't mean to hurt your feelings at all, I have never had a pension before so I'm very new to this, I'm sorry hope you're okay SadThanks
OP posts:
titchy · 13/01/2022 16:45

So whether you should look at other savings schemes will rather depend on your salary and how many full time equivalent years of service you'll have.

titchy · 13/01/2022 16:43

@Mia85

I assume that you're on a defined benefit pension scheme? If that's the case the percentages aren't really comparable to people contributing to a defined contribution scheme. What matters for you is the level of benefit that you get from the scheme.
This. Rather than gloat about your contributions maybe take the time to understand the basis your pension will be worked out on.
Evanesco · 13/01/2022 16:42

Wow 27%!

My total is 8% and that is 5% from me and a measly 3% from my employer... I had a period of anxiety about money recently and this is one of the things I was worrying about one night. I shouldn't have opened this thread Grin