Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU- Fellow school mum drives every morning

437 replies

Mybumlooksbig · 13/01/2022 11:36

So..hope this doesn't out me.
We live in a very small close knit area. All kids attend the same school, lots of us live on the same few streets.
Every morning and pick up we ALL walk the kids to school, bar the few who have to rush off to work etc (it's a 5-10 min walk)
One parent on my street... drives! Big 4x4, she has NEVER once walked her DS.
She doesn't work, no where to rush off to. She has no mobility issues etc neither does the child..
Why does this iritate me so much??

Yabu- live and let live
Yanbu- she should be walking

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 13/01/2022 13:23

it actually is when people pollute the atmosphere. As well as climate change, air pollution causes dementia. These people do have to stop.

“These people”? You mean, those who are judged with no information?

Sure, cars are bad blah blah blah, but rather than singling out individuals, get on board with campaigning for clean air zones around schools, or with the moves for cleaner fuel or better transport etc. It’s not always about choices either. I walked half a mile past the school at the top of the road, to our local shop yesterday morning at 8.45. This involves crossing 2 busy roads. Until a year ago there were crossing patrols on this road but the local authority removed them. There is no way I’d have taken kids across that road without them.

PinkWaferBiscuit · 13/01/2022 13:23

Would have to be an an incredibly life limiting illness to not be able to walk 5-10 minutes.

What a load of nonsense. Hmm

Honestly why do people post such daft statements.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 13/01/2022 13:23

I also don't get the instant hatred for cars that happen to have 4wd transmission and the assumption that anybody who has one (except maybe remote farmers) doesn't care about the environment.

It reminds me of the time when the tabloids used the phrase 'has a flat-screen TV' as a nasty lazy shorthand for 'this is a workshy chav' - and continued to do so for years, even long after all TVs were flat-screen.

Many modern 4x4s are no less polluting than an ordinary family saloon - and people with disabilities and mobility problems will often find the higher seating position crucial to being able to actually get in and out of the car.

They are also commonly used to pull caravans and so owned by families who have holidays in the UK instead of hugely polluting everybody's world by flying abroad two or three times a year, as many other people do.

Ironically, such people could avoid much of the hatred by buying a second, superfluous little car for use around town - even though they can manage perfectly well with just the one car and have no need to pollute the environment further by causing another car to be built, run and maintained.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 13/01/2022 13:21

She probably just cba. I do judge her for having a massive 4x4 though.

ShittyGlitter · 13/01/2022 13:21

Nah I'm with you OP.

Would have to be an an incredibly life limiting illness to not be able to walk 5-10 minutes. Don't know why that's always the first assumption by people, what about the environment?

Anyway, what's wrong with a mobility scooter? Kid could walk at least.

SwordBilledHummingbird · 13/01/2022 13:19

I don't look like I have mobility issues but I have chronic pain from recurrent joint dislocations and chronic fatigue (the fatigue is worse than the pain tbh). I feel so self-conscious using lifts to go up one floor or using an accessible parking bay at work as I don't "look disabled". Maybe there is no "reason" for her to drive but you're not privy to that information. Either way, the world would be a much nicer place for those of us with disabilities if the rest of the world stopped judging.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 13/01/2022 13:15

@FelicityBob

Wow I can’t believe the comments I can’t stand seeing people drive who could easily walk. It’s lazy, teaching their kids to be lazy, and damaging to the planet. YANBU It’s the same here, people drive who literally live a 5 minute walk. And then they go to the gym for exercise. Madness
It's only really fair to judge someone for driving if you KNOW they could 'easily walk', thought, @FelicityBob. A previous poster on here has said her IBS can be set off by walking - that isn't a visible problem, and it isn't necessarily one she would want to share with all and sundry of her neighbours, but it would be unfair to judge her for driving.

I do somewhat see your point about people who drive to school then drive to the gym to exercise - 10 minutes to walk their child to school and get home, and then head to the gym. Unless they are going to a specific class, and this would make them late.

TheKeatingFive · 13/01/2022 13:14

Maybe there's good reason. Or maybe she's just lazy. But who among us hasn't taken a lazy option on certain things?

In the overall scheme of things, it's very minor. Try to cool the jets, it's not worth your energy.

ArcheryAnnie · 13/01/2022 13:13

@AdventureAhead

Whilst it is her choice it has a potentially significant impact on a lot of others.
  1. local air pollution - Schools are often pollution hot spots, largely due to engine idling children. Kids in pushchairs and children walking past idling cars are more exposed than adults as they are closer to the exhaust.
  2. road safety. The height of 4x4s means an average height adult often can't see over the roof so crossing a road between parked cars is more risky.
  3. Impact of hitting a child. Whilst hopefully very very unlikely, if the worst happens and a pedestrian is hit by a conventional car the impact will be partially absorbed by the pedestrian rolling onto the bonnet, windscreen and over the top of a car. If a pedestrian is hit in a 4x4 it is like being hit by a brick wall. The height means they can't roll onto the bonnet, impact is higher and they are more likely to go under the car. To make it worse the height of the front of most 4x4 will hit the body of an adult (more chance of survival/less injury) but the head of a child. This and 4x4s blocking visibility when pedestrians are cross roads is why 4x4s are an awful choice of vehicle to drive around a school, residential area or anywhere where there will be lots of pedestrians, especially children.

So underlying health conditions aside it's possibly lazy to drive but that is her choice. We are all lazy sometimes. But this choice has a detrimental impact on others, made significantly worse by her choice of car.

This. Our choices impact on others. It is our business, and we are allowed to have an opinion on it.
BrutusMcDogface · 13/01/2022 13:13

Get a life, honestly, and leave the poor woman alone.

bobsholi · 13/01/2022 13:13

I live on the same street as the school. My neighbour drives there every morning and usually takes longer than I do. I don't understand why she does it but it obviously makes her happy for some reason.

LittleGwyneth · 13/01/2022 13:13

Maybe she drives on to somewhere else afterwards? Honestly this is very strongly none of your business and I have no idea why it interests you so much. Sounds like you don't like her more generally to be honest.

RichardMarxisinnocent · 13/01/2022 13:13

@BiggestJulie

It’s everyone’s business, including the people who live near the school, and the children walking. Cars are polluting and the school run accounts for a huge amount of traffic.

I believe cars should be banned within half a mile of primary schools and a mile of secondary - with exceptions for residents within the banned area, and for those with a disabled sticker. Everyone would be healthier and the air the children breathe around the school would be cleaner.

How would banning cars work when there is a main A road well under half a mile from a school? Does the A road get closed and drivers have to take a potentially huge detour to get to their destination?
AnnaSW1 · 13/01/2022 13:12

Literally nothing to do with you Grin

SockFluffInTheBath · 13/01/2022 13:12

Are we in psychic link up possession of knowing the nasty 4x4 isn’t hybrid or electric, and that it’s not one of the newer ones that has decent after treatment systems and is actually less polluting than some smaller slightly older cars?

HasaDigaEebowai · 13/01/2022 13:11

I suspect she doesn’t like you and doesn’t want to mix with you..

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 13/01/2022 13:11

@orinocosfavoritecake

And I am wondering how many of the responses defending her are from others who deep down know they shouldn’t be hogging the road in their range rovers.
I don't drive but I'm going to defend the woman. She may just be lazy, she may just want to destroy the environment. She may suffer from something called cold urticaria, she may have another allergy that is affected by walking. The child could have an issue like cold urticaria or just be a lazy so and so but the point is no one knows the truth but her so don't judge.
AryaStarkWolf · 13/01/2022 13:11

Mind your own business

wavecatcher · 13/01/2022 13:11

This is people often hate school mums, judgey and bitchy behind another mums back.

Maybe she doesn't want to walk, maybe she does have to get back for her only fans work requires a live log on at 9:15?

Who knows? Maybe ask her but I hope she tells you it's none of your business.

Mellowyellow222 · 13/01/2022 13:10

Surely there is someone you can report this to?

A parish council committee perhaps - they could work up a plan - perhaps one evening you could all let the airs out of of her tyres then hide in a hedge and see if she walks to school. It will be important to video this - then you will have evidence that it sheer laziness rather than any other issue at play.

Then for the intervention- as many neighbours as possible - call it drinks and nibbles but it will be an ambush. Play the video - present the evidence of her driving to school and open it to discussion amoungst the neighbours t

MrsToothyBitch · 13/01/2022 13:10

Is it that she's driving her kid or that she's NOT driving anyone elses yours? YABU because you really don't know why she's doing this, you can't see her medical records etc.

You'd definitely judge us. DP would do this because his agoraphobia and ptsd wouldn't do well in a busy playground- the resultant headaches take him out of commission for hours. I would drive if the state of the pavements round the school is bad. I walk a fair bit, but I also have recurrent foot & ankle problems from injuries. I've spent a lot of time & energy fixing them but poor pavements are a huge cause of trips, falls and twists for me and it's not worth it. I avoid anything I don't feel safe walking on.

BFPDec21 · 13/01/2022 13:10

How to you know she doesn't work?

I don't 'look' like I do (I wear whatever is comfiest) but no one knows my business. One of neighbours also thinks I'm lazy and don't work. I actually drive in order to rush back home to start working in the morning and afternoon after both school runs. The other parents mostly walk and whilst I had all intentions to walk, it isn't feasible with your distractible DD is and how long it would actually take out of my day.

Tbh I think we should all be less judgemental about other people's lives and focus on what we're doing.

Progress2019 · 13/01/2022 13:09

A woman in my road drives every day. The school is opposite and takes about 90 seconds. I’ve asked her why she doesn’t just walk it (worded politely - more how can you be bothered to get the car out? than what are you up to, you monster?) and she says she likes to go straight to the gym

The whole journey would be a five minute walk, but it takes her longer as parking at school is very limited, and there’s always a queue of cars.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 13/01/2022 13:08

Why does everyone start speculating on her health conditions?! She probably is just a bit lazy...so what?! I am too!

It's a real problem when people with disabilities and other health conditions are dismissed and 'othered' in this way - and I'm glad that so many people on this thread are not doing this.

Living with poor health is hard enough as it is, but it's made even more difficult by able-bodied people declaring you as 'probably just lazy' - purely on the basis that they (with their good health) would feel lazy if they drove instead of walking relatively short distances and can't understand that others are not exactly the same as them.

Additionally, there is a wide spectrum of disability, health conditions and mobility problems. So many people seem to think that you either have a blue badge or otherwise have perfect health, with no in-between possible. Not that actual blue badge holders are immune from abuse and discrimination from those who 'reckon they know better' - far from it.

How some people believe they can proclaim that a particular person has no health problems at all shows breathtaking arrogance. Should those with less than perfect health be expected to wear a big badge at all times, declaring their entire private medical history to the public at large? I'll bet that, even if people with a hidden disability did do this, they'd still be dismissed as exaggerating or making it up.

I hope they're never on a jury, as they'd doubtless make their decision based on whether the defendant 'looks shifty' or not and not trouble themselves to see the need for considering any evidence.

Even if she doesn't have any existing health conditions, we're always being urged to be pro-active in looking after our health - she may just be wisely protecting her mental health by deliberately avoiding exposure to the toxic village judgy mum brigade.

preperri · 13/01/2022 13:08

@BiggestJulie

That will never happen, because it goes against human rights