Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ban racist relative from my house?

81 replies

jazzchilli · 13/01/2022 01:05

I love my father in law and he is like a father to me. However, he has a wife that we can't stand. They've been together for about 18 years and she has drained his savings and is now trying to get hold of our money. When he had cancer, she did absolutely nothing for him, leaving it to their lovely neighbours and us, who live 170 miles away. But the main problem with her is...she's an aggressive racist.

Basically we avoid her as much as we can. Luckily, he always comes to stay with us on his own because we only have one spare room and she refuses to share a bed with him. Today however, he called to say she wants to come with him this time and he'll have to sleep on the floor. He's 78. I'm not comfortable with any adult guest sleeping on the floor in my house, it feels so wrong.

So...AIBU to ban her from the house. I don't think I shouldn't have to tolerate a racist in my house. In the 20 years we've known her she has shocked us with her racist comments every time we've seen her. She even makes comments outside deliberately so neighbours hear.

I feel that not standing up to people like this is unacceptable, especially now. I'm not going to keep quiet and listen to the venom she spouts, so there'll be a terrible row. I have challenged others in the past but it's been difficult to do so with her as I don't want to hurt my father in law. Although he moans about her constantly and is always relieved to get away, so I don't understand why he would inflict her on us!

My husband doesn't want to upset his dad but I think it will be worse if she does come. I would also be left on my own with her most of the day as my husband likes to take his dad out to pubs etc. Then, the three of us have a lovely time drinking and talking in the evening. When this woman is there conversation is limited - she's ignorant and uninformed - and my father in law is subdued.

My husband doesn't know what to do - I'm standing firm but he says that he would just put up with her for the sake of his dad. What do I do?

For additional context, she has been married at least four times before and I've been told that some of her previous husbands' children also hated her. She is literally the most toxic and selfish person I've ever known.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PurpleMauve · 15/01/2022 15:02

@jazzchilli
I appreciate your response.

So, you’d rather be forced leave your own home for the weekend than put your head above the parapet and speak your truth. IMO, this is no way to live. Are you going go away for the weekend every time?

Why would you be worried about being blamed when you and the people involved know you have done absolutely nothing wrong?

These are questions you need to ask yourself. I understand that people have different personalities and some do not like confrontation, but when things get to a point such as this something has to be said/done. Otherwise, it will just continue and get worse whilst you and your DH stand by and watch your FIL being subjected to the abuse. You will continue to be enablers for this woman’s evil behaviour. You know why this woman is on her 4th marriage and her own family member tried to warn you all!
If you and your DH have any conviction or genuine concern for your FIL which has not been lessened by any selfishness on the part of you and your DH, get a backbone and confront this awful woman.

You really do not care about racism if you won’t confront her. You most probably don’t see racism as your problem, as you are not a POC and, therefore, it does not have a negative effect on your life circumstances, choices or the lives any children/grandchildren you have or may have.

Continue to turn a blind eye to this and you’ll never be considered anti-racist.
You can say whatever you want on here, but only you and your DH will know whether you did the right thing.

Attitudes and opinions change over time (decades & centuries), so people alive now should not be blamed for the actions of their ancestors/predecessors. People can simply prove this by being on the right side of history now. This applies to all types of ism’s and abuse, not just racism.

jazzchilli · 14/01/2022 17:04

Just to clarify, I haven't said at any point that I think everyone of an older generation is racist. My personal experiences of racism have been with older people, however, and I feel ill equipped to deal with them as a result of my upbringing. As a 45 year old, my guidance at school was obviously not as comprehensive or nuanced as children of school age might receive now. And it does seem that others my age, or even older, had different guidance at school - that's great, unfortunately I feel mine was theoretical rather than practical.

Hence my problem in dealing with this toxic older woman. Which is also partly because I hear a lot of excuses as to why some older people hold on to their views or are just making comments that are 'naive', and I am absolutely certain that these (in any case) invalid excuses do not apply to this horrible person.

OP posts:
CaptainMyCaptain · 14/01/2022 08:58

I started school in 1959 and I don't think we were taught the word 'racism' at that time but definitely that people of differing coloured skin and origins were equal. My first school, in Harrow, was very racially diverse with many recent arrivals to the country. Looking back, as a teacher, I remember the teachers going out of their way to welcome these children. Although my parents were white British I was born abroad and included myself among the children who were 'born in another country', despite the difference in skin colour.

TurkeyRoastvBubbleandSqueek · 14/01/2022 07:46

@Valeriekat

"My generation - school in 80s and 90s - weren’t taught to challenge racism" Really? I went to school in the 60s and 70s and racism was totally challenged although perhaps not as aggressively as today. I did go to a religious school though. She sounds abusive, is he trying to leave her?
I went to school between 1963 and 1975, I did not hear the words racist or racism used once in school. None of our lessons ever mentioned different races, except for R.E. where we were obviously taught about the Jews and the Palenstines, and the Egyptians - that is how they were referred to in those days. We did not study any different religions than Christianity, and only about the beliefs of the Church of England. In secondary school I met my first RC friend, and my first Jewish friend.

At home it was worse. My Dad admitted to being racist for as long as I can remember. He said he would not be happy if people of colour moved next door to us (his terminology might have been slightly different), that I was never to marry a person of colour and that having a mixed race child (again different terminology) would be a disaster for the child as well as us. I know that from as far back as my memory goes, so at least to 7 years old, that I argued with him about it, and as soon as I could express myself properly I asked him if he actually thought a person with a different colour skin was an inferior human being, and he admitted that he did! I couldn't believe that he thought God would also think that people of colour were less important than us, but he did.

I never agreed with him, I would argue with him about it throughout the years (he was also a misogynist - although I only realised that a lot later - and, not surprisingly I suppose, he was also homophobic). Although I think far too many of his views were vile, and although my childhood was mainly horrible and scary, and although I think he treated my Dear Mum appallingly (as far as I know he was never physically violent - except for slapping me around the face once when I was 13) his scarcely hidden threats of how he was taught during the war to kill people with no weapons certainly terrified me when I was a child, but I never went low or no contact with him. That was for two reasons, my DM didn't divorce him until after I had been married and had children of my own, and I would never have gone NC whilst she was still living with him, and the other reason was because from a very young age I felt very sorry for him. I can't explain why here as it would be very outing, but he had an awful childhood himself. I also think that he had a severe mental illness that was never diagnosed, maybe because he had a very bright academic brain. An example of that is a way he would fall asleep at night, he would go over in his head the exact way to work out the formula for a quadratic equation - he obviously already knew the formula, but he could work out why it was what it was. Looking back I can tell that in some ways he actually had very low self esteem.

I am sorry, I seem to have gone off on a tangent a bit, I suppose I just wanted to show that 'in the old days' we weren't all taught about racism at school, but also despite our parents beliefs (my DM never really shared hers) we can think differently, even when quite small. Lastly, I wanted to point out to the OP that not all of the older generations are inherently racist. None of my friends or family in my age range are racist or homophobic.

jazzchilli · 13/01/2022 21:55

@PurpleMauve I accept everything you've said. I promise you that my husband and I have never stayed quiet on racism in any other situation, but yes we are guilty of not challenging this particular person in order to keep the family peace. I have been silenced for years in order not to upset my FIL. She definitely doesn't have an undiagnosed condition...she also bothers her GP with imaginary illnesses and they send her away every time, so my FIL tells me. So I expect they have explored her mental health at some point.

@Suzanne999 She avoided paying any NI (maybe tax as well) so has no contributions. I think she only worked in between husbands anyway.

I have expressed my opinions on her scrounging and questioned why she didn't look after him when he was ill but not the racism as I think he would just make excuses. He is definitely not racist but since he's been with her, my husband says he's become less open minded. I think that my FIL is deliberately not hearing that we don't like her, so I can't be sure what he thinks. He moans about her constantly and then the next minute is trying to get us to say hello to her on the phone.

@Thethreecs This is my biggest concern. I think she will refuse to let him come without her once she finally has it confirmed that she's not welcome. Many times the family have made arrangements with him and if they didn't suit her she banned him from coming.

My husband is first going to try to dissuade him from bringing her by saying that maybe he's being selfish but he just wants to spend time with his dad on his own. If he insists that she comes and I look after her, we either have the difficult conversation or I go away for the weekend. If he does come by himself, we obviously have to have the conversation so this is settled once and for all.

At the moment I'm leaning towards leaving for the weekend. I would prefer to address the issue but I also know that if everything blows up I will be blamed, not her racism and general abhorrence. I don't think my husband has the appetite for the fallout and I don't think my sister in law has the energy.

Everyone who has said the racism is a red herring - you're right! The other issues should be enough but there's always the possibility I would just be accused of being mean. Instead of challenging her directly I've always just stated that I don't agree or changed the subject. I think early on I used to just walk off and pretend I didn't hear her. I was quite young then, and it was usually in their house. It's very difficult to take a stand like that if you're a newcomer and you don't think anyone else will support you.

OP posts:
PurpleMauve · 13/01/2022 19:25

backtolifebacktoreality

‘I can't believe most of your responses are about where to put her up and to get a camping bed.

This post was about racism. Don't brush it under the carpet!!! If it's not called out each and every time then it will continue.’

^This.

I initially attempted to respond not long after this thread was created in the early hours but fell asleep.

Most of the initial posters who responded totally ignored the question, which is directly about racism. These are examples of micro aggression.
Imagine titling a post:
‘To ban racist relative from my house?
And the first four/five posters respond referencing money, hotels and blow up beds whilst deliberately ignoring the racism! This is exactly why racism exists!

OP - is your FIL also racist?
I assume he ignores his awful Wife’s racist views like you and your DH.

Your FIL is clearly being emotionally and financially abused. It‘s clearly coercive control.
If both you and your DH really felt that racism was unacceptable, either you and your DH would have challenged her racist views a long time ago and wouldn’t be having ongoing disagreements about it and would not have to consult the views of strangers on MN in order to make a decision.
Her prepared to have FIL sleep on the floor at his age and whilst recovering from Cancer is disgusting and cruel. The woman is just vile. She’d be banned from stepping foot in my home without the racism part. You’d do best to help him get him set up in a retirement home closer to where you live without the this awful gold digging witch ASAP.

I attended school in London in the 80’s & 90’s and racism was not ignored in school. If a child’s parents are racist/ignorant/uneducated, it is likely that the child will turn out the same. Do not allow racist behaviour to go unchecked or you are just as bad/complicit. You are condoning it by not saying anything/letting it pass.

Respecting your elders and not checking them regarding their ignorant views doesn’t mean shit when their behaviour is abhorrent.
I have an older family member who spouts racist, colourist, sexist, homophobic and other inappropriate things on a WhatsApp group and I call them out on it each and every single time, whilst also educating them with the facts/correct history. I and others suspect they have an undiagnosed condition but that is damn sure not an excuse to ignore it. Some younger family members have also started to challenge them too. Other youngsters who do not feel comfortable directly challenging this elder out of respect have left the WhatsApp group in disgust, which is also a response in itself.

Thethreecs · 13/01/2022 17:06

*Sorry I referred to him as your Dad once, I meant FIL.

Thethreecs · 13/01/2022 17:02

Does your fil know how you feel about her? Sorry if I missed that bit.

It's easy for us to say ban her, tell fil to come alone. But, how would your fil feel if you said she was banned and he could come? Would he come without her or would he stay home? There's no point him missing out on a visit to you if he feels he can't come without her, visiting you may be something he really looks forward to.

If he won't come without her, then you need to have a plan in place for when she's there. Your dh needs to realise how you really feel and how it's affecting you. He needs to be on the same page as you with regards to what will be said to her if she starts. No brushing it under the carpet and ignoring what she says. He can't leave you alone with her, either you all go out or stay in, yes it's lovely he is catching up with his Dad, they both probably need it but unfortunately you can't be expected to sit listening to her in your own home when she is being racist etc

Your Dad is unfortunately brainwashed at this stage. He's not going to see the light. He may have some thoughts about life without her etc but he won't leave her, too many years have gone by with her in his ear, so many people when they hit 70 settle with what they have, some are happy some aren't, some do leave, some re marry but it's easier to put up and stay.

All you can do is be there for him, which you are. Don't punish him because of her, by that I mean if she is not invited and he won't come without her, don't let him loose out.

You can easily sort out sleeping arrangements, I get the impression he would give her the bed anyway and sleep wherever himself. As others have said there's really good airbeds on the market, we've the high ones, sometimes my own dh sleeps on it as he has Rheumatoid Arthritis and a regular bed leaves him in agony, we have a very comfy mattress protector on it, it's like the fluffiest duvet on the base. You could do this for fil. Our king-sized airbed fits in our sitting room and trust me we don't have a massive house, make it super comfy, nice sheet and duvet, lots of comfy pillows, really go all out and make it special for him, on your spare bed I'd put cold sheets or those flannel ones, depending on her age, if menopausal definitely flannel sheets and one pillow.

I know it's wrong to have her there but if he decides not to come without her, he looses out the most.

SlidingInto2022sDMs · 13/01/2022 17:01

I think the problem you have is that FIL either condones racism or is actually racist himself. You're awfully forgiving of him when he's done nothing to show this bothers him and it wasn't a red line for him.

Thought the same thing with my last post. It's all well and good OP making a fuss about this person's racism but when no one else happens to care or see it as a problem, what does that make them? Seems the dislike FIL has for her has nothing to do with that part.

Anyway, OP, the solution seems to be something to discuss with your DH and come to an agreement. You both don't seem to have one yet.

PearlD · 13/01/2022 16:39

Should you invite an aggressive racist to stay in your house? That would be a fat no from me.

If your husband cant' find his backbone and is happy to be complicit in this then tell him you want no part of it, he can invite them on a weekend but you won't be around. Then take the kids away somewhere. Which will free up some bed space for the racist and the FIL, so they can take their pick where they sleep.

The alternative is that you stay, but be clear with husband that you will not be staying silent, as you need to give the kids a good example in the face of any hateful bile coming from her.

Deisogn · 13/01/2022 16:37

I think the problem you have is that FIL either condones racism or is actually racist himself. You're awfully forgiving of him when he's done nothing to show this bothers him and it wasn't a red line for him.

Personally I'd let her stay but I'd make it clear I didn't want to hear anything racist and ask her if she can agree to that upfront. If she won't then no I wouldn't let her stay and offend my neighbours.

I think you flat don't like her which is fine but racism might be a bit of a red herring. She won't stop being racist because you have a row with her but it will hurt FIL and limit the time DH gets with his dad. I don't think you rowing with her saves a single person any suffering or grief but it does cause your FIL quite a lot.

LakieLady · 13/01/2022 16:27

I have a "no racist speech" rule in my house. Any guest who says something racist gets told it's not acceptable here and I explain that I ask people to leave if they come out with racist shite. If they do it again, I ask them to leave.

Maybe you could try this OP, and kick the racist out if she keeps it up.

PinkSyCo · 13/01/2022 16:25

I would be honest with your FIL and tell him this woman is not welcome in your home for all the reasons you have given. You never know, being truthful with him may make him realise she truly is as abhorrent as he must deep down realise and it will give him the push to get rid of the nasty piece of work he stupidly married.

jazzchilli · 13/01/2022 16:24

@BashStreetKid I'm really sorry if I offended you. I am just talking about my personal experiences of racism and guidance. I didn't intend to make it sound as if I think everyone of a certain age is racist.

I know that's not at all true. It's just that these are the particular instances that I struggle to deal with in a way that doesn't ruin family relations.

OP posts:
Imissmoominmama · 13/01/2022 16:16

Sorry, there’s no room, and we won’t allow FIL to sleep on the floor.

PatriotCanes · 13/01/2022 16:11

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

I would just get dh to call his dad and say something along the lines of

"Dad you are welcome to stay any time, for as long as you like. We aren't able to accommodate X - practically, there is no room for her, and personally, we both find her offensive and hurtful to be around and honestly, we don't like the way she treats you"

Or you go away for the night, your FIL shares with your DH and your DH gets to take her to the pub with him.... which makes option 1 suddenly more popular.
jazzchilli · 13/01/2022 16:03

I do take on board what many of you are saying about generalising about specific generations. I'll avoid doing this as it is's unfair, as you say. I should say then, it's just the part of this issue I am struggling with the most. In this family, it's quite hierarchical I suppose and we're supposed to treat this horrible person with reverence for some reason. I do think if it were a younger family member they would have been put in their place by now.

OP posts:
saraclara · 13/01/2022 16:03

@BashStreetKid

This is how I feel. I don’t want to feel complicit in allowing this kind of hate to continue. My generation - school in 80s and 90s - weren’t taught to challenge racism and that was so wrong.

My children who were at school at that time were definitely taught that racism is totally unacceptable. Again, please don't generalise about generations.

100% agree. I'm 65 and am totally anti-racism and always have been. And my kids at school in the early 90s were definitely taught that racism was unacceptable from 5 years old. I remember being really impressed that it was brought into their lessons from the off.

You're really not helping yourself here.

Having said that, I'm going to focus on your FIL here. He's more important (in practical terms) than you making a stand about racism specifically re this visit.

You say he tries to escape her by volunteering etc. Maybe him visiting you is his escape too? Is she forcing him to bring her this time, even though he doesn't want to? Would you be doing him a favour by saying no?

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 13/01/2022 15:59

I would just get dh to call his dad and say something along the lines of

"Dad you are welcome to stay any time, for as long as you like. We aren't able to accommodate X - practically, there is no room for her, and personally, we both find her offensive and hurtful to be around and honestly, we don't like the way she treats you"

maddening · 13/01/2022 15:58

She is blunt herself, call and tell her that you don't like her and have no intention of seeing her again let alone in your house.

jazzchilli · 13/01/2022 15:55

@Valeriekat

"My generation - school in 80s and 90s - weren’t taught to challenge racism" Really? I went to school in the 60s and 70s and racism was totally challenged although perhaps not as aggressively as today. I did go to a religious school though. She sounds abusive, is he trying to leave her?
@Valeriekat sorry perhaps I'm being a bit ambiguous. I probably shouldn't have written that part late at night. I really meant that knowing that the instances of racism we were likely to experience at school age were from older relatives it would have been useful to get specific guidance on dealing with that. I definitely didn't. I do think this is where guidance often fails on many issues - it doesn't deal with the practicality of a situation ie. a thirteen year old challenging an older relative in their own home when you've been taught to respect your elders and be 'seen but not heard'. But then the school might have been accused of being presumptious etc.

Honestly though, part of me can't believe I'm struggling with this, it's very out of character and I even work on diversity issues in the workplace sometimes but still can't crack this one, maybe cos it's too close to me.

If anyone asked me the same questions I would say, ban her and get your father in law away from her. I think it's coercive control but again, when he says he's willing to do what she wants....what can we do?

OP posts:
BashStreetKid · 13/01/2022 15:54

This is how I feel. I don’t want to feel complicit in allowing this kind of hate to continue. My generation - school in 80s and 90s - weren’t taught to challenge racism and that was so wrong.

My children who were at school at that time were definitely taught that racism is totally unacceptable. Again, please don't generalise about generations.

BashStreetKid · 13/01/2022 15:52

Perhaps the blame is actually with my parents- I was threatened with consequences many times when I was about to challenge a racist. I don’t recall school offering any support. and when I asked my mum for advice she said ‘oh, you can’t ban her from the house just for being racist’. I honestly don’t think that generation get it, at all.

OP, generally I'm with you all the way, but you can hardly blame someone else for racism when you are being so blatantly ageist. You can't tar an entire generation with your mother's brush. I suspect I'm of her generation and, so far as I'm concerned, I certainly wouldn't have a racist as a guest and will call it out every time I come across it. And I know that I am certainly not alone in my generation in having those views. On the other hand, the likes of UKIP and the BNP have plenty of young adult racists.

Suzanne999 · 13/01/2022 15:47

This sounds as if it’s having a huge impact on you. Maybe try breaking it down.
Does FIL want to leave her, live on his own maybe close to you?
If yes, concentrate on that as once he leaves no one has to listen to her racist opinions ever again.
How old is she? Everyone over 66 atm has a state pension , the amount varies depending on number of years of NI contributions but there is a basic pension.
Do not give in and supply any money for deposits etc… as I’m sure your FIL won’t benefit.
Maybe your DH can speak to him alone ( or both of you speak with him if she doesn’t visit) and if he wants to leave, help him with that.
Good luck, it sounds an awful situation all round.

Valeriekat · 13/01/2022 15:09

"My generation - school in 80s and 90s - weren’t taught to challenge racism"
Really? I went to school in the 60s and 70s and racism was totally challenged although perhaps not as aggressively as today.
I did go to a religious school though.
She sounds abusive, is he trying to leave her?

Swipe left for the next trending thread