Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is MN middle class? Feeling inadequate and that my life is boring.

332 replies

sleaf · 11/01/2022 21:50

Is MN mainly full of middle to upper class posters?

Having read through some of the threads, especially tonight's holiday thread where everyone appears to be having multiple holidays this year, I'm feeling very low and inadequate, and that there's something wrong in my life Sad

Oh well, comparison is the thief of joy and all that.

OP posts:
Oblomov22 · 12/01/2022 09:27

Oh come some of the recent comments are just misery comparing. Eg ..., I haven't been on a holiday in 67 years .... aka monty python - we were so poor sketch.

People have different priorities and spend their money differently. Funji said people have had their holidays cancelled. I know that lots have. But I know lots that haven't.

I haven't had covid and Barely anyone I know has. We went to our caravan in Dorset plenty last year. I always go on a long European weekend with my friends and I did again last autumn. And unlike others who hate packing, I love going, and booking all the flights, accommodation, restaurants. I even enjoyed booking all the covid tests to fly. It wasn't a hassle to me. I am called Judith Chalmers. Grin

Just coz you lot find it all a misery. Not all of us do.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 12/01/2022 09:27

You also can’t call your child a name beginning with K

This is especially daft as Katherine/ Katharine considered is the more upper class spelling .

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 12/01/2022 09:25

Deliberately didn’t click on that holiday thread!

Kanaloa · 12/01/2022 09:24

@5128gap

I've learned from MN, that if I were MC I would not be allowed to put my Xmas lights up early, have hair extensions, let my children use character towels for swimming lessons, call my parents mothers 'Nan', have outdoor furniture, go on a package holiday, call my DC a name beginning with J, or date a bin man. Which all seems a bit restrictive to me, so happy to pass.Grin
You also can’t call your child a name beginning with K or shop at b&ms or eat Ferrero Rocher. It’s a hard life pretending to be middle class. Takes ages swapping all the shopping from Asda carrier bags to the Waitrose ones as well.
Kanaloa · 12/01/2022 09:23

@Herani

School fees gobbled up most of our money that would otherwise be spent on holidays. Interestingly, when I had one DC in prep and one in state, it was the state school families I knew who seemed to be jetting off regularly on amazing holidays. I presume either because flashy holidays were either a status symbol (you'd have to understand the area I live in) or lack of fees to pay towards schooling meant (in a wealthy area) a bigger holiday budget. Like many others, we had to grow to love camping and the occasional trip abroad until we were more flush.
Why would you presume they were going on holidays (a normal thing to do) as a ‘status symbol’ when your second option (living in a wealthy area with no school fees) is the obvious reason?

If you couldn’t afford it because of school fees and they don’t pay school fees obviously that’s how they afford it. Presuming it’s a status symbol would be as odd as those families saying ‘yes some people send their kids to the flashy private school, as a status symbol, you know.’

Isn’t it possible people just prioritise their money differently and really love travelling and going on holiday while being happy that the state school is providing a good education to their children?

Waxonwaxoff0 · 12/01/2022 09:21

@aSofaNearYou

I think MN is pretty MC, I think the worst way this manifests is more to do with the extreme expectations of what you will do for and give to your children, which is all based on being pretty wealthy, and the echo chamber of sheer horror at the suggestion some of those things might not be indisputable essentials for being a good parent, that ensues.

For examples, conversations about sharing bedrooms, or not wanting children to stay rent free indefinitely, or not being able to live separately from partners just because it's what the kids would prefer, and the list goes on...

I'm working class and a single mum, of course you can live separately from a partner. Presumably they were already doing that before they met the partner so it can be done. In those cases it's because they just want to do what's convenient for the adults, not the kids.
5128gap · 12/01/2022 09:16

I've learned from MN, that if I were MC I would not be allowed to put my Xmas lights up early, have hair extensions, let my children use character towels for swimming lessons, call my parents mothers 'Nan', have outdoor furniture, go on a package holiday, call my DC a name beginning with J, or date a bin man. Which all seems a bit restrictive to me, so happy to pass.Grin

Herani · 12/01/2022 09:14

School fees gobbled up most of our money that would otherwise be spent on holidays.
Interestingly, when I had one DC in prep and one in state, it was the state school families I knew who seemed to be jetting off regularly on amazing holidays. I presume either because flashy holidays were either a status symbol (you'd have to understand the area I live in) or lack of fees to pay towards schooling meant (in a wealthy area) a bigger holiday budget. Like many others, we had to grow to love camping and the occasional trip abroad until we were more flush.

aSofaNearYou · 12/01/2022 09:09

I think MN is pretty MC, I think the worst way this manifests is more to do with the extreme expectations of what you will do for and give to your children, which is all based on being pretty wealthy, and the echo chamber of sheer horror at the suggestion some of those things might not be indisputable essentials for being a good parent, that ensues.

For examples, conversations about sharing bedrooms, or not wanting children to stay rent free indefinitely, or not being able to live separately from partners just because it's what the kids would prefer, and the list goes on...

Dottybackorcid · 12/01/2022 09:05

I like to think I have a decent income, more than others I live near, but nothing like a majority of MN claim 🤣. I have not been on holiday in 17 years. Others I know who earn far less borrow, lend and spend every penny they get their hands on for holidays.
Different prioritys I guess and you were brought up. For me I want to own a lovely little detached home where I enjoy living and coming home too in the end 🙂. Not about where I have been but where I eventually call home.

WoodenReindeer · 12/01/2022 09:02

Wow that's a lot of holiday leave! I guess lots of jobs have minimum leave and parents need to both use theirs to cover childcare etc so dont have the leave even aside from the money!

5128gap · 12/01/2022 09:01

Yes, MN has a high proportion of MC posters. But, it's also very much the prevailing culture of the site to be MC, well off and well to do, so even those who aren't or who have lower incomes often either pretend they are, or are silent.
I'm WC with an average income and my life is far from boring. I couldn't afford very high end clothes, furnishings or holidays, but that doesn't mean I don't look good, have a nice home and enjoy my life doing the things within my budget. I have been well off in the past, and genuinely found no link between income and happiness/satisfaction, provided there was enough to meet my needs and I didn't have to worry.
As for MC, well I've no interest in that as a cultural thing, as it seems to me mainly about imposing a lot of rules about how you live and how you look, which are typically understated, discreet, sensible and worthy, which to me would be very boring.

DeepaBeesKit · 12/01/2022 08:58

Ha I can afford a holiday but I'm not fool enough to book one! A friend lost thousands when her last one had to be cancelled.

Booking a holiday right now is like playing Russian roulette

LadyPropane · 12/01/2022 08:57

@Spidey66

MN isn't full of middle class people. It is, however, full of people obsessed with class. There's daily threads on it. "Are my clothes middle class?" "Does shopping in Waitrose make me middle class?" No-one in my world discusses class in the same way.
Haha 🤣 this is absolutely true.

Everything that you do and don't do gives away your "class"...

ZoeTheThornyDevil · 12/01/2022 08:55

That Paris-hotel-room lie was quite a few years ago now, and has been repeated ad nauseum. I'm not saying we don't have a fair shower of liars, exaggerators and full-on trolls, but most people probably aren't doing more than stretching the truth, because that's true everywhere.

There are threads for everyone. For those on benefits and for those with seven-figure sums to invest. MN skews disproportionately MC and always has, yes. Is that the worst thing in the world? Mostly it has a reputation for skewing intelligent and educated, which transcends class. "Educated" does lead in itself to a MC skew, because one thing that defines MC as it exists in this country at the moment is valuing education highly. But there are plenty of other places with skews of their own if you don't care for this one. It's virtually impossible to have any community that doesn't have a skew, because there is quite genuinely no topic on earth that is of equal interest to all people. Parenting forums skew female. Weightlifting forums skew male. Education forums skew to upper income bands. COVID forums skew in complicated interesting ways to do with education and political identity. Take your pick.

Lilifer · 12/01/2022 08:54

@PickAChew

You need to read the thread about broken things that we put up with. So many of us live in rather crumbly houses, it turns out.
Please link to that thread I need it!
AngelsWithSilverWings · 12/01/2022 08:49

@progress2019 I wonder if we live in the same town. Camping is extremely popular and many families go abroad a few times a year too. No one actually discusses money or class though. You can tell from the Facebook check ins at airport first class lounges and fancy hotels just how much money people are spending.

We always camp for two weeks in the summer and love it but also go abroad a couple of times a year in normal times. Last year we camped for two weeks in Wales and then when we got home we flew to Corfu on a last minute deal for a week in a villa.

Our normal pre pandemic year would be a long haul trip at Easter , a short haul trip in either May or October and our two weeks camping with friends. We usually do a weekend European Christmas markets city break in December too.

UserBot989 · 12/01/2022 08:14

Ps, I think you can end up with a different impression of MN depending on what threads you're drawn to. I don't seem to have the impression that everybody is loaded. Although there was a 27 year old who had a baby 3 months ago and she posted a pic of herself in a lovely dress asking if it looked good. And I did notice her mirror was absolutely beautiful and probably cost a small fortune, but nobody commented on that!

Most of the time when people post photos you can see the clutter in their room and the 10 year old slippers on the floor.

Spidey66 · 12/01/2022 08:13

MN isn't full of middle class people. It is, however, full of people obsessed with class. There's daily threads on it. "Are my clothes middle class?" "Does shopping in Waitrose make me middle class?" No-one in my world discusses class in the same way.

Bagelsandbrie · 12/01/2022 08:12

No idea what class I am to be honest but we’re fairly low income - dh earns under £25k and we manage on that and disability benefits for myself and Ds. I stay away from the holiday threads etc as it’s just beyond our reach! Plenty of other threads to get involved in.

UserBot989 · 12/01/2022 08:11

Well, despite being middle-class, I haven't been on a 'holiday' for about 20 years Shock

Single parent, two teens, younger son very hard work. I've been for a few days here or there to visit friends in Spain/UK/Denmark. So I suppose those mini breaks count as they were fun but I've never been away longer than I felt my parents could cope with two DC. And now? the teens would fight, trash the house, leave the oven and the heating on 24/7

And I've nobody to go with! So.

funji · 12/01/2022 08:08

We live in SW London & DH works for a MC law firm so I think my experience would be comparable.

Maybe it's an age thing though, if your dc are older & you are retired then maybe missing holidays/self isolation isn't such an issue.

Tal45 · 12/01/2022 08:07

I always get the impression that it's a bit of an older crowd as well. In my 20's I wasn't going abroad several times a year just the odd package holiday every few, in my 30's maybe once a year but now I'm well into my 40's, there are lots of cheap flights and cheap air bnb's with a kitchen and it can be done very reasonably and easily.

I just read that the average income in the UK is £31,461 and if you earn between 75% and 200% of that you are considered middle class according to the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development.

funji · 12/01/2022 08:05

@Oblomov22 I don't think most people would assume one weekend break means people are lying.

I think 7 abroad holidays in one year during a pandemic is slightly unbelievable. Everyone I know has a holiday that's been rescheduled & have either attempted to get away & couldn't - 4 colleagues missed out on Dec holidays due to a family member testing positive just before. It's a faff at the moment to travel abroad.

Progress2019 · 12/01/2022 08:05

@Waxonwaxoff0 I completely agree with you.