Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pushy sales assistants asking you to take out "loyalty" or "points" cards

87 replies

nutelladreams · 12/01/2022 19:32

This has happened to me a couple of times recently. Each time in a shop just buying something really mundane like shampoo or tea.
Today I was buying a coffee gift set for a friend and got to the till.. Assistant asked if I had one of their "points" cards and would I like one. Thinking it would be something quick and painless I said "ok", expecting it would be the kind of thing where your card just gets stamps each time you shop there or something.
Assistant wanted my name (fair enough), but then also my address, email, phone number and DOB.
It was a busy shop and I'm uneasy about giving out so much personal data just for the sake of saving a few pence off my next purchase.
I asked the assistant to stop processing my "points" card and just let me pay for the item and leave in the end as she was faffing around asking for so much and struggling to spell my name, address and email. Sigh.
Other people get frustrated by this kind of stuff in a shop?

OP posts:
BlinkingBananas · 12/01/2022 22:28

@ilovepixie

Management don't care if it upsets the customer, their theory is ask 10 people and 2 will take it up. And the sales assistant is way down the bottom of the food chain, they have no power or input, if they complain to the management and say customers don't like it they are just told to suck it up
Vote with your feet...... Vote with your feet.......
ilovepixie · 12/01/2022 22:23

Management don't care if it upsets the customer, their theory is ask 10 people and 2 will take it up.
And the sales assistant is way down the bottom of the food chain, they have no power or input, if they complain to the management and say customers don't like it they are just told to suck it up

Mary46 · 12/01/2022 22:10

Very pushy in Superdrug! I find I end up holding up queue with all the questions to sign up. Sigh

elelel · 12/01/2022 22:00

I had an Argos store card in 2001 so they are definitely not new. Remember it vividly as I used it to buy things for DS first Christmas.

BlinkingBananas · 12/01/2022 21:59

@Ohshittt

I find Superdrug really bad for this at the minute, do you have a loyalty card? Would you like one? You will get your points from your shopping today? Are you interested in our perfumes with 20% off? No? We also have make up wipes on 3 for 2? Do you need any top ups or stamps? It's actually put me off shopping there now. Totally appreciate the asking if you have/would like a loyalty card but a no should be taken as no in the first instance. The hard sell on other products after just adds to the irritation!
Was just about to say Superdrug!

I've stopped shopping in store because of this. I do order online but had the hump last time as 2/3 of the products I wanted were out of stock including the packet of ibuprofen that necessitated me filling out a form. Tell me it's out of stock before I fill in the form!!!

phoenixrosehere · 12/01/2022 21:51

Argos was the business I was talking about, I worked there before I went to uni, so they've had the card since at least 2011/12. It's definitely not new, and the rates we're just as crap then, it's definitely a store credit card and unless they've changed things you don't collect points or get any reduced costs.

I’ve been going to Argos for just as long and never been offered one nor has my DH who has been going longer than me and have never been asked about the Argos card. Wonder if it’s by certain locations?

GirlInACountrySong · 12/01/2022 21:50

@TooManyPJs

I always find the responses to these questions bizarre on MN. They have to do it so we just have to accept it?!? Yes they are required to ask BUT their employer won't know that customers are unhappy with it unless you complain (Or just say no so the policy is ineffectual). And the only person you have to complain to is the shop assistant as they are the face of that organisation in that moment. You can't ask for the CEO or Jenny from marketing. They have delegated the responsibility for asking if customers want the cards and handling customer complaints to the shop assistant. Dealing with both is part of their job.

Doesn't mean you need to be arsy about it though. A polite complaint to say you don't like the policy, can you feed that back, or you don't like being asked for personal details in a public area, or just saying no thank you is sufficient.

they will just forget about you the minute you've left the store!!!

no store asisstant will waste their time 'feeding back' about a pissed off customer not wanting a card!!

DerAlteMann · 12/01/2022 21:39

Personally, I reckon this was one of the major causes of Debenhams going down the pan.

Offmyfence · 12/01/2022 21:38

[quote 100problems]@Offmyfence I was being sarcastic.[/quote]
🤦‍♀️ sorry hectic day in the office, has frazzled my mind!!

greenlynx · 12/01/2022 21:17

I usually say no thank you and then again no thank you about promotions items, pay for things and that’s it. I was in your situation once and learned my lesson.
However I’ve got a card at a Hotel chocolate shop recently and it’s surprisingly quick and painless, but the shop was empty and DD looked very interested in their products Smile that’s why I went for it.

Triplecheeseplease · 12/01/2022 21:12

I’m sure the majority of shop staff hate asking this type of stuff. And it’s absolutely no good complaining to them either. They may be the face of the organisation but the policies are usually set from head office and not even the managers have any power to change it.

I work for a company who force products at the checkout. Thankfully I have a mainly off till role but I don’t ask on the times where I’m on the checkout. I’ve been in trouble once or twice but It doesn’t bother me, I don’t agree with it and I like to feel like I’m doing my bit in fighting against itGrin.

I’d always encourage any customer who isn’t happy with the policy to complain to head office. Email/phone numbers are easy to find usually on receipts and just a polite no thanks to the assistant is all that’s needed.

elelel · 12/01/2022 21:05

You can say no thank you, or in your situation just tell them you will do it on one when you are home.

AllKindsOfWrong · 12/01/2022 20:59

I just say no thank you and go about my day.
What I find more shocking is that the poor staff get chastised or disciplined for not selling enough.

WabbitsAndWeasels · 12/01/2022 20:49

Argos was the business I was talking about, I worked there before I went to uni, so they've had the card since at least 2011/12. It's definitely not new, and the rates we're just as crap then, it's definitely a store credit card and unless they've changed things you don't collect points or get any reduced costs. I also feel by now that those that want one will have one (there's surely a limit pool of potential card holders), it also felt extremely irresponsible to be offering it knowing it was a terrible deal. I imagine the majority of people using cards like the Argos card struggle to get other forms of credit. I genuinely did hate having to push it and I imagine most other retail workers hate it too but I didn't have a choice if I wanted to keep my job.

Also complaining to the poor retail worker in front of you that you don't like to be offered the card will do other as will escalating it to a manager. Head office doesn't care, as long as the store is meeting it's targets they're happy. From their point of view, so what if a few people so inconvenienced they complained, we sold some cards along the way (I think they should be way more restricted and regulated). Consumers have far more powers on social media than retail works have in store.

phoenixrosehere · 12/01/2022 20:31

Argos are the worst. The woman asked me several times if I wanted a card. She explained it wad a loyalty card and you collect points. Her exact words were "just like a boots advantage card" So I said ok sign me up. While she was filling in my details I scanned the leaflet. It wasn't a points card at all but more like a credit\store card

Is this a new thing? I’ve never been asked about a card. The most they ask is if I purchased an additional warranty for an item otherwise I’ve just picked up my stuff with a thank you and left.

Sparklesocks · 12/01/2022 20:31

Years ago my sister worked in Topshop and the staff would be chastised for not selling enough store card accounts. Always felt off to me that they had to really push them when most of the customers are quite young women and are being asked to open a line of credit with high interest rates because you get money off your purchase for it. The managers would tell staff to compliment customers on their outfits etc to make them feel like friends so they were more likely to sign up. They’d have student discount nights on the late shopping days and heavily push them there too as the idea you could get more clothes for clubbing etc.

As others have said, often the loyalty card stuff/till selling comes from senior staff and you can get told off for not doing it. It’s just a bit unpleasant on both sides as I don’t know many people who want to hear the sales pitches as a customer (especially if they’ve been queuing a while), and equally a lot staff often feel uncomfortable having to do that spiel.

MrsGatsby99 · 12/01/2022 20:29

@nutelladreams YANBU
I read your post as you were not annoyed about the employee asking at all but expected a quick stamp type loyalty card when really it's the company's way to gather data. Some aspects of modern life are super tedious and repetitive. I get it.

Just a quick, oh, sorry, i don't feel comfortable about giving my personal data for this, thanks for the offer anyway. Smile, shrug.

Bittercloudylemonade · 12/01/2022 20:24

Argos are the worst. The woman asked me several times if I wanted a card. She explained it wad a loyalty card and you collect points. Her exact words were "just like a boots advantage card" So I said ok sign me up. While she was filling in my details I scanned the leaflet. It wasn't a points card at all but more like a credit\store card. When I pointed this and said I didn't want the card. She was annoyed at me. My friend later went to work there they have target numbers of people to sign up. She said her boss tells them to say anything to get people to sign up. I wonder how many people they have duped into getting a store card.

Sportslady44 · 12/01/2022 20:18

How about when they ask you if you want any chocs or perfumes etc that they have by the till? Annoying.

WabbitsAndWeasels · 12/01/2022 20:15

I have absolutely had the same experience as other retail workers here, fortunately I don't work in a role where I have to ask anymore. When I did you absolutely had to ask every single customer if they either had a card or if they wanted me to sign them up. This job was a store credit card with terrible rates so I felt terrible pushing it but I could actually lose my job if I stopped doing it (there's no protection under 2 years employment).

It's just as frustrating for the retail worker as it is for you if not more. I don't want to ask you, I don't want to push a crap card and I certainly don't want to be asking the same question for 9 hours a day. Just say no in future unless you actually want the card and are prepared to give the details (how are they supposed to look you up by name alone when you inevitably forgot your card?) And take the time needed. What cards have you signed up to recently where they just need your name?

TooManyPJs · 12/01/2022 20:01

I always find the responses to these questions bizarre on MN. They have to do it so we just have to accept it?!? Yes they are required to ask BUT their employer won't know that customers are unhappy with it unless you complain (Or just say no so the policy is ineffectual). And the only person you have to complain to is the shop assistant as they are the face of that organisation in that moment. You can't ask for the CEO or Jenny from marketing. They have delegated the responsibility for asking if customers want the cards and handling customer complaints to the shop assistant. Dealing with both is part of their job.

Doesn't mean you need to be arsy about it though. A polite complaint to say you don't like the policy, can you feed that back, or you don't like being asked for personal details in a public area, or just saying no thank you is sufficient.

Ohshittt · 12/01/2022 19:58

I find Superdrug really bad for this at the minute, do you have a loyalty card? Would you like one? You will get your points from your shopping today? Are you interested in our perfumes with 20% off? No? We also have make up wipes on 3 for 2? Do you need any top ups or stamps? It's actually put me off shopping there now. Totally appreciate the asking if you have/would like a loyalty card but a no should be taken as no in the first instance. The hard sell on other products after just adds to the irritation!

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 12/01/2022 19:55

@Offmyfence - I think PP was being sarcastic Grin

100problems · 12/01/2022 19:53

@Offmyfence I was being sarcastic.

LuckyLuckyWoman · 12/01/2022 19:52

I work in a store that has loyalty cards. It is part of my job to ask. I do just that, if you say no I process your transaction, no hard sell from me.

I get asked in lots of shops, I find no thank you suffices.