Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask this at an interview?

196 replies

FriendshipsAreHardForMe · 12/01/2022 19:55

I have an interview coming up for a full time position (37hrs).

I'd ideally like to work part-time but was finding the right opportunity hard to come by so decided to apply to some full-time positions in hopes to negotiate down.

Anyway.... In terms of asking them if they'd consider me working part time...

Am I being unreasonable to not say anything about hours until I receive a job offer (if I do of course)? So as not to put them off too quickly. But maybe they'd be annoyed I've potentially wasted their time.

YANBU - wait until job offer to ask for P/T
YABU - mention P/T hours at the interview

Thanks 😊

OP posts:
notthemum · 13/01/2022 11:03

@Graphista

I've been on hiring side of things - I'd be annoyed you'd wasted my time to be honest. If you want part time apply for part time roles!
I haven't been on the hiring side of things like this poster. However like this poster I would be very fed up that you had wasted my time and that of other applicants. If hiring for a full time role that is what I would expect. As Grahista said "if you want part time apply for part time." Also depending on the information i may consider sharing this with others I knew in the business obviously not your name, but letting them know that this person had completely wasted my time and moving forward I would never consider them again.
BillMasen · 13/01/2022 11:00

@HerculesMulligann

This thread is so frustrating, and really shows what mothers are up against in the workplace.

Unfortunately I think for some organisations and industries change will only really happen when men start requesting 0.8 or compressed hours etc in greater numbers. And so employers won’t be able to simply go to their second preferred candidate, get a ft person, and not think seriously about flexibility.

I think there’s some truth in that

My experiences probably differ from the norm as I need flexibility (divorced, 2 kids with disabilities) and I make that very clear when discussing new roles. That means I filter out inflexible companies so the vast majority of the companies I’ve worked for have been great. And im always extremely clear I allow (encourage) the same flexible working in my teams.

But I know that’s self selecting. There may be lots of old school organisations out there where women needing flexible hours find it hard, and where men wanting flexible hours find it not open to them. That’s wrong

WomanStanleyWoman · 13/01/2022 10:58

@Isntitironic1

To those saying she’s wasting the employers time, sometimes employers actually prefer to have to part timers job share a role than one full time. I would explain the benefits of a job share to the employer.
Surely those employers put ‘jobshare preferred’ in the ad? Two little words, yet they save everyone a lot of time.
FriendshipsAreHardForMe · 13/01/2022 10:56

@SpookyScarySkeletons

Blimey, I do hope you can be up and about next year too. Wishing you all the best with your recovery/rehab.

Thank you for your advice 😊

OP posts:
BillMasen · 13/01/2022 10:53

[quote FriendshipsAreHardForMe]@alexashutup

I agree with you ethically. But in reality, I worry if I ask too early it will put them off me. I'll look difficult and they'd rather just say no and not have to consider it.

Whereas if I wait, they'll hopefully have time to want me (fingers crossed) and then not mind putting more time/flexibility in considering my request.[/quote]
Rock and a hard place I know

Differing views but mine, as a long time senior manager, and recruiter, is to start the discussion on flexibility as early as you can in the process.

HerculesMulligann · 13/01/2022 10:53

This thread is so frustrating, and really shows what mothers are up against in the workplace.

Unfortunately I think for some organisations and industries change will only really happen when men start requesting 0.8 or compressed hours etc in greater numbers. And so employers won’t be able to simply go to their second preferred candidate, get a ft person, and not think seriously about flexibility.

SpookyScarySkeletons · 13/01/2022 10:46

[quote FriendshipsAreHardForMe]@spookyscaryskeletons

I'm sorry to hear you've been recently disabled, although I'm glad there is a silver lining for you getting to see family more 😊

Family is so important and finding balance is definitely the goal.[/quote]
Thank you, I'm fighting hard and working with rehab to get me walking this time next year!

I think the WFH epidemic is one of the good things to come out of the pandemic for me!

And yes 100% you are right about the work life and family life balance.

Honestly I would go for the interview and when they ask at the end if you have questions that will be the right time to ask about flexibility and home//work balance. If they are a no then it's not the right place for you. But if you wait until offer and it's a no and they have already rejected other candidates it won't go down too well.

FriendshipsAreHardForMe · 13/01/2022 10:42

@ChampagneLassie

Hi *@FriendshipsAreHardForMe* I haven't read all your posts but scanned. I was offered a job and I asked about working 0.8 / 4 days a week and it was totally fine. I've got several friends who do 4 days and have asked at outset in FT roles. I think this is very do-able, less than this becomes trickier I think. At this stage I'd get them to offer you the job first. BUT is this a non-negotiable for you? Or will you take a FT role? I also previously started a role FT but with agreement that I could reduce to 5hr days / 25 hrs a week after a few months. I think most FT employees there is a degree of slack and increasing recgoniition that PT staff you get more bang for your buck
Thank you, it's reassuring to hear positive stories!

Luckily I can be flexible. I can work FT (providing I can find the childcare) and am willing to do it at a push for the right job. But I really would prefer PT, even if that's 0.8 or condensed hours. Happy to have an open discussion with them.

25hrs would be magical 😄

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 13/01/2022 10:36

@Hemingwayzcatz

I think they’ll be annoyed you’re wasting their time. If you want a PT job, don’t apply for FT roles. They want someone who can work 37 hours a week and you can’t, it’s pointless even applying.
A fair few pp have said they have done this and got reduced hours though
Hemingwayzcatz · 13/01/2022 10:35

I think they’ll be annoyed you’re wasting their time. If you want a PT job, don’t apply for FT roles. They want someone who can work 37 hours a week and you can’t, it’s pointless even applying.

ChampagneLassie · 13/01/2022 10:35

Hi @FriendshipsAreHardForMe I haven't read all your posts but scanned. I was offered a job and I asked about working 0.8 / 4 days a week and it was totally fine. I've got several friends who do 4 days and have asked at outset in FT roles. I think this is very do-able, less than this becomes trickier I think. At this stage I'd get them to offer you the job first. BUT is this a non-negotiable for you? Or will you take a FT role? I also previously started a role FT but with agreement that I could reduce to 5hr days / 25 hrs a week after a few months. I think most FT employees there is a degree of slack and increasing recgoniition that PT staff you get more bang for your buck

FriendshipsAreHardForMe · 13/01/2022 10:33

@spookyscaryskeletons

I'm sorry to hear you've been recently disabled, although I'm glad there is a silver lining for you getting to see family more 😊

Family is so important and finding balance is definitely the goal.

OP posts:
BlinkingBananas · 13/01/2022 10:33

Well, your approach isn't working, is it? You're also not listening to the vast majority of people on this thread.

I was trying to help you by offering a different perspective but it's clearly not welcome.

Good luck

FriendshipsAreHardForMe · 13/01/2022 10:28

@SE13Mummy

The job I'm currently in was advertised as full-time but I only wanted to work 0.8 (four days). In my application I stated this clearly and I had also spoken with the head of the organisation prior to application and interview. During the interview I raised it and was told they'd advertised a full-time position so I politely pointed out that my application very clearly stated I was only available for four days... and then mentioned I was aware it was the third time this post had been advertised as no previous candidates were suitable so maybe 80% of me might be preferable to 100% of no-one. I got the job.
I'm glad it worked out for you and perhaps opened their eyes to benefit of being flexible.
OP posts:
BlinkingBananas · 13/01/2022 10:26

I did actually have success a few months back. I went for a FT job, asked for 4 days at interview and was called later to say I'd have been offered it except the job was no longer available. Which was incredibly frustrating as finding PT roles is like finding a needle in a haystack. But I only mentioned it at interview because we were specifically talking about hours and id have had to lie to avoid it. Which of course I wouldn't do as it would be an awful way to start a job given I'd have had to ask afterwards anyway. I had intended not it mention hours.

I wouldn't really call that a success.

FriendshipsAreHardForMe · 13/01/2022 10:26

@BlinkingBananas

But you are expecting them to design the job around you. Unless you are a highly desirable candidate in terms of your skills and experience that just isn't going to happen.

You're assuming that employers are going to be falling over themselves to offer you a job so much so that you can dictate your hours. It all sounds a bit entitled really.

You're not being contacted by headhunters. You can't even find suitable part-time opportunities. When something isn't working you need a new approach.

Why do you have that attitude?! You don't have to insult me to make a point. That reflect more on you than me 👍

I'm not entitled, far from it. I probably won't get offered the job. But equally I don't want to rule myself out too soon. I have skills and qualifications, Im entitled to value myself.

Equally I haven't said at all they need to redesign jobs for me. 0.8 or compressed hours is hardly significant for lots of jobs.

I'll leave it there with you, but thanks for your insight...

OP posts:
SE13Mummy · 13/01/2022 10:26

The job I'm currently in was advertised as full-time but I only wanted to work 0.8 (four days). In my application I stated this clearly and I had also spoken with the head of the organisation prior to application and interview. During the interview I raised it and was told they'd advertised a full-time position so I politely pointed out that my application very clearly stated I was only available for four days... and then mentioned I was aware it was the third time this post had been advertised as no previous candidates were suitable so maybe 80% of me might be preferable to 100% of no-one. I got the job.

Brainwave89 · 13/01/2022 10:23

I work in financial services and I would not raise this at the interview stage. I do a lot of recruitment and if my aim was to recruit two part timers I would have specified this. Wholly different a few years in when you have demonstrated good performance.

FriendshipsAreHardForMe · 13/01/2022 10:22

@alexashutup

I agree with you ethically. But in reality, I worry if I ask too early it will put them off me. I'll look difficult and they'd rather just say no and not have to consider it.

Whereas if I wait, they'll hopefully have time to want me (fingers crossed) and then not mind putting more time/flexibility in considering my request.

OP posts:
SpookyScarySkeletons · 13/01/2022 10:21

[quote FriendshipsAreHardForMe]@spookyscaryskeletons

How did you find working compressed hours?[/quote]
Long days but to be honest I was already working more than my contracted hours anyway (unpaid) so it wasn't too bad. What really mattered for me was that I got Fridays off and could do the school run and speak to my DDs teacher and she knew who I was.

I worked 35 hours a week and that spread over 5 days meant that when I went for parents evening she didn't have a clue who I was! And my DD looked forward to Fridays because we could go to the park for a bit after school.

I work permanently from home now as I'm recently disabled and the office isn't wheelchair friendly. It suits me fine though! DD at high school now so I'm here when she gets home.

BlinkingBananas · 13/01/2022 10:20

But you are expecting them to design the job around you. Unless you are a highly desirable candidate in terms of your skills and experience that just isn't going to happen.

You're assuming that employers are going to be falling over themselves to offer you a job so much so that you can dictate your hours. It all sounds a bit entitled really.

You're not being contacted by headhunters. You can't even find suitable part-time opportunities. When something isn't working you need a new approach.

AlexaShutUp · 13/01/2022 10:20

@bertiebutton

I've done just this, recently, but I phoned and asked before I applied. I asked whether there was any way that the role could be done over 4 days ie 80%, or whether business need was such that it had to be full time. The hiring manager was actually pleasantly surprised, he felt it could be done part time, but felt he wouldn't get the right candidate if he'd advertised it as part time - and was delighted as he could use the rest of the budget elsewhere.

So yes, I'd ask, but before you go for the interview.

That's the way to do it in my view.

Years ago, before it had occurred to me to state clearly on the job descriptions what flexible options were available, I responded to several prospective applicants to say that we would consider part time or compressed hours. I have never agreed to this after interviewing someone, however!

bertiebutton · 13/01/2022 10:17

I've done just this, recently, but I phoned and asked before I applied. I asked whether there was any way that the role could be done over 4 days ie 80%, or whether business need was such that it had to be full time. The hiring manager was actually pleasantly surprised, he felt it could be done part time, but felt he wouldn't get the right candidate if he'd advertised it as part time - and was delighted as he could use the rest of the budget elsewhere.

So yes, I'd ask, but before you go for the interview.

AlexaShutUp · 13/01/2022 10:13

But also - I asked WHEN to ask for PT hours; interview or at offer. Not IF I should ask which is what lots are essentially saying (that I shouldn't as FT adverts are only for FT worker).

In my organisation, ft adverts are indeed only for ft workers, because we always state upfront if flexibility is an option. However, I still think it's fine to ask about this, because you can't possibly know that we have already considered it. My point is that it's better to ask at the beginning of the process rather than further down the line - not that you shouldn't ask at all.

FriendshipsAreHardForMe · 13/01/2022 10:11

@pangolina

I'm an HR manager and I would recommend bringing it up at interview. I recently recruited for a FT position and by happy coincidence, two of the best candidates both said at interview that they ideally would like PT job share. So, they both got the job on 0.5. If they had waited until the offer was made then one would already have been filtered out and the other would have been rejected if they couldn't have done FT. I find it hard to believe you've been a recruitment manager if you think screening, shortlisting, interviewing, and making a decision takes a max of 2 hrs per candidate.
I was recruiting for entry level jobs that weren't difficult to fill. Perhaps your sector/job roles are different.

That's good advice. I think I'll have to see how the interview goes.

OP posts: