Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU-Sick of the narrative that young people can’t buy homes?

439 replies

Henryhoover12 · 12/01/2022 17:04

I had a heated discussion with some friends who said it’s “impossible for young people to get on the property ladder these days”.If they do their parents either lent them the money, gifted them the money or they lived at home rent free to save up. It’s not just my friends a lot of people of this age go on about it.

As a young person myself I’m bloody sick of this narrative, anything can be done if your willing to make sacrifices and prioritise for your goals which most young people aren’t. I purchased my own 4 bedroom home at 22 (few months ago) WITHOUT any help from family and whilst paying rent on a flat WITHOUT help from my family to pay for.

I called out all my friends who are blaming how it’s going on their ability to stop online shopping for new outfits every event, going out for cocktails, getting hair/nails/tan done weekly, Taking flashy cars out on finance, etc. that if they stopped then they to could buy but I got told I was being extremely unreasonable and that it’s impossible, well is it or do they not just like to hear the truth.

OP posts:
NoNameHere12 · 12/01/2022 18:04

But you had a partner so that’s the big difference!!

No matter how hard you worked, no matter how much you tried to save, if you wasn’t with your husband and was a single person you would not have been able to buy that 4 bedroom house on your own. Period.

YOU GOT LUCKY! That’s all.
Cheap area and found your partner early in life, nothing to do with hard work.

mumda · 12/01/2022 18:04

3 years at uni and went travelling.

Really?

SickAndTiredAgain · 12/01/2022 18:03

You are generalising though. Obviously if your friend has the same income as you, and the same essential outgoings, and you’ve been able to buy a house, she could have as well. But your OP was that the whole idea that it’s hard for young people to buy a house is wrong which I’m not sure is true.

Of course there’ll be people who spend rather than save for a house - I know someone who spent £30k on her wedding then complained she couldn’t buy a house. Nothing wrong with spending £30k on a wedding if that’s what you want, but don’t then complain you don’t have a house deposit.
But I wouldn’t use her example to generalise to all young people as a whole. And certainly your comment “anything can be done if your willing to make sacrifices and prioritise for your goals” isn’t true. Plenty of people scrape by, don’t buy clothes, or go out for cocktails and still cannot save.

Henryhoover12 · 12/01/2022 18:01

I cant tag whoever said this but “ Disclaimer: this of course only applies to people who do actually have enough money to save, but choose to spend it instead and then moan that they can't afford to save, can't afford a pension etc” this is pretty much what I wanted to say but perhaps I didn’t word it correctly. My issue is with young people who have every opportunity to buy a house as long as they just prioritise it but splash their money and then moan.

OP posts:
TheFairyCaravan · 12/01/2022 18:00

I’ll bite.

DS2 and DDIL bought a house when they were 23 &24. They’re both nurses. It’s a 3 bed detached and cost £270k. They were incredibly fortunate in the fact that DDIL’s parents allowed them to live with them rent and bill free from the day they graduated, hence they saved a hell of a lot of money. We saved money from the get go for our children so we gave DS2 that, too. They are both fully aware that if they’d had to rent a house they would never have been able to buy a house when they did, never mind the size and price it was.

Me and DH are in the process of relocating. Where we’re moving to a 4 bedroom house is far less, almost half, of what a 2 bedroom house costs here. Not everything or everywhere is the same. In some places you can buy a house for under £50k, in other places that wouldn’t buy you a path.

Crowing like you are makes you sound a bit think tbh.

Lulu1919 · 12/01/2022 17:58

How much did your four bed home cost ?

NoNameHere12 · 12/01/2022 17:57

Basically you just got lucky with the area you live in and had a partner to help you save the deposit and get the mortgage.

That’s a bit different to what your trying to portray isn’t it.

(Be careful, your only 22, your a baby, so much time for things to go wrong and for you to turn around and find your worse off than before and all your hard work has fallen down the drain. Just saying, it happens)

BitcherOfBlakiven · 12/01/2022 17:55

Oh, and my Grandparents bought their first home outright aged 16 and 18, so why didn’t you do that OP?

LulaLulaloo · 12/01/2022 17:54

Aren’t you a little superhero. Thank god we have you to put the rest of us in our place.

Not everyone is in the same situation as you, it’s a shame you can’t recognise this. Your friends don’t have the exact same life as you, they are entitled to enjoy their younger years and not just work and save for security. Life is for living.

latetothefisting · 12/01/2022 17:54

I don't know if anyone else reads things like Refinery's or the Independent's "money diaries", or Metro's "how I save", or "What I rent"- I'm a nosy cow so I love them Grin. But a lot of them do prove OPs point, in that the person being interviewed says "Oh I would never be able to afford to buy" and then lists off a huge list of entirely non essential luxury expenditure costing several hundred a month.

Obviously if the person is a social worker in tower hamlets they probably won't be able to buy, no matter how many Starbucks they don't buy, and that is truly shit as they are doing a necessary, worthwhile and underpaid job. But often the person has an average or even highly paid job in a not particularly expensive location, but still thinks owning is completely out of reach, while getting 3 takeaways a week and booking their 5th trip abroad (pre covid obviously!). There's loads that are like "Can't be bothered to wait ten minutes for the bus so get a Uber home, £12" multiple times a week, which just makes me laugh!

ToykotoLosAngeles · 12/01/2022 17:53

www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailypost.co.uk/business/business-news/workers-north-wales-county-third-13883114.amp

So, say you live in parts of North Wales and want a £200k house. The average wage mentioned here is £21k before tax. Max borrowing of £100k. That's a mighty big deposit to save without help and while renting.

Guess one can just stop eating avocados and buying Starbucks tho.

BitcherOfBlakiven · 12/01/2022 17:52

@FTEngineerM

Wouldn’t we all want to live in the Center of London

Umm.. fuck no

Can’t imagine anything worse tbh, I live on the outskirts of a Midlands City as it is (so I’m close to Uni) and it’s bad enough here let alone there,
mewkins · 12/01/2022 17:52

OP I think that what you have done is very admirable but agree with posters that it really does depend where you are buying. A 4 bed here would be 600k which I can't afford I my 40s! However, also inspired by a thread I read earlier, I remember saving for a house years ago and having absolutely no disposable income. I couldn't afford a haircut let along manicures, car on finance etc. I didn't feel hard done by as all of my friends were in the same boat. I think there has been a massive shift in what essential and luxury means now. It must be partly down to social media I guess. But a few decades ago you just wouldn't even consider that you needed a regular manicure if you were a student for example. I miss those days. Everyone expects so much now.

Henryhoover12 · 12/01/2022 17:52

@gabsdot45 I totally agree! When I used to rent my rent was more then my mortgage and that’s what made me make sacrifices to ensure I wasn’t doing that anymore.

@monkeysmum21 thank you! My friend funds Zara through all her spending then wonders how she can’t afford to buy a house. Would I not love to drive around in a flashy Audi and the latest trainers. Yes! But could I … no. So I prioritised

OP posts:
ComtesseDeSpair · 12/01/2022 17:52

[quote Henryhoover12]@Broads93 oh bless you, must of forgotten to read my comments where I said I didn’t grow up in a life of luxury and that’s why I worked hard to get out of it. I haven’t been handed a penny from my parents and you know what I never expected it because they owed me nothing! They taught me the most valuable lesson that if I want anything in life I have to work for it and so I did[/quote]
But your husband will have helped to save half of the £20k deposit, and presumably earns a decent proportion of the approx £45k joint income of your household? So if your friend is a single person earning the same as you (assuming half of your joint income for ease), she wouldn’t be able to afford a mortgage, would she?

TheMarzipanDildo · 12/01/2022 17:52

Well done?

BitcherOfBlakiven · 12/01/2022 17:52

I left home at 18 because it was abusive, worked multiple part time jobs at the same time which only just covered my rent and bills, and didn’t always cover food.

So you have had immense privilege compared to me.

Whilst my friends were swanning around with cars bought and paid for by parents, working full time and living with their parents with no rent or bills to pay, saving 50% of their wages and spending the rest on holidays, nights out and nice clothes, I was often sat in the cold, eating noodles as my only meal of the day.

FTEngineerM · 12/01/2022 17:51

Wouldn’t we all want to live in the Center of London

Umm.. fuck no

Youngstreet · 12/01/2022 17:51

My ds was hopeless with money until he finished uni despite working.
Spent every penny on tech and rubbish food.
Left uni in debt.

Dd was careful, never worked because she had to study outside normal hours.
Left uni with money in the bank.

One of ds school friends however went to a uni near his home.
Took out his student loan and invested it and then repaid it and kept the interest he made.
He worked all hours around uni.
Got a good job fairly quickly.
He bought a nice home at 23 in a not inexpensive area .

It can be done but I think it takes someone very savvy and determined.

BertieQueen · 12/01/2022 17:51

Here you go 👏👏 well done cause that’s clearly all you want is a round of applause and for people to say how great you have done.

Surprised you actually have any friends with such a horrible attitude.

Tee20x · 12/01/2022 17:51

YABU because the majority of young people can't buy houses. it's not some fairytale narrative that young people can't buy homes. You just happened to be lucky that you live in an area where it's cheap.

For a lot of young people the issue comes down to salary not being high enough to get a decent mortgage rather than an inability to pay the cost of a mortgage.

Ridiculous that people can pay £1000+ in rent but won't be approved for a mortgage which will cost £700. But ANYWAY.

Goldi321 · 12/01/2022 17:50

Just seen you bought in Wales. My DH's family are in S. Wales. We could buy a family home outright with the deposit we needed to live where our jobs are based (and no, we can't move somewhere cheaper because then we wouldn't have an income). Jog on with your gloating!

FuryPleury · 12/01/2022 17:50

I bought in a cheap ish area as a first time buyer and actually it wasn't a good decision when we wanted/ needed to move up the ladder. We had spent quite a lot on doing it up and there was a definite ceiling price for the area. We ended up with very little equity for 10 years worth of mortgage payments.

So whilst it might be feasible to buy a house, it might also not always be the sensible decision when you are young as you are then more tied to the area.

So I don't think young home ownership should be sold as the ultimate dream.

Henryhoover12 · 12/01/2022 17:49

@Broads93 oh bless you, must of forgotten to read my comments where I said I didn’t grow up in a life of luxury and that’s why I worked hard to get out of it. I haven’t been handed a penny from my parents and you know what I never expected it because they owed me nothing! They taught me the most valuable lesson that if I want anything in life I have to work for it and so I did

OP posts:
monkeysmum21 · 12/01/2022 17:48

I agree with you. There was this young lady at work that she was always complaining about not being able to save money but every year
she has holidays abroad, buy lots and lots of brand new clothes and goes out every weekend. You can't have it all. That simple.

Swipe left for the next trending thread