Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be depressed that my children are unlikely to own a nice house?

188 replies

contributory · 13/01/2022 12:06

Both my kids did really well at school and have ended up on good salaries. But despite this, they will probably never own a nice house.

They are fortunate that they can afford to get on the property ladder, as a lot can't. But I can't help but feel depressed that they work so hard and such long hours, for a fairly modest life style.

If I compare against my parents (one of whom did the same job as dd), when they were in their late 20s they could afford to buy a nice detached house and send me and my siblings away to school. We always had good quality clothes, nice furnishings in the house, holidays abroad etc.

But now, my kids work longer hours, are (on paper) more successful than my parents or me (a teacher) but get so much less. Rather than a nice detached house in a good area, my kids are stuck in tiny one-two bed flats with enormous mortgages.

OP posts:
Porcupineintherough · 13/01/2022 16:44

The tragedy of not being able to buy a nice detached house in your 20s. The shame of being semi-detached. Hmm

BasketBlocks · 13/01/2022 16:43

We both have professional jobs and a combined salary of about £100k but the house we live in is an terraced Victorian workers cottage. High ceilings but that’s the only thing big about it Grin. Postage stamp gardens to front and back.

Having said that, we made the decision to buy the worst house in the best area, mainly for schools and amenities. We could easily afford somewhere bigger elsewhere but have compromised space for other things.

Embracelife · 13/01/2022 16:43

[quote Lipsandlashes]@Embracelife every single one of us on the property ladder has benefited from huge increases in property. Don't be so hypocritical.[/quote]
The time period when prices Increased so much has gone
Somebody buying one bed now for 300k in London
Can't expect doubling in price to 600k can they?
Maybe up by 50k in five years ???
While the terrace is now at 1.5 million so the jump to next step is unfeasible

Hemingwayzcatz · 13/01/2022 16:41

Obviously depends massively on location. We live in Yorkshire and own a 5 bed detached house but in the city where we’re from we could only afford either a nice apartment or a house in a terrible area for the price we paid for this (rural village). We’re both professionals on decent salaries, it’s just the way it goes in this country. Much more for your money in the countryside in general and definitely more up north to down south.

Lipsandlashes · 13/01/2022 16:40

And @Lipsandlashes I have definitely so far lost from having been on the property value after having a flat that has decreased in value by 100% and once the cladding issues are fixed I’m hoping to sell for maybe 60% of what I bought it for. Hoping the house fares better!!
Sorry to hear that. The cladding scandal has been abhorrent for so many reasons.

5128gap · 13/01/2022 16:37

Its a bit early in their lives to decide they will never own a nice house. You must be about my age if you have adult DC, so you will no doubt have experienced the ups and downs of the housing market, interests rates going up to 15%, recessions that make 'jobs for life' redundant, new industies that make people very well off, bad areas becoming desirable and vice versa. There's no doubt things are tough now, but its impossible to tell what the future will bring. Perhaps in ten years we may even be over our obsession with property ownership, and seeing our homes as an investment, and just be fine with somewhere to live and a good life and experiences outside of our houses.

prsphne · 13/01/2022 16:34

I’m not sure I quite believe that they won’t be able to buy a nice house. Husband and I are on relatively good salaries, not the MN six figure earner type though, and have a three bed detached with biggish garden that we’ve renovated (cosmetically).

We are up north, but this was after buying a cladding-scandal flat too that we’ve had to keep and rent out as we can’t sell it.

We’ve done this without family help, saving 15% deposit for the flat then 5% deposit for the house (plus exorbitant stamp duty for a second property).

It did mean cutting back a bit so that we could save but it’s definitely been achievable and we haven’t lived miserly lives to get here.

And @Lipsandlashes I have definitely so far lost from having been on the property value after having a flat that has decreased in value by 100% and once the cladding issues are fixed I’m hoping to sell for maybe 60% of what I bought it for. Hoping the house fares better!!

Lipsandlashes · 13/01/2022 16:26

@Embracelife every single one of us on the property ladder has benefited from huge increases in property. Don't be so hypocritical.

Onionpatch · 13/01/2022 16:24

I think the idea of a ladder only works when wages are rising too - otherwise your grotty flat goes up in value as does the nice mid terrace by the same percent so you need to have progressed your career which in many jobs isnt possible quickly or had general wage inflation over a few years, as you now have a bigger deposit but also need a bigger loan.

StoneofDestiny · 13/01/2022 16:15

In some countries home ownership isn't the 'gold standard' it's become in the UK and they seem to enjoy a good standard of living. Germany 50% approx - UK 64% approx.
Sounds like your children are ok if they already are on the property market and your parents did well for their age. My parents never owned a house, I do. I never benefitted from inheriting their property, hopefully mine will get some benefit from mine.

Embracelife · 13/01/2022 16:13

"Sold for huge profit"
"Made lots of lovely equity"
"Bought detached "

It was luck not design

BiscuitLover3678 · 13/01/2022 16:12

As an example, someone working in finance with a very high salary would have bought a nice house in London. Someone with that same job and same high wage percentage now, would be affording a flat or a nice terrace/semi if lucky in a commuter town.

PattyPan · 13/01/2022 16:11

I voted YABU. YWNBU to complain if they couldn’t get on the ladder at all but surely they just do their places up and gradually work up the ladder? Expecting to buy a detached house straight away is U.

godmum56 · 13/01/2022 16:10

@contributory

Both my kids did really well at school and have ended up on good salaries. But despite this, they will probably never own a nice house.

They are fortunate that they can afford to get on the property ladder, as a lot can't. But I can't help but feel depressed that they work so hard and such long hours, for a fairly modest life style.

If I compare against my parents (one of whom did the same job as dd), when they were in their late 20s they could afford to buy a nice detached house and send me and my siblings away to school. We always had good quality clothes, nice furnishings in the house, holidays abroad etc.

But now, my kids work longer hours, are (on paper) more successful than my parents or me (a teacher) but get so much less. Rather than a nice detached house in a good area, my kids are stuck in tiny one-two bed flats with enormous mortgages.

define modest lifestyle? holidays? mobile phones? nights out? takeaways?
Embracelife · 13/01/2022 16:10

@Lipsandlashes

But surely your children are on the first rung of the property ladder (aptly named!) - It's supposed to be shit! DH and I bought a one bed flat in a rough part of London when we were 24. Lived there for 5 years and sold it for a profit. Then we moved to a 3 bed terrace just outside of London. We've been here for 12 years and made a lot of equity on that. This year we will be moving to a lovely big 4 bed detached, a little bit further out still - hopefully we won't be moving again. None of that would have been possible if we didn't start out in our 'grotty' little one-bed.
And you benefitted from huge increase in price rises. If price rises continued to increase at the same rate No one can buy the grotty one bed Unless giovt scheme like htb Which just perpetuates the problem
BiscuitLover3678 · 13/01/2022 16:10

It’s unreal. People with very average jobs would get big houses on interest only mortgages (which they are now not paying back, btw!), having loads of kids and just living a certain life. Now people are working their socks off and will get a lot less. Also why people are having fewer children and later on in life.

It is a shame but there are also some benefits to living now. Don’t be sad op, their lives are different but not terrible by any means! There are actually a lot of improvements too.

YukoandHiro · 13/01/2022 16:08

@ilovesooty Well I was going to say that the government should make some enormous effort to incentivise downsizing earlier, perhaps by reducing inheritance tax for descendants in return. It was save the NHS an enormous amount. So many issues with elderly care begin with unfit and impractical housing.

What were you thinking...?

Lockheart · 13/01/2022 16:05

@onedayoranother

Yea but back in the day we didn't have expenses like mobile phones, pay for TV like Sky, broadband and eating out was a once in a blue moon treat. Takeaway coffee was unheard of. Several of my friends and family didn't have central heating and Christmas was one main and a couple small gifts. And we were upper middle class. So yes nice house (in Chelsea!!!!) but other than that was our 'lifestyle' better? We had one car and walked mostly. Holidays were to relatives or self catering by the sea. I'm pretty sure your grown kids have phones and computers and at least one TV, kindles and iPods etc. washing machine and dishwasher maybe? Go out at least once a week? Holiday abroad? My parents bought for the first time in their mid 30s, yes a nice house but two incomes and a mortgage even then (60s). And without the above mentioned luxuries.
Oh good, the Daily Mail is leaking again.

I have a good salary, but I can't afford to buy a home within a reasonable distance of my work. Not even a 1-bedroom flat. I am in my 30s and live in a single room in a houseshare because I want to try to save to buy, but even with that I would still need to double the deposit I have (which is not small) to be able to buy and still be able to afford the season rail ticket to work, which is the rub. Those things are thousands of pounds. So unless I suddenly find a rich fiancé / husband, win the lottery, or inherit tens of thousands of pounds, it's not happening.

And to counter a few things:

  • I don't own a car. Or a bike, for that matter.
  • I don't like coffee, and I refuse to buy tea when I get it for free at work.
  • Not a huge fan of avocados either, since I know some idiot will trot that one out.
  • I haven't been on holiday since 2018. I don't have one planned this year.
  • I don't go out to eat except on special occasions, and I'm not really a massive going out person anyway.
  • I don't own a kindle or an iPod or a camera.
  • I do have a laptop which is 7 years old now.
  • I don't have Sky. I do have Netflix but at £10 per month I'd need to wait for 1,000 months to save £10k. So I feel like £10 a month isn't particularly luxurious and isn't what's stopping me being able to buy a home.
  • I have a very basic phone contract. Again, £20 a month isn't going to buy me a flat.
  • The washing machine came with the house we rent, but perhaps I should ask my landlord to take it away.

The problem is not young people being profligate, the problem is the hugely overheated asset market and the decades of stagnating wages.

Lipsandlashes · 13/01/2022 16:03

@Glitterygreen Yes, you're right. Although my DH had managed to save a big chunk of deposit by not going to uni (he did professional accounting qualifications instead) and living with his parents until we moved in together. So there was still quite a lot of sacrifice on his part.

Roosk · 13/01/2022 16:02

[quote Roosk]@Fauxpains, you put it on and rolled it up so that the bottom edge was above the water level when you sat in the bath and washed your lower body. Then you took it off, and washed the rest of you extremely quickly and jumped out again — these were not lingering baths![/quote]
I should say that this was a flat attached to one of the grander Oxford colleges. Grin (Whose washing arrangements were still primitive in places — there was an undergraduate staircase that didn’t have any bath or shower at all, so you would see people crossing the quad in dressing gowns with towels and shampoo to use the next nearest ones…)

Onionpatch · 13/01/2022 16:01

I think the big picture is wages have stagnated, employment contracts are 'worse' in that many jobs that used to be a proper contract are now zero hours and for 6 months at a time, entry qualifications are higher, studying is expensive and house prices dont relate yo earnings in much of the counrty although this is regional.
So generally things are a bit rubbish for people twenty years younger than me, even if many an individual is doing just fine.

ilovesooty · 13/01/2022 16:01

@YukoandHiro

Have to say OP, you've highlighted part of the problem. Asset hoarding of large properties and refusing to downsize by older people causes inflation lower down in the market due to a lack of suitable stock, and entrenches wealth disparities - as well as being morally wrong, and often impractical in lifestyle terms leading to earlier hospital admission and even death among those who insist on staying in a property unsuited to their needs.
You can see where this thread is heading... 🙄
Roosk · 13/01/2022 15:57

@Fauxpains, you put it on and rolled it up so that the bottom edge was above the water level when you sat in the bath and washed your lower body. Then you took it off, and washed the rest of you extremely quickly and jumped out again — these were not lingering baths!

Glitterygreen · 13/01/2022 15:56

@Lipsandlashes

But surely your children are on the first rung of the property ladder (aptly named!) - It's supposed to be shit! DH and I bought a one bed flat in a rough part of London when we were 24. Lived there for 5 years and sold it for a profit. Then we moved to a 3 bed terrace just outside of London. We've been here for 12 years and made a lot of equity on that. This year we will be moving to a lovely big 4 bed detached, a little bit further out still - hopefully we won't be moving again. None of that would have been possible if we didn't start out in our 'grotty' little one-bed.
To be fair though, not many can achieve this at 24 now. Which is a key factor in making it harder as people are starting families in their 'grotty' little one beds as they're already in their 30s by the time they can buy it.

And then it's harder to move up because there is either a part-time worker or childcare costs factored in.

Fauxpains · 13/01/2022 15:51

@Roosk

Don’t assume your criteria for ‘success’ is theirs. In my late 20s I was a postgraduate student, living on fresh air and small change, in a flat so cold I used to take baths wearing a jumper. My parents, despite being poor themselves, thought it was terrible I wasn’t married with a ‘nice house’. I was having the time of my life.
How did this work? Didn’t the jumpers get wet?