Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be depressed that my children are unlikely to own a nice house?

188 replies

contributory · 13/01/2022 12:06

Both my kids did really well at school and have ended up on good salaries. But despite this, they will probably never own a nice house.

They are fortunate that they can afford to get on the property ladder, as a lot can't. But I can't help but feel depressed that they work so hard and such long hours, for a fairly modest life style.

If I compare against my parents (one of whom did the same job as dd), when they were in their late 20s they could afford to buy a nice detached house and send me and my siblings away to school. We always had good quality clothes, nice furnishings in the house, holidays abroad etc.

But now, my kids work longer hours, are (on paper) more successful than my parents or me (a teacher) but get so much less. Rather than a nice detached house in a good area, my kids are stuck in tiny one-two bed flats with enormous mortgages.

OP posts:
amijustparanoidorjuststoned · 14/01/2022 08:29

A lot of bitter Belindas on this thread! It's not a race to the bottom, you know.

As one PP pointed out, of course it is reasonable to feel sad that it seems to just be accepted that we just have to accept poor standards of living and a worse quality of life due to rising inflation and the like.

I know MN hates when this is brought up but remember that doctors/accountants/wealthy famous people on good salaries quite often have to house share in London, which would have been unheard of back in the OP's mum's day. It isn't unreasonable to want your own space and to be paid a decent wage to cover said cost of living.

For balance though, the only thing YAB slightly U about is the description of a "nice" house. Not that a detached house isn't nice, but a nice house is in the eye of the beholder... if that makes sense Grin I'd have killed to have my own flat in my early 20s.

OP, I wish your children the best of luck with their careers and hope things improve for them Cake

Emerald5hamrock · 14/01/2022 08:23

I'm in my 40's too.
It has always been difficult for people buying on a single wage.
A working couple with decent jobs could definitely afford a decent home after some cheaper start up homes.

oatmilk4breakfast · 14/01/2022 08:17

There’s no ladder anymore.

Onionpatch · 14/01/2022 07:54

I am the older generation at mid 40s so im not jealous. I Just think its harder for someone buying their first home now in the south east and I dont think not having a phone or internet would work as so many people use them for work itself.

Emerald5hamrock · 14/01/2022 07:50

There is a lot of investors interest in Ireland it is impossible to bid against them they've a money pit. I wouldn't mind if they were inland investors however they're a Canadian pension fund whipping every 1 to 4 bedroom off the market, they are tax free.

Emerald5hamrock · 14/01/2022 07:41

Life is forever changing, they need to buy lucky which is an unlucky time for most.
I suspect there'll be a recession shortly behind covid, businesses will close, house prices will crash.
My Dbro had the same job as my Father, we were poor as DC dad's wage covered our mortgage in a shit area.
Dbro is a millionaire, he bought his first home from 100,000 sold it for 300,000 during boom.
Dsis made money this way too.
They'll get there.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 14/01/2022 07:39

There is a lot of jealousy towards the older generation on here.

But would those of you who don’t have nice houses give up your phones and the internet to have one? And, if you discover a lump in your abdomen, the choice would be watchful waiting or ‘exploratory’ surgery (few scans).

Large detached houses in good areas are expensive now but successful professionals (especially with two working parents) would certainly afford a decent house.

Your children children, in particular, are very lucky, with potential large inheritances to come from the money locked up in two properties (yours and your parents).

Soontobe60 · 14/01/2022 07:37

I went to my grandchild’s 3rd birthday party this summer, at his home. All the guests drove fancy cars, most live in really nice houses and are clearly better off than I ever was. (i too am a teacher).
My daughters both have highly paid jobs, the eldest (34) has just bought a stunning house worth around £1m, the youngest (25) has also bought a lovely house worth double my house!
I think it’s very much dependent on location tbh. If you live in London, then I guess house prices are off the scale. If you live elsewhere, not so much. In today’s Times, there’s an article about this very thing - living in Manchester
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/why-everyone-under-30-is-moving-to-manchester-sqmgxwc0v?shareToken=655ce7bae203484e8002f35885355ae8

dafey · 14/01/2022 07:36

Yea but back in the day we didn't have expenses like mobile phones, pay for TV like Sky, broadband and eating out was a once in a blue moon treat. Takeaway coffee was unheard of.

🙄

dafey · 14/01/2022 07:33

What makes you think it's ever been different.

statistics

Mountaingoat12 · 14/01/2022 07:30

But when young people are buying somewhere cheaper / less fun / above a kebab shop they are making compromises the likes of me didn’t have to make at the same age, and yet they have to listen to the older generation who have no comprehension of an economic picture that has shifted so far against the young coming out with unintelligent comments like:

Well just don’t eat anything but lentils for 10 years.
But it’s your fault for buying a beer once a month
Lattes
Sky
Avocados

Life is much harder. I’m surprised the young are not much more resentful than they are.

grey12 · 14/01/2022 07:28

@Crowdfundingforcake

Grey12, I'm guessing op's kids are in their twenties - starter home territory, not 4 bed detached family home territory. When we were selling our last place the estate agent we used suggested our 3 bed townhouse was just the thing for a first time buyer. I suggested maybe first time buyers would be looking for a 1/2 bed flat but EA said they were usually looking for minimum 3 bed new builds.

Where we are, you can buy a nice 2 bed flat with modern kitchen and bathroom for £75k, but first time buyers don't want them, so they are bought by BTL landlords.

It seems to me that nowadays a lot of first time buyers are older than 20s 🤷🏻‍♀️ and starting a family.... at least that is the case with me and the greatest majority of people I know
Onionpatch · 14/01/2022 07:22

Lots of people have moved to cheaper areas due to being able to work from home. There are some areas that rose by 30% as a result which probably means locals are struggling now. Its a really good for solution for some peoole but not all.
We need an economic strategy that doesnt centre on London so much.

I also agree a nice house doesnt mean 4 bed detached - but i do think there are areas that are more suitable for different points of your life. It might be ok living above a busy kebab shop as a young person on your way up. It might be quite depressing trying to settle a baby to the sound of drunks fighting over the kebab at 2am.

MrPickles73 · 14/01/2022 06:22

Move out of the SE to a cheaper area?

ufucoffee · 14/01/2022 06:10

@Mountaingoat12

I have sent how much harder it has got in the 20 years I have been working.

Bought our first place with my husband a few years out of uni in 2003 a 2 bed flat for £150k, (deposit was £10k). Both had graduate trainee jobs paying roughly £20k each. The same flat sold in May 2021 for £435k. The graduate jobs would now pay £25k and £30k. The price of the flat has gone up nearly three fold. The salaries have risen 50%, moving an ok flat wholly out of reach of two hardworking graduates with no parental help.

If young people study hard for many years at school and uni to get good jobs only to find rewards for that hard work have been moved out of reach, they are going to wonder whether all of that work was worth it. It is not a fair way to run a society.

Yes, that flat would be but those young people would buy somewhere where housing is cheaper now. They can still buy a property.
VoiceOfCommonSense · 14/01/2022 02:50

Anyone can get a nice house if they are prepared to work for it. I saved and scraped to buy my first house, did it up and sold it, then did the same again. I've had 4 friends that bought a house together and did the same, now they all have 3 or 4 houses each they rent out. None of us had any money from our parents or high paying jobs. We did it all ourselves. Anything is possible, you just need to work for it and if that means sacraficing things like nights out or holidays then thats what you have to do.

Mountaingoat12 · 14/01/2022 01:59

I have sent how much harder it has got in the 20 years I have been working.

Bought our first place with my husband a few years out of uni in 2003 a 2 bed flat for £150k, (deposit was £10k). Both had graduate trainee jobs paying roughly £20k each. The same flat sold in May 2021 for £435k. The graduate jobs would now pay £25k and £30k. The price of the flat has gone up nearly three fold. The salaries have risen 50%, moving an ok flat wholly out of reach of two hardworking graduates with no parental help.

If young people study hard for many years at school and uni to get good jobs only to find rewards for that hard work have been moved out of reach, they are going to wonder whether all of that work was worth it. It is not a fair way to run a society.

wishingitwasspring · 13/01/2022 23:03

And moving to a 'nice house' nicer than our bog standard pre war semi never crossed our minds. It was just normal for us

wishingitwasspring · 13/01/2022 22:59

What makes you think it's ever been different.

I married early 80s. I was a registered health professional, DH a qualified tradesperson. He worked ft, often 6days to manage to pay the mortgage. I worked night shifts with no childcare (free childcare hadn't been invented, I just stayed awake). We had no spare money. I recall my parents were no different.

40 years on we've done the hard bit and live a frugal retirement.

It's about expectations IMO.

RobertaFirmino · 13/01/2022 22:44

Why is a 'nice house' in a 'good area' the be all and end all? I can think of plenty of things which are far more important.

Will your DC have enough food on the table?
Will they have somewhere to live which is affordable, secure and warm?
Will they have the privilege of good health (mental and physical)?
Will they have a loving, supportive partner (assuming they want one, of course)?
Will they be able to spend time doing things they enjoy?
Will they have enough money to make ends meet?

No house in the world can compensate for these things.

Roominmyhouse · 13/01/2022 22:38

Oh are only detached houses nice then? I didn’t realise. I have a lovely two bedroom end of terrace, I didn’t realise it wasn’t nice as it’s not big or detached! Silly me.

Not everyone’s goal in life is to have a huge detached house. If your children have flats now, they probably won’t live in them forever but if they do that’s up to them!

Crowdfundingforcake · 13/01/2022 22:34

Grey12, I'm guessing op's kids are in their twenties - starter home territory, not 4 bed detached family home territory. When we were selling our last place the estate agent we used suggested our 3 bed townhouse was just the thing for a first time buyer. I suggested maybe first time buyers would be looking for a 1/2 bed flat but EA said they were usually looking for minimum 3 bed new builds.

Where we are, you can buy a nice 2 bed flat with modern kitchen and bathroom for £75k, but first time buyers don't want them, so they are bought by BTL landlords.

Swonderful · 13/01/2022 22:31

@Mushrooms0up

Why are the above posters so negative?! It’s not a race as to who has it worse.

Why do we all just accept such a decline in living standards whilst billionaires get ever richer.

OP you are not unreasonable at all. It’s all driven by the stock market that all the money from companies goes to shareholders rather than being reinvested, and giant corporations hoovering up property as assets.

It’s a crime it’s been allowed to happen and the decline and gap between rich and poor is only getting worse. (And by rich I don’t mean doctors / accountants). The person down the road earning £50k - £100k is not the issue. I mean shareholders and large business owners.

The shareholders are all of us with pensions, so not the mega rich but ordinary people.
DroopyClematis · 13/01/2022 22:18

It's really difficult to see your offspring struggling when they are working so hard and in great jobs but can't afford to buy.

Though I've been on a thread today where a 22 year old can't understand why her mates can't afford to buy a home like she has .. in Wales.

Made my blood boil.

VestaTilley · 13/01/2022 22:11

Yabu. How old are they?

If they move to slightly cheaper areas, build up equity in their flats and/or get partners who earn similar salaries they’ll definitely be able to trade up.

Will they be able to buy in Knightsbridge? No, but nowadays only Russian and Arab billionaires can. But will they be able to buy a detached or semi in less fashionable bits of the south east? Yes, absolutely.