Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not vote for Labour as a former conservative voter, would you vote for Labour now?

139 replies

SonicBroom · 12/01/2022 13:42

Just that. This thread is for anyone who has voted conservative in the past to ask what you’d do in the future. Please don’t derail with anything else.

I voted conservative most of my life until Boris came along. I voted LD in the last election not just because of Brexit, but because I couldn’t support the way that Boris conducted himself and his party.

But. If there were an election tomorrow I couldn’t bring myself to vote Labour. I can’t put my finger on why. It’s partly because KS just hasn’t cut through, I don’t question his integrity but I can’t quite see him as a statesman? And partly because Angela Raynor makes me worried that the Corbyn politics could rear their head again at any moment. Rightly or wrongly, she comes across to me as being too aggressively against people who have made a success of their lives —there, I said it— !!

So I wondered how many former conservative voters feel the same or not and why… partly as a proxy for how BJ might weather the partygate storm?

YANBU - I don’t want to vote conservative but Labour haven’t convinced me either so I won’t be voting for them

YABU - I don’t want to vote conservative again and I’d vote Labour

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 12/01/2022 17:07

I can’t accept removing sex based rights though which is a big issue.

I couldn’t do it to my dd even to go in that direction.

Hollyhead · 12/01/2022 17:05

I like Kier Starmer but I don’t trust the people who were heavily involved with Corbyn. I would like to see people like Liz Kendall promoted. If you ask me the party were fools getting so swept up in corbyn that they overlooked a modern woman with sensible ideas. It makes me concerned the party is structurally sexist.

pointythings · 12/01/2022 17:01

If people on here vote solely based on gender issues, we'll be stuck with Tory governments for decades. Which will be dreadful for women, children, disabled people and immigrants. There are so many other issues which are just as big, if not bigger. Being a single issue voter isn't rational.

FOJN · 12/01/2022 16:57

The current trans debate has come about because of CONSERVATIVE PROPOSALS TO REFORM THE GRA. THEIR STARTING POINT WAS TWAW. Remember Penny Mordant?

This is true although I'm not sure if their starting point was actually TWAW and I don't think any of us who have taken an interest will forget Penny Mordant.

I think they realised their failure to consult women's groups in 2015 was a big mistake and they have been trying to distance themselves from a shit show of their own making since. However, unlike Labour, LibDems and Greens they haven't told women they don't want our vote if we're not prepared to chant TWAW and they haven't branded feminist organisations hate groups or called for party members who know biological sex is a fact to be expelled. Neither do they have party members who think it's wrong to say only women have a cervix (KS on Andrew Marr) or anyone who thinks you can grow a cervix if you take the right hormones (David Lammy).

I will grant you these are all crumbs and women have a right to demand more from their political representatives but it's 2022 and this is where we are.

travellinglighter · 12/01/2022 15:56

[quote SonicBroom]@Earlydancing I agree with you, maybe this is one of the reasons I feel the way I do.

@travellinglighter you’re right about the ERG, they’re a huge problem. I don’t see enough MPs willing to stand up to them either, not even with the kind of majority they have right now. As for independence, I think it’s a failure of this government, not of all governments. Nations should be careful not to make a long term decision on a short term problem (which is what many proponents are trying to make happen!). I say that as a Scot.[/quote]
To be honest, if we could wave a magic wand, do away with Brexit then I think the union would still be here in a 100 years. If the union goes then the same non bigoted arguments for Welsh independence that persuaded non bigoted brexiteers exist. The right to make our own laws, the right to make our own destiny. The arguments for staying tied to a diminished England are very poor.

Ericaceae · 12/01/2022 15:55

Interesting question, OP. We've got what, potentially just over 2 years until the next General Election?
I have my doubts that Johnson will be there as leader by that time. I think others are jostling for position already, and are just waiting for the right time.
I think that would make a vast difference, and I can easily see the Tories getting in again, depending on who's at the helm.

I'm a Green/SNP Voter, and have little opinion on Starmer myself. But I find it interesting that he seems to commonly get a "meh" reaction in comments sections for want of a better description. I don't think he's going to get Labour over the line if he's there in a few years.

MarshaBradyo · 12/01/2022 15:49

I’m a floating voter and decide at each election, I did want Starmer to bring something new but I’ve struggled with some of the policy talk so far

Labour isn’t occupying the same positive space it has in the past for me

For the next election I’ll decide at the time

Noisyprat · 12/01/2022 15:47

Previously I have voted Conservative although I didn't at the last election as I would not vote for Boris Johnson. That said I am in a safe seat so my vote won't have an impact.

I am also politically homeless. None of the other parties support women's rights and don't know what a woman is so I won't vote for them.

Beowulfa · 12/01/2022 15:42

I've never voted Labour or Conservative. Can't see any reason to do so in the near future.

I'd like to vote Green, but they don't acknowledge women's sex based rights.

I may consider the SDP (who knew they even existed anymore), as a sort of LibDem minus the gender woo obession.

Otherwise it's another spoiled ballot paper unfortunately.

Lifeisforalimitedperiodonly · 12/01/2022 15:42

I am a strange one (!) because I am a conservative who is also a lifelong trade unionist. I can separate the two. I have always been a a union rep and I loathe the way the tories have penalised workers rights. But I also don't agree with the socialist views of the Labour Party.
However. I now find I would not piss on a tory politician if they were on fire.
I may have to vote Labour or maybe LibDem. But I live in a true blue area so there's some thinking for me.

SisyphusDad · 12/01/2022 15:35

[quote SonicBroom]**@Mumofsend* and @SisyphusDad* have you voted conservative in the past too?[/quote]
@SonicBroom

Yes, but not for quite a while.

SonicBroom · 12/01/2022 15:33

@Earlydancing I agree with you, maybe this is one of the reasons I feel the way I do.

@travellinglighter you’re right about the ERG, they’re a huge problem. I don’t see enough MPs willing to stand up to them either, not even with the kind of majority they have right now. As for independence, I think it’s a failure of this government, not of all governments. Nations should be careful not to make a long term decision on a short term problem (which is what many proponents are trying to make happen!). I say that as a Scot.

OP posts:
TooBigForMyBoots · 12/01/2022 15:24

The current trans debate has come about because of CONSERVATIVE PROPOSALS TO REFORM THE GRA. THEIR STARTING POINT WAS TWAW. Remember Penny Mordant?

There is cross party support and opposition to the Tory government's reforms. The current shit show wrt the definition of woman is down to the Conservatives.

travellinglighter · 12/01/2022 15:20

I have wandered politically for years. I was in a safe red area that went blue at the last election and will go red again when the next vote comes. I have voted Tory when I was younger, couldn’t vote labour so voted Lib Dem or Plaid Cymru. Last time I voted labour despite Corbin who I hated in the hope we’d get a hung Parliament and a second referendum. As it is now, I believe Scotland will leave the union, Ireland will unite and that will leave wales tied to a humiliated England who will vote Tory no matter how horrifically they behave. When the union goes, I will campaign for independence.

Please bear in mind that when you vote Tory now, you aren’t getting the Tory party you are getting the ERG, their aims and agendas are the aims and agendas of the small numbers of wealthy backers who find them. The end of the nhs and the safety net for the poor in the name of a low tax economy that cannot afford to fund the basics.

Earlydancing · 12/01/2022 15:20

Typically the thread has gone the way of 'I've never voted Tory so I'm not going to vote Tory." I'm not sure what that adds to people's understanding.

I have voted Tory, don't know if I would next time, I'd have to see what was happening by the time of the GE. But I see so many aggressive posters on here chastising and insulting people who vote or voted Conservative, that it puts me off voting Labour. If that's what Labour represents, it's not something I really want to be a part of. Plus I have voted Tory and I know lots of Tory voters who are all very decent people, do lots of good works, work hard, and are kind and generous. I like to think I'm similar. So if Labour supporters on here think we're all scum, I guess they wouldn't want us to vote for Labour. So maybe I won't. 🤔

SonicBroom · 12/01/2022 15:19

Interesting how many are saying that Labour’s gender ideology is a problem. Especially as women tend to be more likely to be floating voters than men

OP posts:
thewhatsit · 12/01/2022 15:19

I agree that Angela Rayner puts me off too much. I’m not sure I could vote for a party that has her in such a prominent position.
I really like Lisa Nandy.

Floundery · 12/01/2022 15:17

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Lordamighty · 12/01/2022 15:15

I can’t vote Labour because of gender ideology. Their wilful blindness over this issue will cost them at election time, even against incompetent opposition.

SonicBroom · 12/01/2022 15:14

Sorry @RedRobyn2021 you’re right… by “former” I should have qualified voted Tory in past but don’t want to this time, need to find a more sophisticated way of doing it!

OP posts:
Floundery · 12/01/2022 15:14

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Alisae · 12/01/2022 15:12

Please don't vote Tory folks.

I do not honestly know how any person with a shred of decency could vote, campaign or stand on a Tory ticket these days.

There are no "decent" people left in the Tory party. Not if you take decent to mean kind, empathetic, honest and principled human beings.

And this kind of immature hyperbole is exactly why I usually stay off these threads. The black and white thinking of Tory/evil and will eat the poor = Labour/good and will change everything is what I blame for a lot if people being turned off Labour. It only entrenched views, certainly NEVER changes someone’s vote and only leads to polarisation of political discourse.

All parties have good/bad policies depending on your viewpoint. All politicians are human beings, whether you vehemently disagree with them or not. All parties have corrupt elements. Instead of trying to beat people over the head with your purity for a brief rush of feeling superior, maybe try discussing things respectfully and not pigeon holing entire segments of the population!?

lilikiki · 12/01/2022 15:10

Nope
Because as much as I detest Boris I’m not voting for self ID. Womens rights are more important than this issue, to me.

Mamamia7962 · 12/01/2022 15:08

No I wouldn't vote for Labour.

sst1234 · 12/01/2022 15:07

@Viviennemary

I might. But not with Angela Rayner as deputy. Not keen on her ilk.
A reminder of Corbyn that needs to be got rid off, if labour are not ever to become electable again.
Swipe left for the next trending thread