Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU Friend is refusing to attend DD's Christening

189 replies

LouBan · 12/01/2022 00:11

My DD has just turned two and we are finally getting her dedicated (just like a Christening but without water). We would have done it soon after she was born but had to put things on hold due to Covid. We have chosen to invite just family, godparents and one other close friend who is almost like family. He is not a Christian and doesn't like the idea of church at all but we have been to weddings and a funeral with him, all were which in churches and he seemed fine. Ever since our DD was born he has said he would come to her dedication even though he doesn't like church. Now 10 days before, he has let us know by text that he's not coming without giving a reason. AiBU to be upset? We are asking him to be part of something that is really special to us but it is for us and our DD, not him, and as a friend I think he should respect that we want to do this at our church. All he has to do is sit through one church service (No one is going to check if he's singing the hymns or joining in the prayers) and join us for lunch afterwards. I don't think this is a lot to ask. AIBU?

OP posts:
DontWantTheRivalry · 14/01/2022 07:42

YABU.

I am not religious and try and avoid Christenings at all costs. I feel very uncomfortable attending them because I don’t believe in the words being spoken so I feel very hypocritical.

A previous poster said a Dedication is about thanking God for the safe arrival of a baby whereas in my mind the arrival of a baby (whether safely or sadly not) is down to the efforts of the medical team and most importantly the mother, not God. Your friend may feel the same.

ThirdElephant · 14/01/2022 06:19

@Parker231

I go to christenings but happy to avoid them when I can as they aren’t something I agree with. Let the child decide on whether they want to follow an organised religion when they are old enough to understand rather than you making the decision for them as a baby.
Christenings don't force anything, just so you know. You promise to teach/raise them in the belief but the kid itself isn't compelled to do anything- they sign up themselves via confirmation if they want to when they're older. The purpose of a christening is more of an introduction and, in some branches of Christianity, stops them wandering purgatory forever if they die before confirmation.
merrymouse · 13/01/2022 19:59

@Flowersandhearts

Maybe there's another reason that he's not attending?

Cancelling 10 days before an important event is rude, regardless of someone's beliefs and particularly if he knew you were only inviting a few close people!

I'm agnostic but guessing that 80+% people have a strong atheist belief (people should keep in mind that atheism is a position of belief).

I agree.
Flowersandhearts · 13/01/2022 19:56

80+% of people on this thread I mean.

Flowersandhearts · 13/01/2022 19:54

Maybe there's another reason that he's not attending?

Cancelling 10 days before an important event is rude, regardless of someone's beliefs and particularly if he knew you were only inviting a few close people!

I'm agnostic but guessing that 80+% people have a strong atheist belief (people should keep in mind that atheism is a position of belief).

Willome · 13/01/2022 19:34

Other people's DC are just not that important to some people.

sadpapercourtesan · 13/01/2022 19:34

If he isn't a Christian, then he has a good reason. Why on earth would he want to go and collude in you making a solemn commitment to indoctrinate your child into a supernatural belief system? Why would he want to collude in your making a commitment on behalf of your child, who is a person in his/her own right and too young to consent?

It always amazing me that Christians (particularly the US right-wing ones who bleat on about "religious freedom") make no effort to understand how their rituals and behaviours appear to those who simply do not share their beliefs.

He's not trying to stop you from having your child christened. He just doesn't want to be involved.

psydrive · 13/01/2022 19:30

@LouBan

Have you spoken to him yet?

Somebodylikeyew · 13/01/2022 18:00

@StrifeOfBath

You are being a Godzilla.
Grin
CuntyMcBollocks · 13/01/2022 09:10

Maybe he does have a good reason but doesn't want to/can't say what it is right now.

EmmaH2022 · 13/01/2022 07:41

@LouBan

We attend church regularly and our faith is very important to us. My husband is actually training to become a Vicar. Our friend knows all this so shouldn't be surprised. We were just hurt that he doesn't want to come.
So have you asked why he can't come? Why are you just assuming it's an anti church reason?
londonrach · 13/01/2022 07:36

Yabu...invite not court summons. He can turn the invite down for whatever reason. Life not all about you!

MagnoliaXYZ · 13/01/2022 07:34

I agree with what other people gave said regarding there being a big difference between weddings/funerals and christenings.

I've never been invited to a church wedding but would attend one as the couple would have chosen to get married in a church, and are presumably religious.

I have been to funeral/cremation services which have been religious because that is all I have ever known, fortunately the only people I have known well enough to go to the funeral have been older so a religious ceremony was expected - I guess there are non-religious services available.

When I volunteered with an organisation, we were expected to attend a couple if church services per year, such as remembrance parade. I felt uncomfortable in church but attendance was expected. The best church service I attended was one where we had a child of a different religion with us, either parents or child didn't want them going in (child attended for the parade part only), parents weren't there so I was the lucky one who got out of the church service to sit outside with the child until it was over.

I would feel really uncomfortable at a baby/young child's christening (or equivalent). I feel that someone making a commitment to the church should be made of their own free will and I would be uncomfortable being part of, what I viewed as, an unfair induction in to that religion. If one of my friends decided to become religious and be baptised/confirmed etc and invited me to attend the ceremony, I would go as I would view it as their choice and they would be making it freely. I would probably decline an invite to a baby or young child's christening etc though.

I used to be quite religious and go to church every Sunday, from the age of about 11 or 12 for a few years. I can't really remember who made the decision, but parents or grandparents thought it about time my siblings and I got baptised. I suppose we just got swept up in it all as we were taken along to church and attended every Sunday for weeks and weeks beforehand. We were baptised along with another girl around the same age. She and her parents stopped going but we continued for another few years. We got involved in volunteering for the church and started helping out at Sunday school as we got older. I don't think it was called confirmation but we went to the classes for whatever it was called and then had that service. There were regularly christenings in the Sunday services, I think she babies except one man who was being baptised so he could marry (one of the women who attended church regularly) in the church. I stopped attending the church when I was about 17 or so and completely stopped believing in religion and I'm actually very anti-religion now. None of the people I saw be christened/baptised etc did it of their own free will or legitimately consented (and I include the man who was baptised as I believe he only did it so he could give the woman he loved what she wanted - a church wedding) and that bothers me. I think even we were coerced into it, I think we got swept up in the whole baptism thing and religion thing - I really can't remember being properly religious before then (we were taught we had to say prayers before bed but that was it) - I think it was being in church that made me believe every word in the bible was true. It actually makes me quite angry. I think the only time a baby or young child should be christened should be if they are going to die and it would distress the parents if they hadn't been christened (is it catholics who believe even a baby can't get to heaven if they've not been baptised?). If you were my friend inviting me to your baby's christening etc, I wouldn't want to say this to you but it is how I would feel.

StrifeOfBath · 13/01/2022 03:54

You are being a Godzilla.

StrifeOfBath · 13/01/2022 03:49

The dedication is a religious event, meaningful to religious people.

I would feel hypocritical and uncomfortable being part of such an event.

Celebrate this essentially religious event with those for whom it means something.

Your friend does not care for you or your child less because he does not share your religious practice.

You on the other hand seem to expect him to comply with your way of doing things.

TheHamburgler · 13/01/2022 02:27

Non-religious myself.

I’ll happily go to a religious ceremony for a wedding, because even if I don’t buy (or like) the religious aspects, I can still enjoy friends or family members having a do to celebrate their relationship.

I’ll happily go to a religious funeral to provide emotional support, and to show my appreciation and/or respect for the deceased.

A christening or similar though...I just don’t like any aspect of them and would have nothing to celebrate. I’d just feel quietly judgy. Probably not what you’d want in a guest.

Migrainesbythedozen · 13/01/2022 00:19

@LouBan

We attend church regularly and our faith is very important to us. My husband is actually training to become a Vicar. Our friend knows all this so shouldn't be surprised. We were just hurt that he doesn't want to come.
But OP @LouBan do you even know why he is not attending? You haven't even answered that. Did you ask him why? It may be because of the church, it may not be.

You have a right to be hurt, however you need to understand, as pointed out on this thread by many others, that many people do not agree with forcing religion on innocent babies/children. Adults can make up their own minds. But Christenings are dying out because people now see (in their opinion) that it is wrong to do that to a child, hence the difference between weddings/funerals, and christenings.

'If' it is because of religion, maybe he said he would go to placate you, but couldn't go against his values and principles at the end? And doesn't feel he can tell you that he believes what you are doing is wrong? Either way, you need to accept that many people disagree with Christenings and that's ok and to accept that. Just as he needs to accept that you believe in Christenings, and he can either choose to go or not go.

bluegreygreen · 12/01/2022 17:47

I think you are being unreasonable for two reasons

  • one, you haven't had a conversation with your friend to ask him why he no longer wants to come (you don't actually know)
  • two, there are many reasons, detailed in the thread, why people would not be comfortable attending a dedication / christening when the would attend a different ceremony
WeAllHaveWings · 12/01/2022 16:36

@LouBan

We attend church regularly and our faith is very important to us. My husband is actually training to become a Vicar. Our friend knows all this so shouldn't be surprised. We were just hurt that he doesn't want to come.
Hopefully he will have more understanding by the end of his training Hmm
Stroopwaffle5000 · 12/01/2022 16:04

@MintJulia

yabu. You are asking him to pay lip service to a religion in which he has no faith. To be a hypocrite.

And you are asking him to support you in imposing that religion on a child who cannot make their own decision.

He must be allowed to act with his conscience.

This is why I refuse to attend Christenings.
MsMeNz · 12/01/2022 15:10

Yeah I can't stand going to religious stuff it makes me deeply uncomfortable to the point of panic (I have religion based traumas) i still love and respect those that do all that so long as they don't try to push and of it on me. Maybe it's not that bad for your friend but no everyone is comfortable with that stuff. I appreciate I seem dramatic about this stuff so I never discuss irl.

Sportslady44 · 12/01/2022 15:03

Do you want to lose his friendship if so carry on moaning and making a thing of it.

I should just let it it dosent matter if he is there or not as long as you and your daughter are what does it matter?

Ovenaffray · 12/01/2022 13:45

There are many branches of Christianity that do adult baptism with adult confession of faith.

Those tend to have a dedication service for babies.

This isn’t hard to understand, surely?

Hemingwayzcatz · 12/01/2022 13:07

It might be nothing to do with the fact it’s a christening, perhaps he has personal problems he didn’t wish to divulge. Who knows really.

1AngelicFruitCake · 12/01/2022 12:46

@MelonTits

Surely people have heard the phrase "hatching, matching and dispatching"? Religion is often there for the big moments of our lives- birth, marriage and death. What is so terrible about wanting to mark major moments in life with rituals? This is one of the core functions of religion throughout history.

But a lot of people now think more critically about that sort of thing, realise it’s often a bit of a sham and decide not to participate. I appreciate that cultural Christianity does run strong in Britain but I’m glad that there is less blind following of that now.

I went to a few christenings as a child & enjoyed the pretty dress I wore and the chance to see family, and then didn’t go to another one until I was about 24 and my best friend had her daughter christened. It was then I realised what an odd ritual it was (especially for someone who had a non-religious wedding on an Italian lakefront!) and I haven’t been to one since.

I agree. I find it ‘weird’ that people use going to a church, get christened then forget about it as something you just do! What’s the point unless it has proper meaning behind it?
Swipe left for the next trending thread