Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU-Sick of the narrative that young people can’t buy homes?

439 replies

Henryhoover12 · 12/01/2022 17:04

I had a heated discussion with some friends who said it’s “impossible for young people to get on the property ladder these days”.If they do their parents either lent them the money, gifted them the money or they lived at home rent free to save up. It’s not just my friends a lot of people of this age go on about it.

As a young person myself I’m bloody sick of this narrative, anything can be done if your willing to make sacrifices and prioritise for your goals which most young people aren’t. I purchased my own 4 bedroom home at 22 (few months ago) WITHOUT any help from family and whilst paying rent on a flat WITHOUT help from my family to pay for.

I called out all my friends who are blaming how it’s going on their ability to stop online shopping for new outfits every event, going out for cocktails, getting hair/nails/tan done weekly, Taking flashy cars out on finance, etc. that if they stopped then they to could buy but I got told I was being extremely unreasonable and that it’s impossible, well is it or do they not just like to hear the truth.

OP posts:
gabsdot45 · 12/01/2022 17:48

It is possible but you have to really sacrifice.
We rent out a granny flat and out last tennants were a young just married couple. They lived in one room for 3 years to save and they were able to buy a lovely new build home in Dublin last year. Now their mortgage repayment is about half what renting the same house would cost. I know it wasn't easy for them but it was worth it in the end.

5128gap · 12/01/2022 17:47

@Henryhoover12

Can people just read what I’m saying instead of asking the same questions that I’ve already answered. My point is and remains: that person A (me) who earns roughly the same salary as person B (my friend) can buy a house in the area we both live in as a young person as it is possible. However person B wants to do that whilst having her cake and eating it to of having a flashy car that she can’t really afford, going out every weekend, ordering stuff on klarna every other day and that she can’t really moan that the opportunity isn’t there for her. Also it’s coming from a place of frustration not gloating as actually person B lives rent free at home where as I was paying rent, her parents supported her through uni whereas I had to make do, her parents helped secure her job whereas I had to do my own. So it’s frustrating hearing her moan.

Also for the people who say I worked for 1 year I worked for 7 all through my studies and that’s how I afforded it.

Again I repeat I live in wales which I know is cheaper then London but it’s the fact that young people in wales still say they can’t buy!

To be honest, if this is true, I think your friend is probably the one whose got it right. At 22, you've got decades ahead to work, sacrifice, buy houses. If your friend wants a nice car and to enjoy her life while she's young with no responsibility, all power to her. From the tone of your posts you seem very bitter and resentful, which makes me wonder if the choices you made were really the right ones for you. Happy people don't tend to get that angry, either with their friends or with strangers on MN.
Baystard · 12/01/2022 17:47

I agree and disagree OP. I think that there's a culture amongst younger people that it is impossible to buy a house with an inheritance, prices have rocketed etc because in many areas it really is true, even though in some areas there hasn't been the same price inflation.

I read something interesting recently that explained that people in this generation are expecting that they won't be able to buy a house, so aren't saving for deposits or home improvements, but are instead spending their income on 'experiences'. I guess that's having fancy coffee, buying clothes, the nice car etc. So whilst I agree that your friends may well have been able to buy a house in your particular area if they didn't spend so much on "stuff", but I think it's unfair to give them a hard time because I think that generation are constantly being told it's not do-able, that there's no point trying to buy a house, and there's a social expectation that they spend their income on stuff.

Henryhoover12 · 12/01/2022 17:47
  1. how did I manage to save- well not spend it not sure how else to explain that one? When everyone else is splashing out on the latest designer gear I just didn’t. 2)for the millionth time I have purchased in wales so yes it’s cheaper then wales. 3)I don’t get what sharing my private details will help with this but my house was £200k. So no it wasn’t £50k but not sure why that would be bad anyway? I won’t say my salary because I don’t feel comfortable but I’m sure you can do the math. 4)I say “young people” because it’s a hot topic around a lot of people my age, we were having this discussion with a big group of young people lots of people on both sides of the fence. I keep mentioned my friend as she was the one that kicked off but she’s in the exact same position as me so I thought good comparison.
  2. yes I know wales is cheaper but then that’s also a sacrifice surely? Wouldn’t we all want to live in the Center of London but that’s not an option.
  3. I didn’t work for 1 year I worked for 7 since I was 16

Think that’s all the answers

OP posts:
NoNameHere12 · 12/01/2022 17:46

You live in Wales so that’s not impressive at all.
At the age of 22 I would have been able to buy 2 of your 4 bedrooms houses outright and get a mortgage on a 3rd.
I live in a 3 bedroom terraced house just outside south east London…..wanna guess how many 22 year olds can do what you did in this area?

ComtesseDeSpair · 12/01/2022 17:46

Has your friend also been married for several years, as you have? Because having a spouse who has contributed half the deposit, will be paying half the mortgage, and with whom you share living costs is a lot of an easier and less scary prospect than being a young, single person trying to do it all alone.

Broads93 · 12/01/2022 17:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Cornettoninja · 12/01/2022 17:45

@darkNlovely

The point of the op is NO help at all. Not possible, sorry. Without even living at home? Nah.
I agree.

You overegged it with the four bedroom house, travelling post uni and barely being into your 20’s.

I call fantasist.

chaosrabbitland · 12/01/2022 17:45

went to uni , so presumably have student debt , travelled a bit which costs money and just bought a 4 bedroom home at 22 with no help at all , yes of course you have dear

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 12/01/2022 17:45

Aren’t you lucky?

My ds hardly spends anything. He’s struggling to buy a one bedroom flat.

Could you share how you did this?

GizmosEveningBath · 12/01/2022 17:44

Your being very cagey about the details OP, us mere mortals want to know so we can aspire to be like you.

You say you haven't had help from family, have you purchased a house alone or is there a partner on the scene?

Is it a freehold or leasehold property?

Do you own a share of the property or the whole thing? Did you use the help to buy scheme?

BitcherOfBlakiven · 12/01/2022 17:43

I’m in the East Mids and manky 2 bed terraces sell for 250K now.

So nope, I won’t be buying unless some long forgotten random relative leaves me some mega money.

WindyState · 12/01/2022 17:43

[quote Henryhoover12]@ninnynonny no I can’t see that because that’s exactly my point. As both Person A and Person B live in the same area, want to buy in the same area, earn the same amount so what’s stopping them from buying when they both can? For person B it’s that they want all the little luxuries in life such as her car, clothes, cocktails but then moans she can’t buy when she can if she just made it her priority.

I’m not comparing buying in wales and buying in London[/quote]
If you are friends with person B you sound like you don't like them very much. So what if B wants to have a nice car? She still gets to want that and a house, you know.

The smugometer is off the scale with you.

80sMum · 12/01/2022 17:43

House prices have gone up to ridiculous levels, so I do think it's a lot less likely that a young couple doing the same jobs that DH and I had in 1977 would be able to buy the same house that we bought then.

However, I do agree that some people do seem to want to have their cake and eat it, so to speak.

I watched a reality/help type of TV programme a couple of months ago. There was a youngish couple with 2 children who were renting their home but wanted to buy. They said they "couldn't afford to save" for the deposit, but they had 2 cars, 2 holidays each year, expensive hobbies (the husband had 3 bikes, for example) and were always buying new things for the children or for their home.
The basic premise of the programme was that money can be saved by buying cheaper versions, which they called "swapping". It was SO irritating! The couple "didn't like" most of the suggestions. They disliked the alternative holiday cottage because it didn't have this, that and the other etc.
OMG! I was shouting at the telly by that point! "FFS!", I yelled "you can't have both!" If you a serious about wanting to save for a deposit then:-
Don't just "swap" one of your holidays, instead cancel both of them and stay at home!
Sell your expensive bikes and go without.
Only buy clothes when the old ones are worn through or outgrown.
Buy the children's clothes (and your own if available) from charity shops.
Go to car boot sales or charity shops to buy the children's toys for Christmas.
Stop going out to the Theatre, cinema etc.
Always take a homemade packed lunch to work, instead of buying lunch.
Limit going out for a meal to once every 3 months - and only drink tap water with the meal, to keep costs down.
Learn to enjoy activities that are free, such as walking.
Cancel your subscriptions to Netflix etc and just watch whatever is on Freeview instead.

There is a lot of money frittered away on unnecessary things. That's absolutely fine if that's what people want to spend their money on. But they must understand that they can only spend it once!

Disclaimer: this of course only applies to people who do actually have enough money to save, but choose to spend it instead and then moan that they can't afford to save, can't afford a pension etc. Obviously, it does not apply to people on low incomes who have barely enough to pay for the essentials.

mumshouse · 12/01/2022 17:43

Clearly it's harder these days. Back when my parents married my father had a job in a small pet shop. Didn't own it, just worked there five days a week. My mother didn't work. They got a mortgage on a three bed semi near Oxford with no difficulty.

Renting is also much harder these days, because now all the new builds are snapped up by BTL landlords who slap a rent on the place that is double the mortgage payment. So a renter has to pay someone else's mortgage, and then some, while saving for a deposit.

latetothefisting · 12/01/2022 17:43

I agree to some extent. Like you the majority of people I know (and that's old school friends, uni aquaintances, similarly aged siblings and cousins and their friends, work colleagues, etc. etc.) have bought their own homes before the age of 30, with lots on their 2nd homes by then, and without amazing jobs or big deposits from their parents. The ones that haven't are usually the ones who rented their own flat in a nice area rather than slumming it in dodgy shared housing for years, or bought a coffee and a pret lunch every day instead of yesterday's leftovers, or had manicures, hair extensions, spray tans every time they went out, and so on. No it's not 'give up avocados and save £20 grand' but the stereotypes exist for a reason - for a lot of people saving a deposit is actually fairly doable, and more so, doable while still living a perfectly nice life with treats and holidays, not miserly counting every penny.

HOWEVER this is with the caveat that I live in a reasonably affordable part of the UK. If I was doing the same job in the South East I probably wouldn't be able to afford a home now. I definitely wouldn't have been able to afford it 5 years ago when I first bought mine, and if I could afford something it would be a 1 bed flat not the 2 bed semi I live in.

So I find the South East bias of "ABSOLUTELY NOBODY UNDER 40 CAN AFFORD TO BUY" annoying, as it excludes the majority of the country where it is totally achievable. But at the same time I feel the frustration of the people living there, as it is shit to have to move away from your friends, family and social network to be able to buy.

BitcherOfBlakiven · 12/01/2022 17:43

How much of the house do you own?

A lot of my cousins who are early 20s like to brag that they’ve bought homes when us older ones in our 30s haven’t, but they only own like 25% of the house Hmm Which cost them 200K and they’ll never be able to buy the other 75%. Ever.

darkNlovely · 12/01/2022 17:41

The point of the op is NO help at all. Not possible, sorry. Without even living at home? Nah.

DrWhoNowww · 12/01/2022 17:41

OP do you actually live and work in Wales?

I could’ve bought a 4 bed house in the university town I did my degree in. It would’ve cost me £120k which on a start salary of £35k would have been fine.

Utterly bloody useless as I needed to be in work everyday in a totally different part of the country to be paid that £35k.

Generally cheap local housing is a result of low wages locally - so I suspect OP might well have been able to buy a super cheap property in Wales but is likely WFH at a company that has a city rating for salary.

LumosSolem · 12/01/2022 17:41

@Henryhoover12

Can people just read what I’m saying instead of asking the same questions that I’ve already answered. My point is and remains: that person A (me) who earns roughly the same salary as person B (my friend) can buy a house in the area we both live in as a young person as it is possible. However person B wants to do that whilst having her cake and eating it to of having a flashy car that she can’t really afford, going out every weekend, ordering stuff on klarna every other day and that she can’t really moan that the opportunity isn’t there for her. Also it’s coming from a place of frustration not gloating as actually person B lives rent free at home where as I was paying rent, her parents supported her through uni whereas I had to make do, her parents helped secure her job whereas I had to do my own. So it’s frustrating hearing her moan.

Also for the people who say I worked for 1 year I worked for 7 all through my studies and that’s how I afforded it.

Again I repeat I live in wales which I know is cheaper then London but it’s the fact that young people in wales still say they can’t buy!

So this is basically 'look at me, aren't I so much better/harder working/more clever than my friends/most other young people'.

Shame humility isn't one of your 'virtues' isn't it.

darkNlovely · 12/01/2022 17:41

@oviraptor21

You can get 4-bed terraced houses within commutable distance of London for £350-400K. They're not ideal locations or wonderfully appointed but look OK. But most FTB should be looking at 1 bed anyway.
And how does a 22 yo acquire one the year after graduating, shortly after travelling the world, whilst also paying rent and living costs?
FTEngineerM · 12/01/2022 17:40

I mostly agree people laughed at me when I ate nothing but home made lentil Dahl for months on end whilst we saved for a deposit. Needed £7k as 5% for a 4 bed here 🥲.

That same 4 bed house has now sold stc for 34% more than we paid for it 3 years ago.. that £7k and spending NOTHING for a year (we paid rent!) meant we are now sitting on £67k+ in equity.

People seem to be crap at delayed gratification, short sightedness.

lap90 · 12/01/2022 17:40

People are reading your posts OP, you just don't like the responses.

TimBoothseyes · 12/01/2022 17:40

@Henryhoover12

Can people just read what I’m saying instead of asking the same questions that I’ve already answered. My point is and remains: that person A (me) who earns roughly the same salary as person B (my friend) can buy a house in the area we both live in as a young person as it is possible. However person B wants to do that whilst having her cake and eating it to of having a flashy car that she can’t really afford, going out every weekend, ordering stuff on klarna every other day and that she can’t really moan that the opportunity isn’t there for her. Also it’s coming from a place of frustration not gloating as actually person B lives rent free at home where as I was paying rent, her parents supported her through uni whereas I had to make do, her parents helped secure her job whereas I had to do my own. So it’s frustrating hearing her moan.

Also for the people who say I worked for 1 year I worked for 7 all through my studies and that’s how I afforded it.

Again I repeat I live in wales which I know is cheaper then London but it’s the fact that young people in wales still say they can’t buy!

So now you are just talking about your "friend's" attitude...although the way you speak about her it doesn't appear much of a friendship. Whereas in your OP you said, As a young person myself I’m bloody sick of this narrative, anything can be done if your willing to make sacrifices and prioritise for your goals which most young people aren’t The word there is most, not my friend.

I've seen less backflipping from an Olympic gymnast.

FinallyHere · 12/01/2022 17:39

Good for you. Well done.

It might not be impossible, but it is certainly more difficult for younger people now.

My first house purchase in my own name only was in 1990, £60kish, salary just less than £20k. Deposit came from selling my part of a jointly owned house.

Similar houses now sell from some £180k, roughly three times what I paid. Salaries for entry level jobs have absolutely not risen by 300%.

The difference between the mortgage someone can get and the total cost of the house has risen very, very significantly.

That difference cannot be made up by making your own coffee.

It's not impossible, but it is a lot more difficult than it was when I started out. At the time, I welcomed rising house prices because it represented a great return on my investment. Now, I understand the downsides for subsequent generations.

The solution is to expand the housing stock and good, affordable rental opportunities. There is no appetite amongst the haves to help the have nots in this way.

Swipe left for the next trending thread