Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think age 21 is not a 'young mum'?

665 replies

546321yeah · 12/01/2022 20:40

I fell pregnant with my daughter at 20, had her at 21. I am now referred to by a lot of people as a 'young mum'. I don't feel like 21 to have a child is young at all and 10 years on, I've gotten on with my life very well, just the same as I would have without having my child.

AIBU to think a young mum is someone about 15, 16, 17? Anything above that is normal age to have children?

OP posts:
jezziej · 13/01/2022 10:00

@sweetcheekweak
So you're just judgemental towards everyone? If someone implies your a disappointment to your parents, I think you'd try and defend yourself, as posters have done

Most young mothers don't go around bleating about how happy they are. They get on with their lives. But it does seem some posters are dead set on insisting young parents are missing out, can't possible be educated etc.

Why? I think we know.

sweetcheekweak · 13/01/2022 09:59

[quote jesuistot]@sweetcheekweak surely just a normal response to seeing criticism on these discussions, if a poster sees someone posting why having a baby at 25 or 45 is such a bad thing then it’s natural to respond with your own positive experience. Plenty of people have children in their 20s and are very happy and fulfilled and pleased they didn’t wait until later on. And vice versa.[/quote]
They are justifying it to themselves and others

It's natural, but still what's happening

Anyone who genuinely thinks it's better to have children just out of school is loco

Classicblunder · 13/01/2022 09:58

My DP worked evenings and weekends and then he just worked nights at weekends as the money was better. I worked Mon to Fri office hours

Makes sense but must have been hard not spending much time together

Classicblunder · 13/01/2022 09:57

I had my kids late - 36 and 38. Not by choice, we had a lot of fertility issues I really wanted to have children at more like 30 and 32 and I still sometimes feel sad that that didn't happen because I do think for me that would have been the sweet spot in terms of finances and energy levels but there we are.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 13/01/2022 09:57

@Classicblunder

I can see a lot of benefits to having children young - but the bit I don't really get is how you can afford to? My DH and I both have good salaries now in our late 30s but when we were in our early 20s we couldn't have afforded to pay for childcare and our parents were still working.
My DP worked evenings and weekends and then he just worked nights at weekends as the money was better. I worked Mon to Fri office hours
jesuistot · 13/01/2022 09:56

@sweetcheekweak surely just a normal response to seeing criticism on these discussions, if a poster sees someone posting why having a baby at 25 or 45 is such a bad thing then it’s natural to respond with your own positive experience. Plenty of people have children in their 20s and are very happy and fulfilled and pleased they didn’t wait until later on. And vice versa.

Classicblunder · 13/01/2022 09:55

I can see a lot of benefits to having children young - but the bit I don't really get is how you can afford to? My DH and I both have good salaries now in our late 30s but when we were in our early 20s we couldn't have afforded to pay for childcare and our parents were still working.

sweetcheekweak · 13/01/2022 09:55

@jezziej

The only people who think having children young is great are those who had children young, and they do that to validate their decisions.

Let's bash "old" mums next.

Anyway, nobody invited comment on their life choices. Those who insist young parents lives suck are strange, and I'm in inclined to think they're not entirely happy with having children later.

Could very easily substitute young for old, then you'd probably throw a fit.

Then you'd be wrong

I also feel the same towards the much older parents who also bend over backwards to justify why it's the best thing ever to have kids at 47.

Instead of being honest and saying 'they had other priorities and wanted to wait, understand the risks'

It's the ones who pretend it better to have them at 21, or 45 that are the ones trying to validate their own choices, that smacks of insecurity about their decisions.

No one with half a brain cell would honestly claim it's better to get pregnant at 20 than when you're more established in life, let alone a career or a solid relationship etc.

Couchpotato3 · 13/01/2022 09:52

This is a huge generalisation, but people seem to make comments about mothers whatever their age and circumstances. Being pregnant or in the company of a small child seems to give people a free pass to comment. Most of the time it's done with kindly intent but people can be very judgemental. Also these comments can 'press our buttons' if we're feeling a bit sensitive. It's hard to ignore, but try not to let silly comments from people who know nothing about you get you down!

jesuistot · 13/01/2022 09:51

@RedHot22

The only people who think having children young is great are those who had children young, and they do that to validate their decisions.

OR:
The only people who think having children when older is great are those who had children when older, and they do that to validate their decisions.

The truth is. Either is fine.

This. How would some commenters feel if this was about ‘older mums’ or ‘having kids in your 40s’ being bad or disappointing.
sweetcheekweak · 13/01/2022 09:51

@RedHot22

The only people who think having children young is great are those who had children young, and they do that to validate their decisions.

OR:
The only people who think having children when older is great are those who had children when older, and they do that to validate their decisions.

The truth is. Either is fine.

There is a middle ground

The other extreme often do the same.

It's just you always see younger parents justifying on these threads and it smacks of trying to validate a decision.

Those who said 'well I didn't want to travel anyway' - the issue is the option has been removed

Those who say 'some people don't want a career' - same as the above.

But at least they'll be a young grandparent Grin such a benefit Wink

jezziej · 13/01/2022 09:50

The only people who think having children young is great are those who had children young, and they do that to validate their decisions.

Let's bash "old" mums next.

Anyway, nobody invited comment on their life choices. Those who insist young parents lives suck are strange, and I'm in inclined to think they're not entirely happy with having children later.

Could very easily substitute young for old, then you'd probably throw a fit.

PunchyMojitos · 13/01/2022 09:48

I had my one (and likely, only) at 22. I definitely felt like a young mum. I mean, 21 is young and it's young to have a baby, but it doesn't mean it's wrong. I wasn't mentally prepared at all and certainly not in the right relationship. I did the best I could, but personally, I would have been a better first time mum in my 30's. I feel so much more self assured and confident now.

Everyone's different though.

AppleButterfly · 13/01/2022 09:48

In my mind it's about the normal age to become a mother. Around when my mother had me and I had my first. I hope my children have babies around that age, so I can enjoy my grandchildren and perhaps great grandchildren. But the average age go become a mother these days is 30 so I suppose its young. But I don't really consider it young.

RedHot22 · 13/01/2022 09:47

The only people who think having children young is great are those who had children young, and they do that to validate their decisions.

OR:
The only people who think having children when older is great are those who had children when older, and they do that to validate their decisions.

The truth is. Either is fine.

RobinPenguins · 13/01/2022 09:45

I assume you have time to look after your own children though?

Weekends, holidays, evenings

Yes, because I work fewer hours to do so. Once I don’t have small children I’ll be working full time again. I want to spend my own weekends, holidays and evenings with my children, not work during the week and then send them to their grandparents for evenings, weekends and holidays. When would I get to spend time with them if I did that.

jezziej · 13/01/2022 09:45

@crazyjinglist

It's very very young. I would be disappointed if my children had babies that young - I would feel they were missing out

I agree.

Who asked?

Confused It's on topic. People don't need to be asked individual specific questions on a chat thread in order to be allowed to give their opinions!

Nah nobody asked if you'd be disappointed - the question was is it young. Next!!

PattyPan · 13/01/2022 09:45

@RobinPenguins

I don’t get the “young grandparents can help more” thing. 40s is usually the height of peoples’ careers. I’m in my mid 30s now, in a decade time I expect to be working more than I am now and can’t foresee a situation where I’d have time to look after grandchildren.

I wish my parents who are grandparents in their late 60s were a bit younger for health reasons, there’s things they can’t do with my DD because of that. But they wouldn’t have been able to do them 10-15 years ago either, because they’d have been at work.

Agreed, I don’t get it either. I’m 27 now, hoping to have my first by 30. But my parents and ILs are in their 50s and still working, so can’t see how they would be able to help out.
phoenixrosehere · 13/01/2022 09:44

I can't ever imagine feeling disappointed because my children chose to follow a different life path to what I considered the "right" one. Unless it involved criminality!

Disappointment doesn’t mean the parents will stop loving their children or not support them though.

HacerSonarSusPasos · 13/01/2022 09:43

@sweetcheekweak, thanks for say what I didn't dare say and prepared to be flamed! Grin

RedHot22 · 13/01/2022 09:43

@RobinPenguins

I don’t get the “young grandparents can help more” thing. 40s is usually the height of peoples’ careers. I’m in my mid 30s now, in a decade time I expect to be working more than I am now and can’t foresee a situation where I’d have time to look after grandchildren.

I wish my parents who are grandparents in their late 60s were a bit younger for health reasons, there’s things they can’t do with my DD because of that. But they wouldn’t have been able to do them 10-15 years ago either, because they’d have been at work.

I assume you have time to look after your own children though?

Weekends, holidays, evenings

3scape · 13/01/2022 09:43

Natural fertility is approximately up to late 40's. 21 is still the younger end of that. Particularly in a society where education is generally up to early 20s and certainly up to 18 now. Accidents happen though. No point in people making a big deal out of it.

HacerSonarSusPasos · 13/01/2022 09:41

@RandomLondoner

It's on topic. People don't need to be asked individual specific questions on a chat thread in order to be allowed to give their opinions!

It is rude to imply that the OP has done something stupid and must be a disappointment to her parents. There are many cases were opinions that upset other people are justified, in this case they aren't.

But the poster didn't imply anything. They simply states how they personally would feel. Didnt make any generalisations.

Stop looking for any tiny reason to br offended Confused

sweetcheekweak · 13/01/2022 09:40

@RandomLondoner

It's on topic. People don't need to be asked individual specific questions on a chat thread in order to be allowed to give their opinions!

It is rude to imply that the OP has done something stupid and must be a disappointment to her parents. There are many cases were opinions that upset other people are justified, in this case they aren't.

Well they haven't made the most ideal decision have they?

The only people who think having children young is great are those who had children young, and they do that to validate their decisions.

HacerSonarSusPasos · 13/01/2022 09:39

[quote AllThingsServeTheBeam]@HacerSonarSusPasos undignified?! Who gives a shit. It's nothing like prostitution. You don't even need to leave your living room or go near any of the creeps that pay for it.[/quote]
I didnt say onlyfans was prostitution (though it is sex work). I said sugar babies are prostitution. And there's a lack of dignity in both.