Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

letting the Colston 4 go unpunished was a vandal's charter

95 replies

MaMaLa321 · 12/01/2022 18:59

As I type, there is a man on the front of Broadcasting House, bashing away at Eric Gill's statue of Prospero with a sledgehammer. The police, as ever, are standing around ineffectually. Now that you can attack whatever piece of art offends your sensibilities (vs Colston) you are free to destroy it.
FWIW I think Gill was a disgusting human being. But where does this stop?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
jgw1 · 14/01/2022 15:56

[quote DdraigGoch]Surprise, surprise. A jury has now cleared members of XR who glued themselves to a DLR train in 2019. It seems that you can now use "belief" as an excuse for anything now.
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-59996870[/quote]
Certainly does seem to be the case. The Prime Minister said only a few days ago that when he was at a garden party with food and wine being consumed he believed he was at work.

DdraigGoch · 14/01/2022 13:47

Surprise, surprise. A jury has now cleared members of XR who glued themselves to a DLR train in 2019. It seems that you can now use "belief" as an excuse for anything now.
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-59996870

DdraigGoch · 14/01/2022 13:46

@brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr

I’m commissioning a statue to be put up in your town. A huge bronze tribute to the man who as leader of the country that contributed the most to defeating Hitler should be honoured and celebrated by every single one of us for giving us our freedom.

Yes, a big bronze Joseph Stalin. Any objections ?

History is complicated and often misrepresented.

A few years ago, Manchester erected a statue of Engels (torn down following the end of communism in Ukraine). They even invited the local Ukrainian community to its unveiling. How on earth they thought that would be a good idea when the very reason that Manchester has a Ukrainian community is that they arrived as refugees from the communist regime there. Highly offensive.
MrsBaublesDylan · 13/01/2022 19:28

It's not just art though is it? I couldn't listen to music knowing its creator had been instructive in causing suffering and pain.

I don't suppose anyone listens to The Lost Prophets anymore.

History is complicated and changing all the time. How we regard an event a year after it happens, will probably change over the next 100 years.

People should be allowed to reflect on history and those who made it and express their opinions, even if that means destroying a work of art.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 13/01/2022 18:01

I’m commissioning a statue to be put up in your town. A huge bronze tribute to the man who as leader of the country that contributed the most to defeating Hitler should be honoured and celebrated by every single one of us for giving us our freedom.

Yes, a big bronze Joseph Stalin. Any objections ?

History is complicated and often misrepresented.

SommerTen · 13/01/2022 17:30

And Eric Gill. What a disgusting sick man.

SommerTen · 13/01/2022 17:29

@MaMaLa321 I have actually seen proper paintings by Rolf Harris displayed in certain very expensive galleries long before his conviction.

They were very good paintings but obviously now we know he's a sex offender no one wants to look at his artwork!!

Nesbo · 13/01/2022 17:18

@Toomanyradishes - In answer to your question, I know nothing about the life of Antonio Canova (so as far as I know it was blameless), but if he were discovered to be a rapist would I demand the destruction or removal from public sight of The Three Graces? No, I wouldn’t.

It is a beautiful and historically significant work of art. I think it can be appreciated in isolation, it now has its own existence and it’s own relationship with the people who see it.

I don’t think the life of the artist should prevent us from appreciating it. I think we are sophisticated/intelligent enough to understand that bad people can create beautiful things.

JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 13/01/2022 16:57

Notice whenever the Tory party’s crimes come to light (2 in last 48hrs - Covid parties and the high court ruling the corrupt PPE contracts fast lane was unlawful), the culture warriors get to work to try and distract?

StoneofDestiny · 13/01/2022 16:53

It's time we stopped building statues - we can do so much better by creating something useful in memory of people or events.

StoneofDestiny · 13/01/2022 16:52

It was a brilliant verdict by the jury - well done to them.

If you want to accuse something of creating a 'vandals charter' start with this Tory Government under Johnson who have broken the law. They are clearly communicated that the law of the land can be broken with impunity - any law, including that protecting 'private or public property'.

Still - that what the Bullingdon Club members did - of which Johnson (and Cameron) were members. Don't say we weren't warned.

megletthesecond · 13/01/2022 16:51

Yabu.
Hardly anyone wanted the statue of Colston. People had complained for years.

Same goes for the Eric Gill sculpture. He wasn't just a bit of a dick and slightly controversial. He sexually abused his children FGS. That sculpture can go.

BashStreetKid · 13/01/2022 16:49

I also don't remember hearing cries of vandalism and mob rule when Saddam's statue was pulled down.

BashStreetKid · 13/01/2022 16:48

If you go to a former Communist country you will note that lots of the communist statues and structures have been taken down. Is that vandalism?

JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 13/01/2022 16:47

When did trial by jury become mob rule?

BashStreetKid · 13/01/2022 16:46

@TameDucksAtChatsworth

It's mob rule and the tide of shit it embodies will touch everyone one way or another as it gushes on.
And yet we haven't seen hordes of statues being pulled down since the verdict, have we? That's a very strange tide of shit.
JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 13/01/2022 16:45

Yes it’s completely reasonable to expect people to respect the celebratory statue of a murderer and rapist which many locals have campaigned for years to be removed.

Would you want to walk past the statue of someone who’d raped and murdered your relatives?

Should we erect a statue of Hitler? He was also a historical figure.

Don’t stress about Colston who you probably only heard about for the first time last year. His decedents are probably still very rich off the back of his crimes and his statue is still on view for you to pay homage to in a museum. Having him in a museum is fine, it’s less celebratory. The fact the statue was pulled down is now also a part of history. History is not static.

VikingOnTheFridge · 13/01/2022 16:41

@TameDucksAtChatsworth

It's mob rule and the tide of shit it embodies will touch everyone one way or another as it gushes on.
Trial by jury?
TameDucksAtChatsworth · 13/01/2022 16:39

It's mob rule and the tide of shit it embodies will touch everyone one way or another as it gushes on.

EnglishMcSwedeFace · 13/01/2022 16:36

@SirSamuelVimes

For me the difference is that the suffragette movement had a specific aim, an action, something concrete that would be different in future - women having the legal right to vote. What is the specific aim of the men who pulled down the Colston statue? What is the specific aim of the man hammering at the Gill statue? What is the concrete thing that will be different in the future?

Not to mention the fact that the suffragettes wanted to be jailed, despite knowing they would be force fed (tortured) and abused, to further their cause. These four men seem delighted with their acquittal.

You know one of the Colston Four is a woman right?
EnglishMcSwedeFace · 13/01/2022 16:32

@MaMaLa321

I can tell you're not from Bristol. The people there have been trying to get the statue removed for a long time but committees, councils and anyone else responsible passed the buck and tried to bury it.

Sorry - I do live in Bristol. Who are the 'people' you're talking about? Some people have, but those pesky democratically elected bodies i.e. committees and councils, have to represent everybody. Not just you and your friends.

I wasn't replying to your post but whatever. The 'people' (why the marks?) I'm talking about are my friends, family members and former colleagues. I haven't lived in Bristol (or the UK) for a long time but it's been a discussion going on for as long as I remember. Those pesky democratically elected bodies have done fuck all about moving the statue as mentioned by myself and several other posters upthread. Would you have been happy to see it go if the fucking council had done their job and taken it down or are you one of the people who think it should stay up come what may?
VikingOnTheFridge · 13/01/2022 16:28

@ginghamstarfish

Agree it is setting a precedent for further such acts. I'm surprised a Labour/Green/Lib Dem politician did not make themselves spokesperson for the campaign to (legally) remove it, and get it done with kudos for their party.
Please, read the thread and in particular the post below yours. It doesnt.
BashStreetKid · 13/01/2022 16:26

Jury verdict doesn’t set legal precedent, so the law hasn’t changed.

Except that it does. When cases are run, previous cases are cited for reference.

It was an appalling outcome. It should have been guilty but with mitigation.

It really doesn't, @Gargellen. Previous decisions of judges are cited as precedents, and generally judges at a higher level. The decisions of juries are never cited as precedents and couldn't possibly be, because we are never told the reasons for their decisions.

It wasn't at all appalling. Juries are entitled to make a decision based on the facts and evidence as presented to them. One of the glories of the jury system is that, just sometimes, they give what might appear to be a contrary verdict - it's well known, for instance, that in the days of capital punishments they would regularly deliver Not Guilty verdicts or verdicts of guilt of a lesser offence because they didn't feel the accused deserved t die.

None of us (I assume) were in court so can't claim to have better knowledge of the case as presented to the jury than they do. Even if we were, it doesn't mean we know best. I was once on a jury where we all agreed that the accused was almost certainly guilty of something but the prosecution simply hadn't produced the evidence to show he was guilty of what he was charged with, so we found him Not Guilty. I was unfortunately foreman, and the prosecutor was obviously absolutely furious - if looks could kill I'd be dead now. But it was his own fault for not assessing the evidence properly.

ginghamstarfish · 13/01/2022 16:20

Agree it is setting a precedent for further such acts. I'm surprised a Labour/Green/Lib Dem politician did not make themselves spokesperson for the campaign to (legally) remove it, and get it done with kudos for their party.

BashStreetKid · 13/01/2022 16:16

@MorningStarling

If you don't want a statue or other piece of artwork to be displayed there are legal ways to attempt to get it removed. I hadn't heard of the Colston statue before it was removed. I hadn't heard of the Gill statue until it was attacked. Why wasn't everyone aware of these things that were so offensive being displayed? Why aren't there peaceful demonstrators protesting against them? If people are overwhelmingly against a statue remaining on display it usually gets removed, the reason things stay in place is because not enough people care.
As I understand it, the people of Bristol were well aware of the Colston statue and its background, and it had been the subject of requests to remove it literally for years, as well as petitions attracting thousands of signatures. So your optimism would seem to be misplaced.
Swipe left for the next trending thread