Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU-Sick of the narrative that young people can’t buy homes?

439 replies

Henryhoover12 · 12/01/2022 17:04

I had a heated discussion with some friends who said it’s “impossible for young people to get on the property ladder these days”.If they do their parents either lent them the money, gifted them the money or they lived at home rent free to save up. It’s not just my friends a lot of people of this age go on about it.

As a young person myself I’m bloody sick of this narrative, anything can be done if your willing to make sacrifices and prioritise for your goals which most young people aren’t. I purchased my own 4 bedroom home at 22 (few months ago) WITHOUT any help from family and whilst paying rent on a flat WITHOUT help from my family to pay for.

I called out all my friends who are blaming how it’s going on their ability to stop online shopping for new outfits every event, going out for cocktails, getting hair/nails/tan done weekly, Taking flashy cars out on finance, etc. that if they stopped then they to could buy but I got told I was being extremely unreasonable and that it’s impossible, well is it or do they not just like to hear the truth.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HintofVintagePink · 15/01/2022 14:47

What a nice story.

IDidntKnowItWasAParty · 15/01/2022 13:59

Please provide a rough financial breakdown since you were 16 - incomings & outgoings - incl uni costs etc. I can't see how the numbers add up by the time you're only 22, that's only 6 years, incl uni fees, rent etc.

AlDanvers · 15/01/2022 12:07

@HJFTM

As I’ve written in my first post - rent to my parents, food, toiletries etc. Not that much every single month, no. Overtime which was available here and there, bonus’ were saved too and I used money saved to ‘flip’ items for a higher cost than I bought them.

I have not said every single young person can purchase a property. My original post was simply agreeing with OP and offering my personal experience. Nothing more, nothing less 😊

So not earning 17k. 17k plus overtime and bonus. And some side money.

I know you are simply agreeing. I am simply saying to be in that position, where we can buy a 3 bed house cheap is lucky. And it's not something 'most' young people have available. Most are not lucky enough to live at home, with cheap rent and bills (yours were cheap) be able to get overtime or bonuses or have time for a side business. Or live in an area where its affordable.

How much is your house worth now? Some young people can do this. No one disputed that. But most can not and it has nothing to do with them shopping too much. It would be completely out of reach.

HJFTM · 15/01/2022 12:01

As I’ve written in my first post - rent to my parents, food, toiletries etc. Not that much every single month, no. Overtime which was available here and there, bonus’ were saved too and I used money saved to ‘flip’ items for a higher cost than I bought them.

I have not said every single young person can purchase a property. My original post was simply agreeing with OP and offering my personal experience. Nothing more, nothing less 😊

AlDanvers · 15/01/2022 11:23

@HJFTM

5 years ago, 115k.

I’m not saying every single person is able to :) I’m saying that I agree with the original statement of “young people can’t buy homes” when some can if they are mindful with their incomes and I’ve provided my personal example of doing so.

So you saved approx 800-900 everyone's for 4 years. On top of, reasonable living expenses? Most can't do this.

Of course some can. When people say young people can't buy houses, no one suggests it ever means every single one of them.

But the vast majority can't.

HJFTM · 15/01/2022 11:07

5 years ago, 115k.

I’m not saying every single person is able to :) I’m saying that I agree with the original statement of “young people can’t buy homes” when some can if they are mindful with their incomes and I’ve provided my personal example of doing so.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 15/01/2022 09:33

4 bed house round me is 500000. No one buys them at 22

use257 · 15/01/2022 04:07

You were at uni for 3 years, then travelled for a bit and have now come in time to buy your first 4 bedroom home at 22? Yeah right

AlDanvers · 14/01/2022 19:22

@HJFTM

I absolutely agree with you.

Age 24 I bought an 8 year old 3 bed detached house - every penny was my own for the deposit. I was on £17k a year. I set myself goals and made sacrifices to get there but I did it in 4 years. For full transparency; I lived with parents but I paid £240 a month to live there, paid for my own food, toiletries etc.

Given the wage and timeline. I am guessing this was a while ago and the house was approx 100k. And several years ago.

4 years ago I bought a 3 bed terrace for 87k. That doesn't mean that every, single parent everywhere in the country can do the same.

ToykotoLosAngeles · 14/01/2022 19:00

@SpindleyCrow I agree. I can make myself sound amazing by saying DH and I bought a house a year after we graduated. If I leave out -

It was May 2008, so they would give us a 95% mortgage on 13k and 14k with one of us being a temp
The deposit was £6k as the house was £123k
The mortgage rate was 7% so it was costing more than renting
We spent 5 years in negative equity

It paid off, as we moved in 2013 to a 4 bed at £170k that is now valued over £100k more than that, but we couldn't afford to upsize. It's all relative.

BoredZelda · 14/01/2022 18:47

To be fair, I'm going back a bit further as my parents married in 1964 and this was shortly after that.

Ours was about 10 years later, still well before right to buy. My parents were actually local to the area and born the raised there most of their lives, on the electoral roll etc, they moved away for a short time whilst my dad was in the army.

SpindleyCrow · 14/01/2022 18:30

@HJFTM

I absolutely agree with you.

Age 24 I bought an 8 year old 3 bed detached house - every penny was my own for the deposit. I was on £17k a year. I set myself goals and made sacrifices to get there but I did it in 4 years. For full transparency; I lived with parents but I paid £240 a month to live there, paid for my own food, toiletries etc.

I don't think this happened terribly recently
5128gap · 14/01/2022 18:08

@BoredZelda

but there was a time before right to buy and the ban on local authorities building, when people got to choose between buying and opting for a council house.

I’m not sure when that time was @5128gap but 40 odd years ago when my parents relocated to North East Scotland, even then we had to wait over 6 months for a council property to come up in the area they were choosing to move to. We stayed with my grandparents until a house was available. I have no doubt it would be a much longer wait now, but I’m not sure when it was possible just to choose a council rented property in the area where you wanted to live.

To be fair, I'm going back a bit further as my parents married in 1964 and this was shortly after that. My parents actually opted to buy, but their friends chose to rent. Perhaps area as well as time played a part, as I understand they were very much 'local houses for local people' so maybe it would have been different for someone wanting to relocate to the area. I'm not sure, I only know what their experience was.
BoredZelda · 14/01/2022 17:56

but there was a time before right to buy and the ban on local authorities building, when people got to choose between buying and opting for a council house.

I’m not sure when that time was @5128gap but 40 odd years ago when my parents relocated to North East Scotland, even then we had to wait over 6 months for a council property to come up in the area they were choosing to move to. We stayed with my grandparents until a house was available. I have no doubt it would be a much longer wait now, but I’m not sure when it was possible just to choose a council rented property in the area where you wanted to live.

Hont1986 · 14/01/2022 16:54

If you were only £17k a year, then your max mortgage would have been around £76k. Where and when are you buying a three bedroom detached house for, what, £100k? £125k?

HJFTM · 14/01/2022 16:49

I absolutely agree with you.

Age 24 I bought an 8 year old 3 bed detached house - every penny was my own for the deposit. I was on £17k a year. I set myself goals and made sacrifices to get there but I did it in 4 years. For full transparency; I lived with parents but I paid £240 a month to live there, paid for my own food, toiletries etc.

PonyPatter44 · 14/01/2022 07:21

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Monty27 · 14/01/2022 06:11

It amazes me that this thread is still going.
Why would anyone need to justify their individual circumstances to OP?
Lol

TheOriginalEmu · 13/01/2022 22:32

@Henryhoover12

Honestly I had no help from my parents, they were never in a position to help me and so I was always raised with the mindset that if I want something I work for it. I agree it’s so much more difficult then before but if it’s all we ever know is it? we have only ever known house prices to be this much and so I always knew I had to work hard to get that and so I did.

Also I did make sacrifices but I never didn’t enjoy being young, I was at uni for three years and then I travelled for a bit. So it’s not like I stayed at home watching life go by to afford it

You went to uni for 3 years which means you qualified when you were 20/almost 21 at the very youngest then travelled and still earned enough fog s deposit by 22 AND rented? Ok then.
AllThatGlittersAndAllThatGold · 13/01/2022 22:28

I know a 38 Yr old who lives at home. Single, lives in London and in employment but not enough to rent or buy alone. I would hate that.
Feel glad I was young at a time when it was a hell of a lot easier to buy.

Whataroyalannoyance · 13/01/2022 17:57

You clearly have no idea about how much property costs in other areas. The nmw is the same in Wales as in London but property prices are massively different. The cheapest 2 bed property I can find in Ealing, a Borough 30 mins out of London is 250000. The equivalent property in Cardiff is 60000. 190 thousand pound difference.
That is why it is so damn hard

dafey · 13/01/2022 17:50

@vavavoom123 if you were paying market rate it's likely you would have struggled to save fast enough to combat price increases.

vavavoom123 · 13/01/2022 15:59

Me and my partner bought a fairly nice house this year. We're in a our early twenties and saved up for a couple of years after leaving uni. We're both from working class families and had no financial help (apart from the cheap board - which I appreciate is a big help in itself) towards the house. We also got the house on the equivalent of two full time minimum wages. It was actually very easy but I appreciate we had the following advantages:

  • We live up North
  • We're a couple (honestly have no idea how a single person could do that)
  • We paid a small amount of board to my parents and didn't rent whilst saving
  • We have no financial dependants

It does annoy me when people buy into the narrative without looking into it - e.g. if people are in the same position of us and just assume they can't buy a house without even bothering trying (which a lot of people do!!) But if I was single/lived in a different part of the country I'm not sure if would be so easy.

Notjustanymum · 13/01/2022 15:36

Of course you can purchase a house as a young person if you work hard, are able to save ( i.e. in that your salary is enough to cover your essential bills like phone, car insurance and keep/rent as a minimum) AND you live in an area where property prices don’t exceed 3xjoint salary plus an attainable deposit.
The point is that property prices in many areas have risen to such an extent that it isn’t possible to buy unless you are earning in excess of £100,000 p.a minimum.
When I bought my first property with my fiancé, we were earning £2,750 and £3,300 p.a respectively. With a small deposit of £2,000 we were able to purchase a studio flat for £26,500, with a mortgage of £24,500. Today, with entry-level jobs like we had, many people of 21 (our age at first purchase) are only earning between £17,000 and £25,000, but that same studio flat recently came up for sale at £325,000!
You need to do the maths, and to realise that not only have property prices increased far in excess of the scale of salaries, but that not everyone is prepared to move to a low-cost area of the Country (where the locals might be unfriendly and jobs hard to come by) just to get a house.
Most of my peers expect to have their children living with them well into adulthood for this reason, and we are allowed to despair at the hand that fate, and the intolerable greed of developers, landlords and employers, has dealt them, as it’s hard for both generations in this situation - hence the “impossible” sentiment!

Everanewbie · 13/01/2022 15:31

OP you'll get support in what you're saying from one camp and be vilified by the other camp. My take is that reality is somewhat more nuanced.

I agree that many young people aren't willing to make sacrifices and sayings its too difficult can be a bit of a cop out. But then again, if you're in a city in the south, in the rent trap and circumstances restrict career profession, well, even ar' Mollie must see that things are stacked against you.

So yeah, kinda agree that maybe a sim only on a god forbid older iphone, and a bit of restraint on nights out etc. would help, but for some people, in some circumstances, even without smashed avocado for brunch its virtually impossible.

Swipe left for the next trending thread