Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If there was an election tomorrow, who would you vote for?

590 replies

SecretKeeper1 · 12/01/2022 19:23

Obviously the Tories are a complete shitshow, but Labour aren’t a lot better and I couldn’t hand on heart vote for either in good conscience right now.

So… IF a snap election was called, like in December 2019, who would you vote for? Would it make a difference to you if Boris was replaced as Tory leader? Would you even bother voting or maybe go for a totally different national or local party?

Just curious!

OP posts:
LizzieW1969 · 15/01/2022 12:40

I’ll be voting Labour, in order to get the Tories out; that’s the only party that can beat them in my constituency. I’m not comfortable about it because of their stance on self ID, but this lot really need to be voted out.

liliainterfrutices · 15/01/2022 12:36

@ItsSnowJokes

I live in a true blue area. And literally all the constituencies that surround us are true blue. I will vote Labour but it is a waste of time, we will never be able to oust the shit that is the Conservative party from here. They could literally come and shit on everyone's Xmas Dinner and they would still be voted in. It makes me weep.
So do I but am taking hope from North Shropshire . . .
Terfydactyl · 15/01/2022 12:23

So all you actually wanted were one word answers?
Could have specified that at the beginning and none of us would be here.

ItsSnowJokes · 15/01/2022 12:20

I live in a true blue area. And literally all the constituencies that surround us are true blue. I will vote Labour but it is a waste of time, we will never be able to oust the shit that is the Conservative party from here. They could literally come and shit on everyone's Xmas Dinner and they would still be voted in. It makes me weep.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 15/01/2022 12:10

@SecretKeeper1

And be fed up that a thread about the next election has become all about self ID?

Indeed. I started this thread more as a “bloody hell, we’re stuck between a rock and a hard place” and didn’t think it would turn into full on rant complete with essays and manifestos.

Sorry, everyone! Blush

Well that's fairly naive of you. Starting a conversation about politics will always lead to debate. What is more, there is nothing wrong with debate. If you set up such a thread again you need to stipulate one word answers in your op. Then accept you'll attract less engagement because who's going to read through twenty pages of party names.
SecretKeeper1 · 15/01/2022 12:06

And be fed up that a thread about the next election has become all about self ID?

Indeed. I started this thread more as a “bloody hell, we’re stuck between a rock and a hard place” and didn’t think it would turn into full on rant complete with essays and manifestos.

Sorry, everyone! Blush

OP posts:
heelforheelandtoefortoe · 15/01/2022 12:05

Labour

Only because the only other alternative is SNP and I loathe them. Don't agree with independence or the GRA.

Not a fan of Raynor at all but Starmer seems okay (albeit wooden).

A vote for the Tories is wasted up here

Terfydactyl · 15/01/2022 12:05

@hopperrock

So we are many yet we are also few, yet we take over every other issue.

Surely it's not difficult for you to understand that one person can think that the numbers are small and another person can think that there are more than 6? And be fed up that a thread about the next election has become all about self ID?

Right , so you post why you'd vote for whoever and I post why I'd vote for whoever and then someone inevitably says ( to the gc crowd) that we are wrong because and usually that we are bigots and a bit more lambasting to really drive home that we are wrong. And then gc poster defends their reason and then it all looks like a takeover. I mean that's the whole debate idea I guess. Oddly it's very rare that GC poster derides non GC poster for their reasons to vote, usually we just say something like well you vote as you see fit and I'll vote my way. And any lurkers see this played out time after time and potentially go look at the womens rights board, and fall down rabbit hole and then come out GC. Que sera sera
ilovesooty · 15/01/2022 11:57

@hopperrock

So we are many yet we are also few, yet we take over every other issue.

Surely it's not difficult for you to understand that one person can think that the numbers are small and another person can think that there are more than 6? And be fed up that a thread about the next election has become all about self ID?

They don't care. They're the equivalent of the voice in the pub or at meetings that insists on talking over and pursuing their own preferred line of conversation. I'm getting fed up with it and it seems I'm not alone in that.
hopperrock · 15/01/2022 11:48

So we are many yet we are also few, yet we take over every other issue.

Surely it's not difficult for you to understand that one person can think that the numbers are small and another person can think that there are more than 6? And be fed up that a thread about the next election has become all about self ID?

hopperrock · 15/01/2022 11:38

Oh well if they're polling well, maybe your time has come nearly eh?

I am not a Labour voter, so not my time, no.

Terfydactyl · 15/01/2022 11:33

@hopperrock

You seem worried that a lot of women think the same

I think the numbers are very small and probably wouldn't have any effect on an election result given how few votes actually count in a meaningful way. But yes I am amazed that people call themselves feminists while supporting a party whose policies have caused such harm to so many women over the last 10+ years. The only explanation I can think of for a feminist knowingly making life worse for other women is that if you're relatively unaffected by who's in power and don't care much for others, maybe you can afford such principles and live comfortably with them. Many women are not in that position.

It feels like a much louder voice than that, and one which is trying to drown out any other issue. And make no mistake: a spoiled ballot is a vote for the incumbent candidate - more than likely a Tory

So we are many yet we are also few, yet we take over every other issue.

Or we are many, we care about women and this is our line in the sand?
I suppose when a GE finally happens we will see.

DestroyerOfHouseplants · 15/01/2022 11:25

Such a hugely difficult question. I think there's nobody credible in Labour and echo others' points here about the erosion of women's rights with Lib Dem and Greens. If Tories could get rid of their hideously outdated, public school elite cronies and actually move into the modern age then they'd have a chance. As they stand they are mostly just dinosaurs led by a morally bankrupt baffoon.

ilovesooty · 15/01/2022 11:13

And @MrBlobby,of course you can use your vote as you please. Your agenda is clear and you can pursue it at the ballot box. Other views and voices should be heard..

ilovesooty · 15/01/2022 11:10

We do really well for the 6 of us
It feels like a much louder voice than that, and one which is trying to drown out any other issue. And make no mistake: a spoiled ballot is a vote for the incumbent candidate - more than likely a Tory.

Pendolino · 15/01/2022 11:10

@WorriedMumsDontSleep

You are voting to get rid of the NHS

As someone who has been on the sharp end of the NHS I have seen how unfit for purpose it is. I mean, really really bad. Due to the NHS not providing proper care for me or my child we're facing a lifetime of inadequate care. The NHS seems to be a scared cow but it's not working for the most vulnerable (again, I have direct experience of this, not some hypothetical). It needs to be thoroughly reformed and perhaps that. Might mean another system. Lots of other countries have different CA options that work well. American system and the British ones aren't the only option and I, like many others have been permanently damaged by them trying to keep it afloat when it's inadequate.

Conservatives are all for total free market ideology and would have us take on US style insurance healthcare. I spent a while in the US and it is really expensive and has all sorts of downsides.

A politically more centre government would probably still want to introduce reform, but would look at European models that are centered on the quality of care and value, not just profit.

MrBIobby · 15/01/2022 11:09

[quote Likkleredridinghood]@MrBIobby and that surely says it all. Quietly voting for the status quo which benefits them and screws the rest of us.[/quote]
Self ID screws over all women. And I will use my vote as I want. As you will use yours. You(general you) are not persuasive in changing my mind and certainly don't encourage me to vote labour. If people really want more labour votes then it might be helpful for them to consider a better approach. When labour come out and back women's rights rather than denying their existence as a sex class, then I may reconsider. Until then, no chance. And going over the same old ground over and over again had no point or value to me. So yes. I will vote Tory. As will many others. As you will see.

ilovesooty · 15/01/2022 11:05

@hopperrock

It's a struggle we can minimise by not letting them in until they change their minds first.

And in the meantime, it's a big 'fuck you' to the millions of women who will suffer at the hands of the tories. Anyone whose feminist principles lead them to vote Tory is completely deluded imo. You are voting to get rid of the NHS and to erode workers' rights. To enrich the rich at the expense of the poor. You are condoning corruption and dishonesty, racism and hypocrisy. But yeah, self ID.

Absolutely. Self ID. How single minded you must be if nothing else influences your voting and you can ignore child poverty, the NHS, the erosion of women's rights (including pregnancy and maternity rights), crime (including crimes against women) , to mention just a few issues.
Pendolino · 15/01/2022 11:04

Spot on @ilovesooty

The Tories couldn't give a stuff about women's rights.. I think the priority is to get them out, in the interests of all who are vulnerable.

Largethighsbadeyes · 15/01/2022 11:02

Labour. I'd prefer lib dem but I live in a Labour stronghold so it would be pointless.

Have never votes Conservative so won't be starting now

Pendolino · 15/01/2022 11:02

I’ve been following the self ID issue since well before the pandemic started. In the past few years I would say it has been weaponized for political ends.

Activists including many here have done a brilliant job in exposing the flaws. My view is that we keep pulling the issues into the light and engaging the public. The masses don’t want the consequences of self ID, like mixed sex hospital wards or unfairness in sport. We can win this. An election hasn’t even been called but until that point I will be campaigning and telling politicians what I want to see.

I’m with @cafedesreves and @hopperrock in that Tory policies have hurt many, and women disproportionately.

Terfydactyl · 15/01/2022 11:00

No. I'd just like the odd political thread to acknowledge the full range of issues instead of the single issue self ID voice drowning everything else out

So theres so few of us we wont swing the election and theres so many of us we drown out all other issues?

We do really well for the 6 of us .

Likkleredridinghood · 15/01/2022 10:59

@MrBIobby and that surely says it all. Quietly voting for the status quo which benefits them and screws the rest of us.

ilovesooty · 15/01/2022 10:56

@Pendolino

I care very much about womens rights and self ID, but I’m sensing it is being used as a tactic to divide the opposition vote. I think we are playing into Tory hands.

Let’s do whatever we can to get them out, then tackle the self ID issue hard after. I hate that our choices are so stark. We need a better class of politicians with more honesty, integrity and intellect.

Well said. The Tories couldn't give a stuff about women's rights.. I think the priority is to get them out, in the interests of all who are vulnerable.

And now of course we have the expected riposte that women who care about women's rights are being silenced. No. I'd just like the odd political thread to acknowledge the full range of issues instead of the single issue self ID voice drowning everything else out.

MrBIobby · 15/01/2022 10:54

Oh well if they're polling well, maybe your time has come nearly eh? Grin

I'll direct you back to this point

Tory voters don't really bother to engage back in the same way because they can't be bothered with the raging conflict and don't need to. They just quietly go and vote Tory anyway.

Enjoy the rest of your day 😉