Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be depressed that my children are unlikely to own a nice house?

188 replies

contributory · 13/01/2022 12:06

Both my kids did really well at school and have ended up on good salaries. But despite this, they will probably never own a nice house.

They are fortunate that they can afford to get on the property ladder, as a lot can't. But I can't help but feel depressed that they work so hard and such long hours, for a fairly modest life style.

If I compare against my parents (one of whom did the same job as dd), when they were in their late 20s they could afford to buy a nice detached house and send me and my siblings away to school. We always had good quality clothes, nice furnishings in the house, holidays abroad etc.

But now, my kids work longer hours, are (on paper) more successful than my parents or me (a teacher) but get so much less. Rather than a nice detached house in a good area, my kids are stuck in tiny one-two bed flats with enormous mortgages.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
baroqueandblue · 14/01/2022 13:48

On reflection, I agree that OP is exaggerating her own children's 'plight' somewhat, and needs to reexamine the basis for saying it's affecting her mental health. My sympathies lie far more with young people who can't get a foot on the ladder which may not even exist anymore. OP your kids are housed and comfortable and more than that, they have invested in property at a time when opportunities for doing so are shrinking for many young people. In fact, young people failed by education, for example, don't even have consolatory social housing programmes to assist them in making their way in life. The more I think about it, you don't know you're born compared with many Confused

CrimbleCrumble1 · 14/01/2022 12:47

Where I live in the south east there is a ladder, couples across the road from me move into small town town houses from one bedroom flats, they stay for about five years and then move to detached new build houses or chunky semis with room to extend.

dafey · 14/01/2022 12:37

There’s no ladder anymore.

Yes there was a really good article in the FT about this.

dafey · 14/01/2022 12:34

Immigration, death and birth rate: forgive the bluntness but why not one in, one out? As a country set a population target and each year adjust tax incentives and immigration targets to meet it. I'm pro-immigration but there's no reason we can't manage it properly. This would reduce pressure on housing stocks.

there aren't enough young people though, the population has grown because people are living longer.

speakout · 14/01/2022 12:07

This is causing you depression?

You are experiencing mental health problems because of this?

Please don't trivialise depression and use this term so casually. Depression kills.

TedMullins · 14/01/2022 12:00

Yes YABVU. I’m a socialist, I’m literally sat here wearing a T-shirt with Karl Marx’s face on it, but I’m sceptical that people who think a nice big detached house is a measure of success would vote for any government that wanted to level the playing field. In an ideal world secure housing would be accessible to all, renting would be more secure and protected and come with more freedoms, taxes would be higher to provide things like free childcare and bigger state pensions and the housing market wouldn’t be about assets and profit. That’s the world I’d like (and I say this as a homeowner).

But in the context of the system we live under, your kids are doing better than many people. I’m assuming they live in London or another major city - they probably could afford a detached house outside of London but maybe they don’t want a long commute or to sacrifice the city lifestyle. Do they even want a “nice” detached house? What is actually wrong with flats? They don’t sound like they’re struggling so I really can’t find a violin small enough I’m afraid.

jonny9487 · 14/01/2022 11:51

First World problems eh

Such a dull and predictable thing to say on any thread. Pretty much anything discussed on here is a first world problem.

5128gap · 14/01/2022 11:28

@TheReluctantPhoenix

There is a lot of jealousy towards the older generation on here.

But would those of you who don’t have nice houses give up your phones and the internet to have one? And, if you discover a lump in your abdomen, the choice would be watchful waiting or ‘exploratory’ surgery (few scans).

Large detached houses in good areas are expensive now but successful professionals (especially with two working parents) would certainly afford a decent house.

Your children children, in particular, are very lucky, with potential large inheritances to come from the money locked up in two properties (yours and your parents).

If I gave up my Internet and phone it wouldn't mean I could have a better house as the saving would be negligible compared to house prices. Or do you mean that older people got nice houses while the compensation for younger people is the Internet and their phone? Because as far as I'm aware older people can have those things too. (Obviously not before they were invented, but you can't miss something that doesn't yet exist) Again with medical advancements, yes the care is more developed but access to it gets harder every year. I'm not young by the way, I'm 52. And the idea that young people are jealous of us is ridiculous. No one would choose to be older. That doesn't mean they (and we) can't acknowledge that aspects of our lives may have been easier than theirs.
Pendolino · 14/01/2022 11:14

The money is still there as it always was, inequality is the issue. There are far more billionaires these days. No one needs a billion pounds.

Blossomtoes · 14/01/2022 11:05

I'd rather be a skint 20 year old than a rich 70 year old.

Amen to that. Trouble is you have to be that 70 year old to appreciate it.

YourenutsmiLord · 14/01/2022 10:33

Thing is the world changes. My DPs (I'm in my sixties) did not own their own home. I (working for the nhs on their famously low wages at that time) did not expect to own my house, didn't really think about it it was so out of the question. However I went abroad to earn more (that is an option still open to young people) and, fortunately met DH who was in a better paid career. We bought our first detached house when we were early 40s.
The world changed hugely between my DPs 40s and mine. The world is changing again, home working, falling birthrate, immigration, perhaps the UK becoming a less desirable place for foreigners to buy land and property (Gov could change taxes).
It might be hard now but could be quite different in 10/20 years time. And we oldies might have had it lucky but we are now counting down to our demise, writing our wills. Facing age related illness. I'd rather be a skint 20 year old than a rich 70 year old.

Zilla1 · 14/01/2022 10:21

agree with @oatmilk4breakfast where I live outside London, personal experience and EAs confirm there is no ladder like there was pre-2008.
Buying, doing up, using pay rises and moves up he ladder as a model has stopped.

Zilla1 · 14/01/2022 10:19

@Lasttraintolondon every time I've seen reporting on multiples and have some insight then this led to a cull of lowest paid staff with outsourcing to worse pay and conditions.

Lasttraintolondon · 14/01/2022 10:00

The argument others have it worse is so weak. Yeah it's shit for your kids and for many others.

Want it fixed? Here's two ideas:
Put in place a maximum gap between the worst paid in an organisation and the lowest, say thirty times the bottom income. That'll see lower wages rise. Who doesn't want that level of fairness except the 1%?

Immigration, death and birth rate: forgive the bluntness but why not one in, one out? As a country set a population target and each year adjust tax incentives and immigration targets to meet it. I'm pro-immigration but there's no reason we can't manage it properly. This would reduce pressure on housing stocks.

Proudboomer · 14/01/2022 09:56

My son is looking to buy late this year. He is will be 24. If he takes the smallest mortgage he can he can buy a nice size one bed flat, another £25-£30k will up to a two bed flat or if he maxes out what he can borrow a 2 bed starter house. He works long hours and diy and gardening are not things he can do or wants to so he is looking at the second option of a flat with two beds and hopefully a terrace or balcony.
This way he won’t over stretch himself and will still have disposable income to enjoy life whilst he is still young.
And still better than my first flat back in the 80’s which was a studio above a bookies. We are in the south and I am giving him some help with his deposit but he has also saved since 19 so I am going to match what he has saved. He choose not to go to university but to do an apprenticeship as he wanted to buy asap and knew he couldn’t do both but it has worked out well for him as his skill set is in demand (IT) and he has the experience employers are looking for. He was offered two jobs just before Christmas at more than he was earning so he used those offers to negotiate a pay rise with his employer so now his mortgage multiples are good.

FiveGs · 14/01/2022 09:52

Sorry, but I think YABU

Yebbie · 14/01/2022 09:51

I'm 27 and last year bought my first house, it's a new build which isn't what I wanted but it's a 4 bed detached with a nice big garden and it's mine. No help from parents on either side.

Yes it's a lot harder than it used to be, but it isn't impossible. I'd say around half of my friends own their houses, while half still rent.

seekinglondonlife · 14/01/2022 09:48

Gosh OP, I think your dc are in a really good position to have bought in their 20s. I don't know anyone of that age who can buy detached houses as FTBs. I'm in my 40s and still haven't been able to buy.

etulosba · 14/01/2022 09:46

The only way houses will get cheaper is if people stop paying silly money for them.

Sandinmyknickers · 14/01/2022 09:39

Obviously there is no right and wrong but I'm curious about the idea that owning a nice house in the suburbs should be a desirable thing in your 20s. It robs you of any flexibility, spontaneity etc if you want to up and move for a new job in Barcelona for example....yes you could sell, but I think for a lot of people home ownership and suburbia in your 20s sounds like a recipe for a dull life. Why a race to 'complete' life achievements by the time you're 30 as if you somehow go off your sell by date after that?

ParkingFeud · 14/01/2022 09:22

Young person here. We don't have a tv. Or phone contracts, just the SIM cards which are £11 a month each. If we got rid of those it would still take us 530 years to save up the average deposit needed for a 3 bed terraced house. P.s we would want 3 beds as we are getting to family having age. An average first time buyer in our area is something like 35. Time is running out for women at that point. Worried about a crash too as interests you've all benefited from are only going to one way so would want to be somewhere we can stay a while if that happens and the ladder falls.
P.s I eat loads of lentils, no meat, shop in Aldi and have a 10 year old tiny car that I barely use. Our only holiday was 4 days camping in Dorset in September. But houses are still expensive.....what are we doing so wrong?

Oh and despite good salaries , we are only getting poorer with national insurance hikes, bill hikes, inflation, continually rising prices etc. Can't even move to Europe now. ..yes I'm resentful and angry.

crossstitchingnana · 14/01/2022 09:16

I agree OP. We are working as hard, if not harder, for less. And we have smart phones, cars, washing machines, foreign holidays and other stuff but life is harder. Now we have NI hike, fuel increases and (my rant of the day) no bloody NHS dentists. Where I live, from April 1st, there will be no NHS dentists forcing us all to go private. That's a costume parents didn't have.

grey12 · 14/01/2022 09:08

@dafey

Yea but back in the day we didn't have expenses like mobile phones, pay for TV like Sky, broadband and eating out was a once in a blue moon treat. Takeaway coffee was unheard of.

🙄

Didn't you know?! Everyone in the UK in the 60s to 90s lived with no mod-cons at all! Never went out, never went to the pub, ate only potatoes and wore only potato sacks as clothing Wink
Dexy007 · 14/01/2022 08:56

I get where you are coming from OP. This doesn't apply to me anymore as I moved overseas (because of this!) but I do have friends - couples, both lawyers with very high London salaries who are buying £1m houses in what are - frankly - horrible areas in zone 3/4. Neighbourhoods full of chicken shops and hoodies hanging out on street corners, parks full of dog shit and litter.

When privately educated professionals pulling in £200k between them a year are living in places like that you know something has gone really wrong in SE.

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 14/01/2022 08:31

@contributory

Interesting points, and I would agree that we can't point the finger at one cause in isolation.

I don't have a particularly nice house no, my dm certainly views it as below 'her station'. Meanwhile, my parents still live in the same house and refuse to down size.

Sounds like a family of snobs sorry.

You have to reach a certain stature to make parents happy.

You for your parents. Your kids for their parents.

It's not your fault. Sounds like an inherited trait.

Swipe left for the next trending thread