Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not vote for Labour as a former conservative voter, would you vote for Labour now?

139 replies

SonicBroom · 12/01/2022 13:42

Just that. This thread is for anyone who has voted conservative in the past to ask what you’d do in the future. Please don’t derail with anything else.

I voted conservative most of my life until Boris came along. I voted LD in the last election not just because of Brexit, but because I couldn’t support the way that Boris conducted himself and his party.

But. If there were an election tomorrow I couldn’t bring myself to vote Labour. I can’t put my finger on why. It’s partly because KS just hasn’t cut through, I don’t question his integrity but I can’t quite see him as a statesman? And partly because Angela Raynor makes me worried that the Corbyn politics could rear their head again at any moment. Rightly or wrongly, she comes across to me as being too aggressively against people who have made a success of their lives —there, I said it— !!

So I wondered how many former conservative voters feel the same or not and why… partly as a proxy for how BJ might weather the partygate storm?

YANBU - I don’t want to vote conservative but Labour haven’t convinced me either so I won’t be voting for them

YABU - I don’t want to vote conservative again and I’d vote Labour

OP posts:
Luredbyapomegranate · 12/01/2022 20:20

I have voted labour in the past.

Wouldn’t dream of doing so right now, because they are still in the grip of insanity. I have never lived through a period of such incompetence in UK politics, on all fronts. But Corbyn and his cabinet would have fucked up the last 18 months to a greater degree than Johnson and his posse, extraordinary thought though that is.

I hope Corbyn sets up his party, as it may draw a lot of the poison out. But as yet I can’t see any sign that Starmer is Kinnock, or who the hell would come after him to actually win.

I wouldn’t vote Tory now either, so depressing times..

whenwillthemadnessend · 12/01/2022 20:16

I voted for tory this election but I've voted Labour and Lib Dem in the past

I tend to go for the party I feel willl support my life more at the time. And those needs do change before I get jumped on.

Now I'm leaning towards Labour because of the sleeze however if they get a new leader in and she or he can turn things around then maybe I'll vote Tory again

However I will say I need more clarity from Labour as I do t really know what they want to do and I really don't like Angela raynor. If she went for PM there is no way I'd vote Labour.

StoneofDestiny · 12/01/2022 20:15

Please do tell us how the ongoing welfare of women will be effectively addressed under a continuation of the Conservative government...

Yes, do tell

DdraigGoch · 12/01/2022 20:13

@TooBigForMyBoots

The current trans debate has come about because of CONSERVATIVE PROPOSALS TO REFORM THE GRA. THEIR STARTING POINT WAS TWAW. Remember Penny Mordant?

There is cross party support and opposition to the Tory government's reforms. The current shit show wrt the definition of woman is down to the Conservatives.

Yes, they were heavily implicated in what has happened so far. Even so, they seem to be the only party so far to have had second thoughts. Only one Labour MP and one SNP MSP have spoken out for women and children, both have received abuse from within their own party for speaking out.

Penny Mordaunt and a few others may be signed up to TWAW but they are in the minority on the Conservative benches. The government as a whole have begun to wake up to what is going on and is starting to U-turn. That's the best we've had so far.

As for Starmer, he appears to be shit-scared of saying absolutely anything controversial. Not just on that subject but on any policy at all. He appears to feel safer sitting on the fence until he's worked out which way the wind is blowing. As far as I am concerned he is a coward.

JanuaryBluehoo · 12/01/2022 20:07

I'm a former Labour voter who could not vote for them.

As repugnant as the downing Street parties are, they are simply child's play when it comes to labour's dangerous tinkering into what consistutes a female...

I'm female, I have daughters. No way will I vote for them.

DdraigGoch · 12/01/2022 20:03

@Alisae

Please don't vote Tory folks.

I do not honestly know how any person with a shred of decency could vote, campaign or stand on a Tory ticket these days.

There are no "decent" people left in the Tory party. Not if you take decent to mean kind, empathetic, honest and principled human beings.

And this kind of immature hyperbole is exactly why I usually stay off these threads. The black and white thinking of Tory/evil and will eat the poor = Labour/good and will change everything is what I blame for a lot if people being turned off Labour. It only entrenched views, certainly NEVER changes someone’s vote and only leads to polarisation of political discourse.

All parties have good/bad policies depending on your viewpoint. All politicians are human beings, whether you vehemently disagree with them or not. All parties have corrupt elements. Instead of trying to beat people over the head with your purity for a brief rush of feeling superior, maybe try discussing things respectfully and not pigeon holing entire segments of the population!?

Hear, hear. 99% of politicians want exactly the same things for the country. They want their constituents to be happy and healthy. The only thing that they disagree upon is how best to achieve it. Juvenile claims of "evil, heartless tories" achieve nothing.
NoWordForFluffy · 12/01/2022 19:54

@stoppedlurking

I hear the word honest and Starmer mentioned. He knew about Jimmy Saville and the rest of them but put a lid on it. He knew about the groups grooming children in certain areas and help in preventing any further movement in terms of investigations. I now hear Allister Campbell telling everybody there are public standards. He and Blair fabricated documents so we could go to war and then Blair buried the information for 100 years. Career politions in my view are the scourge of modern society.
That isn't right about Starmer. It's been debunked for a very long time, yet people with an ace to grind keep trotting it out as fact, when it's anything but.

I voted Tory when I was younger, then moved on to the Lib Dems. I voted Labour in the last GE, tactically.

I'm another politically homeless person at present, due to women's rights being erased. I've no clue who to vote for next time; I'll potentially spoil my ballot, even though I'd prefer not to.

Worldwide2012 · 12/01/2022 19:36

Former Conservative voter here. I would vote Conservative again. Tony Blair took us to war on a lie, Boris attended an illegal party. There are more pressing matters to deal with going forward, and the Conservatives are more capable of dealing with them than the opposition, IMHO. The illegal party is a storm in a teacup whipped up a media obsessed with Twitter and who are ignoring many more important issues. Ditto No.10 wallpaper. Yawn.

madisonbridges · 12/01/2022 19:02

@stoppedlurking

I hear the word honest and Starmer mentioned. He knew about Jimmy Saville and the rest of them but put a lid on it. He knew about the groups grooming children in certain areas and help in preventing any further movement in terms of investigations. I now hear Allister Campbell telling everybody there are public standards. He and Blair fabricated documents so we could go to war and then Blair buried the information for 100 years. Career politions in my view are the scourge of modern society.
Every time I hear Alistair Campbell talking about honesty, I can feel my hackles rising and steam starting to rise. He got his staffers to look for anything they could find on the internet that would help justify war. When the found it, he got them to change all the 'mays' and 'mights' to 'are able to' and 'do' and 'will'. He instructed Geoff Hoon not to correct misinformation that was going around. He cost hundreds of thousands of lives and he has the gall to criticise others over lack of integrity. He hasn't one moral in his body. Ugh.
Alarae · 12/01/2022 18:37

I voted Conservative in the past but I honestly couldn't give my vote to anyone at the moment.

I've always viewed the election as a necessary evil, but I can't say I know who the lesser of all the evils is.

stoppedlurking · 12/01/2022 18:23

I hear the word honest and Starmer mentioned. He knew about Jimmy Saville and the rest of them but put a lid on it. He knew about the groups grooming children in certain areas and help in preventing any further movement in terms of investigations. I now hear Allister Campbell telling everybody there are public standards. He and Blair fabricated documents so we could go to war and then Blair buried the information for 100 years. Career politions in my view are the scourge of modern society.

TooBigForMyBoots · 12/01/2022 18:18

I think they realised their failure to consult women's groups in 2015 was a big mistake and they have been trying to distance themselves from a shit show of their own making since.

Not really, in March 2021 PM once again asserted that TMAM and TWAW. ^The context of Mordaunt’s remark was theMinisterial and other Maternity Allowances Bill: a bill that allows the Prime Minister to designate a Minister on maternity leave as a ‘Minister on Leave’. Once upon a time, such legislation would naturally have talked about pregnant women. But this is 2021. Only after a lengthy debate in the House of Lords last week was the bill amended to replace pregnant people with expectant mothers.^

The Conservative party created this. They have kept it going. They have the power to scrap it because of the clear problems it creates for women but they haven't.

Did they have an official policy on it in the last election?

stoppedlurking · 12/01/2022 18:17

Boris will be gone soon. Nobody really wanted the job after Brexit but with Covid, nobody could have come out of that in the lead.

For me I will stick with the Tories, Labour would be horrendous with the up and coming recession inbound.

anewdispensation · 12/01/2022 18:00

Lib Dem all the day. The Lib Dem MP in my constituency is simply inspirational and I was glad she kicked out the Tory waste of space who was in place in the last GE. However at a national level I wish there was a truly centrist moderate party with a strong leader who will actually lead with heart and soul

madisonbridges · 12/01/2022 17:53

@Paranoidandroidmarvin

I would vote for anyone other than this corrupt government.
Do you usually or ever vote Conservative?
Paranoidandroidmarvin · 12/01/2022 17:51

I would vote for anyone other than this corrupt government.

crazyjinglist · 12/01/2022 17:36

I've voted Tory (long ago), Labour and Lib Dem in the past. No way I'd vote Tory now, and I refuse to vote for anyone who doesn't know (or rather, pretends not to know) what a woman is. So I guess I'll be spoiling my ballot paper.

Hunderland · 12/01/2022 17:29

A B B

Anyone but Boris

Aprilx · 12/01/2022 17:29

Your poll makes no sense. You say it is for people who have voted conservative in the past (fine, whatever), but you go on to assume that nobody would vote conservative in the future.

SilverontheTree · 12/01/2022 17:23

Maybe Labour should listen to the people and realise that the vast majority of us are centrist. I would support a Labour who supported women’s rights and the freedom to privately educate/ use private medicine.
I have never forgiven them for the 2006 dental contract either!
As I say my Tory MP is very good (answers emails, I have seen him standing on the street in my small village talking to constituents, volunteers at the vaccine centres. So I would vote for him.

MajorCarolDanvers · 12/01/2022 17:20

I am a former Labour voter who switched to the Tories because of Corbyn.

I am happy to return to Labour now they have a sensible leader again.

Shade17 · 12/01/2022 17:19

I could never EVER vote Labour.

icelolly12 · 12/01/2022 17:18

So people will still vote Tory as they cannot bear the thought of voting Labour. Great.

SilverontheTree · 12/01/2022 17:18

Voted Tory all my life until Brexit. Voted LibDem in 2019.
I like Keir Starmer but would still never vote Labour. They just don’t seem capable of running the country- they seem to think men can be women for a start!?
Politically homeless until the Tories sort themselves out.
I do think our local Tory MP seems very good and connected with local issues and people.

Dillydollydingdong · 12/01/2022 17:14

I'll never vote Labour. Angela Rayner, Diane Abbott, Emily Thornberry, Corbyn, Starmer, David Lammy? Nightmare.

Swipe left for the next trending thread