Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some dog breeds should never ever be around babies and children

254 replies

Redburnett · 13/01/2022 10:09

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-cambridgeshire-59953038
Such a sad case where the dogs had apparently never shown aggressive tendencies previously.

OP posts:
Fidgetty · 13/01/2022 15:06

No dog should be allowed in reach of a newborn. Wholly the parents fault. I hate seeing cutsie videos online with teeny tiny babies being "protected", "licked" or "soothed" by the family dog. I wince every time at the idiocy. I love dogs more than most people yet I would never be so bloody stupid as to believe they'd never hurt a child accidentally or otherwise. I have the most gentle, small, lovely fur ball on the planet yet I still ensured he got nowhere near my DCs when they were babies, even though in all likeliness there was more chance of them hurting him! You just don't take the risk. Sheer Negligence as far as I'm concerned.

PearlD · 13/01/2022 14:59

@Wallabyone

The child was a CPP plan, the mother took sleeping pills and left the baby with the dogs not behind the gates. The poor baby should not have been left alone in that vulnerable position Sad
And here is all we need to know. Unless a witch hunt is in order for dogs that you don't like the look of? Yes? Thought so.
user313213521 · 13/01/2022 14:56

Dogs are animals not 'fur babies' as ridiculous people lacking in something call them. When you hear of dogs in bedrooms or beds with people and even babies you have to question the thinking skills of the owner.

Please can you be more specific about what is wrong with dogs in adults bedrooms / on adults beds, or supervised in a child's bedroom?

I'd never leave dogs and young children unsupervised, but saying people who allow dogs in bedrooms are thick is ridiculous.

Branleuse · 13/01/2022 14:54

Well clearly the dog did attack the baby for whatever reason, but jeez, with the amount of people that have them, its still rare enough that its national-newsworthy when it happens.

People need to do a course i think and get a dog licence. I think its really important to be able to have a dog for so many people. So beneficial, but its also far too easy to get one and a dog in the wrong hands can be a lethal weapon.
I hate the stereotypes around staffie owners, and theyre also quite outdated now anyway. Most staffies i see are just normal dogs with normal owners. Theyre not status dogs anymore thankfully. The irresponsible dickhead thugs pay a fortune for xl bullies or big mutant frenchies.

User1isnotavailable · 13/01/2022 14:24

@IncompleteSenten

The baby was put on a child protection plan before he was even born. The issue was not the dogs themselves. It was the parents.
Ah so the dog didn't think the baby was a toy and shake it then. The dog killed the baby. The parent was in the room asleep but the dog still killed the baby. Why make excuses for an animal that reacts like an animal? Startled or scared or whatever, an animal reacts to that as an animal. Some dogs are dangerous, most are not but why take a chance.
User1isnotavailable · 13/01/2022 14:22

So why do some owners call dogs their babies/fur babies. I see this as a new trend on social media 'me and my fur babies' usually some silly person snuggled up with a dog dressed up in whatever/in their bed/doggie selfie/etc. When did people stop realising that dogs are animals, great pets but animals at the end of the day!

"Sophie Bradley, a social worker who had dealt with the family before the incident, said Ms Litchfield described the dogs as "her babies" and had been "warned dogs can be unpredictable and can get jealous"."

IncompleteSenten · 13/01/2022 14:18

The baby was put on a child protection plan before he was even born.
The issue was not the dogs themselves. It was the parents.

User1isnotavailable · 13/01/2022 14:15

If anyone that reads this statement from the report thinks and changes how they behave, it may save an injury or a life of an innocent child:

"Simon Newbury, a specialist in veterinary forensics, said there were 23 individual puncture marks on Reuben's body.

He said they came from "at least four to five bites or engagements" and "quite possibly as many as 18 to 23 if single punctures are single engagements each time".

"I suspect Reuben was shaken between engagements," Mr Newbury said.

He said the attack "would have lasted a minute or longer".

"It's possible Dotty was stimulated into prey drive by a certain movement."

He said he believed Dotty "saw Reuben as a small prey or squeaky toy"."

User1isnotavailable · 13/01/2022 14:13

@HacerSonarSusPasos

I know I'm going to get shit for this, but I think anyone who keeps a pitbull type dog around their kids is massively irresponsible and naive and deserves to go to prison if the dog end up injuring or killing the kids.
This.

People are very naïve when they spout the line it's so good, would never hurt their baby or child etc. The fact is when a dog with a very strong jaw latches on it can do tremendous damage. If a dog is angry/scared etc then the response might be extreme so why even take the chance.

Dogs are animals not 'fur babies' as ridiculous people lacking in something call them. When you hear of dogs in bedrooms or beds with people and even babies you have to question the thinking skills of the owner.

vivainsomnia · 13/01/2022 14:13

I would never, ever leave a baby or small child alone with a dog present
But in this case, the baby wasn't. Report states mum was asleep next to baby.

Iamclearlyamug · 13/01/2022 14:06

@Branleuse

Absolutely

BlondeDogLady · 13/01/2022 14:06

I work with dogs for a living. I would never, ever leave a baby or small child alone with a dog present. That said, you have to acknowledge that larger breeds would be more dangerous as they can cause so much more damage. Think Alsation versus Yorkshire Terrier!

Dogs do not like sudden erratic behaviour. Which is typically how toddlers behave. My own absolutely lovely dog (now deceased) was a Husky, and she was the softest dog going, with a heart of gold. But, I remember the time a young and very erratic child entered our garden and started running around with his arms flapping, she started to bear her teeth. As much as I adored her, I knew that there was a real possibility that she could bite him, even though she had never bitten before. You can't trust dogs not to bite, just because they haven't previously.

wetotter · 13/01/2022 13:58

it also gives people a false sense of security around other dogs. All dogs need careful supervision with young children, and especially very young children theyre not used to and visiting children

Good point

Getyourjinglebellsinarow · 13/01/2022 13:57

YABU. no dogs should ever be left alone with babies. All dogs are unpredictable. All dogs are able to kill babies. In fact I remember not too long ago a jack Russel killed a baby being in the news.

The dog wasn't at fault. They even killed the dog that did nothing but lived in the same house. The baby was left on the floor with a dog while the dad was outside having a fag and the mum was asleep.

Branleuse · 13/01/2022 13:57

I love staffies. I have a real soft spot for them.
I absolutely trust mine with my children. Seems excessive to want to stop certain breeds being around children just because of a few fuckwits that dont train their dogs or pick up warning signs in behaviour.
Im in favour of licences to own a dog, but not breed specific legislation, as not only is it not fair to breeds like Staffs, it also gives people a false sense of security around other dogs. All dogs need careful supervision with young children, and especially very young children theyre not used to and visiting children.

sweetcheekweak · 13/01/2022 13:55

This was more a case of neglectful parents being at fault than the dog

They had SS involvement from birth.

OhWhyNot · 13/01/2022 13:53

Look at lists of incidents of children being killed by dogs (and adults)

It’s always reported as it’s a horrific tragic news

Hugasauras · 13/01/2022 13:50

And there's also never any need to leave babies and dogs together unsupervised. If DD was asleep and I wanted to leave the room for a moment, I called DDog and took her with me to wherever I was going. If we were both going to sleep, DDog went in another room. When she was learning to walk and a bit grabby and unpredictable, they were kept separated. It's not particularly difficult to manage.

Suzanne999 · 13/01/2022 13:50

NO dog should be left near a defenceless baby. I have a Labrador, daft as a brush, never bitten anything in her ( long) life but I’d never leave her alone with a newborn or a small child.

Iheartmysmart · 13/01/2022 13:50

My sister has two rescue staffies that had a pretty rubbish start in life. They are both a bit bonkers but incredibly gentle and loving dogs. I actually trust them far more than my own cocker spaniel who has known nothing but love and gentleness from a pup but is a snappy little sod at times. You just never know what you’re getting with a dog and it’s madness to take a risk with any breed around children in my view.

HacerSonarSusPasos · 13/01/2022 13:49

@Iamclearlyamug are you that confident that if your dog attacked your DD while you were in another part of the house you'd be able to intervene before it did irreperable damage? Because i wouldn't. And all dogs seem perfect angels before they snap for the first time. The issue with these breeds is that they are stronger, more stubborn when they attack and thus capable to inflict much more damage than your other family breeds.

DogInATent · 13/01/2022 13:48

@OhWhyNot

Reporting bias on children being mauled to death by a dog

Oh please Hmm

Do a quick online search. I found almost as many news reports where the dog breed wasn't specified as reports where it was.
olivehater · 13/01/2022 13:47

*dog licencing

Hugasauras · 13/01/2022 13:46

Some people are just absolutely oblivious to obvious dog body language. We have a toddler and a dog and their interactions have always been carefully managed. DD is almost 3 now and knows never to approach DDog when she's eating, never to put her face near DDdog's face, to make sure DDog knows she's there before she strokes her, never climb or stand on DDog, etc. But you see videos of people letting their toddlers climb over dogs who are giving off blaring alarm signals that they aren't happy: lip-licking, whites of eyes showing, ears back. And the parents are absolutely oblivious. It's terrifying.

The good thing is that growing up with a dog is making DD very sensible around other dogs. She never screams or shouts when a dog comes near and she knows how to safely interact and I think that's important too. I think keeping them away from dogs entirely and not allowing safe interactions is problematic in itself. Learning how to do-exist safely with dogs and other pets (we have a cat too and are just as careful with interactions there) is v important, IMO.

JustWonderingIfYou · 13/01/2022 13:46

*wouldn't trust they had well trained dogs!

Swipe left for the next trending thread