Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

4 year old refusing activities

58 replies

Frizzyhairhelp · 12/01/2022 10:41

Uses to love them. Now refuses. Swimming lessons although He loves swimming with us. Very despondent. Any advice?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
jojolondon81 · 21/12/2022 14:33

I just found this thread as was searching for a similar problem… 4yo dd suddenly refusing to take part in gymnastics after being really enthusiastic about it previously. I totally get your frustration, especially when tired. Jeeeeeez, some of these comments. Why do so many people immediately rush to judgement? Have they honestly never experienced frustration at the contradictions of 3/4yos?! For me it’s been tricky deciding how to play it. I certainly wouldn’t force her to do an activity I honestly thought she hated, but it’s harder when you suspect they do enjoy it really. Shame for them to miss out entirely because of a temporary blip. Just wanted to say solidarity really, and I hope it all worked out for the best for you.

Frizzyhairhelp · 12/01/2022 19:19

Thank you so much to everyone who understands the feelings i had!

I think as @LovelyMoans says it might be a case of not feeling good at it (For some reason). It's very hard to get 121 swimming lessons around here and I'm not keen to repeat weekly the experience of him refusing to go in while everyone else is happy to! I don't want to put him off it.

As for the activity he has always done, I'm really hoping it's a 1st day after Xmas blip...

I'm a bit surprised at some of the negative assumptions that have been made by some, I must say!

OP posts:
LovelyMoans · 12/01/2022 19:08

I think at this age there's a bit of shift from doing activities purely for the fun of it, to a bigger expectation that you will follow instructions, make progress, and actually learn.

I think a lot of kids simply find it less fun, they start being aware they maybe can't instantly do everything that's being asked of them, it's a bit harder.

My DS has been a bit the same, I just make it clear that in return for me taking him "fun" swimming on the weekend, he has to do his best in lessons on a weekday. I also dropped another activity as realised we were doing too much.

elelel · 12/01/2022 19:02

It's not the swimming lesson OP is talking about.

itshappened · 12/01/2022 19:01

My 4 year old screamed about swimming classes for years but we stuck at it as I think it's just something they need to learn. These days she loves it so I'm glad we did. I find with other activities she is much better if I'm not there, as for some reason the minute I'm in the room she won't get involved or interact with the other children. I thought that perhaps she has a social anxiety but I am told she is very popular and loves it when I'm not there... but I can totally relate to how you felt today. I have felt exasperated in the past when we have organised an activity or she goes to a party and all the other children are happy and seem to love doing the activity together, whilst my daughter hides behind my legs crying.

SeasonFinale · 12/01/2022 17:28

Hi I think if you do family things that mean swimming is a necessity then it is a non negotiable activity. I think he will soon get bored of standing with his arms crossed and just join in. Perhaps appeal to a competitive side by having some form or reward chart based on the things he is learning at swimming. Perhaps have a level after which he can stop eg. 25metres .

I find little boys are open to bribery!

Frizzyhairhelp · 12/01/2022 13:49

Thanks everyone!

OP posts:
Merriwicks · 12/01/2022 12:57

My 5 year old went through this and 3 year old starting to go through this. If they have told me they want to do it and I've paid then they have to at least go. I tell them though that if they don't like it they can leave (I be outside) and if they don't enjoy it they don't have to go back next week. They have yet to come out saying they didn't enjoy something. It is always yes i want to go back next week and occasionally cycle would continue. 5 year old is totally out the other side of this and looks forward to all her activities. 3 year old is now at the stage where she struggles to move between activities. Doesn't want to go as playing at home etc. So won't get changed into her gear. But when leaving the house to take her sister she will come running looking to go. I don't force her to get changed because she is still little, I would rather her have fun doing the activity. (the class also has other kids not in uniform so it is not like she is the only one)

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 12/01/2022 12:57

Give it a couple more weeks, he might just be exhausted after Christmas. Mine go moody when they are exhausted.

If he’s still not budging pull him out. You don’t want swimming to become a negative experience for him, especially if you do a lot of water related stuff. Focus on swimming as a family and having lots of fun - we had to with dd and she’s very confident swimmer now, loves her lessons.

SVRT19674 · 12/01/2022 12:54

Curious. My daughter kicks up a fuss going in to swimming lessons, doesn´t want to go to the "station" as she calls it and it really got to me. The only reason she goes once a week to swim on Saturdays is because our block has a swimming pool by it and we are concerned she is near it and can´t swim and we think it is an important skill. She is 3.5 years old. The thing is when you pick her up 45 minutes later she is all smiles and thumbs up and she had "a very good time" at lesson. Sometimes I want to strangle her :-) So I can relate where you are coming from. It is sometimes difficult to be calm and collected. Reading the responses you got I have also taken them on board. Be kind to yourself. You aren´t killing her just taking her to swimming lessons!

Frizzyhairhelp · 12/01/2022 12:50

And @skgnome thank you. These are really useful comments which help!

OP posts:
Incywinceyspider · 12/01/2022 12:48

When you say it's something he's done for years, is it largely aimed towards toddlers (e.g. a dance class or similar)? Could it be that he's just growing out of it?

Frizzyhairhelp · 12/01/2022 12:47

Lol.i didn't flounder out of the room!! Most parents leave. After trying to encourage him nicely I thought it would be best to leave to see if he was better without me there!

And I think some are assuming I was going to shout at him. I was just worried I would say something stupid which wouldn't help.

Thank you for the reality check! You're right it's just 1 class and the tiredness is clouding my feelings!

OP posts:
Frizzyhairhelp · 12/01/2022 12:44

Thanks @seeline :)

OP posts:
SmellyOldOwls · 12/01/2022 12:39

@Frizzyhairhelp

Yes first week back. I know it's ridiculous. It's just disappointing when you plan something nice and then it's not great. And you're tired!!
Hello, welcome to parenting? You are the adult so it's up to you to look after your DC, listen to what they are telling you, hide your disappointment and take them home when they don't want to join in rather than flouncing out of the room, starting a mumsnet thread and generally being over dramatic about it. Take the kid home, spend a bit of time with him and talk to him about why he didn't want to join in rather than stamping your feet about it.
Frizzyhairhelp · 12/01/2022 12:38

That's a strange comment!!! @esloquehay please explain how you got that ....

OP posts:
skgnome · 12/01/2022 12:38
  1. First week back - just persevere a couple more weeks to get back in the routine
  2. Even at 4 they are allowed to change their mind on things they have always enjoyed, if it’s meant to be for their enjoyment just let him out
  3. Swimming, that I would agree with you… however my DD has always loved/enjoyed water… been swimming since baby lessons… we had to take her out at 3, since lessons at that age were not an enjoyable experience for anyone… and we were paying for her to sulk on the side of the pool (although she did had the best time on the weekends with us) - we did took her out, keep swimming as a fun weekly family activity, she went back at 6 and still going strong at team level at 11 - so I would say, give him a break from lessons, but keep swimming as a fun activity
Seeline · 12/01/2022 12:35

If it's just been one week, in the nicest way, I think you're being a bit dramatic Smile

Maybe it was a bit overwhelming after the Christmas break
Maybe he was feeling a bit tired, or under the weather
Maybe he just didn't fancy it last night
Maybe if he's been doing it for a while he has just got a bit bored of it

Don't make a fuss, just try again next week. If he really doesn't want to do it anymore, accept it and wither try something new, or let him have a break from activities for a bit.

esloquehay · 12/01/2022 12:32

You seem more concerned about how this impacts on you, rather than how it affects your DC.

Frizzyhairhelp · 12/01/2022 12:28

It's just this week he has always loved it. It's just this plus the swimming the other day. The arms crossed and refusing

OP posts:
Frizzyhairhelp · 12/01/2022 12:24

Yes first week back. I know it's ridiculous. It's just disappointing when you plan something nice and then it's not great. And you're tired!!

OP posts:
Seeline · 12/01/2022 12:19

Is it just this week he hasn't joined in?
Was there a break over the Christmas holidays and this is the first week back?

converseandjeans · 12/01/2022 12:15

frizzyhair

I can't watch as I'll just say something I'll regret

This is ridiculous. What might you say? Why would you have a go at a 4 year old who doesn't want to do an activity? Just let him have a couple of weeks off & see if he is better then. He might be tired post Christmas?

Frizzyhairhelp · 12/01/2022 12:03

Baby is 11 months so not that young! Just disappointing to plan stuff they have always enjoyed. Completely take on board comments and will see what it's like next week then try cancel if not. Shame as i used to love watching him have lots of fun

OP posts:
Frizzyhairhelp · 12/01/2022 12:00

Exactly @volhhg

OP posts: