Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If there was an election tomorrow, who would you vote for?

590 replies

SecretKeeper1 · 12/01/2022 19:23

Obviously the Tories are a complete shitshow, but Labour aren’t a lot better and I couldn’t hand on heart vote for either in good conscience right now.

So… IF a snap election was called, like in December 2019, who would you vote for? Would it make a difference to you if Boris was replaced as Tory leader? Would you even bother voting or maybe go for a totally different national or local party?

Just curious!

OP posts:
Coronado2 · 13/01/2022 18:52

I think all those saying none or split ballot should consider that they would likely be helping the conservatives secure a win.

Terfydactyl · 13/01/2022 18:50

@Sabire9

JulesJules - how many trans sex offenders have been housed in women's prisons?
How many would be too many?
Lolamento · 13/01/2022 17:25

Conservatives. I do not care I know the other are much worse. Think BJ as Mayor ( bad) Sadiq Khan ( terrible and a waste of space) unfortunately LIB DEMOCRATS are just like Labour.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 13/01/2022 17:02

Meant trans women (males) in male estate. Women not a human shield.
Shows how important facts(Lammy thinks men can grow a cervix) and simple language (Starrmer thinks women is a dirty word) are when it is difficult to put across a simple fact like no male rapists in women's prisons.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 13/01/2022 16:58

That it's a miniscule amount of people makes it all the more shocking. Every Lia Thomas and Laurel Hubbard means a woman has lost out. One woman too many.

A prisoner took the moj to court because they were assaulted by a man who claimed to be trans that they were housed with.
Trans men should be housed in the male estate, with other vulnerable males. If they have particular needs that can't be met there a trans wing is not beyond the realms of possibly. Funny isn't it that the moj absolutely don't allow trans men in the male estate. It's like they understand males are a threat to female people.

Your 'I'm a midwife' speech is bizarre. No one is saying that there are not issues in midwifery. I'm allowed to be concerned about more than one thing at once.

By the way, my midwife ignored my request for the male trainee doctors not to come in and giggle whilst I was shitting myself. So as a bloody midwife you should be more sensitive to the dignity of women.

You should also know that however they identify only women get pregnant and have the various issues that go along with that.

If you don't know that I think you are in the wrong job.

Check out fairplayforwomen if you want stats.
Educate yourself.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 13/01/2022 16:54

None of them

I've never not voted in 47 years, but right now I couldn't support any of them

AssignedBlobbyAtBirth · 13/01/2022 16:50

Why should vulnerable women have to accommodate males in prison with them?
Giving up single sex categories and spaces only harms women. If you really do work in maternity services think it's tragic how little thought you give to women

SecretKeeper1 · 13/01/2022 16:47

Erm… this wasn’t meant to turn into a trans rights debate.

Thanks to all those who appear to be as politically homeless as I am, without writing essays on the matter.

Good job there isn’t going to be a snap election tomorrow is all I can say, seems a lot of us would be in a right pickle Grin

OP posts:
Sabire9 · 13/01/2022 16:40

"My friend gave birth
Well that's one massive factor that women alone shoulder the burden for.
Can't protect maternity rights, discrimination against child bearing age women if we are suddenly in a category with men who will never be discriminated against for that."

I work in maternity.

The biggest issue women are facing right now that's negatively affecting their safety & their experience of birth is a shortage of midwives. I know quite a few midwives and none of them have an issue with caring for pregnant trans men. Firstly because these parents only make up a vanishingly small percentage of patients, but mainly because most midwives are deeply compassionate people who only want to help women & birthing people to have a safe and happy experience of pregnancy & birth.

"You are letting the fact that you know a person who has a mental health problem"

They don't have a problem. They're not depressed or ill, they're functioning extremely well in their career and have happy relationships with family, partner & friends.

"It's already playing havoc with women on the receiving end. Men stealing sports places"

Is this a really big problem? Can you put a figure on it? Only a minuscule percentage of the population are trans, and only a minuscule percentage of trans people are involved in competitive sport.

"men incarcerated with women"

Where do you think the very tiny number of incarcerated trans women should be held?

"That you know a person who wants to identify out of their sex does not justify shafting the women on the sharp end of this".

Have you got any non-hypothetical examples of where this is happening?

StoneofDestiny · 13/01/2022 16:36

SNP

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 13/01/2022 16:05

My friend gave birth
Well that's one massive factor that women alone shoulder the burden for.
Can't protect maternity rights, discrimination against child bearing age women if we are suddenly in a category with men who will never be discriminated against for that.

You are letting the fact that you know a person who has a mental health problem/and or a political position cloud your acknowledgement that naming some men as women is a gift to the men's rights movement.

It's already playing havoc with women on the receiving end. Men stealing sports places, men incarcerated with women, men winning women's awards and positive discrimination places.

That you know a person who wants to identify out of their sex does not justify shafting the women on the sharp end of this.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 13/01/2022 16:04

@OhdearOhdearOhdearIndeed

Anything but not Tory.

I hate voted for all 3 major parties at one point. I can't get behind the Tories now after Brexit, austerity, rising poverty and the rampant corruption. Ever again. The last 10 years have been awful for the country and we have gone backwards.

I would love a coalition most of all. I'm aware of the drawbacks of this, but I think we need it to progress and I do think Keir Starmer is getting better. Haven't heard enough about Lib Dems of late, which is a shame as I don't know what they stand for.

Self-ID is an issue for me too, but If it is between self-ID being an issue, or corruption, incompetence, increasing poverty, lack of progression, increasing inequality and blatant lying, I think I would be happy to accept the self-ID problem over those issues. We can do something about that, but if there is a shitty attitude to the general public and our leading politicians are only in it for what they can get out of the system and think their voters are all idiots, I can't foresee any positive change in the future.

^ I agree with most of this, despite never having voted Tory.
Welliesandpyjamas · 13/01/2022 16:04

To answer OP, not the conservatives. No way. No more.

If no party sorts out the self ID issue...spoiled ballot 🤷🏻‍♀️ tricky one that needs thinking about

BashStreetKid · 13/01/2022 15:59

People who would vote Tory because of Self ID are the absolute epitome of anti-feminism. If you seriously think the Conservative party supports women's rights, you are absolutely deluded. Voting them in again would effectively give them carte blanche to cut down or get rid of maternity leave and maternity rights, and when they revise the Equality Act as they want, such women's equality rights as might be left will be severely weakened.

AssignedBlobbyAtBirth · 13/01/2022 15:56

If a transwoman is in a female space it is not single sex
A transwoman will never need a smear test, pregnancy care, any gynaecological care or anything connected to what makes me a woman- female biology
Including any male in female statistics renders them useless. The only thing that connects me with every other woman on the planet is our shared biology.

BashStreetKid · 13/01/2022 15:55

I would vote LibDem, but that is purely because in our constituency they have the best chance of unseating the Conservative MP. Anywhere else I would vote Labour.

Sabire9 · 13/01/2022 15:54

"A thousand and one things that have only and will only ever effect women, the cunty type, will now be shared with "women"

Can you give me an example of things you don't think we should share with trans women?

Sabire9 · 13/01/2022 15:51

"If this reality had been accepted from the start we wouldn't be in the ridiculous position of having to pretend males can be females"

My friend gave birth to a daughter who recently had gender reassignment surgery and now presents as a man. Their name is a male name. They are identified as 'male' on their birth certificate. They are in a stable, happy long term relationship with a person who was born a woman who identifies as a female heterosexual.

I'm wondering what changes you would like to see in the way this trans man is treated by the law, by services and by friends, family, colleagues? And how would these changes benefit you, me and other women. In a concrete sense? I'm not aware how accepting this person as they wish to be accepted takes anything from me so I'm struggling with your stance.

AllThePogs · 13/01/2022 15:49

The polls are showing Labour is way in the lead.

And anyone who calls themselves a feminist but votes Conservative because of self ID, has a very poor understanding of feminism. The rising poverty alone will see more children and mothers in emergency accommodation and more women involved in the sex industry.

Terfydactyl · 13/01/2022 14:20

@Sabire9

Can anyone who wouldn't vote Labour (assume would be ok with another 5 years of Conservatives) say which current Labour policy is unacceptable to them. Unacceptable enough to continue with our current kakistocracy.
Self Id. Every single time. If you cannot tell who a woman even is, then how can you campaign for better treatment of women. How can you quantify the pay gap. Define rape. Especially now as several "women" have committed rape. Prepare for maternity services. Stats on women only cancers will be very skewed. Stats on maternity issues will also be very skewed. A thousand and one things that have only and will only ever effect women, the cunty type, will now be shared with "women"

I say fuck that.

OhdearOhdearOhdearIndeed · 13/01/2022 14:20

Anything but not Tory.

I hate voted for all 3 major parties at one point. I can't get behind the Tories now after Brexit, austerity, rising poverty and the rampant corruption. Ever again. The last 10 years have been awful for the country and we have gone backwards.

I would love a coalition most of all. I'm aware of the drawbacks of this, but I think we need it to progress and I do think Keir Starmer is getting better. Haven't heard enough about Lib Dems of late, which is a shame as I don't know what they stand for.

Self-ID is an issue for me too, but If it is between self-ID being an issue, or corruption, incompetence, increasing poverty, lack of progression, increasing inequality and blatant lying, I think I would be happy to accept the self-ID problem over those issues. We can do something about that, but if there is a shitty attitude to the general public and our leading politicians are only in it for what they can get out of the system and think their voters are all idiots, I can't foresee any positive change in the future.

Sabire9 · 13/01/2022 14:16

"Transwomen are males who have different needs."

Can you say more please?

I was born a woman. My needs are:

  • access to appropriate medical care
  • secure housing
  • safety from assault
  • a secure income
  • education.

What different needs does a trans woman have because she wasn't born a woman?

AssignedBlobbyAtBirth · 13/01/2022 14:09

And I would love to see the LP and society in general put so much effort into support for disabled people, poor people, children who are in, or have been in, the care system

AssignedBlobbyAtBirth · 13/01/2022 14:08

Women are a distinct sex group and unless that is accepted there is no way of ensuring women's needs and rights are met
Transwomen are males who have different needs. The same goes for men and transmen.
Accept difference and accept women are entitled to representation. If this reality had been accepted from the start we wouldn't be in the ridiculous position of having to pretend males can be females

LondonWolf · 13/01/2022 13:11

Tory. There’s no other choice for me due to Self ID.