Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ban racist relative from my house?

81 replies

jazzchilli · 13/01/2022 01:05

I love my father in law and he is like a father to me. However, he has a wife that we can't stand. They've been together for about 18 years and she has drained his savings and is now trying to get hold of our money. When he had cancer, she did absolutely nothing for him, leaving it to their lovely neighbours and us, who live 170 miles away. But the main problem with her is...she's an aggressive racist.

Basically we avoid her as much as we can. Luckily, he always comes to stay with us on his own because we only have one spare room and she refuses to share a bed with him. Today however, he called to say she wants to come with him this time and he'll have to sleep on the floor. He's 78. I'm not comfortable with any adult guest sleeping on the floor in my house, it feels so wrong.

So...AIBU to ban her from the house. I don't think I shouldn't have to tolerate a racist in my house. In the 20 years we've known her she has shocked us with her racist comments every time we've seen her. She even makes comments outside deliberately so neighbours hear.

I feel that not standing up to people like this is unacceptable, especially now. I'm not going to keep quiet and listen to the venom she spouts, so there'll be a terrible row. I have challenged others in the past but it's been difficult to do so with her as I don't want to hurt my father in law. Although he moans about her constantly and is always relieved to get away, so I don't understand why he would inflict her on us!

My husband doesn't want to upset his dad but I think it will be worse if she does come. I would also be left on my own with her most of the day as my husband likes to take his dad out to pubs etc. Then, the three of us have a lovely time drinking and talking in the evening. When this woman is there conversation is limited - she's ignorant and uninformed - and my father in law is subdued.

My husband doesn't know what to do - I'm standing firm but he says that he would just put up with her for the sake of his dad. What do I do?

For additional context, she has been married at least four times before and I've been told that some of her previous husbands' children also hated her. She is literally the most toxic and selfish person I've ever known.

OP posts:
jazzchilli · 13/01/2022 15:06

Thank you everyone so much for all of this - even (or maybe especially!) those who don't agree with things I've said. It's such a relief to get different views after going round in circles on this issue with my husband for years. It's literally the only thing we've ever really argued about.

Just to answer on some of the comments with some more context, sorry if I miss anything! I've read and take on board everything that's been said while I was waiting for my physio appointment. Sorry it's going to be a long one...

As far as the bed situation - I wouldn't be willing to give my bed up for a racist anyway, but I'm recovering from a shoulder op so it's out of the question really. I don't think the bed is the issue though, if she was nice, or god even vaguely tolerable, we would be happy to accommodate her however we could. The bed situation has been our way of avoiding her staying. I have said to my husband that I would go away for the weekend but he says that would be too obvious that I hate her. I really don't care...I have actually avoided going with my husband to visit them for a few years now, but obviously now she's attempting to ambush me in my own home.

We moved just before COVID and had to ensure that we arranged the house so it wasn't possible to have more than one spare room, as in the past they have had to stay with relatives for months on end. When my FIL came with us to see our new house before we moved in he actually looked at one room with an ensuite and said 'Yes XXXX will have that room, it's got a full shower, not a bath, that's what she prefers.' I promptly made it my dressing room with fitted wardrobes and enough furniture to exclude a bed, but he pokes his head in there every time! Maybe she is determined to examine the house to see if we're lying about having only one spare room...

@Suzanne999 I'm so stupid...I hadn't even thought that the reason she's suddenly insisting on visiting was to make another pitch for money! My FIL has mentioned to my husband that she gets upset that we don't send her presents on Mother's Day and her birthday etc.They are having problems with the house they're renting as well so she may be gearing up to insist that someone (us, my sister in law) buys her a house (again). She forced him to move there from another area he really loved, the first thing he talks about every time we speak is how much he misses the old house and his neighbours.

When he was forced to move we did finally ask him whether he was happy with her or wanted to split. He pays for everything anyway as she has no pension (so she says) so it would actually have been cheaper for him to stay there on his own. As far as we can tell there was a big fight but the next day he panicked about being on his own and gave in - which included moving away and handing over his savings so she could redecorate the new house. When she buys anything he gives her cash but then he says she just uses his credit card for it and pockets the cash! I have no idea how he affords to give her all this money, he only has his pension.

Last time he was here, he did start, unprompted, to explore whether he would like to live near us in a retirement flat after she was gone. We have made it very clear that we would be there for him, and that we want him to be closer. I've stated in no uncertain terms, when he talks about their disagreements on their living situation, that we support what is best for him, and that what he wants is valid and important. Because I don't think he believes that, he just says 'happy wife, happy life' as if he doesn't matter. I hate this because any other woman would be thrilled to be with him - he's intelligent, has lots of stories from his past careers, can cook, is kind and loves technology and keeps up to date with everything. Yet he's ended up with this awful woman out of fear of being alone.

On the school/racism thing. Perhaps my location was key here - plus I was a brat at school and maybe wasn't paying enough attention. It wasn't particularly diverse, but it seemed very inclusive at the time. Now, I feel stupid for believing that. I was suppressed a lot by my parents for having 'too many opinions' so no chance of guidance there. Still get that from my mum when she doesn't like what I have to say, but on racism she has now at least admitted that I was right.

Overall, my husband completely agrees - although she often, weirdly, targets me when I'm on my own to start airing her vile opinions and questions me about who I associate with. And never likes the answer. There is a big issue for me that our new neighbours who just moved in are Asian and our other neighbours are black. At our old house, right after we moved in she made racist comments that our old neighbours heard, who were Asian. They were so lovely that they never mentioned it at all and we ended up being very close. I know that wasn't the right thing and I should have acknowleged it and apologised, but was struggling with depression at the time and didn't feel up to tackling it as I might have cried and made it even more awkward! I'm not being put in that situation again and none of our existing neighbours should be.

My ultimate concern, as many have identified, is that my husband gets to spend as much time with his dad as possible. And I want to too, we're very close, he calls me his daughter and I call him dad. We have lots to talk about and as with my husband, that's not possible when the racist witch is there and she shuts down any plans we try to make, and sulks when she can't join in the conversation because she's so ignorant.

My husband knows I'm posting about this to get advice. He's weighing up how valid my concerns are and whether I have the right to ban her from the house. He is an amazing person and finds a way to rise above it, I suppose, even though he despises her. I hate causing him extra stress - his work provides plenty - but equally I don't see how this can carry on and we can feel good about ourselves. Left to him, he would suffer in silence if that was what his dad wanted. It definitely isn't - he loves coming here to get away from her!

I honestly don't know what is worse.

  1. Her coming and there being a massive row, one way or another.
  1. Finally making it clear we want nothing to do with her, and they don't come. Which will obviously also have repercussions with my sister in law and her family, who will get dragged into it. They don't like her but they have kids and so every contact revolves around them and they have less time to worry about other issues. My lovely niece is a bit of a handful and prone to tantrums...the racist witch is completely intolerant and has left their house when she went off on one, a few years ago. I think my niece might have kicked her Grin So there is already negativity there, I don't know if she has seen them since.
  1. I suppose my only other option is to go away for the weekend. Make my husband pay for a spa, read books in a jacuzzi, drain the minibar? But does this make me complicit again? I REALLY don't want to be that person. Does me refusing to be in the house with her make enough of a stand against her racism?

Massive apologies for the long rant...

OP posts:
Budapestdreams · 13/01/2022 12:11

I think your FIL would prefer a few days away from her.
Also, he shouldn't be sleeping on the floor.
I would say that you and your DH would prefer to spend time with him alone, so it would be best if she didn't come.
Also, you're right, racism shouldn't be tolerated and should be called out. I wouldn't want her in my house either.

Snorkmaidenn · 13/01/2022 12:01

I agree, but whatever op days or does will end in tears I guess, and won't be the old dear's tears.

iklboo · 13/01/2022 11:52

We actively challenge FIL & BIL2 making racist comments. FIL's is more the 'of his age name for POC / gay people' but he still gets pulled up. BIL2 is a nasty piece of work & probably every 'ist' there is. We rarely see him by choice and never at ours.

On top of her foul racist behaviour she thinks it's ok for her cancer-recovering husband to sleep on the floor? Fuck that for a game of soldiers.

backtolifebacktoreality · 13/01/2022 11:35

@Snorkmaidenn

How about you mention to her that you are having your new friends of colour over and they will be cooking, so it's best she doesn't attend. I couldn't handle the racism , so lying is nothing in comparison.

How about you just tell her you don't like racists!

backtolifebacktoreality · 13/01/2022 11:34

@magicstars

Definitely don't let your dh think it's ok for him to have a lovely time with his dad, leaving you to entertain this woman. If she does come, you are not responsible for babysitting her! Could you tell your FiL that you'd like to meet somewhere half way & see them both for a day out somewhere instead?

I wouldn't even be meeting her if she's continually making racist comments!

backtolifebacktoreality · 13/01/2022 11:32

@Darbs76

Just say no you’re not comfortable with anyone sleeping on the floor. They’d have to pay for a guesthouse if they both come

No!!!!!

Say you're not comfortable with a racist in your house!!!!

SlidingInto2022sDMs · 13/01/2022 11:21

Do your FIL and DH not realise she's racist? I'm wondering why you have to tell them, can't they see it for themselves and what have they said about it?

Pbbananabagel · 13/01/2022 11:15

@jazzchilli I really feel for you here and absolutely agree you should ban her from the house. I do however (as a child of the 80’s/90’s school system) disagree with your point about our generation not being taught to challenge racism. It really depends on where you grew up, I’m from London and challenging racism and sexism were really big principals that all my schools focused on.

Trinidading3 · 13/01/2022 10:50

Be honest with your FIL tell him she's a racist and she is not welcome in your house, he knows she's racist it won't be a shock to him....then tell her so she knows and whatever happens, happens.....well done for standing up to her and you might not realise this but it's a great thing you're doing...stand strong and speak out you know it's the right thing......all the racist comments she says you and the family should not have to hear or put up with! Who does she think she is? Well done in advance[flowersStar

SeeMyLanyardAndWeepBitch · 13/01/2022 10:35

I think the racism thing is a red herring here. You've listed loads of reasons you don't like her and they are enough. Tell her she can't come because you won't make FIL sleep on the floor. If she says she'll sleep on the floor then just say 'I think it's best if you don't come.' And leave it at that.

I won't spend time with my mother's partner for similar reasons - he's an arrogant windbag who is also a racist. But I'd be a liar if I didn't already have issues with him before I discovered this. It's just given me extra ammunition to be able to tell my mother I won't be around him at all, instead of having to admit I didn't want to be around him to start with.

StrifeOfBath · 13/01/2022 10:28

Family can be complicated. If I had a racist relative I wouldn’t ban them (unless they launched a personal attack or insult on a member of our family, friend or neighbour) but I would challenge, challenge, challenge every single comment.

And no way would DH be disappearing to the pub with FIL leaving her with me!!! This is another thing your DH needs to say to his Dad in advance.

BliainNua · 13/01/2022 10:26

This sounds so hard OP. Not just her vile racist views, but also the way she treats your FiL.
If you said no to her, would your FiL come anyway? Would he be secretly delighted that he was getting away from her?
Is there any way to talk to your FiL about her and how she treats him, and others, and tell him it's not acceptable and he doesn't have to stay with her?

magicstars · 13/01/2022 10:25

Definitely don't let your dh think it's ok for him to have a lovely time with his dad, leaving you to entertain this woman.
If she does come, you are not responsible for babysitting her!
Could you tell your FiL that you'd like to meet somewhere half way & see them both for a day out somewhere instead?

StrifeOfBath · 13/01/2022 10:24

I honestly don’t think that generation get it, at all

It isn’t the generation. Please don’t generalise like that.

I would get your DH to say ‘Dad, why are you suggesting she comes? We are not comfortable with you sleeping in the floor as our guest. And it won’t come as a surprise to you that as you spend time avoiding her, we don’t want to spend time listening to her racist venom. We love to see you, but it is not acceptable for you to sleep on the floor, and if she does come, we will not listen to her racism without telling her what we think’.

SlidingInto2022sDMs · 13/01/2022 10:23

If your husband doesn't mind her coming, then he shouldn't leave her with you ever! I'd not let an unrepentant unpleasant person whom I have to take care of into my home. Why should I?

YANBU. If your husband won't let her tag along each time he's out with his dad, I'd tell your father in law that you only have space for him to stay, not his wife.

neonpaws · 13/01/2022 10:20

I think there are three factors you need to think about here, in order of importance:

  1. Your DH being able to spend time with his father.
  2. MIL's racism
  3. Your FIL's comfort.

Before I get flamed, your comfort is obviously important too but only you can decide where to place it on this list.
I agree with PPs that a conversation needs to happen with FIL to tell him that racist views will not be tolerated in your house and MIL will be asked to leave if she expresses them. I would make that clear up front.
I would also be unhappy that she expected an elderly man to sleep on the floor, so would tell FIL that he is getting the bed and that MIL will have to have the floor. FIL can then work out whether or not he will be happier at yours without her, or whether he is prepared to deal with any fall-out from her behaviour.
If point 1 overrides everything else then personally I couldn't stop DH seeing his father but I would be spending as little time with them as possible.

ErrolTheDragon · 13/01/2022 10:17

I wouldn't want a racist in my house.
I wouldn't want someone who'd drained a relative of their savings.
I wouldn't want someone who expected a 78yo who is recovering from cancer to sleep on the floor. Wtf?

Frankly it sounds as though your FIL is in an abusive relationship. The difficulty is that it makes it extremely important that she doesn't drive a wedge between you/your DH and your FIL.

jeaux90 · 13/01/2022 10:13

My grandfathers wife was racist. We used to shut her down every time she said anything.

Question is whether you want to deal with it or whether you want to avoid.

I absolutely don't blame you for not wanting her around, she sounds vile. I hope that your FIL will still come if she's banned, and whether she will make his life even more hellish.

Snorkmaidenn · 13/01/2022 10:11

How about you mention to her that you are having your new friends of colour over and they will be cooking, so it's best she doesn't attend.
I couldn't handle the racism , so lying is nothing in comparison.

LookItsMeAgain · 13/01/2022 10:05

My advice is to welcome your Fil. Ahead of any visit, tell him that he is most welcome but she is not. If he asks why, tell him. Don't skirt around it. She is racist and she must be called out on it every time.
If he wants to continue visiting, he is most welcome to stay with you. She can find alternative accommodation (which shouldn't be any skin off her nose because she doesn't appear to share a bed with her husband anyway when she has stayed in the past).
Please don't put up with her behaviour. She sounds truly dreadful. Shockingly dreadful!

Suzanne999 · 13/01/2022 09:59

Maybe I’m odd but I’d have her there just to shut her down every time she opened her mouth.
Anything with a hint of racism she wouldn’t even get to the end of the sentence. I’d talk firmly over her with we don’t have any racist talk in this house. ( or similar sentence) . Each and every time she started I’d repeat the same sentence, nothing more. It really freaks people out. They try to argue, you repeat the same sentence. Don’t get into any discussions with her over her views, that’s what she wants.
I’d think of another one to counteract any question of borrowing money from you ( maybe that’s why she wants to visit?) and do the same thing.

Skeumorph · 13/01/2022 09:54

The choice you do have is not to see her. And you can be clear to your DH that you will not host her or want to see her at all.

Being a nice person who does not want to get in the way of your DH and FIL's relationship and who also does not want to see a 78 year old poorly person sleep on the floor, you will therefore go away for the weekend, if neither of them want to rock the boat. Then FIL can have your room, horrid woman the spare, your DH can go on the sofa.

What's that, DH? You don't want to have to entertain her all weekend and not spend proper time with your dad, you don't want her coming out with you and you having to do the hosting for both?

Ah so what you actually mean when you say 'you'd just put up with her for the sake of your dad' is that I should put up with her, I should absorb all that difficulty while you just pretty much have the same kind of visit as usual, taking dad out and doing your stuff?

Nope...

lucillelarusso · 13/01/2022 09:46

I am absolutely shocked that pp think you should tolerate this or even pay for her to stay in a fucking hotel! I'd tell him straight that you love him and want to support him but will not tolerate her in your home. Tell him you think she is a racist and is financially abusive. Maybe it will damage your relationship, maybe it will set him free and he'll divorce her! But I would not have it on my conscience to have her in my home under any circumstances.

Hoppinggreen · 13/01/2022 09:04

If you decide to let her come (I wouldn’t) tell your H you are not hosting her on your own and if he goes out with his Dad you are either going with them or they have to take her with them