Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU-Sick of the narrative that young people can’t buy homes?

439 replies

Henryhoover12 · 12/01/2022 17:04

I had a heated discussion with some friends who said it’s “impossible for young people to get on the property ladder these days”.If they do their parents either lent them the money, gifted them the money or they lived at home rent free to save up. It’s not just my friends a lot of people of this age go on about it.

As a young person myself I’m bloody sick of this narrative, anything can be done if your willing to make sacrifices and prioritise for your goals which most young people aren’t. I purchased my own 4 bedroom home at 22 (few months ago) WITHOUT any help from family and whilst paying rent on a flat WITHOUT help from my family to pay for.

I called out all my friends who are blaming how it’s going on their ability to stop online shopping for new outfits every event, going out for cocktails, getting hair/nails/tan done weekly, Taking flashy cars out on finance, etc. that if they stopped then they to could buy but I got told I was being extremely unreasonable and that it’s impossible, well is it or do they not just like to hear the truth.

OP posts:
OhdearOhdearOhdearIndeed · 13/01/2022 15:25

Where do you live OP? Sorry if this is abrupt, but you sound really ignorant to be honest. If you are in the north east it might be achievable, but where I live to buy a 2 bed house you would need to earn 74k a year and have a 24k deposit (at least). I'm sorry, but I think it's very rare to have that sort of money at 22, especially after studying until 21.

LemonSwan · 13/01/2022 15:18

@5128gap

100% agree right to buy was a disaster and we need more social housing. But then there is a large social housing estate in that area - but I can guarantee the people who would want to live there would outstrip the supply no matter how many were built.

Isn't that also the problem? That desirable places are only more desirable because of the amenities they have - ie. cafes, restaurants, shops, facilities etc. Our little village is unrecognisable from what it was 20 years ago. Because of the money that has come to the area my parents now have incredible amenities on their doorstep which weren't there before. I was sad to leave, I moved to a cheap midlands town. But then I feel like in a way I can hopefully contribute to this area - to bring my skills and my family and make a life here. Perhaps in 20-30 years this area will be like my parents village.

5128gap · 13/01/2022 15:01

@LemonSwan

You do realise that if everyone made the choice to just up and leave London / the south, and move to Skegness, then Skegness property prices would go through the roof?

They would sure, but people dont do they. Thats the point I am trying to make. I understand its probably more irritating to see why someone is not owed a home in an area they grew up if its not super desirable ie. Multi Million £ average now. But where do we draw the line. If those people deserve to purchase there and not have to move to a more affordable area then why shouldnt I be able to be given a home in my village of Chelsea footballers. I am under no delusion that I should be handed this due to some kind of heritage but then why do others think the same? Or do you think I should get my multi million £ property and not move out?

I agree with you to a point, in as much as you don't get an automatic right to a place based on an accident of birth. But, there's a bit of a difference in wanting to live somewhere like a rural village because you grew up there, and needing to live somewhere because its where you work, and the job you do is needed there. The first is individual preference, the second is societal need. For me the answer would be to ensure that there was access to decent quality social housing in all areas and for all those who wanted it. It seems pie in the sky these days, but there was a time before right to buy and the ban on local authorities building, when people got to choose between buying and opting for a council house. My own parents had a choice of renting from the council or buying a very similar house in the same street. Obviously there has been a huge shift in how social housing is seen, and everyone today seems obsessed with home ownership, but if living where you grew up mattered enough it would be an option.
BoredZelda · 13/01/2022 13:43

But every single one of my peer group had that option

Did they, though? You can’t possibility know the individual circumstances of everyone in your peer group.

CharSiu · 13/01/2022 11:07

Housing was not my specific area but I do know that in the 1970’s the average house was x3 the average salary and now we are at almost x8 average salary for an average house.

It’s no revelation that people have different attitudes to saving and spending.

The house next door to me sold last year, over 20 years compared to when I bought mine the price went up 400%.

LemonSwan · 13/01/2022 10:24

You do realise that if everyone made the choice to just up and leave London / the south, and move to Skegness, then Skegness property prices would go through the roof?

They would sure, but people dont do they. Thats the point I am trying to make. I understand its probably more irritating to see why someone is not owed a home in an area they grew up if its not super desirable ie. Multi Million £ average now. But where do we draw the line. If those people deserve to purchase there and not have to move to a more affordable area then why shouldnt I be able to be given a home in my village of Chelsea footballers. I am under no delusion that I should be handed this due to some kind of heritage but then why do others think the same? Or do you think I should get my multi million £ property and not move out?

VeryLongBeeeeep · 13/01/2022 10:22

Even assuming any of this is true (I've skipped the last couple of hundred posts; did we ever find out how the OP managed to go travelling at the height of a global pandemic?) I despair of this horrible, capitalist, "work hard and you'll succeed, poverty is a moral failing" mindset. Be a good little worker bee from the day you're old enough to tie your own shoelaces and make your bosses nice and rich, and if you're lucky - and by lucky I mean you don't become disabled or have a child with profound disabilities, you don't get dumped by your husband after having his children, you don't get made redundant and then struggle to find another job - you too can be rewarded with a four bedroom identikit box on an estate full of them.

It's all so fucking joyless.

I bought my first flat - nowhere near London - aged 23 for £25k on a salary of £11.5k as an office administrator. That same flat now would cost £95k and I can guarantee you that office administrators in the area are not earning £44k these days, which would be the equivalent increase. And no, I didn't drive a 'flashy' car at the time or wear designer gear because they weren't what interested me, but I had enough left over each month to buy whatever food I wanted to eat, to eat out or go for a drink with friends occasionally, to buy clothes as and when I needed, or even - shoot me! - when I fancied something new, to go to the theatre or the cinema regularly, to build up a great collection of books and CDs and other things I loved. Because life is about more than being a unit on someone else's balance sheet, and when you're young is when you should be free to care about more than work-work-work, save-save-save without worrying that if you don't start saving from your first paper round, you'll miss the boat on ever getting a foot on the property ladder.

The fact that living in a decent property is seen as an investment rather than a basic human right is obscene, quite frankly.

5128gap · 13/01/2022 08:36

@LemonSwan

That’s easy to say when you’re buying in Wales. If you bought a house with a partner then that is relevant as you only needed half the deposit.

Comments like the above are just how house prices work though. I don't think anything could possibly change that.

I say that because a house is only worth what the average house purchaser in the area can afford - because their are a limited number of houses.

So if you live in an area with higher average incomes (ie. London) - then house prices will be higher. And vice versa.

Likewise a single person will always struggle to buy a similar priced house to a couple; unless they earn double the average for the area - because they will be competing against couples when bidding.

It might not be fair but its simple supply and demand economics; and we have to cut our cloth. So a single person should probably buy a one bed flat or studio rather than a house when starting out - or go for shared ownership; and if your profession is not high paid and you live in London - then you should probably leave for a cheaper area.

A house is only worth what what the average person can afford in smaller towns that people typically don't particular want to move to unless they have existing ties. Even then, external factors such as schemes to help first time buyers buy a share in a house more expensive than they could otherwise afford and low interest rates push prices up. London is entirely different due to its desirability to people outside of the area, including wealthy overseas investors.
Sabire9 · 13/01/2022 07:55

"Yes because anyone can buy a house if they work hard enough (ie. get a NMW wage job fulltime) and live or move to a super cheap area & undesirable area."

The reason why areas where property is cheap are undesirable is often because there are no jobs.

Keke94LND · 13/01/2022 07:40

@LemonSwan

This is a thread where the OP is claiming that buying a house is easy if you just save a little and anyone can afford to buy a house if they work hard enough.

Yes because anyone can buy a house if they work hard enough (ie. get a NMW wage job fulltime) and live or move to a super cheap area & undesirable area. Thats a sacrifice most are unwilling to make, but its a choice.

So London should have no teachers, nurses, cleaners, shop workers, bar staff?
This is hardly going to happen because as many have said on the thread they would rather rent in London than buy in Skegness. Thats a personal choice etc. It is about priorities - some prioritise London life more than home buying but you then cant complain you haven't bought a home.

I was born in London, I grew up in an area which over the last 20 years became very 'naice' indeed - I am not owed an affordable home there regardless of my profession.

You do realise that if everyone made the choice to just up and leave London / the south, and move to Skegness, then Skegness property prices would go through the roof?
dafey · 13/01/2022 07:35

Yes because anyone can buy a house if they work hard enough (ie. get a NMW wage job fulltime) and live or move to a super cheap area & undesirable area. Thats a sacrifice most are unwilling to make, but its a choice.

In the super cheap & undesirable areas are there an abundance of jobs?

AlDanvers · 13/01/2022 07:05

Doh! Missed a word 100% yours

AlDanvers · 13/01/2022 07:04

The house is 100% but you are married? Didn't realise that was possible in Wales.

Monty27 · 13/01/2022 04:15

Hehehe OP. Aren't you the clever one..

Nat6999 · 13/01/2022 03:56

When I bought my house I was earning £20k & my house was 34k. That house is now worth £120k but I still only have £20k coming in, how am I supposed to buy a house? The only time I will be able to buy a house now is when my mum passes away & I inherit half of her house.

LemonSwan · 13/01/2022 03:43

[quote worriedatthemoment]@LemonSwan do you not see what would happen if everyone went and bought elsewhere though ? Those places would go up its called supply and demand and also many of those areas do not have a load of jobs
Some stay close by to look after relatives etc
And my family born in cornwall why should they not be able to stay were they live and by family because second home owners have priced them put
We can't all just up and leave for many reasons and like I said if we all did prices would go up drastically
[/quote]
And my family born in cornwall why should they not be able to stay were they live and by family because second home owners have priced them put
Totally agree! Why should I not be able to stay in my childhood area now surrounded by Chelsea football players for neighbours? There not even their second homes - probably more like 'weekday during training season homes'. Its bloody outrageous. If you get the issue resolved please let me know. I can assure you I will be happy to claim one of these properties! No arguments there

SpindleyCrow · 13/01/2022 01:57

@CurzonDax

Is anyone else more concerned about who looked after the OP's dog while she went travelling for a year, during COVID?
I imagine the dog had to pull itself together and find a well-paid job. At first it had to share a trash can with Top Cat as sleeping quarters. But after a reasonable amount of time, maybe around a few days, DDog has saved enough for a deposit on a detatched kennel in Kensington.

As for Top Cat, well, still in the trash can with Benny comparing tan lines and microblading.

Wotsitsits · 13/01/2022 01:51

OP what was your deposit contribution and what was your OH's contribution?

Also you do realise that applying for a joint mortgage with both applicants earning money, the banks are clearly going to offer you a much larger amount of money than your single friend would get?

CurzonDax · 13/01/2022 01:38

Is anyone else more concerned about who looked after the OP's dog while she went travelling for a year, during COVID?

worriedatthemoment · 13/01/2022 01:36

@LemonSwan do you not see what would happen if everyone went and bought elsewhere though ? Those places would go up its called supply and demand and also many of those areas do not have a load of jobs
Some stay close by to look after relatives etc
And my family born in cornwall why should they not be able to stay were they live and by family because second home owners have priced them put
We can't all just up and leave for many reasons and like I said if we all did prices would go up drastically

lunalovegreat · 13/01/2022 00:21

I call bullshit

Hont1986 · 12/01/2022 23:56

Well, OP's message certainly got watered down once it came out that she's already married and buying in Wales... obviously that is not the scenario people are talking about in most cases. Hmm

LemonSwan · 12/01/2022 23:48

This is a thread where the OP is claiming that buying a house is easy if you just save a little and anyone can afford to buy a house if they work hard enough.

Yes because anyone can buy a house if they work hard enough (ie. get a NMW wage job fulltime) and live or move to a super cheap area & undesirable area. Thats a sacrifice most are unwilling to make, but its a choice.

So London should have no teachers, nurses, cleaners, shop workers, bar staff?
This is hardly going to happen because as many have said on the thread they would rather rent in London than buy in Skegness. Thats a personal choice etc. It is about priorities - some prioritise London life more than home buying but you then cant complain you haven't bought a home.

I was born in London, I grew up in an area which over the last 20 years became very 'naice' indeed - I am not owed an affordable home there regardless of my profession.

GettingStuffed · 12/01/2022 23:11

You can buy a 4 bed house for £100,000 or thereabouts in parts of wales this is within commuting distance of Cardiff www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/118460105#/?channel=RES_BUY

Mickarooni · 12/01/2022 23:10

@AgrippinaT

All the Londoners are triggered 😂
I think they would be….if only this were true. Wink