Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If there was an election tomorrow, who would you vote for?

590 replies

SecretKeeper1 · 12/01/2022 19:23

Obviously the Tories are a complete shitshow, but Labour aren’t a lot better and I couldn’t hand on heart vote for either in good conscience right now.

So… IF a snap election was called, like in December 2019, who would you vote for? Would it make a difference to you if Boris was replaced as Tory leader? Would you even bother voting or maybe go for a totally different national or local party?

Just curious!

OP posts:
cafedesreves · 15/01/2022 10:54

@hopperrock

You seem worried that a lot of women think the same

I think the numbers are very small and probably wouldn't have any effect on an election result given how few votes actually count in a meaningful way. But yes I am amazed that people call themselves feminists while supporting a party whose policies have caused such harm to so many women over the last 10+ years. The only explanation I can think of for a feminist knowingly making life worse for other women is that if you're relatively unaffected by who's in power and don't care much for others, maybe you can afford such principles and live comfortably with them. Many women are not in that position.

But it's not the only issue... you could say the same about people voting Tory knowingly making life worse for poor people.
WorriedMumsDontSleep · 15/01/2022 10:53

You are voting to get rid of the NHS

As someone who has been on the sharp end of the NHS I have seen how unfit for purpose it is. I mean, really really bad. Due to the NHS not providing proper care for me or my child we're facing a lifetime of inadequate care. The NHS seems to be a scared cow but it's not working for the most vulnerable (again, I have direct experience of this, not some hypothetical). It needs to be thoroughly reformed and perhaps that. Might mean another system. Lots of other countries have different CA options that work well. American system and the British ones aren't the only option and I, like many others have been permanently damaged by them trying to keep it afloat when it's inadequate.

hopperrock · 15/01/2022 10:42

@MrBIobby

Oh that will be it hopperrock youve nailed it. I'm sure labour will be successful next time as the general public don't care about self ID. Those damn non feminists don't know anything about anything.

Lolz.

Well they seem to be polling pretty well at the moment so maybe your Vote Conservative message isn't cutting through. Or maybe there aren't very many of you 🤷‍♀️
MrBIobby · 15/01/2022 10:38

Oh that will be it hopperrock youve nailed it. I'm sure labour will be successful next time as the general public don't care about self ID. Those damn non feminists don't know anything about anything.

Lolz.

hopperrock · 15/01/2022 10:34

You seem worried that a lot of women think the same

I think the numbers are very small and probably wouldn't have any effect on an election result given how few votes actually count in a meaningful way. But yes I am amazed that people call themselves feminists while supporting a party whose policies have caused such harm to so many women over the last 10+ years. The only explanation I can think of for a feminist knowingly making life worse for other women is that if you're relatively unaffected by who's in power and don't care much for others, maybe you can afford such principles and live comfortably with them. Many women are not in that position.

MrBIobby · 15/01/2022 10:27

You vote as you see fit, I'll vote as I see fit. You seem worried that a lot of women think the same and will vote the same as me? But if any single other party was twam then a lot of us would vote for them?

It does seem to be the way. Labour voters etc shouting at Tory voters and calling them all the names under the sun and not listening to any concerns or reasons. Tory voters don't really bother to engage back in the same way because they can't be bothered with the raging conflict and don't need to. They just quietly go and vote Tory anyway. And labour voters are left scratching their heads wondering what went wrong for them. A story as old as time.

Justkeeppedaling · 15/01/2022 10:17

In their favour, non politically, the Tories have had 2 women pms, and have a good balance of non white and/or non male people in the cabinet.

Terfydactyl · 15/01/2022 10:17

But yeah, self ID

You vote as you see fit, I'll vote as I see fit. You seem worried that a lot of women think the same and will vote the same as me? But if any single other party was twam then a lot of us would vote for them?
This is not difficult. And btw trying to shame people on their voting choice will just turn people away from you.

Justkeeppedaling · 15/01/2022 10:15

No idea.
I'm a life long Conservative voter, but really don't know if I'd vote for them again.
I don't know who else I could vote for though. Definitely not Labour. Their stance on the gender ID thing will play a BIG part in my decision because on a day to day "running the country" basis, they are all of a muchness.
I doubt the shenanigans at No 10 would have been very different if Labour were there - quite a few seem to have been instigated by civil servants.

1haudyerwheesht · 15/01/2022 10:10

SNP Grin

ScribblingPixie · 15/01/2022 10:06

The OP asked how we, as individuals, would vote, not how we think all other women 'should' vote.

MrBIobby · 15/01/2022 10:03

Yep absolutely self ID. Because when men can identify as women, women no longer have any rights. If parties like labour want to attract more voters they know what they have to do. Otherwise they can just fuck off.

hopperrock · 15/01/2022 09:58

It's a struggle we can minimise by not letting them in until they change their minds first.

And in the meantime, it's a big 'fuck you' to the millions of women who will suffer at the hands of the tories. Anyone whose feminist principles lead them to vote Tory is completely deluded imo. You are voting to get rid of the NHS and to erode workers' rights. To enrich the rich at the expense of the poor. You are condoning corruption and dishonesty, racism and hypocrisy. But yeah, self ID.

cafedesreves · 15/01/2022 09:53

Self-ID will be very far from the minds of many women who have been most damaged by this Tory government when they come to take a decision. Benefits cut, schools underfunded, NHS underfunded.
I am gender critical myself but I feel that if you asked women at food banks what their main concerns were I would guess it wouldn't feature.
So someone saying that surely all women will vote Tory makes me feel very upset when people are suffering to such an extent.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 15/01/2022 09:48

Enough secondary school teachers will tell you how the pushing of trans and gender stereotypes is harming vulnerable children. The most vulnerable child I know is damaged from turbulent family and going down the path that usually leads to surgery and hormones. She's autistic too.
I have a child that is not neuro typical and a recognised disability and would never normally vote conservative as they are less likely to serve the need we have . However, I can't vote to benefit my child when it will actively harm another. I'm really caught between a rock and a hard place. The only thing I can hope is that Labour sort it out but it's a bleak hope.

That's why it's so insulting when people harp on about the vulnerable. I am not well off and have a disability in the family. That people use my pain to further their agenda, which will harm other vulnerable people is shortsighted at best.

Terfydactyl · 15/01/2022 09:46

@Pendolino

So we continue to work our arses off to bring the issue into the light for the nonsense it really is. We make it abundantly clear to the candidates what we want to see. No self ID. Strong safeguarding for women and girls. Stay on their case, don’t let up. It is being used as a tactic to divide the left. Can’t you see this?

As for me, I work with vulnerable people and I can’t face another term of picking up the pieces. People are dying and being made destitute due to Tory policies and mismanagement of the economy / pandemic / Brexit.

Its literally in the last year made mainstream news and even then it's being hushed up. Some of us have been doing this for a very long time. I noticed in 2004 and some women saw what was happening before that even. In all those years we have made barely a dent in getting this mainstream. If we could introduce the entire world to it now we would see a shift in a matter of months. Until that happens it's all be kind. I admire your optimism however if this is a tactic to divide then it a fucking long term tactic.
Pendolino · 15/01/2022 09:39

So we continue to work our arses off to bring the issue into the light for the nonsense it really is. We make it abundantly clear to the candidates what we want to see. No self ID. Strong safeguarding for women and girls. Stay on their case, don’t let up. It is being used as a tactic to divide the left. Can’t you see this?

As for me, I work with vulnerable people and I can’t face another term of picking up the pieces. People are dying and being made destitute due to Tory policies and mismanagement of the economy / pandemic / Brexit.

Terfydactyl · 15/01/2022 09:37

@Pendolino

I care very much about womens rights and self ID, but I’m sensing it is being used as a tactic to divide the opposition vote. I think we are playing into Tory hands.

Let’s do whatever we can to get them out, then tackle the self ID issue hard after. I hate that our choices are so stark. We need a better class of politicians with more honesty, integrity and intellect.

Possibly it is being used as a tactic. Cant rule that out. But we can all only vote on the information we have. Put it this way if boris came out a stated twaw I would not vote, I'd spoil my vote but none of the parties would benefit from me.

As for changing things after say labour get in, well its admirable but it's now been tried for around a decade maybe longer.
Women have been thrown out of the parties for wrong think.
Enough female MPs have stated that if we think twam then we shouldnt bother voting for them. Short sighted of them but ya know it's their party, they are entitled to state this, and I'm entitled to not vote for them.
Plus if say labour get in then rules and laws can be changed quickly and we then have to change their mind on twaw AND then row back changes to laws. It's a struggle we can minimise by not letting them in until they change their minds first.
It's not like we all dont have better things to do than convince a lot of people who believe they are right that actually women matter and are equally as important as men.

Nemorth · 15/01/2022 09:34

I used to decide my vote based on which party would create the best policies for the most vulnerable person I know.

That tended to be Labour but they can go take a long walk off a short pier now!

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 15/01/2022 09:29

Let’s do whatever we can to get them out, then tackle the self ID issue hard after.

How on earth would we do that having voted in the people who are relentlessly pushing it at numerous opportunities, despite one of their own members receiving death threats for recognising women as a sex.
If they won't protect or listen to their own members (Rosie Duffield) why would they listen to the electorate after they've been voted in. They won't even change course to win votes, that's how set they are and they have told women who won't vote for that reason they don't want their bigoted vote.
They have put ideology before winning power. If you disagree with the ideology not a good idea to hand them power. They've told us what they will do with power. Listen.

3scape · 15/01/2022 09:28

Green.

Nemorth · 15/01/2022 09:24

Alba.

Scottish independence and support for women.

Pendolino · 15/01/2022 09:22

Nuking the lot of them is a bit strong but I get the sentiment that a clean slate is needed. A government of people who are grounded, with a blend of wisdom and real world skills that don’t centre solely around self promotion and cronyism.

Pendolino · 15/01/2022 09:20

I care very much about womens rights and self ID, but I’m sensing it is being used as a tactic to divide the opposition vote. I think we are playing into Tory hands.

Let’s do whatever we can to get them out, then tackle the self ID issue hard after. I hate that our choices are so stark. We need a better class of politicians with more honesty, integrity and intellect.

JustcameoutGC · 15/01/2022 09:19

I think we should just nuke westminster whilst parliament is sitting. Yeah, there is the odd decent GP who might get vaporised, but i really think we need clean slate. And to send a strong message that feckless idiots should stay in the City and out of politics