Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect my child to make progress in reception?

142 replies

LovelyMoans · 12/01/2022 19:12

Even if they started the year already where they need to be by the end of it, in reading?

The attitude from school seems to be that because DC has reached the required level for reception, they should just sit at it all year while others catch up.

It's implied I'm pushy for questioning this because "DC is doing well, why are you concerned".

Doesn't every child deserve to make progress from wherever they started the year?

Particular keen to hear views from teachers as to what I'm missing as I feel I'm going a bit mad.

OP posts:
LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 12/01/2022 21:01

@AshLane

You could ask other questions than just a retell. Looking at the pictures and asking DD questions based on them or asking why she thought such a thing happened or identifying the who, why, when, what, how from the story.

Again depending on focus and definitely not as part of phonics. I've just had a school severely criticised for a staff member doing the above with a child reading phonetically - because by doing the above, this is not consistent with teaching children to read phonetically.

Interesting, I'm not UK based, didn't occur it would be different 🤦. Our readers aren't specifically phonics based, we start with sight words and there is sounding out, but not within a specific phoneme and also inferring from pictures for words the child doesn't know yet.
pinksquash13 · 12/01/2022 20:54

Experienced teacher here. I don't think it's great from the teacher. Agree that it could be due to new gov phonics expectations. There's always uncertainty when something new comes along. Perhaps worth trying to speak to the literacy coordinator next to ask them to explain the system for moving up as you feel your child knows more sounds and is ready for blue books. Developing inference skills will be a priority for a good reader in reception and I agree that the lower books are more of a challenge to develop these skills so I'd state that as a reason to move up. Perhaps like someone else said your child isn't showing their best skills with the teacher. Could you record your child reading fluently and then share with them to check you're seeing the same thing.

samwitwicky · 12/01/2022 20:54

We bought a pack of reading books with the different colour levels (think along the lines of Biff, Chip & Kipper).

As DC read through them we moved them up a level at home, regardless of where they were at school.

Didn't notice any downside to this. Maybe you could do something similar?

Looneytune253 · 12/01/2022 20:49

My dd was always very very able and she always got to a certain point and then they made her wait. The comprehension just isn't there even if the reading ability is. I really wouldn't worry. Play is supposed to be the focus until year one so I would just wait and see what year one brings

AshLane · 12/01/2022 20:48

I don't understand this. They won't be covering the sounds my DC already knows at school until at least year 1. How does this allow for stretching more able pupils?

@LovelyMoans - I've posted the full guidance above to give you the understanding you need.

LovelyMoans · 12/01/2022 20:48

Like what should school do when a child has already learned all the letter sounds on the syllabus for reception reading?

Stop teaching them?

OP posts:
CouldIhaveaword · 12/01/2022 20:46

[quote MananaTomorrow]@CouldIhaveaword was told a similar version for my dc.
This didn’t work for him and the areas where I predicted he would struggle, he did.

Learning self discipline by learning an instrument doesn’t always transfer into self discipline for school for example, esp when things are always coming very easily to the child.[/quote]
That was exactly the problem with DS. We were told that at sooner or later he would come across something that he found difficult and wouldn't be able to cope. He messed about at school and then It happened at university. He had a real meltdown. Couldn't work out how to study. I'm not sure that we could have done anything more to avoid this, but I do think that the passion he had developed for other activities helped to pull him through.

AshLane · 12/01/2022 20:46

You could ask other questions than just a retell. Looking at the pictures and asking DD questions based on them or asking why she thought such a thing happened or identifying the who, why, when, what, how from the story.

Again depending on focus and definitely not as part of phonics. I've just had a school severely criticised for a staff member doing the above with a child reading phonetically - because by doing the above, this is not consistent with teaching children to read phonetically.

LovelyMoans · 12/01/2022 20:46

School are really being criticised (by LA or OFSTED)when children are being given home reading books which contain letter sounds which they haven't YET been taught in class. This may explain why they are cautious to simply move a child to the next book band.

I don't understand this. They won't be covering the sounds my DC already knows at school until at least year 1. How does this allow for stretching more able pupils?

OP posts:
LovelyMoans · 12/01/2022 20:45

If you could afford to fund new reading books for the school can’t you just buy a set for your DC?

It's the attitude towards progress that bothers me & what it means further down the school. I'm sure I'll get grilled for saying it but I do not think it's ok for my DC to be left coasting.

OP posts:
AshLane · 12/01/2022 20:42

@Mollymopple

Teacher here- be aware that there has been recent changes and guidance relating to the teaching of reading & phonics. School are really being criticised (by LA or OFSTED)when children are being given home reading books which contain letter sounds which they haven't YET been taught in class. This may explain why they are cautious to simply move a child to the next book band. In practice this means children learn a set of letter sounds and then get given the books containing those same letter sounds in the following weeks. Home reading books after often misunderstood in their purpose- they are to practise and consolidate what children have already learnt ( to make that learning stick) rather than to learn lots of new words. A rough guide which reading specialist teacher used was that a child should know approximately 90% of the text and just 10% should be new learning. I always offer to give a 2nd book at the same level for extra text. Could your child have 2 yellow books? Of course any reading and sharing of books will help enormously with reading skills, but I would say try not to let your push kill the enjoyment
I agree.

It is really worrying that there seems to be a mix of phonics programmes at the 'Op's school' and also that some of the advice on here also suggests a range of programmes.
I really wish that this without up to date knowledge didn't offer incorrect advice.

This is the latest reading framework. (July 2021) which we are all working to.

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachmentdata/file/1000986/ReadinggframeworkTeachinggthefoundationssofliteracyy-_July-2021.pdf

MolkosTeenageAngst · 12/01/2022 20:41

@LovelyMoans

Lego I did actually offer personally to the governors to fund new reading books.... and was turned down.... I kid you not
If you could afford to fund new reading books for the school can’t you just buy a set for your DC?
LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 12/01/2022 20:40

@LovelyMoans

It could be a simple as the Reception classroom only has books up to a certain level and the next ones are in the Year 1 classroom and there isn't enough to go round.

This really seems like a poor excuse to not challenge a child.

What is her inference like? Is she able to answer questions about what she has just read, or tell you about the story on her own words? Is she reasonably fluent. They are the main reasons I’d have for not moving a child on. Sometimes a child can be brilliant at decoding, but that is quite different from really reading.

DC is fine at this but tbh on yellow level books there's not a huge amount to infer or retell. Pretty fluent. Will have an odd unfamiliar word they sound out but not loads. I do think comprehension is weaker area, its partly why I'd like harder/longer books, there's more to discuss.

You could ask other questions than just a retell. Looking at the pictures and asking DD questions based on them or asking why she thought such a thing happened or identifying the who, why, when, what, how from the story. You could also read your own books to her and ask her questions based after each page or so of reading.

Our DC who was a natural reader was paused on levels twice in reception, so her comprehension skills could catch up. Reading ability can outstrip comprehension. I would expect DC to be given more complex readers that suit their skill levels as long as comprehension and fluency is good at the current level.

womaninatightspot · 12/01/2022 20:39

I know what you mean my child's progress was slow in P1 (Scotland so no reception) although an excellent reader they seemed happy just to plod her through the stages. Now in P2 and was moved up from stage 3 books to stage 6 in October. I do think she should of been assessed and progressed during the course of P1 but we just read at home plus did reading eggs so I don't think she's lost out.

Marleymoo42 · 12/01/2022 20:36

Teacher here. Your child should be making progress in reading and in my opinion should be moved to an appropriate level. However difficult to say what that appropriate level is without knowing the child.

I often have parents telling me what reading level their child should be on. It's a difficult one. Sometimes a child's comprehension level does not match their word reading level. Sometimes the parent (and then the child) are very focused on moving through the bands rather than just enjoying the books. As a general rule, the book going home should be a book they can read fluently so she maybe reading more challenging books in class.

Early reading books are matched to phonic phases. She may be kept on yellow to consolidate what they are learning in phonics right now.

The most important thing is that she likes the books she's reading.

INeedNewShoes · 12/01/2022 20:36

We’ve had similar here. DD is getting to the point that she can read most of the books on her shelves at home to me (picture books rather than reading books) but school are really measured in their approach to her school reading books, which she can generally read straight off (and understand). My worry is that she's just going to lose interest in the school books as there's barely a storyline in the 16 simple pages of Biff and Chip. I've decided that rather than only reading the books given by school that I'll just give DD the opportunity to read some more interesting content with me (simple chapter books etc.). She does a lot of reading in the course of a day anyway - things like recipes, instructions for games, messages in cards etc.

Mollymopple · 12/01/2022 20:32

Teacher here- be aware that there has been recent changes and guidance relating to the teaching of reading & phonics.
School are really being criticised (by LA or OFSTED)when children are being given home reading books which contain letter sounds which they haven't YET been taught in class. This may explain why they are cautious to simply move a child to the next book band.
In practice this means children learn a set of letter sounds and then get given the books containing those same letter sounds in the following weeks.

Home reading books after often misunderstood in their purpose- they are to practise and consolidate what children have already learnt ( to make that learning stick) rather than to learn lots of new words. A rough guide which reading specialist teacher used was that a child should know approximately 90% of the text and just 10% should be new learning.
I always offer to give a 2nd book at the same level for extra text. Could your child have 2 yellow books?
Of course any reading and sharing of books will help enormously with reading skills, but I would say try not to let your push kill the enjoyment

C152 · 12/01/2022 20:29

That's a strange attitude from the school. Yes, I would expect your child to progress, not just coast along not improving for the rest of the year. Is there a school library? If so, can your child borrow more appropriate books from the library rather than just relying on what the class teacher puts in the book bag? If not, can you go to your local library with your DC and pick out some better books together?

MananaTomorrow · 12/01/2022 20:27

@CouldIhaveaword was told a similar version for my dc.
This didn’t work for him and the areas where I predicted he would struggle, he did.

Learning self discipline by learning an instrument doesn’t always transfer into self discipline for school for example, esp when things are always coming very easily to the child.

CouldIhaveaword · 12/01/2022 20:16

All of the pupils will, sooner or later, be able to read. At that point they can pick and choose books at a level that they enjoy. No need to rush.

I was advised to stretch DS in other directions to address different aspects of his development. For example, learning an instrument at his own pace to teach the value of practice and self discipline. He was also quite clumsy and struggled to anticipate, so ball games helped with this.

Funnily enough, the non-academic aspects that the teacher had predicted might cause problems later on turned out to be correct and I'm glad we had a chance to address them at an early stage. Reading and writing were not a big issue.

Legoisthebest · 12/01/2022 20:11

Oh that's really sad the governors turned down your offer Sad

Cuwins · 12/01/2022 20:11

@Dindundundundeeer

I do think comprehension is weaker area, its partly why I'd like harder/longer books, there's more to discuss

Harder or even less to understand! They need to ensure they understand the easy stuff first or your building a Jenga tower of knowledge

Agree with this. I was taught that if they are struggling with the comprehension part then you drop down levels to work on that not go up! You want books they can read with no effort so they are not thinking about that and you can focus on comprehension questions.
Just2MoreSeasons · 12/01/2022 20:10

LovelyMoans I use reading chest. It's been great my year 2 child. I have a discount code if you want to PM me. Means you can try it for a month at £4.95. (I would get £5 off too)

RowanAlong · 12/01/2022 20:08

You just gotta stretch em at home. That’s it.

Dindundundundeeer · 12/01/2022 20:06
  • You’re
Swipe left for the next trending thread