Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think age 21 is not a 'young mum'?

665 replies

546321yeah · 12/01/2022 20:40

I fell pregnant with my daughter at 20, had her at 21. I am now referred to by a lot of people as a 'young mum'. I don't feel like 21 to have a child is young at all and 10 years on, I've gotten on with my life very well, just the same as I would have without having my child.

AIBU to think a young mum is someone about 15, 16, 17? Anything above that is normal age to have children?

OP posts:
Kite22 · 12/01/2022 21:37

YABU - seems fairly unanimous, 7 pages in, as well.

13 - 19 yr olds would be teen Mums.
I think 20 - 26/27 is a young Mum.

Whether that is a negative thing or not is a different question, but factually having a baby at 21 or 21 makes you a young Mum without a doubt.

Gymrats · 12/01/2022 21:36

Why would you mourn a life without your child in your 20s when that’s all you’ve known?

I think having children earlier is better personally. Your younger, fitter and have youth on your side, not all 20’s are thick and some have more life experience than most due to a shit upbringing (you know, in the real world)

The pros are that whilst you didn’t spend loads of money and get drunk falling behind the bar in your twenties or travelling through Spain, you get to do it in your 40s, when you have lots more money than you would have had in your 20s, so you get to do more, you also have a career/job and an established home in your 40s, so all the big things are sorted.

Obviously there are cons too, no which way is perfect.

GullyGawk · 12/01/2022 21:36

My 21-year old is finishing uni, most likely will want to travel a bit and have some sort of career to be independent before even thinking about children. I daily read on MN about youngish women (30+) SAHM with no work experience or education who can’t leave their abusive husbands (but all ’amazing dads’) because they have no real way out. No thanks.

tetleyteafan · 12/01/2022 21:35

@Gymrats

I just don’t see how people can have kids in their late 30s-40s, see you not really really tired?

I’m mid thirties now and don’t want a 3rd child based on the fact that I don’t want to start all over again, I don’t think I could hack it nowadays!

No, I'm not! Being 40 plus really isn't so exhausting Grin

OP Based on the fact I was twice your age when I had dc I'd say you are a young mum and I'm an ancient one Wink

dafey · 12/01/2022 21:34

It strikes me as odd that buying a house is seen a presequisite to having children. My DH is one of 6, his parents are in their 50s and they've only ever rented.

because it's often harder to buy when dc are on the scene.
Nothing wrong with renting in theory expect the lack of controls & reduced social housing make it nowadays often insecure & more expensive than owning.

RobotValkyrie · 12/01/2022 21:34

YABU

It's basic demographics, whether you like it or not. Average age for a first child is in your 30s, so 21 is de facto at the younger end of the age distribution.

And even in older times (medieval times), king and queens might have married and bred in their teens, but ordinary working people wouldn't get married till their mid 20s, they'd aim to work for a while first (including women) in order to get enough money to settle down.
So 21 would have been young back then too. It's only toffs who would marry their daughters in their late teens/early twenties.

Ionlydomassiveones · 12/01/2022 21:34

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Kanaloa · 12/01/2022 21:34

Depends. I had mine mid teens so by your reckoning (and most people’s) I was a ‘young mum.’

However, I still think 21 is a young mum. I don’t think that’s anything to be ashamed of but I hope my dd’s don’t go having children so young as I did. I wouldn’t change mine for all the world but I want my girls to have the experience of being young and having many options. If they want to go to uni and then take a big career and move to London to pursue their dreams. Or travel the world working, or try a career in football or go into theatre. These are all things people say ‘oh you could do that with a baby my cousin had a baby at 15 then went to oxbridge and did blah blah blah.’ But realistically for most younger mums these things aren’t possible.

Although I’ve coped and thrived as a young mum it takes away many of your choices. I had to go into low paid jobs because I didn’t have on call childcare and had no savings to support me, can’t get on the property ladder as easily etc. And most of the other young mums I knew didn’t have much money or family support so we all struggled one way or another.

Of course if you have your mum looking after the baby/a huge amount of savings then you could still go into further education and a good career but most people don’t have that. I’d advise my girls to have a sizeable savings if/before becoming mums because it certainly leaves you more vulnerable!

moggiek · 12/01/2022 21:34

I had my eldest the week before I was 20, in 1979. I had my youngest when I was I was 29. My notes for that pregnancy were marked ‘elderly gravidarum’. Changed days.

WindInTheWillows7 · 12/01/2022 21:33

@MaryShelley1818

21 is a very young mum. Would be unheard of in my friends group as at that age, people are still studying/just qualifying and getting ready to start careers/start travelling. Most people probably haven't got married yet or bought their first homes so definitely not in the position to have babies yet.
It strikes me as odd that buying a house is seen a presequisite to having children. My DH is one of 6, his parents are in their 50s and they've only ever rented.
Hayisforhorse · 12/01/2022 21:32

None of my friends had their first child younger than 30, and having started at 30 we are definitely at the younger end of the playground parents. Most had first child at 35-40.

At school there are a couple of 'young mums' who had children in their early twenties.That's different from teenage mums, who obviously had theirs before 20.

I suspect it depends on area though. Ours is mainly middle class and most women have pursued careers first. In other areas 30+ would be considered quite aged. A professional contact once described me as an 'older mother' when I was pregnant at 35, which I thought was a bit much... Or perhaps DC1 had aged me so much I looked positively geriatric.

Riverlee · 12/01/2022 21:32

Depends on the area you live in. When mine were babies (twenty years ago), we had a batch of mums who all had their babies under the age of 22, and several who were in their late twenties (not many mid-twenties). Very few mums had their first babies post thirty,

LynetteScavo · 12/01/2022 21:32

No one should feel old at 21.

At 21 DH had just bought his first house, but that's very unusual at that age. Most people don't have enough work experience or savings or stability aged 21 to be a parent. So yes, it is young. Even in the 1960's 21 was a young mum.

I'm surprised you say you got in with your life just as well as you would have without a child. I had my first aged 26, and my career and travel experiences, and savings took a back burner once I'd had a child. I don't know anyone personally who says they just carried in with their life the same as if they didn't have a child. If that was a case nobody would blink at teen mums.

dafey · 12/01/2022 21:32

Also historically women had more dc in the past whereas many just have one these days.

Puffalicious · 12/01/2022 21:32

Of course it's a young mum. It's not meant as a criticism, just that you are young to have a child these days. My niece was 20 too- she completely acknowledges she was young mum. She's just had her second at 29: She's the same mum she was- fabulous in my opinion- just older, the more common age. She was pregnant the sane time as me having my last, age 39, so was young in that regard.

user5656555 · 12/01/2022 21:31

To say... Young mum isn't negative. I get told I'm a young mum where I live. I take as a compliment

But as you can see from this thread, whilst I don't deny its accuracy, it's often sneered at, how many posts here have snide opinions and ill informed judgements alongside their so called factual stipulation. Hence why some younger mums can feel a bit defensive. I'm sure older mums would if it was pointed out to them they are "old mums".

SantaClawsServiette · 12/01/2022 21:31

As far as it not being pejorative - it often is, actually. Not in quite the direct way people sometimes feel with being called an old mum - in that case it's because our society sees calling women old as rude.

But there can often be implications that women who have children in their early 20s must be feckless, irresponsible, that they are wasting their youth, that they must not have anything better, like a career or travel, to do, etc. Sometimes there are suggestions that it's low class to have children younger, and not in a nice, observational way.

ChiefStockingStuffer · 12/01/2022 21:31

Of course it's young; even you write you 'fell pregnant' at 20 making it sound unplanned ... because you were so young!

Many are still at university/apprenticeships at that age or finding their feet with entry level careers...

gogohm · 12/01/2022 21:30

21 is young, my girls are are at university, dependant financially on me

billy1966 · 12/01/2022 21:29

Really young.

But I thought I was young well into my 30's.

I was both shocked and privately outraged when my consultant called my pregnancy a "geriatric" one!

Now well into my 50's, I do feel a bit geriatric.

MyQuietPlace · 12/01/2022 21:29

You are a young mum. Many women these days have their first baby when they're in their 30s.

I was 22 and almost 25 when I had mine - they're 40 and 37 now

WindInTheWillows7 · 12/01/2022 21:29

It's all relative. In certain middle class circles of the UK it would be considered young. I think it's a perfectly decent age to have a child.

doadeer · 12/01/2022 21:28

@doadeer

I would say 21 is a young mum, I think of 14/15/1) etc as a Teen mum.

Where I live most mums giving birth are late 30s so it would be seen as very young to give birth at 20

To say... Young mum isn't negative. I get told I'm a young mum where I live. I take as a compliment 🤣
lesenfantsdelesperance · 12/01/2022 21:28

You feel like you have got on with your life the same as you would have without having a child. But that's simply not true. Your life and your life experiences are necessarily different to the way they would have been had you not had a child. Do you think you are mourning that in some way? If not, why do you care so much about labels? Most people, as you can see from the comments, don't think 21 is anything other than a young mum. I know that some people are really into the whole, being judged etc etc and I don't get it. Why look to be offended?

cadburyegg · 12/01/2022 21:28

It is young, because it's younger than average and in some areas would be considered very young. I was 27 when I had my first which makes me younger than many, it's not an insult though

Swipe left for the next trending thread