Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU Friend is refusing to attend DD's Christening

189 replies

LouBan · 12/01/2022 00:11

My DD has just turned two and we are finally getting her dedicated (just like a Christening but without water). We would have done it soon after she was born but had to put things on hold due to Covid. We have chosen to invite just family, godparents and one other close friend who is almost like family. He is not a Christian and doesn't like the idea of church at all but we have been to weddings and a funeral with him, all were which in churches and he seemed fine. Ever since our DD was born he has said he would come to her dedication even though he doesn't like church. Now 10 days before, he has let us know by text that he's not coming without giving a reason. AiBU to be upset? We are asking him to be part of something that is really special to us but it is for us and our DD, not him, and as a friend I think he should respect that we want to do this at our church. All he has to do is sit through one church service (No one is going to check if he's singing the hymns or joining in the prayers) and join us for lunch afterwards. I don't think this is a lot to ask. AIBU?

OP posts:
TheNoodlesIncident · 12/01/2022 07:56

Ten days seems like plenty notice that he's changed his mind, for whatever reason, to attend an event like this. It's not like a concert or theatre tickets, it's a religious ceremony in a church. I've attended a Christening and I didn't repeat all the solemn vows of helping the child follow a religion I'm not invested in. The parents and near family can, if they like, but we are simply family friends and it's nothing to do with us. I do note the difference between the two ceremonies but to be honest, there doesn't seem a lot in it between them. Maybe your friend doesn't see much difference either.

But there are many reasons why he might now feel he can't attend, including some very obvious ones. So I don't think you're being reasonable to be annoyed at his letting you know in advance he won't be attending after all.

AnnaSW1 · 12/01/2022 07:56

I think YABU

ArblemarchTFruitbat · 12/01/2022 07:52

If he'd said repeatedly that he'd come and then cancelled by text without giving any reason, I think he is being unreasonable. It would be different if it had never been discussed between the friend and the OP or if the friend had always said he wouldn't attend.

FWIW I am an agnostic but it wouldn't stop me attending this sort of ceremony for a friend.

milkieway · 12/01/2022 07:47

You need to ask if he's ok- at the moment you've no idea why he isn't coming but he does have every right to decline your invite even at this late stage

LadyPenelope68 · 12/01/2022 07:47

@LouBan
Weddings and funeral have non religious elements. Marriage is a legal thing as well as a religious one. A funeral is a personal way of saying good bye. There are reasons to go to both of them even if the ceremonies are religious. A christening/dedication is purely about the religion. Yes its a party for the individual, but the ceremony has no other value than religion. An atheist may not want to celebrate the induction of someone into religion especially when the individual involved (baby/toddler) has no understanding of what's going

Absolutely this ^^

You sound like hard work and very entitled, plus as someone else has said, it’s an invitation not a summons.

5128gap · 12/01/2022 07:47

I can understand why someone would object more to a christening than wedding or funeral. People having church weddings and funerals have chosen to do so, so are presumably accepting of the religious aspects. A child has no choice in the promises made on their behalf, so it seems more of an imposition somehow, and for people very opposed to religion, I can see this would be a moral conflict for them. Would he attend a reception afterwards? I think as a friend he should be prepared to do this.

ExcaliburBaby · 12/01/2022 07:45

I think YABU. Many people who are not keen on religion can tolerate church weddings as they involve consenting adults. Christenings involve pledging a Christian lifestyle for a child who has no say in the matter. This doesn’t sit well with many people. If this is the case with your friend I think while it’s ok to be disappointed that he won’t be there, you need to respect his views. Funerals are also a different situation as they are about paying respects/ saying goodbye to someone in the manner they would have wanted.

MyOtherProfile · 12/01/2022 07:44

You need to ask him if he is ok. He might have a genuine reason.

GoodnightGrandma · 12/01/2022 07:41

He has every right to not go and not give you a reason.

Technosaurus · 12/01/2022 07:40

*should have said "Religious weddings/funerals are organised..."

Technosaurus · 12/01/2022 07:39

I'm an atheist and I don't go to christenings.

Weddings and funerals are organised by consenting adults who choose to believe in it, and I attend them through gritted teeth. Christenings/dedications are, in my opinion, the foisting of one's beliefs onto young child who can't make their own decisions.

Or, even worse, pretending to believe to get into a school at a later stage. Don't even get me started on the "well we're not religious but it's a nice excuse for a get-together" brigade.

If the parents want to do it, that's fine, but I refuse to be present and pretend to be happy for such things.

FocacciaFingerer · 12/01/2022 07:35

I always politely decline a Christening
He obviously has his reasons and you should respect them

Cocopogo · 12/01/2022 07:32

I would reply along the lines of oh that’s a shame, hope everything’s ok? Or I’d just call and check he’s ok if he’s such a good friend.

KiloWhat · 12/01/2022 07:32

He's given you 10 days notice.
You know he's not Christian so why does it matter if he's there or not. Surely the whole point is it means a lot to you and your religion and everyone else going who is Christian.
I went to a dedication and as a non Christian found it very uncomfortable.

Skyeheather · 12/01/2022 07:26

He's declined your invitation not "refusing" to go. People are allowed to decline invitations. Just because the dedication is important to you it doesn't mean it's important to everyone else. Just accept he isn't going and move on.

Luredbyapomegranate · 12/01/2022 07:23

Are you sure it isn’t Covid related?

Other than that it’s annoying but not unreasonable, if he has a real ethical objection to organised religion. As a PP said christenings are a lot less secular than weddings and funerals. If this is the case he should have let you know earlier though.

Anyway, I would just give him a bell, say you are sorry he can’t make it and check he’s OK. It might be an issue you can solve.

MelonTits · 12/01/2022 07:21

Surely people have heard the phrase "hatching, matching and dispatching"? Religion is often there for the big moments of our lives- birth, marriage and death. What is so terrible about wanting to mark major moments in life with rituals? This is one of the core functions of religion throughout history.

But a lot of people now think more critically about that sort of thing, realise it’s often a bit of a sham and decide not to participate. I appreciate that cultural Christianity does run strong in Britain but I’m glad that there is less blind following of that now.

I went to a few christenings as a child & enjoyed the pretty dress I wore and the chance to see family, and then didn’t go to another one until I was about 24 and my best friend had her daughter christened. It was then I realised what an odd ritual it was (especially for someone who had a non-religious wedding on an Italian lakefront!) and I haven’t been to one since.

Wombat98 · 12/01/2022 07:17

Covid?

Not a chance I'd sit in a room with a congregation, singing & talking, just now..

verytiredofbeingshoutedat · 12/01/2022 07:16

I definitely agree with other PPs that if he said he was coming it is annoying he changed his mind 10 days beforehand

But as many said, he's not that into it clearly. So have a great day with those that are. And want to support you

My daughter has a god father that attended church but saw her twice afterwards and she doesn't even know him. He makes no effort at all. He was my exHs friend who we regret having as a godparent as it means one DC had two involved godparents whereas my other two DCs have 3 who are fabulous.

Riverlee · 12/01/2022 07:14

I think you need to find out the reason first.

MoonCowbag · 12/01/2022 07:14

Well that quote didn't work and now I look daft.

MoonCowbag · 12/01/2022 07:13
Grin
Hesma · 12/01/2022 07:11

If he’s such a good friend then you need to respect his views. Additionally you don’t know why he’s declined to attend

WaterBottle123 · 12/01/2022 07:05

Christenings are only for religious family members, it's not reasonable to push your beliefs on others by expecting them to attend

umpahlumpahstickitupyourjumpah · 12/01/2022 07:00

YABU

Swipe left for the next trending thread