Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU Friend is refusing to attend DD's Christening

189 replies

LouBan · 12/01/2022 00:11

My DD has just turned two and we are finally getting her dedicated (just like a Christening but without water). We would have done it soon after she was born but had to put things on hold due to Covid. We have chosen to invite just family, godparents and one other close friend who is almost like family. He is not a Christian and doesn't like the idea of church at all but we have been to weddings and a funeral with him, all were which in churches and he seemed fine. Ever since our DD was born he has said he would come to her dedication even though he doesn't like church. Now 10 days before, he has let us know by text that he's not coming without giving a reason. AiBU to be upset? We are asking him to be part of something that is really special to us but it is for us and our DD, not him, and as a friend I think he should respect that we want to do this at our church. All he has to do is sit through one church service (No one is going to check if he's singing the hymns or joining in the prayers) and join us for lunch afterwards. I don't think this is a lot to ask. AIBU?

OP posts:
HaveringWavering · 12/01/2022 00:46

@negomi90

Weddings and funeral have non religious elements. Marriage is a legal thing as well as a religious one. A funeral is a personal way of saying good bye. There are reasons to go to both of them even if the ceremonies are religious. A christening/dedication is purely about the religion. Yes its a party for the individual, but the ceremony has no other value than religion. An atheist may not want to celebrate the induction of someone into religion especially when the individual involved (baby/toddler) has no understanding of what's going on. The principle is very different.
Bang on. Agree wholeheartedly.
OddshoesOddsocks · 12/01/2022 00:34

You said it yourself- it’s for you and your dd, not him.

Maybe it’s sucky to let you down at short notice but tbh I don’t think 10 days is particularly short notice, especially when he has repeatedly mentioned how uncomfortable he is.

Also I don’t think you can compare a dedication to a funeral…

So YABU and entitled. Your religion (and your dd) will not be as important to anyone else but you and you can’t expect them to be.

Hairyfriend · 12/01/2022 00:34

Neither you nor us know exactly why he has decided not to attend? I've never heard of a dedication, so not sure if its the same as being a god parent, but here a just some of the thoughts that 'might' pass someones mind when being asked and not having all the info about what it involves. I was asked to be a god mother years ago, and some of these thoughts actually crossed my mind a the time, because I had no idea what it really meant:

  • Do I need to buy this child and possibly future siblings gifts for Christmas and their dedication day forever more?
  • If you and partner/DH were to die, I'd have to take on/adopt this child
  • I don't want to be inside a church or any building with randoms during a pandemic
  • What other things does this commitment involve in future? Is there a ceremony every year?
  • Am I suppose to provide emotional support, take care of, baby sit this child as their dedication person?

I assume you have at least 1 other person to take on the role? Is there another you have in mind?

melj1213 · 12/01/2022 00:27

Firstly, you don't know why he has changed his mind - something may have come up in his personal life that he isn't ready to share with you that means he may not be able to attend.

Secondly, just because it is special to you doesn't mean he has to attend.

You have said he doesn't like church, so its up to him whether he is willing to sit through a church service where your child is welcomed into the church family - and especially with such a small service it is hard to sit it out in the same way as you can if there is a bigger congregation where you can blend in and your non-participation is less likely to be noticed.

2022HowDoYouDo · 12/01/2022 00:27

An invitation is not a summons. YABU.

Cattitudes · 12/01/2022 00:25

He isn't religious so it won't hold the same meaning for him and he might feel really uncomfortable there, especially as the congregation would usually make promises too. A wedding or funeral are different. I would be gracious and say if he would be happy to come you would love to see him at the lunch afterwards. In fact we said that to all our friends they were welcome at one or the other or both because they are our friends and we wanted them to be comfortable.

Porcupineintherough · 12/01/2022 00:24

Can you really not think of any reasons other than religion why he might not be comfortable attending a church service right now? Besides which, you should respect his lack of belief.

negomi90 · 12/01/2022 00:23

Weddings and funeral have non religious elements. Marriage is a legal thing as well as a religious one. A funeral is a personal way of saying good bye. There are reasons to go to both of them even if the ceremonies are religious.
A christening/dedication is purely about the religion. Yes its a party for the individual, but the ceremony has no other value than religion. An atheist may not want to celebrate the induction of someone into religion especially when the individual involved (baby/toddler) has no understanding of what's going on.
The principle is very different.

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 12/01/2022 00:21

Hmm, I think yabu.

You're clearly good friends, so he's not going to do this just to spite you. It sounds like he's uncomfortable with christenings and you should respect that. He might think that a person should choose to be christened rather than their parents choosing for them when they're so young.

NatriumChloride · 12/01/2022 00:21

I voted YABU as you don’t even know that the issue here is the church aspect of it? Is he cautious of large gatherings due to Covid? Perhaps he’s tested positive himself or trying to shield someone else?

BobbieT1999 · 12/01/2022 00:19

Agree with @SpindleyCrow

SpindleyCrow · 12/01/2022 00:17

I think you need to accept this with good grace.

Christenings / baptisms / dedications (not heard that one before) aren't for everyone and I think that your friend did try to warn you of that repeatedly.

I think there's a deep Christian religiosity about christenings that isn't present these days within the concepts and events of weddings and funerals.

Hugasauras · 12/01/2022 00:17

If he didn't give a reason, then you can't be sure why he isn't coming, surely? Maybe there's some other reason that's nothing to do with it.

UltraVividLament · 12/01/2022 00:16

YABU in that you don't actually know if it's the church issue that is the reason he now isn't attending. Have you asked him why?

Swipe left for the next trending thread