Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My OH doesn’t want this 2nd baby

189 replies

LB482 · 13/01/2022 12:04

We have just found out we have had an “accident” and we are divided on what to do.

For context we have a 2yo together and he has an adult son. I am 40 he is 50. I have a decent paid FT job and he is self employed builder and doesn’t think he has physical ability to do more than another 10 years. He also has mental health issues and tinnitus. We have no family close by to help and I lost my mum to cancer.

He has always said one child only, and is furious that I am pregnant. He doesn’t think he has the mental, physical or financial capability for another. He says our life is good now and it will be easier having just one. We won’t be divided going to hobbies or parties and still afford to do nice things and even send kid to private school if we wanted. Another would ruin all this and he is happy being a father of 2. He thinks it will ruin our relationship too. He also hates his own brother.

I desperately want another child. I want our child to grow up with a sibling. I may not be close to my own brother but I want the opportunity for our child to have a playmate in childhood (he has a much older half brother which I don’t think is the same) and confidante for life. I love motherhood and want to have another child to love and cherish. I want a bigger family than we have now as we don’t have many others that we are close to, physically or emotionally.

I think I would resent my OH for life if he made me end this pregnancy but I know he may resent me and this child if it does all go horribly wrong and we ruin our relationship or happy family life we have now, or worse still have a disabled child (as we are both mature parents). I don’t know if I can even go through with the process of abortion it actually sickens me to think of it.

He is a constant worrier and thinks it will tip his anxiety over the edge.

AIBU if I carry on with this pregnancy?

OP posts:
Piggyk2 · 15/01/2022 10:16

@3mealsaday but OP knew she always wanted more kids. Why did she continue? Let's be honest I don't think this was an accident.

3mealsaday · 15/01/2022 09:08

@Hrpuffnstuff1

No one has asked what would he like to do? Maybe he has a dream in his head, a bucket list.

No, not allowed, thy must stay awake listening to a screaming baby.
Toddler yrs are fun, but babies, if they're a screamer are bloody awful.

That's fine if they were deciding whether or not to have another baby. Then he would have an equal say and indeed a veto, since no one should be forced to have more children than they want.

But this pregnancy already exists and so sort of trumps these plans. You can't really ask someone you profess to love to abort a baby against their wishes due to your dreams and 'bucket list'.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 15/01/2022 09:02

No one has asked what would he like to do?
Maybe he has a dream in his head, a bucket list.

No, not allowed, thy must stay awake listening to a screaming baby.
Toddler yrs are fun, but babies, if they're a screamer are bloody awful.

PattyPan · 14/01/2022 23:32

@spotcheck

Two is easier than one. I wonder if your DH is able to appreciate that as he gets older, the children will be more likely to play together rather than needing to be played with
Two teenagers are £££ and he will be retiring in 10 years. Doesn’t sound so easy to me. Let alone finding the energy to deal with two teens in your 60s!
spotcheck · 14/01/2022 19:59

Two is easier than one. I wonder if your DH is able to appreciate that as he gets older, the children will be more likely to play together rather than needing to be played with

secular39 · 14/01/2022 19:46

Not only that but there's a high risk of developing Dementia as we age.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 14/01/2022 17:36

It's NOT just about the sleepless nights, it's about him knowing that he has personal responsibility to provide and take care of a young family whilst working in construction. Which is a young man's game. Along with his own health problems which will only accelerate

I and Mrs HR are having a baby, however I'm fully onboard with it, with caveats.

HipsterMum · 14/01/2022 17:03

I understand your husband's age worries him and is a concern for him. People can however get unwell at any age! There are no guarantees in this life. The same applies to 'he only wanted 1 child' . Unless a woman has had her uterus removed there is always a chance pregnancy might happen. Even if it is 1% chance only. I am all pro choice.... but it seems that those things are usually discussed before getting married and then throughout the marriage reflecting the various changes that happen to us as we grow older. For example that you secretly always wanted your child to have a sibling. Why did you hide it from the partner you love and trust so much? You might have been ok with 'one child only scenario' but then once you had the baby, you felt differently. We are not robots. We cannot always write down a detailed plan for our whole life. I do not know your relationship with your partner, I am sure he is a fantastic dad but are you certain you will be able to terminate and then to carry on as normal? I myself wouldn't because to me an essential part of seeing someone as a good father is to know that they take responsibility for their children, all children that they conceive. I cannot imagine to continue seeing someone as a great father after they insisted I terminate a pregnancy. That's my personal worry.

Either way a baby is not necessarily a massive disruption to ones 'perfect life'. Yes, it can be very challenging at first especially with the lack of sleep but there is a big chance you can still enjoy all the same family dynamics and outings with a sling on with a baby sleeping in it.

Decision is only yours but I do hope that your partner is also there to share the consequences for both scenarios. Seeing some of my friends examples a termination can often be an even bigger challenge to ones relationship than a baby and a few sleepless months.

AryaStarkWolf · 14/01/2022 15:30

If the decision was whether to have another child, I'd agree with you. But it's not... it's whether to abort an existing pregnancy.

Exactly. There's a massive difference. On a personal level I'm 100% Pro Choice and would never judge a woman for having an abortion, I don't think I ever could make that choice myself though (under ordinary circumstances anyway, I don't know how I would feel if I was raped etc)

Rubyglitter · 14/01/2022 13:26

am a fit 40yo who runs 3x a week and he is not old in the head either, I could never have imagined my dad dressing fashionably! I lost my mum in my twenties too so I know what it’s like to lose a parent young, it is devastating, but you can’t predict life

I’m in my mid 20s and my dad is 50. Mum is younger. I’m glad they had me in their early 20s because I still have my grandparents (late 70s). I’m sorry you lost your mum at a young age, but most people pass away in their 80s. This means that your dc may lose their df in their 20s or early 30s. They won’t have a relationship with their grandparents as adults. You and dh are ok now, but you will be in your 50s and 60s organising play dates, taking dc to extracurricular clubs, taking them to and from university etc.

Beamur · 14/01/2022 13:05

Fundamentally, your body, your choice.
Good luck.

AnotherEmma · 14/01/2022 13:01

"He has always said one child only, and is furious that I am pregnant."

Completely unreasonable of him to be furious with you. Perhaps he's angry with himself for not getting a vasectomy or wearing a condom.

I can understand why he doesn't want another child at the age of 50. But he doesn't get to decide at this point - you're pregnant now and it's your choice.

You clearly want to continue the pregnancy and you'd be mad to terminate just to appease him. Even if you could go through with it, you would surely resent him for it and regret it.

It sounds as if the relationship might be over unless he can come around to the idea of another child.

Would the two of you be open to couple's counselling?

MsTSwift · 14/01/2022 13:00

Of course there are no guarantees but a healthy 35 year old man is a damn sight more likely to live to see his kids grow up than a blue collar worker 50 year old in bad health 🙄

Arnia · 14/01/2022 12:46

*Don't think abortion would be the right choice for you

Arnia · 14/01/2022 12:46

Seeing your update I would say go ahead with the pregnancy. If he's as good a dad as you say he is then he'll come round. None of it is ideal but it is what it is and while I personally wouldn't hesitate to have an abortion (and have had while married and with existing DC) I do t think it would be the right choice for you and you may be left with a lifetime of regret. He's fearful now understandably but it's not like you've been out of the baby stage for years and are heading back in, you will manage. If your relationship is as strong as you say then you will get through this. Talk to him, acknowledging his fears but ultimately tell him that a termination is not an option for you but you hope he will come to support your decision.

Best of luck Flowers

Sportslady44 · 14/01/2022 12:29

Oh for gods sake the child might lose their father in their twenties. Even if they do they have had a good father for twenty years or more it's more than some people get.

Friend is early 70s and has two children in their twenties and has a great relationship with both of them.

Sportslady44 · 14/01/2022 12:25

Absolutely crazy to mention his age and whether he will die young or not.
There are no guaranteed in life for anyone of either age.

pradavilla · 14/01/2022 12:14

It's a bit of a no win situation in terms of ur relationship. If you don't have the baby you will resent him and no doubt your relationship will not survive it.

However if u have the baby he will resent you for it too and you might be left a single parent.

I will add though I was shocked going from 1 to 2 as to how much harder it is. You've also said u have no family help. So be prepared for that and possibly doing it on ur own.

My first was 2 1/2 when second was born. She's now just turned 2 and it's getting easier but still hard work. I'd probably have another though if I got pregnant by accident as I don't think I cld terminate but would consider it. In your shoes I'd go ahead with the pregnancy.

Aria999 · 14/01/2022 12:08

@GrannytoaUnicorn but if your parents has thought about it and then had an abortion (as the OP is having to think about) then you wouldn't be here, would you? Do you actually wish they had made that choice?

I think the average age of parents is more than it was a generation ago.

Grandparents under 50 at age 11? That means they became grandparents age 39 so both generations had kids at 19 / 20? That's very young. Lots of people are early to mid 30s these days for their first child.

GrannytoaUnicorn · 14/01/2022 10:40

@Lb482

Thank you for the, mostly, kind and considered comments. It has all been such a head-spin of emotions and thoughts these last few days and the advice is really welcome. Our relationship is really strong right now but of course the early months with newborn sleep deprivation challenges anyone and that I think is what scares us most. Neither of us wants to part ways as we have both found each other after less successful relationships and we know we make each other very happy. Our child is a joy to us both and was so very longed for. We love being parents, which makes this such a difficult position to be in as I feel we could give another child such a loving secure and happy life but he has his concerns that it will be too much. We are still talking but finding it difficult to appreciate the others POV right now. We both agree we have never been in such a difficult position before in our lives.

To address a few criticisms…yes it was an accident, I won’t go into our personal life details. I just had to “name” what this is without labelling it something awful like a “mistake”. Whilst I had suppressed maternal desire for another child, as I dearly love my partner and knew what I was getting into, of course emotions and hormones make your feelings heightened and my now longing for a sibling has surfaced. He is a fantastic dad and partner, does more than 50:50 share of housework, cooking, shopping, parenting etc, I couldn’t be with a better person in that regard. He just wants us to continue doing things as a couple and family and not be split in different directions. I am a fit 40yo who runs 3x a week and he is not old in the head either, I could never have imagined my dad dressing fashionably! I lost my mum in my twenties too so I know what it’s like to lose a parent young, it is devastating, but you can’t predict life, my grandparents all lives into their nineties! I would like to think my parenting is not compromised by age.

Thank you 💐

My parents were both fit & healthy! That's how they conceived so late. Unfortunately age affects all bodies, regardless of whether they run or are "old in the head" Your husband would be 71/72 when this child turns 21! Unless he miraculously does live into his eighties or nineties then there's a very good chance the child will indeed lose their father in their twenties....

Also the issues weren't just physical. The 40 & 45 year age difference meant we were just so so different in far, far too many ways.
We didn't have fun together. I thoroughly believe you need to be able to relate in some ways with your child and have fun (alongside the discipline of course) with them and that this is not possible with such a vast amount of an age difference.

I go crawling around the soft play frame and bouncing on the trampolines at the trampoline park with my child. There's no way that's going to be viable for a parent in their 50s.

I remember going on a week long school trip in Year 6. My Mum was turning 50 and I'd decided to use my spending money on buying a present for my mum. The teachers thought this was lovely and gave me a prize/recognition of some sort, in front of the class & when asked why I'd bought my mum a present, I of course said it was because it was her 50th and I'll never forget the entire class' sudden intake of breath like 😲😲😲😲😲 followed by two kids saying "My grandma's not even 50...." I then got asked by the boy next to me if she was secretly my great grandma. I was thoroughly humiliated and wished I'd not told anyone. I was bullied for it for weeks & weeks afterwards.

I'm not trying to make anyone feel bad, just giving my experience to make you aware of how it can turn out.

I wish my parents had thought about all this before having me. All they knew was that they^^ wanted a baby.........

PlanktonsComputerWife · 14/01/2022 10:21

It is your choice. I would keep the baby and lose the husband.

Purpleraspberry · 14/01/2022 10:20

It sounds like.you want the baby, and if you do then you should do what you want to do. Even although the baby is his too and the decision should be 50/50, one of you is going to have to back down, and you have emotionally more to lose than him as it is your body.

You would probably resent him if you have an abortion, and if you ever split up then you'll always have your child, but otherwise, you won't have your dh or the child..

Sorry, I am not a pro lifer, although I know I probably sound like one. If you were saying you wanted to terminate, I'd be offering support and advice based on that. I just feel strongly about situations where women want to have their baby but their partner wants a termination. The poor woman has to live with it for the rest of their life just because their partner didn't want the child. I feel for anyone who has experienced this.

I can't help but feel his reasoning for it is influenced by his own relationship with a sibling.

notquiteruralbliss · 14/01/2022 10:14

OP - I was in my early 40s and my partner in his early 50s when we had DC4 who is now 20. It was fine. Neither you nor your partner is too old and as your current DC is only 2 all you are really talking about is an extra 3 years with dependent DCs

LakieLady · 14/01/2022 09:51

Whether you keep the baby or have an abortion, the relationship is very likely over. Have the baby if that's what you want, just do so with your eyes wide open, knowing that chances are high you'll be a single parent.

Absolutely this. Would you be able to stay in your current home if your relationship ended? Would you be able to support two children financially on your own, given that your OH may well be retiring years before they start secondary school and that you will be unlikely to see much in the way of maintenance then?

But ultimately, it's your body and your choice.

RoseSays · 14/01/2022 09:26

I think you have to go for it.
I'm pro-choice, but in this instance I personally don't think it's the correct moral choice to abort.
He got together with a childless woman 10 years younger than him - it's not crazy yo think you might have wanted children - he has 2 children, why aren't you allowed the same?
Yes he could have had a vasectomy, but he didn't and now he wants you to have a medical procedure because he couldn't be bothered/didn't want to go through it - nah!

No one can predict what will happen to your relationship 2nd child or not. You are very likely (if you stay together) to be widowed (due to the age gap and life expectancy of a blue-worker man) and live possibly decades without him. I'm pretty sure during those years you will be especially pleased you kept your wanted 2nd child.
Look at the bigger picture is my advice (plus your are already pregnant)

Swipe left for the next trending thread