Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are these reasonable requests?

137 replies

Kaandii · 12/01/2022 21:36

Background...
long distance relationship for 5 months, we video call daily, we had an argument and this is what he text after I blocked him on Facebook

I LOVE YOU VERY MUCH AND YOU ARE THE LOVE OF MY LIFE. BUT FOR US TO BE IN A HAPPY HEALTHY RELATIONSHIP, THESE THINGS ARE VERY IMPORTANT, IN ADDITION TO THE THINGS WE'VE TALKED ABOUT AT THE VERY BEGINNING OF THIS. HONESTY, OPENNESS, TRUST, RESPECT, EQUALITY.

YOU SHOULD BE WILLING TO DO THESE:

* I WANT ALL THE PROMISES YOU'VE EVER GIVEN ME TO BE KEPT. YOU CAN'T EVER TAKE THEM BACK UNDER ANY CIRCUSMTANCES

  1. I wanna be unblocked and added on facebook (And need to be given the guarantee that such thing would never happen again on facebook or anywhere)

  2. I would like any pics of you taken with other men removed from facebook. (If you wanna keep (CHILD) dads pics for (CHILD) you can have them privately somewhere, not on facebook for everybody to see). I can't understand why you insist on publicly displaying pics of him I don't need to explain to you how much it hurts me.

  3. You have to work on controlling your anger. I will not tolerate you saying mean and abusive things to me. Remember how it made you feel when it was done to you.

  4. You should tell your doctor everything. You might need treatment for more than depression

  5. I should be able to ask you anything and you should be able to answer without getting mad and getting all defensive.

  6. You need to stop trying to dictate me what to do. I've been putting up with that only because I love you very much, not because I am scared of you or you can control me. We are equal in this relationship so we would decide things together while showing mutual respect.

  7. We need to be able to communicate under all circumstances. You need to answer the phone whenever I call. Communication is the key to everything.

I am certainly wanting to make this work. We have put in so much effort, time, feelings into this I don't want it all to go to a waste. I really don't want (CHILD) to think that I abandoned him too. I really wanna be around for him too. I hope this is how you feel too. I love you very much honey. I want us to be happy together forever.

Are his requests reasonable?

OP posts:
Tabasco007 · 13/01/2022 06:42

@Kaandii

Background... long distance relationship for 5 months, we video call daily, we had an argument and this is what he text after I blocked him on Facebook

I LOVE YOU VERY MUCH AND YOU ARE THE LOVE OF MY LIFE. BUT FOR US TO BE IN A HAPPY HEALTHY RELATIONSHIP, THESE THINGS ARE VERY IMPORTANT, IN ADDITION TO THE THINGS WE'VE TALKED ABOUT AT THE VERY BEGINNING OF THIS. HONESTY, OPENNESS, TRUST, RESPECT, EQUALITY.

YOU SHOULD BE WILLING TO DO THESE:

* I WANT ALL THE PROMISES YOU'VE EVER GIVEN ME TO BE KEPT. YOU CAN'T EVER TAKE THEM BACK UNDER ANY CIRCUSMTANCES

  1. I wanna be unblocked and added on facebook (And need to be given the guarantee that such thing would never happen again on facebook or anywhere)

  2. I would like any pics of you taken with other men removed from facebook. (If you wanna keep (CHILD) dads pics for (CHILD) you can have them privately somewhere, not on facebook for everybody to see). I can't understand why you insist on publicly displaying pics of him I don't need to explain to you how much it hurts me.

  3. You have to work on controlling your anger. I will not tolerate you saying mean and abusive things to me. Remember how it made you feel when it was done to you.

  4. You should tell your doctor everything. You might need treatment for more than depression

  5. I should be able to ask you anything and you should be able to answer without getting mad and getting all defensive.

  6. You need to stop trying to dictate me what to do. I've been putting up with that only because I love you very much, not because I am scared of you or you can control me. We are equal in this relationship so we would decide things together while showing mutual respect.

  7. We need to be able to communicate under all circumstances. You need to answer the phone whenever I call. Communication is the key to everything.

I am certainly wanting to make this work. We have put in so much effort, time, feelings into this I don't want it all to go to a waste. I really don't want (CHILD) to think that I abandoned him too. I really wanna be around for him too. I hope this is how you feel too. I love you very much honey. I want us to be happy together forever.

Are his requests reasonable?

He sounds needy and unreasonable , so yes move in. But I have to say, why would you block someone after an argument, this seems quite childish to me, would really piss me off, so maybe things haven't been a bed of roses for him either as some of his comments do suggest that maybe you have been a bit of hard work too - maybe not, but that's what I picked up. Either way, after 5 months it's not worth it, move on and I hope the next one is less paranoid and controlling and it works out for you. He suggests you have been unreasonable and angry, that's might have been in response to him being out of order, but if not then, it's always worth looking at your own behavior too. Good Luck OP
EishetChayil · 13/01/2022 06:33

Block him. Then do the Freedom Course.

JollyHolly30 · 13/01/2022 06:14

He sounds utterly pathetic.
What a turn off.

MangoBiscuit · 13/01/2022 06:13

Also, if he's this controlling after 5 months long distance, how bad is he going to be in a year? Or if you lived together?! You wouldn't be allowed male friends, he'll get to say what clothes you're allowed out of the house in, you won't be allowed to speak to anyone who expresses concerns about your relationship (because they're trying to tear you apart, or some such shit). Run, OP.

MangoBiscuit · 13/01/2022 06:11

Reasonable? Hell no, fuck that shit. Block him on everything and keep it that way.

CobraChicken · 13/01/2022 06:08

@CurtainTroubles

He sounds insane. Why have you let a virtual stranger meet your child?
^ This!

He sounds utterly terrifying. Run for the hills and move house if he knows where you live

notyouagainn · 13/01/2022 06:06

No it's controlling and coercive I would not entertain this person any longer.

CurtainTroubles · 13/01/2022 05:55

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

Luckingfovely · 13/01/2022 05:49

Grow up, FFS. If your level of analytical reasoning means you can't decide whether this guy is bad news or not, then I have to wonder whether you are responsible enough to look after a child.

Jesus Christ.

whymewhyme · 13/01/2022 05:47

Fuck right off, run for the hills!

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 13/01/2022 05:46

He's being very unreasonable. I wasn't sure which way to vote, if it was based on his behaviour in which case I'd vote he's unreasonable or whether it's asking if you are being unreasonable, in which case you're not.

CareBear50 · 13/01/2022 05:28

More red flags here than a communist party conference

Otter71 · 13/01/2022 05:26

The poll is going near 50/50 but I'm unsure if I picked the right option . These requests are not reasonable. He is trying to control you and not even liviing nearby. The benefit is it is easier to block him and never see him again. I would do that and look for a guy who actually likes you Nd respect you.

Piffle11 · 13/01/2022 05:17

Red flag, red flag, red flag. Run for the hills. This is the sort of thing that my ex would say: he was a jealous, coercive, gaslighting, controlling psychopath. I find it worrying that you have a child… Men like this do not take kindly to other men’s children. Should you ever be foolish enough to continue this relationship and move in together, your child will suffer.

mathanxiety · 13/01/2022 05:14

We are equal in this relationship so we would decide things together while showing mutual respect.

I am speechless.

Zero self awareness is only the tip of the iceberg here.

He is telling you that you are deeply flawed and hard work, yet on the other hand he wants a relationship with you that lasts forever. To put it very mildly, this person is not relationship material.

Tell him he is never, ever, under any circumstances to contact you again.
Block, never unblock, and be prepared to go to the police to report stalking.

LadyNell · 13/01/2022 05:08

I'd tell him to fuck off

Silvershroud · 13/01/2022 04:37

@Kaandii

Yes I did already post this, I wanted to add the entire message he sent, just in case
In case of what? That the responses you get here are different?
AngryApple · 13/01/2022 03:50

Wow! He needs to fuck right off.

Monty27 · 13/01/2022 03:48

@anyfucker
This has to be a joke.

violetbunny · 13/01/2022 03:43

Run as fast as you can in the opposite direction from this man.

As others have pointed out, it's completely hypocritical. You cannot "dictate" anything to him, yet here he is sending you a long list of demands and rules! Double standards everywhere, and screams of wanting to control you.

NumberTheory · 13/01/2022 03:30

.

If any of what he is implying about you in that message is true - if you do try to control or dictate, if you do lose your temper unreasonably - your best course of action is to get out of all relationships and work on yourself. Him even wanting a relationship with the sort of person he is painting you as is itself a huge red flag.

But regardless, no. Most of his demands are abusive and paint him as a controlling and nasty person.

ViaRia · 13/01/2022 02:34

No, this is not reasonable. It is carefully written to make it sounds reasonable - e.g. I agree with “communication is key” and that sounds perfectly reasonable but is quickly followed by “you must answer the phone whenever I call you” which is absolutely not reasonable.

I believe it’s purposely written like this to confuse you and make it sound like you are unreasonable if you reject this list of demands.

The end bit about not wanting your child to “feel that they have abandoned them too” is concerning. They are subtly using your child as emotional blackmail to make you stay / work things out.

RobertSmithsLipstick · 13/01/2022 02:26

Don't send anything back, don't engage, and keep him away from you, and more importantly, your child.
What on earth are you thinking getting them involved with this nut case??

Whatabambam · 13/01/2022 02:24

Is he 14? What a bellend.

Shamoo · 13/01/2022 02:11

Honestly the only response to that is a bunch of laughing emojis.

Swipe left for the next trending thread