Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not vote for Labour as a former conservative voter, would you vote for Labour now?

139 replies

SonicBroom · 12/01/2022 13:42

Just that. This thread is for anyone who has voted conservative in the past to ask what you’d do in the future. Please don’t derail with anything else.

I voted conservative most of my life until Boris came along. I voted LD in the last election not just because of Brexit, but because I couldn’t support the way that Boris conducted himself and his party.

But. If there were an election tomorrow I couldn’t bring myself to vote Labour. I can’t put my finger on why. It’s partly because KS just hasn’t cut through, I don’t question his integrity but I can’t quite see him as a statesman? And partly because Angela Raynor makes me worried that the Corbyn politics could rear their head again at any moment. Rightly or wrongly, she comes across to me as being too aggressively against people who have made a success of their lives —there, I said it— !!

So I wondered how many former conservative voters feel the same or not and why… partly as a proxy for how BJ might weather the partygate storm?

YANBU - I don’t want to vote conservative but Labour haven’t convinced me either so I won’t be voting for them

YABU - I don’t want to vote conservative again and I’d vote Labour

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SantaClawsServiette · 14/01/2022 18:56

I find things like these parties or other mainly personal failings are not usually what prompts me to change my vote. I suppose because my experience has been, and my reading of history, that the leaders who can steer a nation best are not always the most morally upright or the best people in their personal lives.

So while I might think less of a leader, all of that stuff gets slotted in behind, how effective would this government actually be compared to that one.

So mainly policy, how effective or likely I think it is they will actually do things. Also questions around underpinnings - anyone who is a threat to the principles and institutions liberal democracy stands on is a no. Corruption can play into that but not always if it remains low level.

Now, personal evidence of being really stupid - that is another story. I find that difficult to vote for. You never know what misstep a stupid politician might make.

At this point, I think Starmer is a better person than Boris, for sure. I don't think either are stupid, but I dispair over some of the Labour MPs (more than I do with the Tories though neither has a great field of candidates.) But I think Labour are in thrall to id politics and a kind of left authoritarianism. The Tories main problem is probably corruption and lack of vision.

Duchess379 · 14/01/2022 18:35

Nope, I'll never vote Labour. But equally Conservatives are absolutely awful - the current 'party-gate' just takes the piss. So I have no idea who I'll vote for tbh...

Brindle88 · 14/01/2022 16:48

That table shows we have had very high death rates, even though we’re not the worst, and many countries have had tiny rates compared to ours.
I don’t think we can argue that our government handled this pandemic well.

travellinglighter · 14/01/2022 16:04

@derxa

Biggest death toll per head of population in Europe Not true www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/ We have had a terribly badly managed pandemic but don't spread mistruths
I stand corrected but it’s extremely high and given we’re an island. It’s pretty poor.
pointythings · 14/01/2022 08:32

All the nonsense about Tony Blair gives me the rage. You'd think from all the outrage that he singlehandedly took the decision to invade Iraq and dragged the whole world along with it. Yes, it was wrong. And hell yes, the Tories would have done exactly the same thing and anyone who believes otherwise is a complete numpty.

derxa · 14/01/2022 07:00

Biggest death toll per head of population in Europe Not true
www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/
We have had a terribly badly managed pandemic but don't spread mistruths

SarahBellam · 14/01/2022 06:10

I’m a ‘small c’ conservative but can’t countenance voting for this shower of absolute, morally bankrupt, manipulative, contemptuous, gaslighting, lying, bastards, with that utter, utter, fuckwit at the helm. Not a chance in hell will they get my vote. We are living in an abusive relationship with our own government, who appear to have forgotten that they’re there to serve us, not the other at round. If there was an election tomorrow I’d vote for the party most likely to get them out. I really wouldn’t care who that might be at this stage.

travellinglighter · 14/01/2022 05:34

@starfro

Tories have handled the Pandemic pretty well. Labour in charge would've been a disaster and I'd have lost my job and home. The No10 parties are disappointing, but are inconsequential when it comes to me deciding who to vote for.

Tony Blair invaded Iraq resulting in millions of deaths, yet still got re-elected in 2005. Is a drinks party really comparable?

Have they? In what sense?

Biggest death toll per head of population in Europe.
£37 billion on a track and trace system that neither tracks or traces. Rampant corruption with regard to NHS contracts.where donors, friends and families benefited from an illegal vip lane.
Desperate shortage of PPE, millions spent on useless ppe, pandemic ppe stockpiles sold off five years ago against its own experts advice.
Failure to lock down early enough despite advance warning.
Opened up too early against scientific advice.
Eat out to help out should have been called eat out to infect.
Moved infected elderly into care homes.
Lack of testing.
Eased restrictions too early.
Promised a five day Christmas easing of restrictions last year against scientific advice, then they panicked and cancelled it.
Nightingales hospitals seemed like a good idea but we’re actually a total sham due to lack of staff.

All this against a background of an nhs that has been systematically run down and has lost thousands of bed since they came to power. .

Obviously we have no evidence that labour would have done any better under corbyn (who I didn’t like) but I can’t see him giving billions to his corporate mates(he doesn’t have any) and labour ran the nhs a lot better than the Tories did and it’s the nhs that did the lions share of the work when it comes to the pandemic.

With regard to Tony Blair, I despise the man but he didn’t do I alone. Did the tories oppose the Iraq war or did they vote for it in droves. Do you think a Tory prime minister would have told George W Bush to do one?

I don’t want to derail the thread but the fact of the matter is that the uk handled the pandemic badly on almost every metric but kept up a constant stream of self praise that gives the impression they did a great job.

Iggly · 13/01/2022 19:24

@AngelicInnocent

If they get rid of Boris and replace him with Rishi or Liz then yes, I would vote Conservative again. Current Tory MP here in what has always been a Labour seat and he is a bit of a numpty but is a local man and has been approachable and engaged since he got in. Previous Labour MP avoided engaging wherever possible.
You’d take Rishi, the billionaire who profited from the financial crisis in 2008? Or Liz Truss who’s done an about turn on Brexit just for career highs?!

What low standards.

AngelicInnocent · 13/01/2022 15:41

If they get rid of Boris and replace him with Rishi or Liz then yes, I would vote Conservative again. Current Tory MP here in what has always been a Labour seat and he is a bit of a numpty but is a local man and has been approachable and engaged since he got in. Previous Labour MP avoided engaging wherever possible.

chasingrain · 13/01/2022 14:18

I really believe Boris will step down - he has to. I think Lizz Truss will take his place and I will vote for her. She really stuck her neck out for women rights when no one else would. With out her catastrophic changes to the GRA would have happened and for the that I am eternally grateful

I am actually really worried that Angela Raynor will take top spot in Labour. I really really wish Labour would get their shit together so I can go 'home'

maddy68 · 13/01/2022 14:11

I will vote tactically. To get the Tories out be that labour or lib dem whichever is appropriate ar the time

Lurkerlot · 13/01/2022 14:09

Former Tory voter, firstly austerity began to ouch me away, the Brexit in fighting and lies pushed me further away, couldn’t ever bring myself to vote for Corbyn, the current Tory crop are abhorrent to me. If still in place, I will be voting Starmer at the next election.

Iggly · 13/01/2022 14:01

@starfro

Right now Diane Abbott is arguing for Zero Covid. That's how batshit insane the Labour Left are and why Labour are still unelectable.
You’re batshit for putting all the “left” in the same box based on one person.
Meshabubu · 12/01/2022 23:47

@whenwillthemadnessend

I voted for tory this election but I've voted Labour and Lib Dem in the past

I tend to go for the party I feel willl support my life more at the time. And those needs do change before I get jumped on.

Now I'm leaning towards Labour because of the sleeze however if they get a new leader in and she or he can turn things around then maybe I'll vote Tory again

However I will say I need more clarity from Labour as I do t really know what they want to do and I really don't like Angela raynor. If she went for PM there is no way I'd vote Labour.

The last couple of years, I'd actually say Labour have given total clarity about what it is they want to do.

What they want, is to pass everything Boris puts into Parliament, making sure the PM never faces losing a vote. They have said repeatedly on national TV, when something is up to come into the Commons, Labour will be preparing to pass it. Often this is said 3-4 days in advance, meaning they could not possibly have even bothered to read it.

What they want, is hundreds of thousands of NHS staff losing their livelihoods. see the website: NHS100k.com -- and now bear in mind, this is just the number that have put their names to a public declaration. The real figure is likely to be a multiple many, many, many times higher.

After passing said legislation, Labour went on camera boasting about making sure everyone knows, it was them who eased the passage of this law.

So not a chance we will get Labour.

I see some are bigging up the chances of Sunak as a potential Tory PM - but personally I really struggle to see the appeal of a guy with more money than the Queen, a £400,000 swimming pool, gives his Wife a pile of unjustified Government loan money, and is pushing hard for a digital currency that the Bank of England plainly admitted will be "Government programmable." so you can totally forget about buying what you want; it will be predetermined. Forever.

As a longtime Labour voter (who has voted across the board, admittedly, the last 3 elections) there is no future in the current parties in Parliament. Well there is a future, but it is not a pleasant one.

Really has to be time for a whole complete shake up. New blood, please.

starfro · 12/01/2022 23:33

Right now Diane Abbott is arguing for Zero Covid. That's how batshit insane the Labour Left are and why Labour are still unelectable.

Ionlydomassiveones · 12/01/2022 23:26

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

derxa · 12/01/2022 23:10

@starfro

Tories have handled the Pandemic pretty well. Labour in charge would've been a disaster and I'd have lost my job and home. The No10 parties are disappointing, but are inconsequential when it comes to me deciding who to vote for.

Tony Blair invaded Iraq resulting in millions of deaths, yet still got re-elected in 2005. Is a drinks party really comparable?

Precisely
starfro · 12/01/2022 23:07

Tories have handled the Pandemic pretty well. Labour in charge would've been a disaster and I'd have lost my job and home. The No10 parties are disappointing, but are inconsequential when it comes to me deciding who to vote for.

Tony Blair invaded Iraq resulting in millions of deaths, yet still got re-elected in 2005. Is a drinks party really comparable?

SonicBroom · 12/01/2022 23:06

These are great answers thanks all. I realise I could have phrased the question better, by former I meant people who’ve voted conservative but don’t want to again as opposed to anyone who has ever voted conservative… but I think most people understood what I meant!

As for Starmer, he appears to be shit-scared of saying absolutely anything controversial. Not just on that subject but on any policy at all. He appears to feel safer sitting on the fence until he's worked out which way the wind is blowing. As far as I am concerned he is a coward

I’ve not thought of this before but I think you’re right. He actually seems afraid of the British public , he does always seem scared of being controversial and upsetting anyone. And in that way he’s pleasing no one.

@Floundery - spot on. I’m in the same alley as you.

I’m surprised to hear the number of people for whom womens rights would stop them voting labour. Perhaps as I hadn’t given it enough thought myself but now it’s raised, yes wholeheartedly if they’re too scared to even say what they think a woman is then what hope, especially as women, do we have? Not a reason that conservatives are better, just that we have to ask for better from our politicians.

OP posts:
Earlydancing · 12/01/2022 22:56

@SeaWitchly

Which Corbyn policies do you have an issue with?

Great question.

I, personally, didn't have a problem with Corbyn. But I just couldn't figure out what he was about. I felt he was being forced to be dishonest because the party was scared that what he really thought would frighten the voters.

I didn't like that he wanted to do away with the Queen, wouldn't sing the national anthem, wouldn't wear a poppy. But I admired him for taking the stance against so much criticism. The next thing he is wearing a poppy and singing the national anthem (I think he always wanted rid of the Queen, TBF.) So now, he still believed things that I didn't and I couldn't even admire him for standing up for what he believed in so I didn't even respect him.

I agreed with quite a lot of things he said but you could never be sure that he was going to stick with it. He supported Brexit, he opposed Brexit, he opposed Brexit and supported it. Who knows what he thought? And then at the election, every day he was coming up with another policy that the govt was going to spend billions on. I didn't necessarily disagree (although I think people look back on public services as if they were the best functioning ever. My god, the length of time I had to wait to get a phone put in or my electricity started. And trains were dirty and ran equally late.), but there was no long term plan for anything. It was all just reactive and populist and too much.
That's why I couldn't vote for Corbyn.

derxa · 12/01/2022 22:33

@Floundery

I'm also politically homeless - I abhor the odious Boris, find Keir Starmer breathtakingly dull and sanctimonious and think Angela Rayner comes across as the kind of scrote who'd pick a fight with you in a dark alley.

I could probably get behind the Tories under Rishi.

You've expressed it perfectly
JustAnotherPoster00 · 12/01/2022 21:58

A spoilt ballot is a vote for the incumbent MP

SeaWitchly · 12/01/2022 21:48

Which Corbyn policies do you have an issue with?

Great question.

Dogmum40 · 12/01/2022 20:20

For the first time ever I don’t think I’m in a position to vote! I’ve voted all 3 major parties for different reasons in the past but I genuinely have no clue who I would pick out that circus , I suppose I could vote the Green Party 🤷‍♀️